What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

So how long until the Suez is off limits to infidels? How long until the next invasion of Israel? Will they blow up the Sphinx because of its non-Muslim origin?

That reminds me of a hysterical moment in "An Idiot Abroad" when Karl Pilkington is haggling over souvenirs in Cairo and asks if he can get a discount on a statuette of the Sphinx because the nose is damaged.
 
Will they blow up the Sphinx because of its non-Muslim origin?
It's thought that it was Muslims who chiseled off the nose of the Sphinx to prevent it from being worshipped as a god.
 
It's thought that it was Muslims who chiseled off the nose of the Sphinx to prevent it from being worshipped as a god.

Wiki said:
The Egyptian historian al-Maqrizi, writing in the 15th century, attributes the vandalism to Muhammad Sa'im al-Dahr, a fanatic Sufi Muslim from the khanqah of Sa'id al-Su'ada. In 1378, upon finding the Egyptian peasants making offerings to the Sphinx in the hope of increasing their harvest, Sa'im al-Dahr was so outraged that he destroyed the nose.[4]


But it's better to just characterise the vandals as "muslims", isn't it?
 
It's thought that it was Muslims who chiseled off the nose of the Sphinx to prevent it from being worshipped as a god.

Actually, it was the French. And the damage is quite a bit older than that.

untitled10.bmp
 
Situation in Egypt not comparable to Iran 79

Egyptian analyst Mustafa Abulhimal says this is not the Muslim Brotherhood's revolution.

"The Muslim Brotherhood are not behind the organization of the protests," he said. "The Muslim Brotherhood are not inspiring the protests in the street. The Muslim Brotherhood are a small minority among those who are out on the street," he said.

Islamists did take power in Iran 30 years ago, seizing control of a revolution originally backed by many different groups, including Communists and secular democrats.

But the situation in Egypt today is not comparable, Abulhimal argues.

"The Iranian revolution was taken over by an Islamist, a charismatic Islamist, (Ayatollah Ruhollah) Khomeini. Whereas in Egypt, the charismatic figures we have in the street today or yesterday were secular figures like Mohamed ElBaradei or Ayman Nour," Abulhimal said, naming two key opposition leaders.
 
I see the situation in Egypt more comparable to Iran in 1950, before the CIA-coup. Which is what eventually led to Iran 79.

Best thing to do for the West in Egypt is to keep out of it as an internal issue, except express hope for reforms without taking sides.

But every nice word Obama now says about Mubarak makes the US just a little more an enemy to the opposition.
 
If Mubarak falls, he'll probably break his hip.

The guy is older than Hugh Heffner.
 
Good news
Protesters have been buoyed by an announcement from Egypt's military that they will not confront demonstrators.

On Monday the military said it recognised "the legitimate rights of the people" and pledged it "will not use force against the Egyptian people".

Ref: http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/02/01/3127292.htm?section=world

Also any chance of democracy in Egypt? Consequences?

The protests in the world's most populous Arab nation broke out last week when frustration over repression and the lack of democracy under Mr Mubarak's rule boiled over.

Ref: http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/02/01/3126295.htm
 
Last edited:
Actually, it was the French.
Actually, that's a false rumor. The Sphinx' nose and beard had already been vandalized for centuries before Napoleon arrived. The most likely culprit was the iconoclast Muhammad Sa'im al-Dahr, a Sufi Muslim, in the 14th century. (The Egyptians purportedly executed al-Dahr for vandalism for what he had done.)

Napoleon was quite the Egyptophile. And by that, I mean, he pillaged and plundered various tombs for Egyptian artifacts to bring back to France. But he was very careful not to damage anything because he revered ancient Egyptian history. (He just didn't care very much for actual Egyptians.) Among his plunder was the Rosetta Stone.
 
And during the Cedar Revolution you could find any number of analysts saying that this was the end of Syria in Lebanon, and a new era of democracy.
We came to say that conditions are not acceptable anymore," said Tony Khouri, who had come from Amman, Jordan, with his wife, Caroline, on family business and stayed on for the demonstration. "The goal is for everyone to stop interfering in our country and let us take care of ourselves," he said, alluding to Syria's grip on Lebanon.

Such talk was virtually unheard of in public only a year ago. But the resignation of Mr. Karami underscored Syria's weakening grip on Lebanon. For more than 30 years, Syria has held sway over Lebanon's political and economic life through its military and proxy over the government, arming Hezbollah, and using the country as a gateway into the global economy.
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/03/01/i.../01lebanon.html?pagewanted=2&sq&st=nyt""cedar revolution&scp=6

Today, nearly 6 years later, Lebanon is Hizbullahstan and Syria and Iran are still calling the shots.

"Meet the new boss, same as the old boss", quite literally in the case of Lebanon.
 
"Meet the new boss, same as the old boss", quite literally in the case of Lebanon.

Yeah, but doesn't that tend to confirm the idea that what's happening now in Egypt isn't any sort of harbinger of an Islamist takeover of the country? That is, what's most likely to be the end result of all this is simply some iteration of the pre-revolution status quo, and not any kind of dramatic change.

As I've been saying, this isn't the American Revolution. But it's not the Iranian Revolution either.
 
evidence?
You're going to have to read Mawaiz wa al-'i'tibar bi dhikr al-khitat wa al-'athar. That's the first-party source and it is written by the formost historian of Egyptian history of the time. It's been translated into French. Not so sure if it's been translated into English though.

In it, the historian, Taqi al-Din Ahmad ibn 'Ali ibn 'Abd al-Qadir ibn Muhammad al-Maqrizi, relates the tale of the Sphinx' vandalism by Muhammad Sa'im al-Dahr in order to prevent locals from making religious offerings to it. As the book in which this tale is described was written a good two centuries before Napoleon arrived in France, it's pretty solid evidence that Napoleon didn't vandalize the Sphinx. No other accounts of the Sphinx' vandalism have been discovered.
 
IF the shoe fits ...
But only outside the mosque, please? :)

To settle this quite off-topic debate about Israel destroying monuments, here's a link from Haaretz detailing such actions.

I don't understand that so many ignore the evidence uncovered by the eminent historians Goscinny and Uderzo that it was in fact a fat Frenchie who damaged the nose of the Sphinx. :boxedin:
Fat? I'm not fat!


Will they blow up the Sphinx because of its non-Muslim origin?
I don't think that any successor to Mubarak would be so stupid as to blow up the Sphinx. Tourism is a main source of income for the Egyptian economy, and however you turn it, will remain so for quite some years to come.
 
What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

change that is real
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom