What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

The crowd just wen't from celebrating to being furious because Mubarak will still not step down..
 
Mubarak is stepping down as President. I am not an Egyptian, but I think this should be enough to satisfy the people of Egypt.

Wanting the nation not to fall into chaos is an acceptable goal.
 
CORRECTION

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110210/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_egypt

Mubarak is NOT resigning. he will retain his title, but only "transfer" his powers to the VP.

this is not good enough....and very not good.

I hope...that the military will now step in and stage a peaceful coup.

The people support the military...so this is indeed possible and will have the backing of the people. Mubarak should be arrested.

:(
 
I'm not sure I accept the premise that the only two possibilities were "a ruler who suspends free elections and bans political parties that oppose him" and "war". If the US wanted to get invested in Egypt to the tune of $1 billion a year, they should have pushed for true democracy and decent human rights, rather than settling for economic stability across the region a large amount of middle eastern oil is transported through.


You do realise that a large chunk of the hard cash support to Egypt went in the form of pro-democracy reforms and community education initiatives right? You do realise that the USA made Mubarak accept these grass-roots community initiatives as a condition of receiving the other aid, right? This current politicisation of the Egyptian people is almost certainly a direct result of that aid (indeed there's ample evidence of the US government covertly assisting Egyptian democratic reform activists).

When a country has no history of democracy, you can't just dump democracy on them and expect it to burgeon into a peaceful wonderland. That doesn't happen - instead some other muscle group comes in and fills the void (like in Iran). You've got to teach people what democracy is and make them want it (and take it) for themselves. Which is exactly what's happening.

Mubarak was a place-holder; someone who could maintain a bit of stability while the real business of democracising the Egyptian people went on. When they were sufficiently democracised they'd seize power for themselves. Mission Accomplished.
 
Cables: FBI trained Egypt’s state security ‘torturers’

"Egypt's secret police, long accused of torturing suspects and intimidating political opponents of President Hosni Mubarak, received training at the FBI's facility in Quantico, Virginia, even as US diplomats compiled allegations of brutality against them, according to US State Department cables released by WikiLeaks.

One cable, dated November 2007 and published by The Telegraph, describes a meeting between the head of the SSIS, Egypt's secret police, and FBI deputy director John Pistole, in which the secret police chief praises Pistole for the "excellent and strong" cooperation between the two agencies.
"
 
You do realise that a large chunk of the hard cash support to Egypt went in the form of pro-democracy reforms and community education initiatives right? You do realise that the USA made Mubarak accept these grass-roots community initiatives as a condition of receiving the other aid, right? This current politicisation of the Egyptian people is almost certainly a direct result of that aid (indeed there's ample evidence of the US government covertly assisting Egyptian democratic reform activists).

When a country has no history of democracy, you can't just dump democracy on them and expect it to burgeon into a peaceful wonderland. That doesn't happen - instead some other muscle group comes in and fills the void (like in Iran). You've got to teach people what democracy is and make them want it (and take it) for themselves. Which is exactly what's happening.

Mubarak was a place-holder; someone who could maintain a bit of stability while the real business of democracising the Egyptian people went on. When they were sufficiently democracised they'd seize power for themselves. Mission Accomplished.

Can you link us to some of this evidence?
 
Interesting article on how Egypt is more Berlin 89 than Iran 79:

This Egyptian uprising is about the very individual rights Tehran flouted in 2009 and Western-backed Arab security states have denied: the right to vote, to the rule of law, to freedom of expression. Almost every conversation I’ve had on the streets of Cairo this past week returns to these themes.

Israel should welcome this awakening. It is the denial of such rights by Arab despots that has given Iranian populist rhetoric such resonance on the Arab street. Nothing will shrink Iranian sway faster than Arab democracy.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/08/opinion/08iht-edcohen08.html?_r=1&emc=eta1
 
You do realise that a large chunk of the hard cash support to Egypt went in the form of pro-democracy reforms and community education initiatives right? You do realise that the USA made Mubarak accept these grass-roots community initiatives as a condition of receiving the other aid, right? This current politicisation of the Egyptian people is almost certainly a direct result of that aid (indeed there's ample evidence of the US government covertly assisting Egyptian democratic reform activists).

When a country has no history of democracy, you can't just dump democracy on them and expect it to burgeon into a peaceful wonderland. That doesn't happen - instead some other muscle group comes in and fills the void (like in Iran). You've got to teach people what democracy is and make them want it (and take it) for themselves. Which is exactly what's happening.

Mubarak was a place-holder; someone who could maintain a bit of stability while the real business of democracising the Egyptian people went on. When they were sufficiently democracised they'd seize power for themselves. Mission Accomplished.

If this is true, it will increase my respect for US foreign policy. Do you have some evidence? My understanding was that the vast majority of support to egypt went on their military.
 
CORRECTION

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110210/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_egypt

Mubarak is NOT resigning. he will retain his title, but only "transfer" his powers to the VP.

this is not good enough....and very not good.

I hope...that the military will now step in and stage a peaceful coup.

The people support the military...so this is indeed possible and will have the backing of the people. Mubarak should be arrested.

:(

Not a supporter of free and fair elections then?
 
It shouldn't. There's nothing unusual about power brokers spreading their bets by backing both sides.

True, but this would mean that the US had been backing the right side, and had actually had the correct ideology in mind as a long term plan. As I said, I had assumed from reading various newspapers and watching tv channels that the aid being given to egypt by the US was primarily military aid - if gumboot can show otherwise, I will be very interested.
 
The title of this thread is, at last, out of date.

What will happen to Egypt now that Mubarak has fallen?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom