What the Palestinians Really Want

Well, the "bait" was a military vehicle crossing the DMZ, which makes a military response a bit more understandable. And, in fact, this is what the IDF was counting on when they did it.
An armored tractor is not a military vehicle. Its just a piece of farming equipment with armor plating. :)
 
A tractor on the DMZ, which was in Israel proper, is not a war of aggression now is it?

I guess you chose to totally ignore Dayan's statement, as to why these tractors were there in the first place.

Figures.

Next you'll be calling Dayan a left-wing radical, useful idiot.

:)
 
An armored tractor is not a military vehicle. Its just a piece of farming equipment with armor plating. :)

No, it was a military vehicle, owned and operated by the IDF, intended (and mainly used for) combat engineering like building fortifications and towing disabled IFVs. Probably the Caterpillar D9, which has been in continuous use with the IDF since the '50's. It's basically an armored bulldozer with a digging blade on the back end.
 
Thunder has actually disputed this before!
What? The concept?

Especially when Syria has a few artillery and armored divisions taking pot shots at a piece of farming equipment in Israel. Or that the Egyptians pushed the UN out of the DMZ in the Sinai without warning. Or that the Jordanian artillery was striking W. J'lem while at the time having a defense pact with Egypt.

Dayan wasn't a fool knowing full well that Syria and the current armistice line wasn't going to hold out the Arab league for long...
 
dude, I already told you....do not confuse these guys with facts.

facts are their enemy. Facts, can even be anti-Semitic, if used to discredit their values and ideas. :)

You've had your own problems with the facts behind the '67 war. Syria did everything short of sending their own military into Israel to provoke an Israeli military response.

Israel sent IDF tractors into the DMZ for the Syrians to shoot at, yes. But that wasn't the first shot fired in the escalating exchange that led to the IAF blowing the hell out of the Egyptian and Syrian air forces while they were still on the ground.
 
Israel sent IDF tractors into the DMZ for the Syrians to shoot at, yes. But that wasn't the first shot fired in the escalating exchange that led to the IAF blowing the hell out of the Egyptian and Syrian air forces while they were still on the ground.

Never said it was. But the fact is, Syria did not mass troops on the cease-fire line with Israel. Therefore an attack on Syria was not justified.

If aggressive behavior by one side against another, justifies invasion and territorial conquest, then Syria was just as justified as Israel was, in a pre-emptive war.
 
Or that the Egyptians pushed the UN out of the DMZ in the Sinai without warning. Or that the Jordanian artillery was striking W. J'lem while at the time having a defense pact with Egypt.

This has nothing to do with Syria, the Golan, military highground, etc etc.

In other words, its a derail. Or at least a diversion.
 
No, it was a military vehicle, owned and operated by the IDF, intended (and mainly used for) combat engineering like building fortifications and towing disabled IFVs. Probably the Caterpillar D9, which has been in continuous use with the IDF since the '50's. It's basically an armored bulldozer with a digging blade on the back end.
Rubbish. It was a tractor with extra plating. A tractor is not a bulldozer either.

And no need to go all linky here as I'm a reservist in the IDF in search and rescue which specializes in D9's and other heavy machinery.

One doesn't going farming in a D9 and to my knowledge there were no armored D9's during the '67 war. The Americans also took a bit to find out the uses of an armored D9 during Vietnam as well.
 
This has nothing to do with Syria, the Golan, military highground, etc etc.

In other words, its a derail. Or at least a diversion.
Nope. Its another fact of inconvenience for you.

I wouldn't feel all too comfortable having artillery/tank divisions overlooking most of your country, the same country that attacked without provocation along with several other countries to curb stomp your country in '48. Nothing was different in '67 apart from more weapons.

Concept of higher ground still stands. Dayan understood it, its about time you did as well.
 
Last edited:
Never said it was. But the fact is, Syria did not mass troops on the cease-fire line with Israel. Therefore an attack on Syria was not justified.

Troop massing was not the reason Israel attacked. It was the escalating Palestinian terrorist attacks (supported by Syria), as well as direct Syrian actions like shelling attacks from the Golan Heights. Tit-for-tat IDF retaliation wasn't effective in ending these attacks, so Israel decided to strike.

Jordan and Egypt were drawn in because they, in fact, were massing troops on their respective borders with Israel, and because Egypt had a defensive pact with Syria (meaning they'd join in the fight anyway if Israel attacked Syria alone).

EDIT: The head of the UAC, in fact, was pissed at Syria because their actions prodding Israel into war on Israel's terms before the military preparations of the Arab states were complete, when he in fact wanted a war on the Arab states' terms.
 
Last edited:
Concept of higher ground still stands. Dayan understood it, its about time you did as well.

Perhaps you should do just 30 seconds of research on Moshe Dayan, before you speak for him:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moshe_Dayan#Six_Day_War_.281967.29

"He confessed[10][11]:

I made a mistake in allowing the Israel conquest of the Golan Heights. As defense minister I should have stopped it because the Syrians were not threatening us at the time [fourth day of the war].

"He also portrayed the desire of the residents in the Kibutzim beneath the Golan Heights that they be captured as stemming from the desire for their agricultural land and not primarily for security reasons."


sorry Bigjel, had to do it. :D
 
Never said it was. But the fact is, Syria did not mass troops on the cease-fire line with Israel. Therefore an attack on Syria was not justified.
No, but this didn't stop the Soviets falsely stating that Israel was amassing troops along the Syrian border.

If aggressive behavior by one side against another, justifies invasion and territorial conquest, then Syria was just as justified as Israel was, in a pre-emptive war.
Syria's continued shelling and sending Syrian trained Palestinian fedayeen (a practice that was to continue to this day) in Israel, Jordan's shelling of Jerusalem, Egypt's eviction of UN troops and closing of the straits of tiran were considered acts of war.

Taking the Golan Heights the 2nd time around, thus the higher ground, was justifiable.
 
Rubbish. It was a tractor with extra plating. A tractor is not a bulldozer either.

Do you know what model of vehicle it was, then? I can't seem to find any better of a description than simply "armored tractor" (which even Michael Oren called it in his book).

I'm honestly curious, since I assumed it was a D9 based on the limited info I could find, but you know what they say about assuming...

One doesn't going farming in a D9 and to my knowledge there were no armored D9's during the '67 war.

Well, it didn't seem like the Israelis were interested in actually farming anything, when they sent these vehicles (whatever they were) into the DMZ.
 
Well, the "bait" was a military vehicle crossing the DMZ, which makes a military response a bit more understandable.

If a full scale military attack is an appropriate response to illegally ploughing a field, why is it inappropriate response to firing rockets at schools and other civilian targets week after week?
 
Perhaps you should do just 30 seconds of research on Moshe Dayan, before you speak for him:
...
sorry Bigjel, had to do it. :D
Fail at reading comprehension + 1.

Dayan understands the basic military concept of attaining the higher ground, as every military person does. Or is there something in that quote which states that he does not?

My previous post addresses the rest of the issue and what escalated to war...
 
intentionally sending in an armored plow, in order to provocate a Syrian shelling, so that Israel can attack back with air force and artillery, is an interesting way of desiring peace with one's neighbors.
 
If a full scale military attack is an appropriate response to illegally ploughing a field, why is it inappropriate response to firing rockets at schools and other civilian targets week after week?

Second.
 
intentionally sending in an armored plow, in order to provocate a Syrian shelling, so that Israel can attack back with air force and artillery, is an interesting way of desiring peace with one's neighbors.

Implying it is entirely proportional to attack a(n) (armored)tractor with artillery. Were the Syrians really that twitchy? Again, implying you wouldn't mind the Golan Heights being held by trigger-happy enemies who previously attempted to conquer your country.
 
Fail at reading comprehension + 1..

now now, you know better than to attack other members. :D

Dayan understands the basic military concept of attaining the higher ground, as every military person does.

Oh, I'm sure Dayan understood the very basic concept of attaining the high ground. As do I.

However, contrary to your amazing and highly decorated military career and experience, Dayan felt that Israel did not need to conquer the Golan, especially for any reasons of security.

;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom