What the Palestinians Really Want

Wildcat: "Because I can document the press in Lebanon engaged in such malfeasance, for example photoshopping pics to make Israeli bombing look more extensive than it was."

this...is evidence of the UN and the Lebanese media being infiltrated and manipulated by Hezbollah?????

I'm starting to question your impartiality on this issue.

btw, is it STILL your contention, that Wildcat's posts I quoted in post #353, are not remiscent of the logic and reasoning used by 9-11 Truthers?

If you want to question evidence, question it, don't just make vague innuendos.

As you edited your post after I had already replied, I had not seen your additional points, and so have made no such contention.
 
He wants to hear what I have to say...As long as it's what he wants to hear. Otherwise, he dismisses it.

Cleon, you and I have been arguing these issues on this forum for more than seven years now. Our opinions are very different and they are unlikely to ever be reconciled, but that doesn’t mean we can’t engage in meaningful dialogue. No, you will probably not bring me over to your point of view, but if that’s a precondition that any dialogue between any two people becomes pointless.


Fact: APS was not a "sub-group" of ISM, in any way. This is not a matter of "opinion," it's a simple factual matter. It's the equivalent of claiming that Hadassah is a sub-group of the ZOA; similar beliefs or no, it's simply not an accurate statement.

And yet Hadassah and ZOA are very similar groups with very similar goals. If you claim there is no direct organizational or financial links between them, I will certainly believe you, but that wasn’t my claim about the ISM and APS either.

But in a larger sense, you seem to be making a big deal over the smaller issue. The exact nature of the relationship between the ISM and APS is a side issue, the real issue is the degree of sympathy among the APS for Hamas, and similar organizations.

Mycroft's POV is essentially that of conspiracism; he wants to see every group critical of Israel as part of some overarching network, I suppose run by some secret department at Hamas HQ.

Wrong and wrong, but nice straw-man. This is the kind of argument I would expect from the Fool.

You know, anyone who took the time to objectively look at the Palestinian support movement would quickly come to the conclusion that even within these organizations there were many different people with many different views. Muslims, Christians, Jews, atheists, communists, libertarians, etc.

Of course. Just like any large and diverse group. It’s as varied as the individuals that are a part.

There is also an acceptance of supporters of Hamas, which is why that one person on my-space feels free to openly display the Hamas logo without fear of censure. I have no doubt many APS supporters cringe inwardly on seeing it, but at the end of the day nobody will ask him to leave. Someone might contact the guy privately and say something like, ”We understand your feelings and where you’re coming from, but that display is bad for the greater movement”. You gotta tone it down where outsiders might be looking.” Then there are others who see Hamas as a part of the “greater movement”.

Nobody will seek to exclude the Hamas supporter.

But Mycroft, "Skeptic," & co. cannot accept that. To them, everyone is waving green flags and cheering on suicide bombers.

Skeptic gives a most articulate description of how some people meaning to do good end up supporting evil. It is nothing at all like your characterizations.

Look, Cleon, I’m not trying to embarrass, trap, discredit or expose you, but I do think talking about acceptance of Hamas from organizations such as APS is a fair topic for discussion, and that if you want to participate you should offer something more substantial than to just claim Skeptic and I are bad people for even bringing it up.
 
If you want to question evidence, question it, don't just make vague innuendos.

As you edited your post after I had already replied, I had not seen your additional points, and so have made no such contention.

Wildcat has presented no evidence of the United Nations or the Lebanese media (how many radio stations, tv stations, and newspapers are in Lebanon???) being infiltrated and manipulated by Hezbollah. All he has presented, is photos.

In post #353, I presented multiple quotes by Wildcat, showing his logic and reasoning is similar to if not indentical...to 9-11 Truthers.

what say you? are you going to read the quotes I have posted by Wildcat, or are you simply going to continue to defend him?

do you agree that Wildcat has not presented evidence of Hezbollah infiltration and manipulation of the United Nations and the Lebanese media? and if not...please cite his evidence.
 
Last edited:
I thought your raised the matter. Perhaps I inferred too much.

It seems we're agreed: UN242 asks for withdrawal of Israeli forces from occupied territory, it does not ask for any Arab withdrawals.

Sure, I'll agree to that so long as you agree that UNSCR 242 sets aside precisely zero land for a Palestinian state.


See? Two can play that game.
 
Gazan youth issue manifesto:

"**** Hamas. **** Israel. **** Fatah. **** UN. **** UNWRA. **** USA! We, the youth in Gaza, are so fed up with Israel, Hamas, the occupation, the violations of human rights and the indifference of the international community!

"We want to scream and break this wall of silence, injustice and indifference like the Israeli F16s breaking the wall of sound; scream with all the power in our souls in order to release this immense frustration that consumes us because of this *********** situation we live in...

"We are sick of being caught in this political struggle; sick of coal-dark nights with airplanes circling above our homes; sick of innocent farmers getting shot in the buffer zone because they are taking care of their lands; sick of bearded guys walking around with their guns abusing their power, beating up or incarcerating young people demonstrating for what they believe in; sick of the wall of shame that separates us from the rest of our country and keeps us imprisoned in a stamp-sized piece of land; sick of being portrayed as terrorists, home-made fanatics with explosives in our pockets and evil in our eyes; sick of the indifference we meet from the international community, the so-called experts in expressing concerns and drafting resolutions but cowards in enforcing anything they agree on; we are sick and tired of living a ****** life, being kept in jail by Israel, beaten up by Hamas and completely ignored by the rest of the world.

"There is a revolution growing inside of us, an immense dissatisfaction and frustration that will destroy us unless we find a way of canalising this energy into something that can challenge the status quo and give us some kind of hope.

"We barely survived the Operation Cast Lead, where Israel very effectively bombed the **** out of us, destroying thousands of homes and even more lives and dreams. During the war we got the unmistakable feeling that Israel wanted to erase us from the face of the Earth. During the last years, Hamas has been doing all they can to control our thoughts, behaviour and aspirations. Here in Gaza we are scared of being incarcerated, interrogated, hit, tortured, bombed, killed. We cannot move as we want, say what we want, do what we want.

"ENOUGH! Enough pain, enough tears, enough suffering, enough control, limitations, unjust justifications, terror, torture, excuses, bombings, sleepless nights, dead civilians, black memories, bleak future, heart-aching present, disturbed politics, fanatic politicians, religious ********, enough incarceration! WE SAY STOP! This is not the future we want! We want to be free. We want to be able to live a normal life. We want peace. Is that too much to ask?"


http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jan/02/free-gaza-youth-manifesto-palestinian
 
Hezbollah manipulation of foreign media:

err......how does this justify disregarding and handwaving away any/all reporting from the Lebanese media, and statements/investigations from the United Nations? It doesn't.

err...how is this evidence of Hezbollah's infiltration and manipulation of the Lebanese press? it isn't.

I think we are done here.
 
Last edited:
Cheers

It's so rare that we actually get to hear from Palestinians themselves outside of all this anti-Zionist rhetoric. I was tempted to answer the question posed in the title of this thread with...They want the same things everyone else in the wold wants. To get up in the morning, go to work at a job they like, come home, crack a beverage, have a meal, maybe watch some TV, all this without having to worry about getting arrested or bombed.

This only backs up what I said over on some other thread, nobody wants to live under either Islamofascism and here I'll add, In a war zone.

I've heard similar sentiments from a few Israelis before, things like
"I'm from I'm from Israel and I'll never go back there, I don't want to live like that"
or
"Stupid religious people and their stupid conflicts"

Most everybody wants peace, I'm lucky enough to never have known war and I'd like to see my good fortune shared by everyone.
 
Most everybody wants peace, I'm lucky enough to never have known war and I'd like to see my good fortune shared by everyone.

Your assumption is that everyone thinks like a Westerner. The Western idea is that war is bad and should only be used as a last resort. Unfortunately for the Arabs, violence and hate are endemic cultural pathologies. Not everyone thinks this way, but the number is significant enough to retard rather than promote peaceful solutions to their problems.

The example of what happened to Egyptian liberal Ali Salem illustrates the point:

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/blogs/index.php/totten/104901
 
Last edited:
Gazan youth issue manifesto:

"**** Hamas. **** Israel. **** Fatah. **** UN. **** UNWRA. **** USA! We, the youth in Gaza, are so fed up with Israel, Hamas, the occupation, the violations of human rights and the indifference of the international community!

Wow, those are some brave kids.

I really hope this turns into something. Because the reality is they will always be powerless to change their situation until they first gain the ability to change their leadership.
 
Your assumption is that everyone thinks like a Westerner. The Western idea is that war is bad and should only be used as a last resort. Unfortunately for the Arabs, violence and hate are endemic cultural pathologies. Not everyone thinks this way, but the number is significant enough to retard rather than promote peaceful solutions to their problems.

The example of what happened to Egyptian liberal Ali Salem illustrates the point:

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/blogs/index.php/totten/104901


The Western idea of war is that war is very profitable. It's a racket.
 
Your assumption is that everyone thinks like a Westerner. The Western idea is that war is bad and should only be used as a last resort. Unfortunately for the Arabs, violence and hate are endemic cultural pathologies. Not everyone thinks this way, but the number is significant enough to retard rather than promote peaceful solutions to their problems.

The example of what happened to Egyptian liberal Ali Salem illustrates the point:

http://www.commentarymagazine.com/blogs/index.php/totten/104901

That article doesn't say a single thing about war, violence, and/or hate being "endemic cultural pathologies" for Arabs. If anything, it implies the exact opposite, explicitly stating that the ability to forgive former enemies isn't limited to Westerners, and drawing parallels between the emotional roots of the violence in the war-torn Balkans and the emotional roots of the violence in Gaza and South Lebanon.

EDIT: Even Ali Salem doesn't attribute the problem to anything inherent in the Arab mind, but instead traces it back, in the case of the opposition he faced, to Egyptians not having gotten over the fact that they were defeated and forced to sign a peace in the '67 war, with their continuing hostility towards Israel coming from resentment over that fact.
 
Last edited:
That article doesn't say a single thing about war, violence, and/or hate being "endemic cultural pathologies" for Arabs. If anything, it implies the exact opposite, explicitly stating that the ability to forgive former enemies isn't limited to Westerners, and drawing parallels between the emotional roots of the violence in the war-torn Balkans and the emotional roots of the violence in Gaza and South Lebanon.

EDIT: Even Ali Salem doesn't attribute the problem to anything inherent in the Arab mind, but instead traces it back, in the case of the opposition he faced, to Egyptians not having gotten over the fact that they were defeated and forced to sign a peace in the '67 war, with their continuing hostility towards Israel coming from resentment over that fact.

Other than the title of the linked article, I'm not seeing it either and after a cruise through the internet searching for Ali Salem pieces. I agree with what you're saying. Strange, though, that the artistic community would ostracise him. On e would *assume* that if there's any counterculture to be found, the artistic community is where you'd find it.

Speaking of counterculture, that left wing fascist forum I mentioned yesterday has started a thread on the Guardian article. It's been hours and other than the OP questioning it's authenticity, there's been no responses. I wonder whether the lack of interest has anything to do with the article being critical of Hamas?
 
Strange, though, that the artistic community would ostracise him. On e would *assume* that if there's any counterculture to be found, the artistic community is where you'd find it.

I know little about the artistic community in Egypt. Do you mean the references to the reaction he got from the intellectual class as a whole, with the Egyptian Cinema Association and the Egyptian Writers Association kicking him out?

From his description in the translated interview quoted in the Commentary piece, it would seem that the leaders of the professional organizations hew a bit closer to the conservative line than the individual artists do. At least on the writing end - Salem talks about how the boot from the Cinema Association happened without any controversy, but there was an "uproar" after the Writers' Association kicked him out.

Speaking of counterculture, that left wing fascist forum I mentioned yesterday has started a thread on the Guardian article. It's been hours and other than the OP questioning it's authenticity, there's been no responses. I wonder whether the lack of interest has anything to do with the article being critical of Hamas?

If I was forced to speculate, I think I'd agree with you on why there's no reaction other than a doubting OP on that board.
 
Last edited:
I can't claim any inside knowledge on the Egyptian intellectual and artistic communities either but it just strikes me as being rather odd that they'd self-censor on content like they did. Especially since Driving to Israel is listed as an Egyptian best seller. There's always the possibility of political interference having an influence on the leaders of the organisations though.

Coincidentally, if plans I was making last fall had come to fruition, I'd be jumping on a plane headed for Egypt today. I bailed though, in favour of a hotter destination, but Egypt is still numero uno on my list of ME destinations. Well, OK it is my list of ME destinations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom