What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

;)


why do you need evidence? Tell him, Wildcat:

Originally Posted by WildCat [qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/helloworld2/buttons/viewpost.gif[/qimg]
He made the claim, he should provide the evidence. That's the way it works here.

Whatever. It's not that I don't have evidence to counter Chomsky's bald assertions. It's just that I don't need any. One reasonable assertion is more than adequate to counter any group of bogus Chumpsky assertions.

If you must have evidence to support the possibility that an Egyptian government that did something very foolish might compound it's error by doing something else very foolish:

http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/4428

On 5 June 1967, at the beginning of the Six Day War, Egypt closed the Suez Canal. The closure was sudden and unexpected – fifteen cargo ships known as "The Yellow Fleet"' were trapped inside during the closure. At the end of the war, the Egyptian and Israeli armies were stationed on either side of the canal and the prospects for reopening were very uncertain. The canal remained closed until the end of a second conflict – the Yom Kippur War – and subsequent peace negotiations, eight years later.


So, it seems that it was only the peace negotiations and the subsequent 1.3 billion annual payoff to Egypt that got the canal reopened after 8 years and another ignorant war.
 
@ BAC: WTF does Code Pink have to do with Egyptian politics? IIRC, this is the NON US politics forum.

You best ask The Muslim Brotherhood, DR. They've allowed members of Code Pink to speak at their events in the past several years. They've been an active go between between Obama and Hamas (a Muslim Brotherhood *chapter*). And apparently Code Pink was even allowed to place an advertisement on the Muslim Brotherhood website recently: http://loganswarning.com/2010/01/11/code-pink-crazies-advertise-on-muslim-brotherhood-site/ . That's curious, given that this is a supposed *women's* group and the Muslim Brotherhood advocates a religion and laws that promotes female genital mutilation, wife-beating, the stoning of women, and rules against women working, driving and many other things. Strange bed*fellows* indeed.

Perhaps you should ask Code Pink, which currently has a dozen or so members actively working with the *pro-democracy* protestors ... even gathering money for them here in the states (http://bigpeace.com/taylorking/2011...ng-tax-exempt-money-to-overthrow-egypt-govta/ ). This is about Code Pink because Code Pink is interfering in NON US politics (perhaps in violation of US laws, by the way, given their tax exempt status).

Here's something that one of the founders of Code Pink published on Michael Moore's website:

http://michaelmoore.com/words/mike-friends-blog/not-leaving-until-hosni-does

February 2nd, 2011

Tonight our CODEPINK delegation in Cairo returned to Tahrir Square after the terrible events of this afternoon, when Mubarak's thugs busted up their peaceful protest with rocks, sticks and molotov cocktails. Hundreds have been wounded--their hands, legs, arms wrapped in bloody bandages. Despite the beatings, thousands of people are still camped out in the square--absolutely determined to stay there until Mubarak goes.

Imagine that. A group communists whose members have literally idolized Hugo Chavez, Che Guevara, Mao and Lenin don't like a dictator. :rolleyes: And imagine that. Some of the members of this group were among the largest contributors to the Obama campaign ... and here Obama is interfering in NON US politics ... lending support to the Muslim Brotherhood. :D
 
You best ask The Muslim Brotherhood, DR. They've allowed members of Code Pink to speak at their events in the past several years. They've been an active go between between Obama and Hamas (a Muslim Brotherhood *chapter*). And apparently Code Pink was even allowed to place an advertisement on the Muslim Brotherhood website recently: http://loganswarning.com/2010/01/11/code-pink-crazies-advertise-on-muslim-brotherhood-site/ . That's curious, given that this is a supposed *women's* group and the Muslim Brotherhood advocates a religion and laws that promotes female genital mutilation, wife-beating, the stoning of women, and rules against women working, driving and many other things. Strange bed*fellows* indeed.

Perhaps you should ask Code Pink, which currently has a dozen or so members actively working with the *pro-democracy* protestors ... even gathering money for them here in the states (http://bigpeace.com/taylorking/2011...ng-tax-exempt-money-to-overthrow-egypt-govta/ ). This is about Code Pink because Code Pink is interfering in NON US politics (perhaps in violation of US laws, by the way, given their tax exempt status).

Here's something that one of the founders of Code Pink published on Michael Moore's website:

http://michaelmoore.com/words/mike-friends-blog/not-leaving-until-hosni-does



Imagine that. A group communists whose members have literally idolized Hugo Chavez, Che Guevara, Mao and Lenin don't like a dictator. :rolleyes: And imagine that. Some of the members of this group were among the largest contributors to the Obama campaign ... and here Obama is interfering in NON US politics ... lending support to the Muslim Brotherhood. :D
Let me get this right: Code Pink is mad at Obama?

Do they ever take their plugs out, or are they afraid they'd bleed to death? :confused:
 
It's a match made in heaven; the Pinkoids and the Muzz Bros. May they live long and prosper.

On Mars.
 
any evidence whatsoever that a new Egyptian govt. would threaten their own economy and security by making such a stupid move?

What about the Arab world's extensive historical record of stupid moves?
 
What about the Arab world's extensive historical record of stupid moves?

the last Arab-Israeli war was in 1973. that's 37 years ago.

and no, precedent is not evidence of present-day intent or plan.
 
the last Arab-Israeli war was in 1973. that's 37 years ago.

and no, precedent is not evidence of present-day intent or plan.

But precedent is evidence of propensity.

For example, a pair of dice, when rolled, have a propensity to turn up 7 more often than any other discrete number. It is possible to know this by observation alone, without knowing anything about the arrangement of numbers on the dice, or the number of sides, or anything else about them.

the above remains true even if the dice have not been rolled for a long time.
 
Last edited:
But precedent is evidence of propensity.

For example, a pair of dice, when rolled, have a propensity to turn up 7 more often than any other discrete number. It is possible to know this by observation alone, without knowing anything about the arrangement of numbers on the dice, or the number of sides, or anything else about them.

the above remains true even if the dice have not been rolled for a long time.

exciting stuff. how does Connect Four and Scrabble reflect the current situation in the Middle East?

:D
 
exciting stuff. how does Connect Four and Scrabble reflect the current situation in the Middle East?

:D

The current situation in the Middle East is, as always, similar to the condition of a scrabble game after a series of fights have broken out over it.

I'm not familiar with Connect Four. Sounds like a stupid game.
 
What if we are wrong? What if our press is wrong? We see people protesting and we assume they have a legit beef. What if they are the unemployable masses of a society? What if they are the just the loudest and most visible minority? What if most of them are just blindly following because they are getting a rush out of the excitement of the moment?

What if Bob Woodward is right and Obama really has no international direction apart from what the people around him tell him and he just averages others opinions into his own?

What if Dick Cheney is right about Egypt?

I am just asking. I hope we are right. But we have been wrong a heck of a lot of times in the past.
 
What if we are wrong? What if our press is wrong? We see people protesting and we assume they have a legit beef. What if they are the unemployable masses of a society? What if they are the just the loudest and most visible minority? What if most of them are just blindly following because they are getting a rush out of the excitement of the moment?

What if Bob Woodward is right and Obama really has no international direction apart from what the people around him tell him and he just averages others opinions into his own?

What if Dick Cheney is right about Egypt?

I am just asking. I hope we are right. But we have been wrong a heck of a lot of times in the past.

What if you took the time the research your own questions, especially the first two?

You appear to be assuming that "we" have made uninformed assumptions.
 
Last edited:
http://abna.ir/data.asp?lang=3&id=224636

(Ahlul Bayt News Agency) - Spokesman of Muslim Brotherhood said that the unprecedented presence of over 7 million Egyptian people in the Friday protests shook the palace of Hosni Mubarak.

Ahmad Mersi told al-Alam news network that the Egyptian revolutionary people demand a restoration of Islamic rules in the country and an ouster of Mubarak's despotic rule.

Am I wrong in thinking here is an inherent contradiction between "Islamic rules" and democracy? ;)
 
And the islamic fundamentalists never "led" the crowds that eventually toppled the Shaw, either. Riiiiiight. :rolleyes: But look where they ended up, JJ? And look what happened to *democracy* in Iran?

Equate the two if you like, but Iran had a central theocratic figurehead in Khomeini. It was unmistakably an Islamist-led revolution ("Neither East, nor west - Islam" went the chant), with millions demanding the return of Khomeini, and millions mobbing him when he returned.

As much as you want to tie it to Iran '79, you're simply not accurate.
 
It was unmistakably an Islamist-led revolution ("Neither East, nor west - Islam" went the chant), with millions demanding the return of Khomeini

Gee ... wikipedia doesn't seem to agree with you. It says:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_Revolution

The revolution was populist, nationalist and later Shi'a Islamic.

:)

As much as you want to tie it to Iran '79, you're simply not accurate.

Again from wikipedia:

It was in part a conservative backlash against the Westernizing and secularizing efforts of the Western-backed Shah,[17] and a liberal backlash to social injustice and other shortcomings of the ancien régime.[18] The Shah was perceived by many as beholden to — if not a puppet of — a non-Muslim Western power (the United States)/

Gosh ... that sounds almost exactly like the language protestors in Egypt are voicing ... just substitute Mubarak for Shah. :)

More from wikipedia:

The first militant anti-Shah demonstrations were in October 1977, after the death of Khomeini's son Mostafa.[75] Khomeini's activists numbered "perhaps a few hundred in total", but over the coming months they grew to a mass of several thousand demonstrators in most cities of Iran.

In other words, those massive demonstration in Iran weren't all followers of Khomeini ... just a few thousand were hardcore backers at the start? Much like in Egypt.

By summer 1978 the level of protest had been at a steady state for four months — about ten thousand participants in each major city (with the exception of Isfahan where protests were larger and Tehran where they were smaller). This amounted to an "almost fully mobilized `mosque network,`" of pious Iranian Muslims, but a small minority of the more than 15 million adults in Iran.

Again, the massive demonstrations with hundreds of thousands participating couldn't have consisted of members of the "mosque network". There weren't that many of them. They had to have mostly been made of ordinary people seeking what they thought would be a "freer" society. One where they would have more say ... just as ordinary Egyptians are now being led to believe they will get "democracy" once Mubarak goes.

And according to wikipedia, when Dr Bakhtiar, the long time opposition leader in Iran, became prime minister right before the Shah fled, he "dissolved SAVAK, freed political prisoners, ordered the army to allow mass demonstrations, promised free elections and invited Khomeinists and other revolutionaries into a government of "national unity". He asked Khomeini "to create a Vatican-like state in Qom" and called "upon the opposition to help preserve the constitution." Note that Bakhtiar was an advocate of democracy and civil rights. And he had been the opposition leader.

It was ONLY THEN that the monster they'd created began to show it's true face. Sure, when Khomeini finally returned he was greeted by millions chanting "Islam, Islam, Khomeini, We Will Follow You", but how many of those really understood what they were saying? How many were just caught up in the moment and excitement, much like Obama crowds chanting "hope and change"?

In any case, the revolution didn't start out that way. It started with a relatively small number of extremists plotting, goading and directing demonstrations that grew over time, largely because of the excitement created, not because of promises of an Islamic State led by Khomeini (up to the point he returned, he'd said over and over he had no plans or asperation to lead any government in Iran).

The promise was being "freed" of the Shah's dictatorship and becoming more "freer". Even Khomeini used the word "democracy" and spoke of "freedom" many times in his pre-collapse speeches. In fact, here's a source that shows how dramatically Khomeini's language and promises changed once he was actually in power: http://www.iranian.com/Opinion/2003/August/Khomeini/ "Democracy? I meant theocracy". Before, he said "I don't want to be the leader of the Islamic Republic". Before he said "The foundation of our Islamic government is based on freedom of dialogue and will fight against any kind of censorship". Before he said "Our future society will be a free society". Before he said "We would like to run the Islamic government like Islam at its beginning, so that people know how different the Islamic democracy is from other democracies". Before he said "In the Islamic government all people have complete freedom to have any kind of opinion". But after, that all changed. Then he declared "Don't listen to those who speak of democracy. They all are against Islam". Then he said "We will break all the poison pens of those who speak of nationalism, democracy, and such things." And thus began the final transition to the harsh religious dictatorship that now is Iran.

Don't be foolish enough to think that the Muslim Brotherhood won't work the same magic in Egypt if given half a chance.
 
http://spectator.org/archives/2011/02/08/obamas-fantasies-egyptian-real

Regarding the domestic Muslim Brotherhood, Suleiman in 2006 told FBI director Robert Mueller that they had spawned "11 different Islamist extremist organizations" and that "the principal danger…was [their] exploitation of religion to influence and mobilize the public."

… snip …

Obama's talk of a pluralist democracy sprouting in Egypt -- by September at the latest -- ignores the reality of a largely illiterate populace lacking democratic institutions, where the Muslim Brotherhood forms the only strong, organized opposition to the regime in part because of its great appeal to that intensely religious populace. Impulsively backing the "protesters," nudging Mubarak-Suleiman out whether roughly or more gently, means reigniting Israeli-Egyptian conflict and handing a huge victory to the radical forces in the region.
 
The US is happy to ally itself with the theocratic Islamic called Saudi Arabia.

'It Ain't Just Mubarak -- 7 of the Worst Dictators the U.S. Is Backing to the Hilt'
But of course the main difference is that Egypt has nothing to offer, and it isn't like a like anyone from Saudi Arabia is supporting Fox News or anything...cough, Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, cough.

Oh wait...freedom fries are far superior than those damn French fries, and Egypt is going to become Iran because they are the same type of society.
 
But of course the main difference is that Egypt has nothing to offer, and it isn't like a like anyone from Saudi Arabia is supporting Fox News or anything...cough, Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, cough.

Oh wait...freedom fries are far superior than those damn French fries, and Egypt is going to become Iran because they are the same type of society.

Before the US allied with Egypt: Several disastrous wars which almost collapsed the country.

After the US allied with Egypt: No wars.

Why was the US wrong to prevent wars and social collapse in Egypt?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom