What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

Broken_Bones_Not_Spirit1.jpg

Broken Bones, not Broken Spirit
 
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110211/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_egypt

Mubarak has fled to the Sinai.

Is he going to remain there? that might be a good concession.

if he agrees to remain there until the end of his term, I think the protesters should go home.

Why should they give up trying to get him out of office, just because he moves base? The will of the egyptian people appears to be to strip him of all power, not to alter the geographic location from which it is abused. Besides, Suleiman doesn't look much better. They should push for a free election, now.
 
Why should they give up trying to get him out of office, just because he moves base? The will of the egyptian people appears to be to strip him of all power, not to alter the geographic location from which it is abused. Besides, Suleiman doesn't look much better. They should push for a free election, now.

ummm ... he's resigned already
 
Population 1960:................................................27.8 million
Population 2008:................................................81.7 million
Current population growth rate:............................2% per annum (a 35-year doubling rate)
Population in 2046 after another doubling:..............164 million

Rainfall average over whole country:.....................~ 2 inches per year
Highest rainfall region:........................................Alexandria, 7.9 inches per year
Arable land (almost entirely in the Nile Valley):.......3%
Arable land per capita:........................................0.04 Ha (400 m2)
Arable land per capita in 2043:.............................0.02 Ha
Food imports:...................................................40% of requirements
Grain imports:......................................... .........60% of requirements

Net oil exports:..................................................Began falling in 1997, went negative in 2007
Oil production:...................................................peaked in 1996
Cost of oil:.......................................................rising steeply
Cost of oil and food:............................................tightly linked

source: 'Egypt's Warning: Are You Listening?'


~~~~~~~~~~~

'Why Egypt Will Not Be Another Iran'

"Some prominent congressional leaders and media pundits, in a cynical effort to mislead the American public into supporting the Mubarak regime in Egypt and opposing the popular nonviolent struggle for democracy, have raised the specter of Egypt’s government falling into the hands of radical Islamists who would attack Israel and support international terrorism.

To illustrate this frightening scenario, these apologists for authoritarianism try to compare the current pro-democracy uprising against the U.S.-backed Egyptian dictatorship of Hosni Mubarak with the 1978-79 insurrection against the U.S.-backed Iranian dictatorship of Shah Reza Pahlavi.
"
 
Can you link us to some of this evidence?

This is the sort of thing I'm referring to. I've already referenced it, possibly in this very thread, but I can't remember where - there's been so many threads about Egypt recently!

The American Embassy in Cairo helped a young dissident attend a US-sponsored summit for activists in New York, while working to keep his identity secret from Egyptian state police.
 
If this is true, it will increase my respect for US foreign policy. Do you have some evidence? My understanding was that the vast majority of support to egypt went on their military.

The vast majority of aid has been military, but the vast majority of that military aid has been hardware, not cash.

This Paper extensively covers US Aid to Egypt, but it's quite long so I've quoted the relevant passages below.

The amount of foreign assistance going to Egypt from the U.S. has remained high through the present day, despite concerns about the existence of democracy or democratization in Egypt. These concerns, however, have started to show in the distribution of funds.

Per the “Glide Path Agreement” made in 1998, in which Egypt accepted an “assistance phase-down” over the course of 10 years, FMF assistance will be held constant while economic assistance is reduced by $40 million each year.

More recently, in 2007, the U.S. declared that it would be providing $13 billion in military assistance over ten years, which was a clear sign to the Egyptian regime that it could rely on U.S. strategic support.

Though Mubarak now has guaranteed military assistance for the next few years, the U.S. has been trying to reduce economic assistance because of Mubarak’s increasing unwillingness to accept conditioned aid and in hopes of eventually building stronger trade relations.

Over the past few years, economic assistance to Egypt has not only declined, but has also been earmarked for USAID education and health projects, as well as for democracy programs. The funding towards democracy programs will “[include] direct grants to Egyptian NGOs,” the outcome of which could be a democratic challenge to the Mubarak regime.

This Blog provides some more information.

The administration of former president George W. Bush had threatened to link military assistance to Egypt’s human rights progress [9], but it didn’t follow through. When exiled Egyptian dissident, Saad Eddin Ibrahim, called on the U.S. government to attach conditions to aid to Egypt, U.S. officials dismissed the idea as unrealistic [10].

...

Funding for programs that promote democracy and good governance through direct funding to NGOs in Egypt averaged about $24 million from fiscal year 1999 to 2009. But these, too, had “limited impact,” due to “a lack of Egyptian government cooperation [16],” according to an October 2009 inspector general audit [PDF]:

The Government of Egypt has resisted USAID/Egypt’s democracy and governance program and has suspended the activities of many U.S. NGOs because Egyptian officials thought these organizations were too aggressive.

Recently released cables from WikiLeaks show that officials within the Egyptian government have asked that USAID stop financing organizations [17] that were “not properly registered as NGOs” with the Egyptian government. AFP reports on a 2007 embassy cable that describes President Mubarak as “deeply skeptical of the US role in democracy promotion.”

Per the Egyptian government’s complaints, the U.S. now limits its funding to NGOs registered with the government, therefore excluding most human rights groups [18], Huffington Post reported. Such funding has also declined sharply under the Obama administration.

USAID's own website outlines their programs in Egypt:

For over three decades, the United States has worked to improve the quality of life of all Egyptians through programs supporting economic development and regional stability. USAID assistance has totaled $28.6 billion since 1975. Current programs focus on economic growth; education; healthier, planned families; and democracy and governance.


The general picture this draws is that the USA has two distinct attitudes to aid to Egypt. The bigger part - the military aid - is without conditions - despite some murmurings of maybe making it otherwise - as the benefits for the USA were seen to outweigh conflict from forcing the issue.

Interestingly on this point, I think Toontown has raised a really good point, which is that the behaviour displayed by the Egyptian Army is almost certainly a result of the close ties between them and the USA. In a way, the unconditional military aid has been a sort of "back door" democratization of Egypt (whether intended or not) because it has instilled the Egyptian military with the ideologies about protecting the people that are inherent in western military forces but notably absent from Egypt's history (this is the same military that in the past has not hesitated to get involved in the dirty work itself).

Having a military and police force that actually values and stands for democracy is, I think, a vital component in ensuring a state's continued democracy. It's one of the crucial missing ingredients missing from the world's many failed democratic states. I don't now whether the US had intended this effect, or if they even thought about it at all, but it's an interesting consequence.

Now, the remaining non-military aid is where my point lies. The military aid has always clearly been unconditional, but this equally clearly hasn't historically been the case with the rest of the aid. Indeed all of these works speak of tensions between the USA trying to implement democratic reform funding, and Mubarak trying to resist it. It was only with the current US administration that they finally backed down and started giving the aid only to approved organisations, but at the same time we see they switched to funding Egyptian organisations directly - essentially side stepping the issue of Mubarak's protests.

In other words, he wasn't passing on the funding to group X, so the USA has stopped giving the funding to Mubarak and is just giving it to group X directly.

Couple that with the wikileak cable that indicates the US Embassy in Egypt was covertly supporting Anti-Mubarak supporters, and I think you can make a good case that the US's support for Mubarak was not as firm as people might like to claim, and was more about supporting someone who could keep things stable until democracy could take its place.

And to me, that's the only really smart way to get democratic reform. You might be condemned as supporting dictators, but at least you'll get real democracy, eventually.

I think the USA has probably learned by now that when you just storm in, remove a dictator, and thrust democracy on a people, it doesn't work.
 
It'll be interesting to see if the military keep Mubarak's promise of free and fair elections in September, or if they'll come up with some excuse to turn Eygpt into a bigger miltary dictatorship.
 
It'll be interesting to see if the military keep Mubarak's promise of free and fair elections in September, or if they'll come up with some excuse to turn Eygpt into a bigger miltary dictatorship.

i doubt it. the Egyptian military is the sole recipient of American aid & that will end if they do not make a clear path to democracy.
 
i doubt it. the Egyptian military is the sole recipient of American aid & that will end if they do not make a clear path to democracy.

I hope they're also thinking about what Khomeini did to the officer corps in Iran, and how the power and influence of the army there was reduced in favor of ideological militias like the Pasdaran.
 
The general picture this draws is that the USA has two distinct attitudes to aid to Egypt. The bigger part - the military aid - is without conditions - despite some murmurings of maybe making it otherwise - as the benefits for the USA were seen to outweigh conflict from forcing the issue.

Also handy for the US torture program.

Interestingly on this point, I think Toontown has raised a really good point, which is that the behaviour displayed by the Egyptian Army is almost certainly a result of the close ties between them and the USA. In a way, the unconditional military aid has been a sort of "back door" democratization of Egypt (whether intended or not) because it has instilled the Egyptian military with the ideologies about protecting the people that are inherent in western military forces but notably absent from Egypt's history (this is the same military that in the past has not hesitated to get involved in the dirty work itself).

Egypt's army 'involved in detentions and torture'

Military accused by human rights campaigners of targeting hundreds of anti-government protesters


"The Egyptian military has secretly detained hundreds and possibly thousands of suspected government opponents since mass protests against President Hosni Mubarak began, and at least some of these detainees have been tortured, according to testimony gathered by the Guardian.

The military has claimed to be neutral, merely keeping anti-Mubarak protesters and loyalists apart. But human rights campaigners say this is clearly no longer the case, accusing the army of involvement in both disappearances and torture – abuses Egyptians have for years associated with the notorious state security intelligence (SSI) but not the army.

...

"They put me in a room. An officer came and asked me who was paying me to be against the government. When I said I wanted a better government he hit me across the head and I fell to the floor. Then soldiers started kicking me. One of them kept kicking me between my legs," he said.

"They got a bayonet and threatened to rape me with it. Then they waved it between my legs. They said I could die there or I could disappear into prison and no one would ever know. The torture was painful but the idea of disappearing in a military prison was really frightening."
"
 
Last edited:
Before the US allied with Egypt: Several disastrous wars which almost collapsed the country.

After the US allied with Egypt: No wars.

Why was the US wrong to prevent wars and social collapse in Egypt?
I bet the idea of a free Egypt really burns you doesn't? It is okay, because I value the freedom of any people more than some dictator that you support.

Oh and to the answer your "question", we should not be in the business of controlling other countries. I would rather not have another war criminal "Gipper" giving the thumbs up to death squads raping and murdering nuns on my conscience.
 
Last edited:
Interestingly on this point, I think Toontown has raised a really good point, which is that the behaviour displayed by the Egyptian Army is almost certainly a result of the close ties between them and the USA. In a way, the unconditional military aid has been a sort of "back door" democratization of Egypt (whether intended or not) because it has instilled the Egyptian military with the ideologies about protecting the people that are inherent in western military forces but notably absent from Egypt's history (this is the same military that in the past has not hesitated to get involved in the dirty work itself).

Having a military and police force that actually values and stands for democracy is, I think, a vital component in ensuring a state's continued democracy. It's one of the crucial missing ingredients missing from the world's many failed democratic states. I don't now whether the US had intended this effect, or if they even thought about it at all, but it's an interesting consequence.


Army muscling in on protestors:


11.07am: An update from Chris McGreal, in Tahrir Square, who confirms that more people are making their way to the central plaza:

Many more people are coming in to Tahrir square apparently in response to a call from the remaining protesters not to let the army force them out. the military had got the traffic flowing earlier today but the demonstrators are now sitting down in the road and blocking the roundabout after soldiers ripped up their tents and told them to go home.


10.58am: There will be no major reshuffle of Egypt's cabinet, which was appointed by Mubarak, reports Reuters. That goes to the heart of the concerns of those who are still in Tahrir Square and who are demanding that the army move towards immediate transition.

Not only has the army been using force on protesters in Tahrir Square but now the demonstrators have to swallow the fact that the interim cabinet is going to be one appointed by Mubarak and therefore filled with his allies.


10.48am: It sounds like the army's behaviour in Tahrir Square has provoked many people back into action, with thousands reportedly on their way to the central plaza to show solidarity with the protesters who have refused to be forced out by the army.


http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/blog/2011/feb/13/egypt-transition
 
Last edited:
10.58am: There will be no major reshuffle of Egypt's cabinet, which was appointed by Mubarak, reports Reuters. That goes to the heart of the concerns of those who are still in Tahrir Square and who are demanding that the army move towards immediate transition.


Immediate transition to what? Military rule? Muzz Bro rule? Tent city rule?

Not only has the army been using force on protesters in Tahrir Square but now the demonstrators have to swallow the fact that the interim cabinet is going to be one appointed by Mubarak and therefore filled with his allies.

Compared to what? What group is offering itself as a viable alternative to the existing cabinet?

Muzz Bros?

10.48am: It sounds like the army's behaviour in Tahrir Square has provoked many people back into action, with thousands reportedly on their way to the central plaza to show solidarity with the protesters who have refused to be forced out by the army.


They wanted Mubarak out. Mubarak is out. Parliament dissolved. Interim military rule implemented. Now what? They want to go to the movies? And then the zoo?
 
http://www.jpost.com/MiddleEast/Article.aspx?id=207938

Muslim Brotherhood says they will not seek Presidency or Parliamentary majority in Egypt.

In other news, Parky, nobody ever tells an untruth when political issues or political position are at stake ... and your pony will be arriving on a sleigh this Christmas Eve.

What is more likely is that the MB was taken a bit by surprise at the suddenness of the action in Egypt, and so are not making the mistake of leaping forward before they prepare any political ground they wish to gain or contest. Indeed, the MB might be aware that the first folks to replace Mubarak will be likely to be tossed out as well ... so why be in that group? Play the long game.

That would be a smart political strategy, from where I sit.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom