What the Palestinians Really Want

Sure, I'll agree to that so long as you agree that UNSCR 242 sets aside precisely zero land for a Palestinian state.


See? Two can play that game.

But, as you said, the Palestinians weren't a recognised party at the time. Egypt and Jordan were. They are not asked by UN242 to give up any land. Jordan has given up its claim to the West Bank, handing that to the PLO.

Why should the Palestinians be required, under UN242, to give up land when the Jordanians were not?
 
But, as you said, the Palestinians weren't a recognised party at the time. Egypt and Jordan were. They are not asked by UN242 to give up any land. Jordan has given up its claim to the West Bank, handing that to the PLO.

Why should the Palestinians be required, under UN242, to give up land when the Jordanians were not?
UNSC 242 didn't request a withdrawal of Jordanian troops because Israeli troops made the advancements during that war.

In 1948 UN resolution S/RES/61 (1948) did request a withdrawal to October 14th advancements for parties involved:
Calls upon the Interested Governments, without prejudice to their rights, claims or positions with regard to a peaceful adjustment of the future situation of Palestine or to the position which the Members of the United Nations may wish to take in the General Assembly on such peaceful adjustment:

(1) To withdraw those of their forces which have advanced beyond the positions held on 14 October, the Acting Mediator being authorized to establish provisional lines beyond which no movement of troops shall take place;

UNSC 242 requested a withdrawal of Israeli forces from territories gained in 1967. Both request a withdrawal of military personnel and not a request to 'give up any land' and both were requested coincidentally when Arab forces were faltering (as was usually the case with the UN in all wars since this conflict began).

Definitive borders would be negotiated between parties involved. Jordan relinquishing control in 1988 of the WB and handing it over to the PLO does not mean the PLO can universally adopted the (voided) 1949 armistice lines as de facto borders and claim all territory in the WB as theirs. Jordan was the previous occupier of the the territory in question (there's no precedent that allows an occupier to hand over land to an organization it unilaterally declares as representative of the Palestinians, retroactively of course) and the Arab league's rejection, several subsequent wars of aggression, rejection of the partition and UN resolutions (Khartoum resolution, still in effect for some Arab states), and the involvement of Palestinians in said wars, does weigh into the negotiations into final border agreements.

Ignoring any of these circumstances and adhering to the argument with the vague reference to a GC doesn't quite work to counter the arguments against the above.
 
Talk all you like about wars of aggression. UN242 makes clear it is not admissable to acquire territory by force.
 
Definitive borders would be negotiated between parties involved. Jordan relinquishing control in 1988 of the WB and handing it over to the PLO does not mean the PLO can universally adopted the (voided) 1949 armistice lines as de facto borders and claim all territory in the WB as theirs. Jordan was the previous occupier of the the territory in question (there's no precedent that allows an occupier to hand over land to an organization it unilaterally declares as representative of the Palestinians, retroactively of course)

Meanwhile, Israel unilaterally chooses to massively expand the borders of Jerusalem by annexing large areas of the West Bank and calling it "Jerusalem", and unilaterally annexing the Golan Heights and calling it part of Israel. But of course, this bothers you not, for Israel is allowed to act unilaterally.

Right Bigjel? ;)
 
Meanwhile, Israel unilaterally chooses to massively expand the borders of Jerusalem by annexing large areas of the West Bank and calling it "Jerusalem", and unilaterally annexing the Golan Heights and calling it part of Israel. But of course, this bothers you not, for Israel is allowed to act unilaterally.

Right Bigjel? ;)
Here we go with the massive expansion allegation of J'lem. Refer to the threads about that where this has been addressed.

Doesn't bother me that Israel gained the higher ground, ie Golan Heights, which was used as an attack point by Arab league nations via Syria.

Apparently the concept of initiating wars of aggression doesn't have any repercussions.
 
Doesn't bother me that Israel gained the higher ground, ie Golan Heights, which was used as an attack point by Arab league nations via Syria.

Apparently the concept of initiating wars of aggression doesn't have any repercussions.

who...attacked who...Bigjel? who was being aggressive..Bigjel?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1967_war#Israel_and_Syria

Nine years later, Moshe Dayan, the Israeli defense minister at the time of the war, stated in an interview not published until 1997 that Israeli policy at the Demilitarized Zone between 1949 and 1967 consisted of "snatching bits of territory and holding on to it until the enemy despairs and gives it to us." About events on the Israeli-Syrian border he said:
After all, I know how at least 80 percent of the clashes there started. In my opinion, more than 80 percent, but let's talk about 80 percent. It went this way: We would send a tractor to plow some area where it wasn't possible to do anything, in the demilitarized area, and knew in advance that the Syrians would start to shoot. If they didn't shoot, we would tell the tractor to advance farther, until in the end the Syrians would get annoyed and shoot. And then we would use artillery and later the air force also, and that's how it was. I did that, and Laskov and Czera did that, and Yitzhak did that, but it seemed to me that the person who most enjoyed these games was Dado. We thought that we could change the lines of the ceasefire accords by military actions that were less than war. That is, to seize some territory and hold it until the enemy despairs and gives it to us.[58]


I think you need to do a bit more research on the subject.
​
 
who...attacked who...Bigjel? who was being aggressive..Bigjel?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1967_war#Israel_and_Syria

Nine years later, Moshe Dayan, the Israeli defense minister at the time of the war, stated in an interview not published until 1997 that Israeli policy at the Demilitarized Zone between 1949 and 1967 consisted of "snatching bits of territory and holding on to it until the enemy despairs and gives it to us." About events on the Israeli-Syrian border he said:
After all, I know how at least 80 percent of the clashes there started. In my opinion, more than 80 percent, but let's talk about 80 percent. It went this way: We would send a tractor to plow some area where it wasn't possible to do anything, in the demilitarized area, and knew in advance that the Syrians would start to shoot. If they didn't shoot, we would tell the tractor to advance farther, until in the end the Syrians would get annoyed and shoot. And then we would use artillery and later the air force also, and that's how it was. I did that, and Laskov and Czera did that, and Yitzhak did that, but it seemed to me that the person who most enjoyed these games was Dado. We thought that we could change the lines of the ceasefire accords by military actions that were less than war. That is, to seize some territory and hold it until the enemy despairs and gives it to us.[58]


I think you need to do a bit more research on the subject.
​
Yes, clearly they were provoked by a Jew driving a tractor. Who can't resist shooting at that?
 
Way to go, disregarding evidence provided by the Israeli hero, Mr. Moshe Dayan.
Evidence of what? That all it took to get the Syrians to start shooting was the sight of a Jew on a tractor?

If I said "Israeli" on a tractor does that take away your knee-jerk defense of Syria, where I'm sure there is no anti-semitism at all?
 
Hmm. I wonder if Parky would have also justified it if Israeli soldiers would start shooting when Palestinians take civil actions in contested areas. I would not want to think that he uses double-standard when judging the actions of both sides.
 
If I said "Israeli" on a tractor does that take away your knee-jerk defense of Syria, where I'm sure there is no anti-semitism at all?

Whooooooaaaaaaaaaa there.....stick to one subject at a time.

Setting the record straight, contrary to right-wing Zionist propaganda, does NOT equal defending anyone.

There is only ONE country that had soldiers massed on the border just before Israel's pre-emptive war, and that was Egypt.

Now, if you want to discuss anti-Semitism in Syria, create a new thread....rather than derailing this one.

30,000 posts....sheesh!!
 
Whooooooaaaaaaaaaa there.....stick to one subject at a time.

Setting the record straight, contrary to right-wing Zionist propaganda, does NOT equal defending anyone.

There is only ONE country that had soldiers massed on the border just before Israel's pre-emptive war, and that was Egypt.

Now, if you want to discuss anti-Semitism in Syria, create a new thread....rather than derailing this one.

30,000 posts....sheesh!!
Hey, you brought up the Dayan comment.

You think the Syrians are excused because who couldn't resist shooting at an Israeli on a tractor, yes?
 
Bigjel accused Syria of a "war of aggression". I countered his silly claim, with a quote from Dayan, which proves that it was indeed Israel, who was being aggressive:

"We thought that we could change the lines of the ceasefire accords by military actions that were less than war. That is, to seize some territory and hold it until the enemy despairs and gives it to us"

Now, does this mean that Syria was completely innocent in regards to the Golan, leading up to the war? Certainly not. But neither was Israel. That is my point.

Carry on.
 
Evidence of what? That all it took to get the Syrians to start shooting was the sight of a Jew on a tractor?

If I said "Israeli" on a tractor does that take away your knee-jerk defense of Syria, where I'm sure there is no anti-semitism at all?

Calling it simply "a Jew driving a tractor" is a bit misleading, since it wasn't a regular farming tractor, but an IDF armored tractor, a combat engineering vehicle (and it happened multiple times). When the Syrians fired on them, they weren't shooting at some farmer trying to plow his fields, but Israeli military vehicles attempting to plow Arab farmers' fields in the Demilitarized Zone.

The Israeli military did indeed do this in an effort to provoke the Syrians to fire on the armored tractors, but it was an attempt to establish a true casus belli so the IDF could retaliate for the Syrians' active and growing support for Palestinian guerrilla attacks inside Israel itself (and the periodic shelling of Israeli settlements).

EDIT: In other words, Israel in the '67 war was still responding to Syrian aggression, but the tractor thing was a bit more complicated than being simply "a Jew on a tractor".

And this is separate from the quote Thunder's harping on, too.
 
Last edited:
Calling it simply "a Jew driving a tractor" is a bit misleading, since it wasn't a regular farming tractor, but an IDF armored tractor, a combat engineering vehicle (and it happened multiple times). When the Syrians fired on them, they weren't shooting at some farmer trying to plow his fields, but Israeli military vehicles attempting to plow Arab farmers' fields in the Demilitarized Zone.
Which doesn't excuse Syria's response, does it? Shades of the tree-trimming incident last summer.

The Israeli military did indeed do this in an effort to provoke the Syrians to fire on the armored tractors, but it was an attempt to establish a true casus belli so the IDF could retaliate for the Syrians' active and growing support for Palestinian guerrilla attacks inside Israel itself (and the periodic shelling of Israeli settlements).
I'm sure it was, but Syria didn't have to take the bait.
 
Which doesn't excuse Syria's response, does it? Shades of the tree-trimming incident last summer.


I'm sure it was, but Syria didn't have to take the bait.

Well, the "bait" was a military vehicle crossing the DMZ, which makes a military response a bit more understandable. And, in fact, this is what the IDF was counting on when they did it.

I did make a couple of edits to my post to make it clear that even Israel doing what it did was in response to Syrian or Syrian-backed attacks, though, so blaming Israel for first provocation with the tractor thing is still incorrect.

EDIT: And even the other Arab states in the military coalition knew that Syria's actions would force Israel to retaliate, though their worry was (of course) because they preferred to start a war on their terms, rather than on Israel's.
 
Last edited:
Calling it simply "a Jew driving a tractor" is a bit misleading, since it wasn't a regular farming tractor, but an IDF armored tractor, a combat engineering vehicle (and it happened multiple times). When the Syrians fired on them, they weren't shooting at some farmer trying to plow his fields, but Israeli military vehicles attempting to plow Arab farmers' fields in the Demilitarized Zone.

The Israeli military did indeed do this in an effort to provoke the Syrians to fire on the armored tractors, but it was an attempt to establish a true casus belli so the IDF could retaliate for the Syrians' active and growing support for Palestinian guerrilla attacks inside Israel itself (and the periodic shelling of Israeli settlements).

details....details..

some folks here don't need such details.

A poor Jewish farmer, probably a Holocaust survivor, was just trying to
till some soil, and maybe grow some vegetables to feed his starving family. And those evil, anti-Semitic, Nazi-loving Syrians had no ability to resist their urge to fire on the poor helpless Jew, which justifiably brought about harsh Israeli retaliation and pushing the cease-fire line further east, in defense of the poor Jewish Holocaust survivor farmer. :p
 
who...attacked who...Bigjel? who was being aggressive..Bigjel?
...
I think you need to do a bit more research on the subject.
Nope. This has also been discussed in another thread (Dayan quotes). You just need to read a bit more.

A tractor on the DMZ, which was in Israel proper, is not a war of aggression now is it? Shelling from Syrian positions was a normal occurrance. When Syria started shelling Israeli towns, they escalated the situation. Jordan at this point, was doing this for weeks prior to the outbreak of the '67 war against W. J'lem.

You tend to forget the 1948 war as well, eh?

Attaining the higher ground is a basic tactic in war, especially when you have a lovely neighbor such as Syria sitting overlooking the northern chunk of your country.

Try again? Or rather, read before having another :footinmou moment.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom