What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?



Egypt and Mubarak are now and real, bible fairytales are fantasy and history
 
Moved a lengthy derail to Abandon All Hope. Please, stick to the topic.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
if Mubarak resigns, a successor shall be chosen, and hopefully a new more democratic constitution will be written.

I do not expect Egypt to become a new Iran. They are too sophisticated and modern for that. Maybe 30 years ago, but not now.
 
I wonder if Zbigniew Brzenski is in on this. He has had a long penchant for installing muslim-extremist regimes. The Muslim Brotherhood seems to qualify...


INRM
"In closing, I'd like to remind you all that no matter how I die, even if it was in my sleep and there was a suicide note; it was murder"
 
Zbig is mentioned in the article I posted on page one. The sharp old bastard was as usually right on the money:

Pepe Escobar said:
Or, in the elite speak of US foreign policy guru Dr Zbigniew Brzezinski, this is his dreaded "global political awakening" in action - the Generation Y across the developing world, angry, restless, outraged, emotionally shattered, mostly unemployed, stripped of their dignity, acting out their revolutionary potential and turning the status quo upside down (even with the Pharaoh promoting the biggest Internet blackout in history). [...]

As alarmed as the rarified global elites may be by now - one just has to follow the labyrinth of ambiguities oozing from Washington and European capitals - at least Brzezinski has been wired enough to catch the drift, as in "major world powers, new and old ... face a novel reality: while the lethality of their military might is greater than ever, their capacity to impose control over the politically awakened masses of the world is at a historic low."
 
I think the USA have done a silly thing here. They should have distanced themselves from the regime and waited this out. I would have announced I was temporarily suspending all aid until a new government, with the mandate of the people, was in place. Then see what it'll cost you to maintain peace with Israel. Remind the new government that if Egypt makes any moves on Israel it will be seen as a violation of their sovereign territory and Israel will be fully justified in collective self defense in order to protect itself.

If that's too subtle remind them that you're a good friend of Israel, and unlikely to sit by and watch if anything happens.

I.E. You attack Israel, and we will bury you. You leave Israel alone and we'll give you cash. Take your pick.
 
I think the USA have done a silly thing here. They should have distanced themselves from the regime and waited this out. I would have announced I was temporarily suspending all aid until a new government, with the mandate of the people, was in place. Then see what it'll cost you to maintain peace with Israel. Remind the new government that if Egypt makes any moves on Israel it will be seen as a violation of their sovereign territory and Israel will be fully justified in collective self defense in order to protect itself.

If that's too subtle remind them that you're a good friend of Israel, and unlikely to sit by and watch if anything happens.

I.E. You attack Israel, and we will bury you. You leave Israel alone and we'll give you cash. Take your pick.

The US actively intervening on the side of Israel in a war with Egypt, even a completely justified defensive war, would basically screw us with most of the rest of the Muslim middle east.

Well, moreso than we usually are, at least.
 
if Mubarak resigns, a successor shall be chosen, and hopefully a new more democratic constitution will be written.

I do not expect Egypt to become a new Iran. They are too sophisticated and modern for that. Maybe 30 years ago, but not now.

This is the country that reported on Zionist shark attacks not long ago.
 
Mubarak announced he won't seek re-election... I don't know if he can hang on that long.

Reports of protestors getting attacked by pro-Mubarak mobs armed with sticks and swords. Yuck.
 
The US actively intervening on the side of Israel in a war with Egypt, even a completely justified defensive war, would basically screw us with most of the rest of the Muslim middle east.

Well, moreso than we usually are, at least.


They already call you the "Great Satan" and chant "Death to America" at their rallies. I'm really not sure how things could get much worse for you.
 
Just out, another insightful piece by Escobar: The Brotherhood factor

Asia Times said:
[...] The sensible way ahead points to an Egyptian civic alliance dominated by all the sectors opposed to the regime (virtually everyone in the country) and the inevitable component, the army. As much as sectors of the Washington establishment and US corporate media may have been frantically spinning it, there are no objective conditions for an Islamist takeover; this is just plain silly.

Washington may be about to give the green light to Mohamed ElBaradei - who has been crucially endorsed by the Muslim Brotherhood. Yet not even the Sphinx in Giza knows whether this will be enough for the street.

ElBaradei is a credible outsider. During the Pharaoh's hardcore years he was abroad. He is no pushover, and stoically stood his ground against the George W Bush administration as head of the International Atomic Energy Agency over Iran. ElBaradei, winner of the Nobel Peace Prize in 2005, may in fact emerge as the "bridge" before free and fair elections, a new constitution and a new order in Egypt.

But there's no evidence he will concoct an economic policy much different from the usual International Monetary Fund-World Bank "structural adjustment" scam, with lots of dodgy privatizations mixed with that hazy Davos mantra, "good governance". If that's the case the street is bound to get really angry - again.

For the moment, there's not much evidence that Egypt could go the way of Iran in 1979. The secular left was in charge of Iran's post-revolutionary government (in Egypt, the left has been decimated by repression). Iran only became an Islamic republic months later, after a national referendum (were that to happen, Egyptians would overwhelmingly support a secular republic). The most probable, positive, scenario is that by 2012 Egypt may be closer, politically, to Turkey.

That leaves us the burning unanswered question to burn them all; what will be the post-revolutionary role of the Muslim Brotherhood (MB)? [...]
 
They already call you the "Great Satan" and chant "Death to America" at their rallies. I'm really not sure how things could get much worse for you.


I'm waiting for a statement by your worst nightmare Osama Bin Laden for quite some time, gummi. Anybody remember that guy? Seems like they locked him in the cupboard. He didn't even endorse WikiLeaks. :confused:
 
I'm waiting for a statement by your worst nightmare Osama Bin Laden for quite some time, gummi. Anybody remember that guy? Seems like they locked him in the cupboard. He didn't even endorse WikiLeaks. :confused:

OBL is meaningless in this whole situation.

as he should be.
 
I don't think that any successor to Mubarak would be so stupid as to blow up the Sphinx. Tourism is a main source of income for the Egyptian economy, and however you turn it, will remain so for quite some years to come.

It was pretty stupid to blow up the stone Buddhas. I don't put anything past religious extremists.
 
There is a problem with that poll, given that it isn't asking voting intention. There is a big difference between 20% being favourable toward AQ and voting for an AQ style party. Consider the following report, where 22% of Britons said they would "seriously consider" voting BNP. The following year, the BNP polled only 1.9%.

Regardless of this, isn't it up to the Egyptians who they elect, even if it is an Islamist party?
As to the first part, saying one would "seriously consider" voting is not the same as support said party. It just indicates a willingness to at least consider it.
As to the second part, sure, it is up to the Egyptians. But there are consequences if they go the Islamist route. It may be the last time they get to decide without another revolution.
 
I think the USA have done a silly thing here.

Not entirely sure if I agree

They should have distanced themselves from the regime and waited this out.

Agreed here.

I would have announced I was temporarily suspending all aid until a new government, with the mandate of the people, was in place.

Disagree here. The way it is worded makes it taking a side in this. Currently we don't actually know what the mandate of the people is. Yes there are a lot of angery people out on the streets protesting, but are they the majority of the country?

They were talking about 1 million people on the streets, which does sound a lot, but the country has nearly 80 million people, so that means that 78 million weren't out on the streets protesting, about 53 million of them are eligible to vote. Should the 1 million protesting get to say what happens over the wants of the 53 million not protesting?

I might have said that "I was temporarily suspending all aid until an open and free election to determine the mandate of the people, was in place," and add to it that "If it failed to be open and free election that the aid would be ended."

Then see what it'll cost you to maintain peace with Israel. Remind the new government that if Egypt makes any moves on Israel it will be seen as a violation of their sovereign territory and Israel will be fully justified in collective self defense in order to protect itself.

This again assumes that the majority of Eygptians do want a new goverment. Some groups are now counter protesting those demanding Mubarak stand down. We need to keep in mind that in a country of 79-80 million, 1 million people isn't a lot. This is why changes of Government should be via ballots and not revolutions.

If that's too subtle remind them that you're a good friend of Israel, and unlikely to sit by and watch if anything happens.

I.E. You attack Israel, and we will bury you. You leave Israel alone and we'll give you cash. Take your pick.

I'm sure that Israel could do the burying by themselves tbh.
 
The US actively intervening on the side of Israel in a war with Egypt, even a completely justified defensive war, would basically screw us with most of the rest of the Muslim middle east.

Well, moreso than we usually are, at least.

We probably wouldn't need to anyway.

We all remember how previous wars between Egypt and Israel went.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom