What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

Which is why the belief that *democracy* is coming to Egypt from a crowd led by the Brotherhood and with communist trouble makers like Code Pink in support is rather naive.

The crowd isn't led by the Brotherhood nor do Code Pink "trouble makers" represent a sizable faction!
 
Last edited:
The crowd isn't led by the Brotherhood nor do Code Pink "trouble makers" represent a sizable faction!
But..but..but that is what Fox and WND would have us believe, and we all know that what kind of "news" sources are used by BaC given his comment history.

Of course given that I get my news from the BBC and Al Jazeera I am of course one of themTM.
 
Last edited:
I'll be satisfied with some form of representative democracy taking hold in Egypt.

will the MB be part of it? surely.
 
The crowd isn't led by the Brotherhood

And the islamic fundamentalists never "led" the crowds that eventually toppled the Shaw, either. Riiiiiight. :rolleyes: But look where they ended up, JJ? And look what happened to *democracy* in Iran?

Sorry, JJ, but I think you are being naive. The Brotherhood has simply stepped back now, after lighting the fuse on this bomb, and is now waiting from the back of the mob. Quietly manipulating it via their well organized members. Letting the pent up anger of ordinary people, combined with the "education" (or should I say lies) fed them by islamic clerics in mosques over the years do the rest. Letting the support of leftist, banner-carrying, slogan-chanting, *social justice* groups like Code Pink and useful tools like ElBaradei (who also demanded "social justice" the other day) be the front men … the facade … of this *revolution*. And with the left-leaning mainstream media making sure the correct message gets out to the rest of the world, but not the whole story.

But don't think for one minute that when the bomb goes off and Mubarak falls, the Muslim Brotherhood isn't going to be the ones who are best organized to step in and "lead" the mob. Especially if Mubarak is forced out before a normal election as the Brotherhood, leftist agitators, left-leaning media and Obama administration are not insisting happen.

And where will they lead Egypt if that happens, JJ? Are you so naive and blind as to think it will be a peaceful, sectarian democracy? Point to one such instance of that happening in the Muslim. Just one. Sorry, but the cold, hard truth is that more than likely it will be another hardcore islamic socialist government advocating extremist Jihadism … led by none other than the Muslim Brotherhood … the same group that spawn al-Qaeda.

Obama is Stuck On Stupid in voicing support for Brotherhood just because they are now moderating their public image (a little). He's having his Carter Moment and history will look back on this as one his biggest foreign policy mistakes. Or perhaps it's just his plan because afterall, the folks who will take over are socialists … Muslim style.

nor do Code Pink "trouble makers" represent a sizable faction!

Such naivity. :rolleyes: Or purposeful deception.

The left has played an important role in helping the Brotherhood to get things rolling in Egypt. There are video of leftists (including members of Code Pink) giving speeches at Brotherhood events where Brotherhood speakers advocated Jihad against Israel and *Zionists* in general. It is now quite obvious that the far left, including Code Pink, ANSWER and other socialist/communist groups, has been fomenting trouble in Egypt … for quite a while. And now it's been learned that Obama was aware this was going on. And these leftist groups are there now making sure that the crowds of ordinary people do the rest … to stay angry enough to be irrational. With Obama siding with the Muslim Brotherhood.

Here's what you will get if they succeed in making it possible for the Muslim Brotherhood to be the one to *stabilize* Egypt … a terrorist supporting, anti-American, anti-West, socialist government that seeks to destroy Israel … in other words, another Iran. Mark my words. Here, you can hear the *pro-democracy* protestors themselves express how they feel and predict what will happen:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=aWcKewmyh_o#

Israel is our enemy … snip … If the people free in Egypt, … snip … they gonna destroy Israel. The country who control the United States is Israel

So be careful what you wish for. Or perhaps that's what you wish for. :p
 
... useful tools like ElBaradei (who also demanded "social justice" the other day)...

OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

...be the front men … the facade … of this *revolution*.

Oh my sweet Jesus, noes!!!!!!! Not *revolution*!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!!11


... anti-American, anti-West, socialist government

Not that! Mother of God, have mercy on us all!!!1111§!@#@!

Here's some more fuel for your fire:


Americans have for so long pretended that Arab nationalism is dead, their corporate media fail to recognize an Arab nationalist rebellion when it breaks out in front of their noses. Arab nationalism is more dangerous than Islamist politics to U.S. imperial hegemony, because “the path to mass mobilization can be direct and democratic, as evidenced by the spread of the Pan-Arab conflagration from the spark in Tunisia only weeks ago.”

That’s why Washington cannot tolerate a popular nationalist regime in power in Egypt, the largest Arab country and irreplaceable imperial and Zionist ally. If Egypt escapes the control of a comprador, imperial-subservient, anti-nationalist regime, the whole American position in the region unravels. Washington is desperate that some form of gangster order prevail, even if that means a “Tiananmen” Square”-like solution.


'The Arab Nationalist Reawakening in Egypt and Beyond'

http://blackagendareport.com/content/arab-nationalist-reawakening-egypt-and-beyond
 
Last edited:
'The Arab Nationalist Reawakening in Egypt and Beyond'

What exactly does that have to do with my response to you?

Does "Arab Nationalism" explain their hatred of Israel and *Zionists*?

Does it explain Obama lending support to an organization that has preached the destruction of Israel and spawned al-Qaeda?

Does it explain their advocacy of socialism/communism ... which has failed it's promise in country after country where it's been tried?

Does "Arab Nationalism" explain why communists are working with the Brotherhood and inciting the crowds in Egypt (and elsewhere) in support of the *pro-democracy* (:rolleyes:) elements?

For that matter, why is "Arab Nationalism" something we in the US and the US government should do anything to promote?

Do you think mention of "Arab Nationalism" in any way helps convert folks to your views on this thread? Given it's history?

Seriously.

:D
 
What exactly does that have to do with my response to you?

Does "Arab Nationalism" explain their hatred of Israel and *Zionists*?

Does it explain Obama lending support to an organization that has preached the destruction of Israel and spawned al-Qaeda?

Does it explain their advocacy of socialism/communism ... which has failed it's promise in country after country where it's been tried?

Does "Arab Nationalism" explain why communists are working with the Brotherhood and inciting the crowds in Egypt (and elsewhere) in support of the *pro-democracy* (:rolleyes:) elements?

For that matter, why is "Arab Nationalism" something we in the US and the US government should do anything to promote?

Do you think mention of "Arab Nationalism" in any way helps convert folks to your views on this thread? Given it's history?

Seriously.

:D

Indeed, the US government has every reason not to promote Arab Nationalism because Arab Nationalism doesn't put protecting "US Interests" at the top of its agenda.

Eeek! It's Code Pink!

:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

BTW, I'm not interested in converting anyone, on this thread or anywhere.
 
Last edited:
'It's not radical Islam that worries the US – it's independence
The nature of any regime it backs in the Arab world is secondary to control. Subjects are ignored until they break their chains'

"One 1989 comparison has some validity: Romania, where Washington maintained its support for Nicolae Ceausescu, the most vicious of the east European dictators, until the allegiance became untenable. Then Washington hailed his overthrow while the past was erased. That is a standard pattern: Ferdinand Marcos, Jean-Claude Duvalier, Chun Doo-hwan, Suharto and many other useful gangsters. It may be under way in the case of Hosni Mubarak, along with routine efforts to try to ensure a successor regime will not veer far from the approved path. The current hope appears to be Mubarak loyalist General Omar Suleiman, just named Egypt's vice-president. Suleiman, the longtime head of the intelligence services, is despised by the rebelling public almost as much as the dictator himself.

A common refrain among pundits is that fear of radical Islam requires (reluctant) opposition to democracy on pragmatic grounds. While not without some merit, the formulation is misleading. The general threat has always been independence. The US and its allies have regularly supported radical Islamists, sometimes to prevent the threat of secular nationalism.

A familiar example is Saudi Arabia, the ideological centre of radical Islam (and of Islamic terror). Another in a long list is Zia ul-Haq, the most brutal of Pakistan's dictators and President Reagan's favorite, who carried out a programme of radical Islamisation (with Saudi funding).
"

- Noam Chomsky
 
Last edited:
It's not independence that worries the US. It's instability and war around the two primary choke points, the Strait of Hormuz and the Suez Canal.

As you all should be. You will all suffer substantially if those choke points are choked off.
 
It appears that you think I wrote the article!

You chose the words to summarize the article's main point, in the words you chose for your link.

And no, having read the article, I have no doubt you are neither smart enough, nor eloquent enough, to have written it regardless of how little I think of the author's line.

@ BAC: WTF does Code Pink have to do with Egyptian politics? IIRC, this is the NON US politics forum.
 
Last edited:
It's not independence that worries the US. It's instability and war around the two primary choke points, the Strait of Hormuz and the Suez Canal.

As you all should be. You will all suffer substantially if those choke points are choked off.

any evidence whatsoever that a new Egyptian govt. would threaten their own economy and security by making such a stupid move?

thought not.

;)
 
any evidence whatsoever that a new Egyptian govt. would threaten their own economy and security by making such a stupid move?

thought not.

;)

Why do I need any evidence? Chomsky didn't need any. He just wrote what his sycophants wanted to hear, and they dutifully printed it.

At any rate, what kind of stupid gubbermint would decline to consider contingencies until the need for contingencies is staring it in it's vapid, contingencyless face? Is that the kind of gubbermint you think we have? (lq)
 
Why do I need any evidence? Chomsky didn't need any.

;)


why do you need evidence? Tell him, Wildcat:

Originally Posted by WildCat
He made the claim, he should provide the evidence. That's the way it works here.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom