What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

I agree with Darth Rotor's assessment. The Muslim Brotherhood seem to be caught off guard by the suddenness and stregth of the protests. Over all I find that to be a positive. The economic woes facing Egypt are going to be dificult and painful to resolve. I doubt the Muslim Brotherhood has the capability to do so quickly without losing support, if they have the capability to do so even in the long term at all. Whoever, as a party or as an individual, takes up efforts to correct the woes will need quite a bit of trust. Being forced out without achieving quick resolution is a strong possibility.
 
I agree with Darth Rotor's assessment. The Muslim Brotherhood seem to be caught off guard by the suddenness and stregth of the protests. Over all I find that to be a positive. The economic woes facing Egypt are going to be dificult and painful to resolve. I doubt the Muslim Brotherhood has the capability to do so quickly without losing support, if they have the capability to do so even in the long term at all. Whoever, as a party or as an individual, takes up efforts to correct the woes will need quite a bit of trust. Being forced out without achieving quick resolution is a strong possibility.
The MB has no chance at all of improving the Egyptian economy if they managed to take control, since the first thing they would do is start giving material support to terroist groups like Hamas which would trigger economic sanctions on Egypt by the US and others. A point I'd like to see Obama make clear at some time.
 
I agree with Darth Rotor's assessment. The Muslim Brotherhood seem to be caught off guard by the suddenness and stregth of the protests. Over all I find that to be a positive. The economic woes facing Egypt are going to be dificult and painful to resolve. I doubt the Muslim Brotherhood has the capability to do so quickly without losing support, if they have the capability to do so even in the long term at all. Whoever, as a party or as an individual, takes up efforts to correct the woes will need quite a bit of trust. Being forced out without achieving quick resolution is a strong possibility.

Note the demographic reality ... the relative youth of the population in Egypt. Fickle and emotional often goes with that characteristic ...
 
The MB has no chance at all of improving the Egyptian economy if they managed to take control, since the first thing they would do is start giving material support to terroist groups like Hamas which would trigger economic sanctions on Egypt by the US and others. A point I'd like to see Obama make clear at some time.

I am not sure that would be the wise course for the US to take at this moment. A clear condemnation at this point could rally support behind the MB in a gesture of rejecting outsider influence. I agree that the traditional goals of the MB weigh heavily against them solving the problems that sparked the current protests. There appears to be major factionalism within the MB, and their taking a hard line conservative stance could see it dissolve as the leading force. The MPs elected in recent years for instance had a focus on democratic reforms rather than traditional Muslim values. The online activists tend towards being critical of traditional opposition to female and Copt participation. These elements seem in clear contraditction to the direction the leadership suggests. I hope, but have no idea how realisitc the possibility is, that a truly islamic secular movement could be started akin to christian secular movements in Europe. Even though that is not ideal it would be a nice step. If Egypt rallies behind a hard line aggressive against Israel stance I think that would be the more proper time to express our disapproval.

What I would like to see is offers of assistance in transition. Not military support but, constitutional experts, election experts, professional election observers that sort of thing. With the idea of supporting building up an actual election with campaigns instead of a too quick sudden flash prone to hasty decisions. Make it clear that foreign relations and policies should be held off until a legitimate rule is instated and that any transition government attempting foreign policy before so is being presumptuous of the Egyptian people's goals. I feel the less we dictate and more offer support and assistance the better the chances are for an improved outcome. It is a risk, but I think liberty is worth taking risks for.
 
That isn't encouraging. It's also ironic in that unions have been very active lately (3,000 strikes from 2004 to 2010, for example, and some improvement in workers' rights), and were one of the key parts of the coalition against Mubarak. In fact, the April 6 Youth Movement (which is one of the organizers of the broader anti-Mubarak movement) started three years ago because of a massive textile strike in Mahalla, Egypt.
 
The MB has no chance at all of improving the Egyptian economy if they managed to take control, since the first thing they would do is start giving material support to terroist groups like Hamas which would trigger economic sanctions on Egypt by the US and others. A point I'd like to see Obama make clear at some time.

Maybe Iranian oil will subsidize welfare programs like they do in south Lebanon and Gaza. An old commie trick. Good for propaganda, but you can't run a society on it. That's going to be difficult since Iranian corruption has almost looted the economy dry, it's being squeezed with sanctions and Egypt is an enormous population compared to Gaza and Hezbollahistan.

I guess they could pull a North Korea and blackmail other countries into paying up.

So Egypt is going to have to figure out a way to feed itself. Demagoguery and blaming the Jews can't hold that off forever.
 
Interesting interview with Middle East expert, Tariq Ali, discussing the role of the United States, and the nature of the Egyptian uprising. He compares the situation to the wave of uprisings against the Asrto-Hungarian emperor and the Czar of Russia in 1848 rather than 1989 East European revolts. The equivalent emperor today is the President of the United States and the rulers the US has put in power in Arab states.

'Egypt fed up with foreign bullying - people won't accept new stooge'

 
Tariq Ali supported the jihadis in Iraq and called for the murder of elected Iraqi politicians. That's one reason I don't listen to Tariq Ali.
 
Interesting interview with Middle East expert, Tariq Ali, discussing the role of the United States, and the nature of the Egyptian uprising. He compares the situation to the wave of uprisings against the Asrto-Hungarian emperor and the Czar of Russia in 1848 rather than 1989 East European revolts. The equivalent emperor today is the President of the United States and the rulers the US has put in power in Arab states.

'Egypt fed up with foreign bullying - people won't accept new stooge'


OK...scapegoat identified. Again.

Now what? Waves of uprisings leading to communism? No, something tells me that's not exactly what old Tariq has in mind.
 
http://www.alarabiya.net/articles/2011/02/17/138093.html

Banned Qaradawi returns to lead Friday prayers in Egypt

And why was he banned?

Perhaps because of his extremist views. Sheikh Al-Qaradawi offered rebuttals against those who issued statements criticizing suicide bombings, especially against Israelis. When Tantawi and others issued statements condemning such action in the 2000s, he responded that their statements were a betrayal. He maintained that Israelis were not civilians but combatants in a war of occupation. And he also has not done much to change the more extreme aspects of Sharia law that would simply not be tolerable in the US. In fact, he has stated that "secularism is incompatible with Islam" (http://www.saudigazette.com.sa/index.cfm?method=home.regcon&contentID=2010061175024 ). He said "the call for secularism among Muslims is atheism and a rejection of Islam. Its acceptance as a basis for rule in place of Shari’ah is downright apostasy." This view is TOTALLY incompatible with the way we do things in America. Isn't it? So why are democrats celebrating?
 
Egypt fed up with foreign bullying - people won't accept new stooge'

That is a sensible position for the average Egyptian to take. A nice homegrown Egyptian stooge would be far more to their liking. Quite frankly, I think it would be nice for a more homegrown power structure to emerge.

Good luck in finding one, now that the year is 2011 and nobody gets left alone.

Welcome to the Globalized world, JJane. Sadly for many nations trying to come to terms with who they are, or want to be as nations, they won't have, as America did, four years to slaughter and kill one another without much of any interference from foreigners. That bloodletting seems to be an effective way of figuring out a way ahead, for better and worse.

Note what happened to my neighbors just south of here, in Mexico. They had a lot of foreign interference in their various revolutions, and civil wars. Too bad, as I think that is part of why Mexico remains a mess.)

Egypt? If you look at economic potential, demographics, they don't appear to me to have much margin for error when trying to get it right.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom