What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

Depends how it happens. It was rumored that he was planning to step down this year and that his son would likely take over his party.

I'd suggest that he still does, though also announce and oversee truely fair and open elections. That way any change in government is done democratically and without a void as a new government attempts to form out of the ruins.
 
Depends how it happens. It was rumored that he was planning to step down this year and that his son would likely take over his party.

That might well have been his plan (he is an octogenarian, after all). However, I wouldn't count on his plans for succession to come to anything. According to AlJazeera, Gamal Mubarak has already left the country.
 
He writes like a infant school child, or an eighth grade drop-out.

I find it difficult to accept his interpretation or data, without confirmatory evidence.

Try some of his more substantial pieces before dismissing him as a drop-out.

I'd like to see an infant write like this;

http://pajamasmedia.com/michaeltotten/2011/01/15/the-south-is-a-desert-and-the-north-is-a-garden/

His evidence is a poll conducted by the Pew Research Center. Take your issue of numbers and data up with them.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
By far the best thing the US can do is denounce the situation as an internal matter for Egyptians, keep out of it as much as possible and make some meaningless statements about advancing human rights, democracy, etc.

There are basically two possible outcomes, either Mubarak (his faction) stays in power, or the opposition wins.

If Mubarak wins it really doesn't matter if the US remained neutral or supported him - there is no competing Soviet block for him to run to - and China surely isn't going to pay him $1.3B per year. Mubarak is firmly stuck in the US camp.

But should the opposition win, then it will matter if the US supported Mubarak against the opposition or not.
US support for Mubarak would make Egypt a natural opponent if the opposition wins, US neutrality allows friendly relations with Egypt whoever wins.

One would think the US learned something from history. Specifically, how its support for the autocratic Shah in Persia influenced current relations between the US and Iran.
 
A message from Pepe Escobar:

Asia Times said:
Islamophobes of the world, shut up and listen to the sound of people power. Your artificial Middle East dichotomy - it's either "our" dictators or jihadism - was never more than a cheap trick. Political repression, mass unemployment and rising food prices are more lethal than an army of suicide bombers. This is the actual way history is written; a country of 80 million - two-thirds of which born after their dictator came to power in 1981, and no less than the heart of the Arab world - finally shatters the Wall of Fear and crosses to the side of self-respect.


Interesting piece.
 
One would think the US learned something from history. Specifically, how its support for the autocratic Shah in Persia influenced current relations between the US and Iran.

One would think people would have learned that one thing that never happens is the US learning from its mistakes in history. :(
 
pajamasmedia? really?`lol
Yeah, there's some cazy blogs at pajamasmedia, but you can see the original Pew poll here: http://pewglobal.org/files/2010/12/Pew-Global-Attitudes-Muslim-Report-FINAL-December-2-2010.pdf

At least three-quarters of Muslims in Egypt and Pakistan say they would favor making each of the following the law in their countries: stoning people who commit adultery, whippings and cutting off of hands for crimes like theft and robbery and the death penalty for those who leave the Muslim religion.
 
One would think people would have learned that one thing that never happens is the US learning from its mistakes in history. :(
So the Camp David talks in 1979 that brought peace between Israel and Egypt was a mistake?
 
I did not say that. I said the US tends not to learn from its mistakes.
So what mistake do you think was made here? The 1979 treaty obligates the US to supply Egypt with military aid, in exchange we got peace between Israel and Egypt and Egypt got the Sinai back.
 
Michael J. Totten said:
...the 59 percent of Egyptians...

Barry Rubin said:
In Egypt,... Asked if they supported "modernizers" or "Islamists" only 27 percent said modernizers while 59 percent said Islamists.
These claims are false, based on a misinterpretation of the data and a failure to read the fine print.

The Pew research found instead that of Egyptian Muslims (who are 90% of the population), only 31% "see a struggle between groups that want to modernize their countries and Islamic fundamentalists". And of that 31%, 59% identify with the fundamentalists.

100% of Egyptians are Egyptians
90% of Egyptians are Muslims = 90% of Egyptians
31% of Egyptian Muslims perceive the aforementioned struggle = 27.9% of Egyptians
59% who so perceive identify with the fundies = 16.5% of Egyptians

That small figure is far more encouraging than what Rubin and Totten are reporting. I think they would be happy to realize their error.



Furthermore, the Pew data about which non-Egyptian Islamist groups Egyptian Muslims like might not have much to say about the Egyptian people's domestic legislative priorities. Wouldn't they see this more in terms of foreign policy?

However, you will find a more precise understanding of domestic policy preferences from the Pew results about what brutal laws Egyptian Muslims favor. That's a more clear problem, even when you factor in the reality that not all Egyptians are Muslims.

But I still have to wonder what it means when most of those same people think that there is no conflict between "modernizers" and "fundamentalists". The PDF of the poll report includes the English translation of the actual question, which you can read at the end of the document. But, in Arabic and in the Egyptian context, how do the terms for "groups who want to modernize" and "Islamic fundamentalists" come across to the person being asked the question?

Also, how do the poll results about punishment square with the concluding survey of the entire population which found that 41% of Egyptians were somewhat concerned about Islamic extremism, and 20% were very concerned. To us they sound contradictory, but how do the Egyptian Muslims see this?

http://pewglobal.org/2010/12/02/muslims-around-the-world-divided-on-hamas-and-hezbollah/

It's also worth noting that this poll was published before Mohamed Bouazizi killed himself. The questions are focused on Islamic terrorism and tactics, but (as reported) weren't a survey about general issues. I'd like to see the surveys which ask what people in these countries see as the biggest problems facing them and their countries today. Unemployment would probably rank higher than adultery.
 
Last edited:
So what mistake do you think was made here? The 1979 treaty obligates the US to supply Egypt with military aid, in exchange we got peace between Israel and Egypt and Egypt got the Sinai back.
Almo's post was in reply to a quote from me, where I said: "One would think the US learned something from history. Specifically, how its support for the autocratic Shah in Persia influenced current relations between the US and Iran. "

In other words, strong US support for Mubarak against the opposition would poison Egypt-US relations when Mubarak eventually falls.

Much like Iran-US relations are still affected by US support for the Shah, decades ago.
 
That small figure is far more encouraging than what Rubin and Totten are reporting. I think they would be happy to realize their error.


I doubt it.

Also, how do the poll results about punishment square with the concluding survey of the entire population which found that 41% of Egyptians were somewhat concerned about Islamic extremism, and 20% were very concerned. To us they sound contradictory, but how do the Egyptian Muslims see this?


Look at the actual questions. They ask "are you concerned about the rise of islamic extremism in your country/the world". Looking at the actual numbers over the years, there is a slight trend among Egyptians to be less concerned about their own country and more concerned about the world. Could mean that they don't see a rise at all, or that they don't see it as a problem. Misleading, and they omit the "the rise" part in their summary..
 
Last edited:
Almo's post was in reply to a quote from me, where I said: "One would think the US learned something from history. Specifically, how its support for the autocratic Shah in Persia influenced current relations between the US and Iran. "

In other words, strong US support for Mubarak against the opposition would poison Egypt-US relations when Mubarak eventually falls.

Much like Iran-US relations are still affected by US support for the Shah, decades ago.
The support wasn't for Mubarak, it was for Egypt. The aid would have been sent to Egypt no matter who was head of state, just so long as they held up their end of the treaty.

Mubarak was not the head of state when the treaty was signed, Sadat was.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom