What happens to Egypt if Mubarak falls?

The support wasn't for Mubarak, it was for Egypt. The aid would have been sent to Egypt no matter who was head of state, just so long as they held up their end of the treaty.

Mubarak was not the head of state when the treaty was signed, Sadat was.
The $1.3B aid is not the support I was referring to.

I meant the support the US (might) give Mubarak now, to keep him in power against his political opposition, or if the US offers him asylum should he flee.

Already Biden and Clinton are defending Mubarak with words, and I think some senator suggested withdrawing the $1.3B aid should Mubarak fall. That's a dangerous path.
 
These claims are false, based on a misinterpretation of the data and a failure to read the fine print.

The Pew research found instead that of Egyptian Muslims (who are 90% of the population), only 31% "see a struggle between groups that want to modernize their countries and Islamic fundamentalists". And of that 31%, 59% identify with the fundamentalists.

100% of Egyptians are Egyptians
90% of Egyptians are Muslims = 90% of Egyptians
31% of Egyptian Muslims perceive the aforementioned struggle = 27.9% of Egyptians
59% who so perceive identify with the fundies = 16.5% of Egyptians

That small figure is far more encouraging than what Rubin and Totten are reporting. I think they would be happy to realize their error.



Furthermore, the Pew data about which non-Egyptian Islamist groups Egyptian Muslims like might not have much to say about the Egyptian people's domestic legislative priorities. Wouldn't they see this more in terms of foreign policy?

However, you will find a more precise understanding of domestic policy preferences from the Pew results about what brutal laws Egyptian Muslims favor. That's a more clear problem, even when you factor in the reality that not all Egyptians are Muslims.

But I still have to wonder what it means when most of those same people think that there is no conflict between "modernizers" and "fundamentalists". The PDF of the poll report includes the English translation of the actual question, which you can read at the end of the document. But, in Arabic and in the Egyptian context, how do the terms for "groups who want to modernize" and "Islamic fundamentalists" come across to the person being asked the question?

Also, how do the poll results about punishment square with the concluding survey of the entire population which found that 41% of Egyptians were somewhat concerned about Islamic extremism, and 20% were very concerned. To us they sound contradictory, but how do the Egyptian Muslims see this?

http://pewglobal.org/2010/12/02/muslims-around-the-world-divided-on-hamas-and-hezbollah/

It's also worth noting that this poll was published before Mohamed Bouazizi killed himself. The questions are focused on Islamic terrorism and tactics, but (as reported) weren't a survey about general issues. I'd like to see the surveys which ask what people in these countries see as the biggest problems facing them and their countries today. Unemployment would probably rank higher than adultery.

good find, thanks
 
pajamasmedia? really?`lol

I'm sorry but I feel compelled to reply to this comment. I've been a close personal friend of Michael Totten's for many years. He's been to Iraq 7 times and during the Cedar Revolution in Lebanon, he didn't just blog about it but went there for 6 months and spoke with people on all sides, including Walid Jumblatt and Hezbollah. He is the winner of the best "middle east or africa blog" multiple years running and his travel writings are fantastic no matter where you happen to fall on the political spectrum. His work has appeared in The New York Times, The Wall Street journal and other newspapers. He's nothing to "lol" about.
He's also come out with a new book.
 
I'm sorry but I feel compelled to reply to this comment. I've been a close personal friend of Michael Totten's for many years. He's been to Iraq 7 times and during the Cedar Revolution in Lebanon, he didn't just blog about it but went there for 6 months and spoke with people on all sides, including Walid Jumblatt and Hezbollah. He is the winner of the best "middle east or africa blog" multiple years running and his travel writings are fantastic no matter where you happen to fall on the political spectrum. His work has appeared in The New York Times, The Wall Street journal and other newspapers. He's nothing to "lol" about.
He's also come out with a new book.

that might be, and i still lol at pajamasmedia.
 
So how long until the Suez is off limits to infidels? How long until the next invasion of Israel? Will they blow up the Sphinx because of its non-Muslim origin?
 
I'm sorry but I feel compelled to reply to this comment. I've been a close personal friend of Michael Totten's for many years.


Tell him that he got his numbers wrong. GreyArea thinks he will be happy to realize his error. I said I doubt it but based that on the site(s), not the person whom I never heard of. Let us know if he corrects them.

Edited, breach of rule 12.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar
 
Last edited by a moderator:
http://punditpress.blogspot.com/2011/01/obamas-carter-moment.html

January 31, 2011

Obama's Carter Moment

By now the comparison between President Barack Obama and former-President Jimmy Carter is well established. *Both Presidents came to power only after the overhyped "death" of the Republican Party in 1976 and 2008, both Presidents had promised renewed peace and talks with our chief (which both failed), and under both Presidents, the economy faltered.

Yet, with uprisings in Egypt sweeping their nation, another similarity comes into focus: the fall of Iran under Carter and President Obama's handling of Egypt. This is Obama's Carter moment.

:popcorn1
 
Tell him that he got his numbers wrong. GreyArea thinks he will be happy to realize his error. I said I doubt it but based that on the site(s), not the person whom I never heard of. Let us know if he corrects them.

Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content removed.

If you read the comments section, you can see that it has already been brought to his attention.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you send in troops you turn the whole place against the outsider.

I think the US government will be happy with whoever takes over so long as there are no massacres, the canal is kept open and there are no invasions of Israel again.
 
If you send in troops you turn the whole place against the outsider.

I think the US government will be happy with whoever takes over so long as there are no massacres, the canal is kept open and there are no invasions of Israel again.

Oh, sending in troops is the WORST possible move the US could make.
I was remarking on BAC's obvious attempt to use Egypt as grounds for beating up on Obama ..which even the GOP leadership is not doing, with the exception of the usual rant from Rand Paul, who seems to be as well informed as his dad on foreign affairs......
 
It's a bit more complicated then that.....

I do not accept that concept that Mubarak is the lesser of two evils. The devil we know vs. the devil we don't know.

He has been a dictator for a very long time. Its time for change. And it appears that the opposition is broad enough that Egypt won't just become another Iran.
 
Either you dont actually know what non-sequitur means or you are not following the debate.

False dichotomy.^

You have demonstrated that you either have no inkling what the yearly 1.3 billion was for, or you are deliberately trying to disinform.

Which is it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom