What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

Before the US allied with Egypt: Several disastrous wars which almost collapsed the country.

After the US allied with Egypt: No wars.

Why was the US wrong to prevent wars and social collapse in Egypt?

Not to mention: after helping negotiate a peace deal in which they got half their country back, which they'd lost in a war they started themselves.
 
Not to mention: after helping negotiate a peace deal in which they got half their country back, which they'd lost in a war they started themselves.

The evils of the US empire. Creating peace and getting the aggressor's territory back.

Founding_Fathers.gif
 
Last edited:
Before the US allied with Egypt: Several disastrous wars which almost collapsed the country.

After the US allied with Egypt: No wars.

Why was the US wrong to prevent wars and social collapse in Egypt?

Not wrong to prevent war, but is it right to support someone who doesn't value basic human rights?
 
If it stops the Arabs from fighting, yes.

I'm not sure I accept the premise that the only two possibilities were "a ruler who suspends free elections and bans political parties that oppose him" and "war". If the US wanted to get invested in Egypt to the tune of $1 billion a year, they should have pushed for true democracy and decent human rights, rather than settling for economic stability across the region a large amount of middle eastern oil is transported through.
 
The US supported Stalin against Hitler to the tune of Billions of dollars per YEAR in aid without similar compunctions about Human Rights. Heck, they gasve him the Lienz Cossacks. Does that makie it wrong to support dictators?

Remember Stokes, Hillary Clinton and the State Department (heck, every diplomat ever) are aware that foreign policy and diplomacy, especially for a power like the USA, is NOT about roleplaying a Paladin from DnD, which would be utterly stupid
 
Last edited:
If it stops the Arabs from fighting, yes.

ahh.....the truth comes out.

A brutal and repressive Arab dictatorship is ok as long as it doesn't go to war with Israel. Interesting priorities you got there.

But you know what? You ain't alone, cause Israel feels the EXACT same way. In fact, its reported that they have urged the world to be nice to Mubarak.

http://www.haaretz.com/print-editio...to-curb-criticism-of-egypt-s-mubarak-1.340238

...and the Israelis still naively/dishonestly wonder why the Muslim/Arab street hates Israel to the core.
 
Last edited:
The US supported Stalin against Hitler to the tune of Billions of dollars per YEAR in aid without similar compunctions about Human Rights. Heck, they gasve him the Lienz Cossacks. Does that makie it wrong to support dictators?

Remember Stokes, Hillary Clinton and the State Department (heck, every diplomat ever) are aware that foreign policy and diplomacy, especially for a power like the USA, is NOT about roleplaying a Paladin from DnD, which would be utterly stupid

No, that doesn't make it wrong to support dictators. But the US didn't continue supporting stalin after the war, and in fact actively opposed him because they disagreed with many aspects of his leadership, including (but obviously not limited to) his lack of respect for human rights. By contrast, Mubarak was supported long after the war with israel had ended. The US were right to apply diplomatic solutions to the war between Egypt and Israel, but they were wrong to fund a dictator for 30 years. They should have pressed harder for a fair democracy and better human rights. A cynic would suggest that their real interest was economic stability in the regions they relied upon for oil, rather than prevention of war or respect for human rights.
 
No, that doesn't make it wrong to support dictators. But the US didn't continue supporting stalin after the war, and in fact actively opposed him because they disagreed with many aspects of his leadership, including (but obviously not limited to) his lack of respect for human rights. By contrast, Mubarak was supported long after the war with israel had ended. The US were right to apply diplomatic solutions to the war between Egypt and Israel, but they were wrong to fund a dictator for 30 years. They should have pressed harder for a fair democracy and better human rights. A cynic would suggest that their real interest was economic stability in the regions they relied upon for oil, rather than prevention of war or respect for human rights.

You are aware that perhaps they had evaluated the viability of democracy in Egypt at that time and had concluded that democracy is not viable, and that sometimes, a dictatorship was prefereable to the alternatives, especially as the MB (who were more radical then than now) were very active IIRC (they even assassinated Sadat for signing the Peace Treaty).

Remmeber, diplomats are aware that foreign policy should NOT be about being the Paladin, which would be ******* stupid. Rather, they are about securing their nation's interests as much as possible, rather than some lofty idealism which isn't viable.
 
Last edited:
The US supported Stalin against Hitler to the tune of Billions of dollars per YEAR in aid without similar compunctions about Human Rights.

um...we were trying to save Europe and North Africa from Nazi domination. tough choices had to be made.

but as soon as the war was over, Stalin was no longer our "buddy" and we demanded freedom in the USSR.

the Egyptian people, like the Iraqi people before them, deserve democracy and freedom and we should help them achieve it.


............or is a nation without oil less deserving of democracy?
 
I'd say that the democratic forces in Egypt should be supported, seeing as the Mubarak regime is no longer viable.

The US trying to peg post-1978 aid to Egypt to Human Rights would be like doing the same for Chiang Kai Shek's China.
 
Last edited:
You are aware that perhaps they had evaluated the viability of democracy in Egypt at that time and had concluded that democracy is not viable, and that sometimes, a dictatorship was prefereable to the alternatives, especially as the MB (who were more radical then than now) were very active IIRC (they even assassinated Sadat for signing the Peace Treaty).

Remmeber, diplomats are aware that foreign policy should NOT be about being the Paladin, which would be ******* stupid. Rather, they are about securing their nation's interests as much as possible, rather than some lofty idealism which isn't viable.

Well, first off, leave that poor strawman alone. I've talked to him about his rampant idealism, and he doesn't need you rubbing it in.

My personal view is that pragmatism is favourable, but that supporting a dictator isn't a particularly compelling form of pragmatism if you cannot explain why a better alternative isn't possible. The existence of the muslim brotherhood is not a good excuse for avoiding proper democracy, especially since it is not our place to decide for the egyptian people who runs egypt. If we fostered a fair election, and the egyptians elected islamists, that is their choice and we have no right to tell them otherwise.

Is it not supposed to be american foreign policy to promote freedom and democracy? Why exactly was egypt exempted from this? We are quite clearly seeing on the news now that free elections are what the egyptian people want.
 
The US was supporting Mubarak. They did NOT set him in power.

and US policy around the time of Camp David was Peace, no matter the cost. In the Global context, it was the containment of the Soviet Union no matter the cost, and was when Human Rights played second fiddle as any tool short of kicking off the apocalypse was deemed necessary. It was particularly pruident for Reagan and Bush snr not to push human rights in Afghanistan, where such a policy would not have been viable.

And you seriously underestimate the strength of the Brotherhood in contemporary 1970s-80s (NOT Present) Egypt.

And Supporting the Egyptian dictatorship was considered at the time to be better than letting the Middle East become a charnel house if the Israelis used nukes in their next conflict with the other reginal powers such as Jordan or Syria or Egypt. And dropping an ally faster than a tonne of bricks due to being anything less than a paragon of human rights (which is what RPing the paladin would have done) is very undiplomatic. Has the US cut off all relations with China due to their atrocious Human Rights Record?

And remmeber, the US doesn't dmand democracy because of what they learned from WW1 and Woodrow Wilson's policy, which led to Weimar and Hitler due to Weimar's failings. It isn't just about political systems and ideals, it's also about cultures, Social issues, societies, international relations and so many other variable other than "human rights now!". Look at Afghanistan today, which is a mess, while Iraqi democracy is limping along.

And i know this reeks of Godwin, ut should the US have let the Nazis remain in power because they were elected?
 
Last edited:
And i know this reeks of Godwin, ut should the US have let the Nazis remain in power because they were elected?

if they weren't running around breaking international treaties, invading neighboring countries, murdering innocent civilians including their own citizens?

sure.

countries have the right to demand that other nations become more democratic and free. but we don't have the right to call for total political regime change unless the circumstances truly demand it.
 
Last edited:
If it stops the Arabs from fighting, yes.

You seem to have this vile attitude towards Arab people. In fact, it is deeply, deeply ugly.

'The Arabs', 'The Arabs' you keep saying. As if they are a monolithic block.
 
ahh.....the truth comes out.

A brutal and repressive Arab dictatorship is ok as long as it doesn't go to war with Israel. Interesting priorities you got there.

But you know what? You ain't alone, cause Israel feels the EXACT same way. In fact, its reported that they have urged the world to be nice to Mubarak.

...and the Israelis still naively/dishonestly wonder why the Muslim/Arab street hates Israel to the core.

And why should Israelis feel any different? Give me a show of hands. Who wants to die under the tank treads of Egypt's wonderful new democracy?

Is your hand up, Thunder?

As soon as the Egyptians create themselves a peaceful democracy, all the problems you're whining about will disappear, as if by majic.

"Physician, heal thyself."
 
ahh.....the truth comes out.

A brutal and repressive Arab dictatorship is ok as long as it doesn't go to war with Israel. Interesting priorities you got there.

And each other.

But you know what? You ain't alone, cause Israel feels the EXACT same way. In fact, its reported that they have urged the world to be nice to Mubarak.

Israel doesn't prefer war? Wow, would would have thought that?

...and the Israelis still naively/dishonestly wonder why the Muslim/Arab street hates Israel to the core.

They hate Israel because it's successful.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom