What the Palestinians Really Want

still waiting for evidence that Hamas will kill, exile, or convert ANY non-Muslims in Palestine..once Hamas rules it all.

Still waiting for you to acknowledge the reams of evidence already presented.

Here's another ream for you;

Ahmad Bahar, Acting Chairman of Parliament (Hamas):
“This is Islam, that was ahead of its time with regards to human rights in the treatment of prisoners, but our people was afflicted by the cancerous lump, that is the Jews, in the heart of the Arab nation… Be certain that America is on its way to disappear, America is wallowing [in blood] today in Iraq and Afghanistan, America is defeated and Israel is defeated, and was defeated in Lebanon and Palestine… Make us victorious over the infidel people… Allah, take hold of the Jews and their allies, Allah, take hold of the Americans and their allies… Allah, count them and kill them to the last one and don’t leave even one.”

Ziyad Abu al-Haj, Hamas cleric:
"The Jews today are leading the all-encompassing war against Muslims... We, the Muslims, know the nature of Jews the best, because the Holy Quran taught us... it is a cancer that wants to rule the world... The time will come, by Allah’s will, when their property will be destroyed and their children will be exterminated, and no Jew or Zionist will be left on the face of this earth."

Palestinian cleric:
"The Meccan [Quran] chapter entitled 'Jews' or 'Children of Israel' is remarkable... It's about today's Jews, those of our century, and speaks only of extermination and digging graves... This chapter sentences the Jews to extermination before a single Jew existed on earth... Palestine's blessing is linked to destruction of the center of global corruption [Jews of Israel], the snake's head. When the snake's head of [global] corruption is cut off, here in Palestine, and when the octopus' [Jew's] tentacles are cut off around the world, the real blessing will come with the destruction of the Jews, here in Palestine, and it is one of the splendid real blessings in Palestine."

In an article promoting the continued use of suicide terror in the official Hamas newspaper:
"We find occastional condemnation and denunciation of the resistance operations and bombings [suicide attacks], carried out by Hamas and the Palestinian resistance branches... [Eventually] everyone will know that we did this [suicide attacks] only because our Lord commanded so - 'I did it not of my own accord' [Quran] - and so that people will know that the extermination of Jews is good for the inhabitants of the world."

Plenty more here:
http://www.palwatch.org/main.aspx?fi=427
 
Last edited:

I love how they criticize the Palestinians for having maps showing all of Palestine under their control. Meanwhile, Israel posts tourism ads in Britain, with maps of the West Bank...all under Israeli control.

Let alone the many other maps of the land that show the WB as part of Israel.

Oh, and what is "palwatch.org"? Is that like, the right-wing Zionist version of Jewwatch?

:confused:
 
Last edited:
Feel free to quote all the Hamas articles and speeches, delivered to Palestinian audiences, which call for peace.
 
Feel free to quote all the Hamas articles and speeches, delivered to Palestinian audiences, which call for peace.

funny, especially cause I have never suggested that Hamas wants peace.

however, I have called Hamas a terrorist organization that should have its leaders tried at the Hague for war crimes.
 
What do you have to say about all the calls for Jewish extermination from official Hamas spokesmen and clerics?
 
What do you have to say about all the calls for Jewish extermination from official Hamas spokesmen and clerics?

what do I have to say about it?

I just said I want them arrested and sent to the Hague, for war crimes, did I not?
 
So you agree that Hamas calls for genocide and ethnic cleansing of the Jews?
 
Last edited:
Virus claimed Palestinians are lying to non Arabic speakers. you defended his post and provided evidence that he is wrong for at least 30% of Palestinians.

thanks.
What Virus stated:

To foreigners who can't read Arabic, they'll tell you whatever you want to hear.

There's no solution until the Palestinians undergo a major shift in attitude. Until then, they'll just have to get used to it.
Bolding my own. This is in reference to the media outlets and what is stated there. This isn't to say what you are stating, that somehow 'Palestinians are lying to non-Arabic speakers'. Its what's written that he's referring to, which I agree with.

Somehow you still think the 'all', 'every', etc. is still a valid argument when nothing of the sort has been referred to here.

All my points still stand as they still haven't been refuted, let alone replied to.
 
Last edited:
Hah...No. Repeating the lie doesn't magically make it true. Sorry.

Not opinion. Fact. One of us is in a position to know this in absolute certainty; that person is not you.

Repeating something doesn’t make it true, but neither does gainsaying it make it false. Fortunately, I’m not relying on repetition for my conclusions. I’ve seen more evidence than just a my-space friend who feels comfortable enough in your Atlanta Palestine Solidarity crowd to openly display the Hamas symbol without any fear of reprimand or being ostracized, though that alone is more evidence than you’ve brought.


And yet, you continue to perpetuate associations that are not.

Gainsaying, again.

And yet, when the information I provide conflicts with your preconceived notions, you dismiss it out of hand.

I don’t think it’s a choice between accepting whatever you say as verbatim truth or dismissing whatever “conflicts with my preconceived notions.” You have a point of view I’d like to understand better, but you get into this defensive mode where communication is impossible. I’m not trying to discredit or expose you, I’m only stating what seems to be obvious.

If you're not going to approach the subject with an open mind and will simply believe whatever you want to anyway, then why, exactly, should I bother?

An open mind is not an empty mind. I want to hear what you have to say, but that doesn’t mean I don’t have my own experiences and information to draw upon.
 
What Virus stated:


Bolding my own. This is in reference to the media outlets and what is stated there. This isn't to say what you are stating, that somehow 'Palestinians are lying to non-Arabic speakers'. Its what's written that he's referring to, which I agree with.

Somehow you still think the 'all', 'every', etc. is still a valid argument when nothing of the sort has been referred to here.

All my points still stand as they still haven't been refuted, let alone replied to.

yeah i know sweeping generalizations against Palestinians is ok. got it.
your point was refuted by your own source..........
 
yeah i know sweeping generalizations against Palestinians is ok. got it.
your point was refuted by your own source..........
None of that either. I didn't see any superlatives being used in that post, ie 'all', 'every', or the definite article, 'the' being used, except in respect to a 'shift of attitude', which is predominantly the issue with the Palestinians. Israelis, by majority, do understand the concept of concessions to reach a peaceful resolution to this conflict, Palestinians, as the poll showed, only see the 2 state solution, by majority, as a stepping stone to a 1 state solution rather than 2 states living side by side. Israel would cease to exist, either passively, as proposed in this poll, or by an ongoing violent 'resistence'/jihad/etc., as Islamist groups like Hezbollah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, etc. proposed consistently and have acted out on.

This has been the point that ties in all the points Virus and myself have made to this point, whilst you and Parky have been making these pointless side arguments in a slew of 'in other words' attempts or the overused superlatives arguments to deflect, detract, and so on in this and many other threads.

There's nothing more to add to this as there was nothing refuted to begin with. If you feel differently, then point it out specifically.
 
I’d get into an argument over it, and it really does seem as though you would argue it at a much higher level than others on this forum have in the past, but for now I’ll table it with the understanding that at least your accepting that there is an argument to be made is a tacit agreement that Palestinians are not “entitled” to everything and that “international law” is not as definitive on the subject as you first seemed to believe.

I'm not sure if that's intended as a back-handed compliment. :)
I appreciate you don't want to discuss this now, but I have a few things to say which I can refer to if you do want to resume the discussion.


I don't need to believe that the law is clear beyond all possible doubt in order to cite it. I have good grounds for saying that the Palestinians are entitled to all the land defined as 'occupied': territory can't be acquired by force, and that principle is linked (according to the French) to the call for withdrawal from occupied territories.

I have accepted there is an ambiguous sentence in UN242. It doesn't, on its own, say whether withdrawal should be from some or all of the occupied territory. Lucky for us, then, that we don't need to rely on that sentence on its own.

I've also accepted the intentions, as documented by the quotes you gave in the other thread, of those who made the sentence ambiguous. But I have not accepted they succeeded in their aims -- and I've supplied the opinions of the French and Indians, and I think the Russians were also quoted on the wiki page -- to back that up.

Here are 2 of your quotes:
(Your 3rd quote merely states that Israel is the occupying power).

"To seek withdrawal without secure and recognized boundaries ... would be just as fruitless as to seek secure and recognized boundaries without withdrawal. Historically, there have never been secure or recognized boundaries in the area. Neither the armistice lines of 1949 nor the cease-fire lines of 1967 have answered that description... such boundaries have yet to be agreed upon. An agreement on that point is an absolute essential to a just and lasting peace just as withdrawal is... "

Arthur Goldberg, U.S. ambassador to the U.N



“The purposes are perfectly clear, the principle is stated in the preamble, the necessity for withdrawal is stated in the operative section. And then the essential phrase which is not sufficiently recognized is that withdrawal should take place to secure and recognized boundaries, and these words were very carefully chosen: they have to be secure and they have to be recognized. They will not be secure unless they are recognized. And that is why one has to work for agreement. This is essential. I would defend absolutely what we did. It was not for us to lay down exactly where the border should be. I know the 1967 border very well. It is not a satisfactory border, it is where troops had to stop in 1947, just where they happened to be that night, that is not a permanent boundary . . . "

Lord Caradon Britain’s representative to the U.N

Both of which give the opinion of those men that the 1967 borders aren't good enough. They did not succeed in getting that opinion into UN242.

The 2 quotes also state that no particular border is set out in UN242 -- they didn't "lay down exactly where the border should be".

But where, in UN242, is there a specific request for the Palestinians to give up any of the land? I didn't see it. So why should it be expected of them? Of course, the Palestinians can also agree to some border changes and still not break UN242 -- since no territory would have been acquired by force. But I don't see where they are required to do so. OTOH, Israel cannot demand changes to the 1967 borders -- other than to give up some of its own land, because it has no entitlement to the land it took by force. The only way it gets it is if the people who ARE entitled to the land agree to give it up.


There's a link to a pdf of UN242 here:
http://www.un.org/documents/sc/res/1967/scres67.htm
And the wiki page again:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Security_Council_Resolution_242
 
so 30% of the Palestinians do not think "The real goal should be to start with two states but then move to it all being one Palestinian state."
and thus are not liars.

http://www.theisraelproject.org/atf/cf/{84dc5887-741e-4056-8d91-a389164bc94e}/NOV2010_PALESTINIANPOLLPOWERPOINTNEW.PDF


Thanks for that link. It does not sound too bad in theory. But when it comes to implementation I read things like
Support for an actual agreement modest. Only about 30 percent support an
agreement like the Clinton parameters, once you give it a fuller description, including
dividing Jerusalem and land swaps. There is work to do.
which make it seem unlikely to actually work out in the near future.

Pretty interesting how much access to electronics and media the people in the survey actually had. Though I wonder if that is the result of the selection.
 
Repeating something doesn’t make it true, but neither does gainsaying it make it false. Fortunately, I’m not relying on repetition for my conclusions. I’ve seen more evidence than just a my-space friend who feels comfortable enough in your Atlanta Palestine Solidarity crowd to openly display the Hamas symbol without any fear of reprimand or being ostracized, though that alone is more evidence than you’ve brought.




Gainsaying, again.



I don’t think it’s a choice between accepting whatever you say as verbatim truth or dismissing whatever “conflicts with my preconceived notions.” You have a point of view I’d like to understand better, but you get into this defensive mode where communication is impossible. I’m not trying to discredit or expose you, I’m only stating what seems to be obvious.



An open mind is not an empty mind. I want to hear what you have to say, but that doesn’t mean I don’t have my own experiences and information to draw upon.

Yep...You knows what you knows, and facts don't matter. Bye.
 
Yes he does, as do you, but also stated he wanted to hear what you had to say. Where did he say facts don't matter?

He wants to hear what I have to say...As long as it's what he wants to hear. Otherwise, he dismisses it.

Fact: APS was not a "sub-group" of ISM, in any way. This is not a matter of "opinion," it's a simple factual matter. It's the equivalent of claiming that Hadassah is a sub-group of the ZOA; similar beliefs or no, it's simply not an accurate statement.

APS worked with Christian pacifist organizations more than it worked with the ISM, but Mycroft doesn't try to paint APS as a "sub-group" of the Quakers. He's not trying to paint a picture of Israel critics as peace-loving Christians, he's trying to paint one where we're all radicals and Islamists. (His bizzarely distorted view of the ISM is another matter entirely.)

Mycroft's POV is essentially that of conspiracism; he wants to see every group critical of Israel as part of some overarching network, I suppose run by some secret department at Hamas HQ.

You know, anyone who took the time to objectively look at the Palestinian support movement would quickly come to the conclusion that even within these organizations there were many different people with many different views. Muslims, Christians, Jews, atheists, communists, libertarians, etc.

But Mycroft, "Skeptic," & co. cannot accept that. To them, everyone is waving green flags and cheering on suicide bombers.
 
Last edited:
Mycroft's POV is essentially that of conspiracism; he wants to see every group critical of Israel as part of some overarching network, I suppose run by some secret department at Hamas HQ.

But Mycroft, "Skeptic," & co. cannot accept that. To them, everyone is waving green flags and cheering on suicide bombers.

its due to either extreme paranoia, or a very dishonest tactic to destroy all who disagree with them.

either way, its crap.
 
But where, in UN242, is there a specific request for the Palestinians to give up any of the land? I didn't see it.



That's because at the time of the writing the parties involved were the Egyptians, Jordanians and Israelis. The Palestinians as a distinct group with their own nationalistic ambitions were not considered, the two-state solution idea came much later.
 
That's because at the time of the writing the parties involved were the Egyptians, Jordanians and Israelis. The Palestinians as a distinct group with their own nationalistic ambitions were not considered, the two-state solution idea came much later.

never heard of UN resolution 181 huh?

how expected.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom