What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

A hermaphroditic species

I was tempted to suggest a species that reproduces asexually as an example.

they could travel in a generation ship with enormous space. Like an emptied asteroid. In fact it is much much more likely , than in a normal cramped ship, consdiering FTL is impossible,

The OP just says "spacefaring", it doesn't mention interstellar travel. If they're just traveling around their own system, they wouldn't need FTL or generation ships.

Can a sufficiently advance race use dance to communicate? Sure, bees do do that, as do humans to some degree. However, would it be practical for expressing difficult concepts such as used for engineering? Could it be reasonably be used to describe even the rudimentary basics of a fusion reactor?

The answer here is no.


The answer here is yes. Think of it as a whole-body variant of sign language. Since deaf humans can express these same concepts in sign language, there's no reason they couldn't also be expressed in some form of dance language.

Although, it would be more practical for them to indicate the appropriate dance movements using their manipulatory appendages. In other words, sign language.

No. Such an undertaking would pose significantly more engineering difficulties than a normal, cramped ship as to be impractical in the extreme.

Interstellar travel itself is impractical to the extreme.

Apervirus said:
Or communciate through visible change on their body thru IR.

And here I thought the bioluminescent pulse suggestion was ridiculous. Sure there are creatures that can see into the infrared spectrum. But heating up part of the body to the extent that it could be seen on the surface? Such a form of communication would be clumsy and ponderous, to say the least.

Heating would only be necessary if we're talking about far-IR (but I suppose it could be done by altering blood-flow, more than sufficient to be observed if the species have heat-sensing organs like the kind that pit vipers use to find prey by body-heat).

If we're talking about near-IR, it could be produced chemically. It'd be just another form of bio-luminescence that happens to be outside the human range of vision.

I think it strange that you dismiss these ideas straight off, while at the same time accusing us of being close minded.

I return that right back to you. Saying that any alien lifeform must be radically different from anything we're familiar with just because they originate from a different planet is remarkably closed minded, short sighted, and not very logical.

Nobody's claiming that they must be radically different. But since you seem to be arguing from the assumption that they won't be radically different, we're just pointing out that they might be radically different.
 
Nobody's claiming that they must be radically different. But since you seem to be arguing from the assumption that they won't be radically different, we're just pointing out that they might be radically different.
Actually when you think about the permutations of all the ways that have been pointed out for them to be radically different the case that they have to be different almost makes itself. What are the odds that a 4 billion year chain of events will play out similarly elsewhere?
 
I don't understand why chromatographic species is dismissed so handily. I pass an electronic billboard on my way home from work every day, a rapidly-changing display of light and color that transmits information in pictures and words (which are also pictures). Even just a simple message like Eat at Joe's or Looking For a Mate would be a huge adaptation and strongly selected for.
 
I don't understand why chromatographic species is dismissed so handily. I pass an electronic billboard on my way home from work every day, a rapidly-changing display of light and color that transmits information in pictures and words (which are also pictures). Even just a simple message like Eat at Joe's or Looking For a Mate would be a huge adaptation and strongly selected for.

Don't be such a sad individual.... It's written in the Book of Mudcat that it can't be done, so obviously you're imagining any information you get from it.
 
Back to the underwater gentleman chemist...

... Maybe they're partially amorphous, and adept at forming vacuoles within their bodies in which to mix chemicals? In addition to secreting an outer carapace, they also secrete inner linings for these vacuoles, allowing them to mix reactants that won't react with the walls of the container they're in.

Maybe chemistry for them is a kind of extreme body-modification sporting event. Every twelve tidal cycles, they gather together and compete to see who can achieve the most volatile mixtures... and survive. Other contestants might show off their breakthrough in forming chambers within chambers, or complex valve arrangements allowing for innovative mixing strategies. Maybe their applied chemistry community is governed by a few rockstars who can consistently produce useful results, and invidiuals swim the currents for many leagues for a chance to apprentice under one of these masters.
 
Maybe they're partially amorphous, and adept at forming vacuoles within their bodies in which to mix chemicals? In addition to secreting an outer carapace, they also secrete inner linings for these vacuoles, allowing them to mix reactants that won't react with the walls of the container they're in.
Tidal surges driving work surfaces together at great pressures, then 'eating' and 'digesting' the intermediate work product in specialized processing organs?

This leaves me wondering exactly what kind of evolutionary pressures would result in such abilities
 
This leaves me wondering exactly what kind of evolutionary pressures would result in such abilities
Evolution is efficient in the sense that anything that isn't useful will atrophy. But it's not necessarily efficient at building the most economical path to solving a problem. Our ability to do math may be a side effect of the process that could have worked had it only come up with a way to get us to throw a rock accurately.
 
Can a sufficiently advance race use dance to communicate? Sure, bees do do that, as do humans to some degree. However, would it be practical for expressing difficult concepts such as used for engineering? Could it be reasonably be used to describe even the rudimentary basics of a fusion reactor?

The answer here is no.

lack of imagination noted.

If they are 6 limbed, and 2 or 3 articulled per limb, an immensely complex language can be developed.


No. Such an undertaking would pose significantly more engineering difficulties than a normal, cramped ship as to be impractical in the extreme.

You under estimate wildly the engineering difficulty of bringing enough food, air, and water with yourself. They are not so impractical as you may think. I note that you did not mention what those engineering problem are so you are just hand waving.

Might as well suggest magic while you're at it.

Radio communication is only a different wave length to visible light. it is far more likely to use visible light for a variety of reason, but radio wave communication is not impossible.

And here I thought the bioluminescent pulse suggestion was ridiculous. Sure there are creatures that can see into the infrared spectrum. But heating up part of the body to the extent that it could be seen on the surface? Such a form of communication would be clumsy and ponderous, to say the least.

But not impossible. heck even in visible light if you prefer. A portable screen on your stomach.

I return that right back to you. Saying that any alien lifeform must be radically different from anything we're familiar with just because they originate from a different planet is remarkably closed minded, short sighted, and not very logical.

Yeah suggesting other possibility is close minded short sighted and illogical.

Yeah.

Right.
 
If you could provide an example of a working 'normal' interstellar ship . . .

Neither you nor Aepervius have stated the mission of the purported ship, nor which technological advancements are assumed. Without a mission or technology base, I think it's very difficult to say which design philosophy is more practical. YMMV.

The mission is easy : go from a star to another star hundred of light year away, and come back with information about the local life.

Baring an automated ship, for which then the life form does not matter (thinking "opportunity" for example, or lunarkod), then you are somewhere for extremely long time over long distance, possibly without even a pit stop in another solar system.

Frankly the more i think about it, unless you want to colonize, there is no reason whatsoever to send a "cramped" mudcat ship or a generation ship. Just send an automated sonde.
 
Last edited:
The asteroid idea sounds good at first but we can safely conclude, even without having done it, that it's next to unworkable. It would present several engineering challenges that would have to be overcome.

First you have to locate, secure, and transport an asteroid that meets your criteria. Which should immediately raise red flags because doing so would be enormously difficult. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

You realize that one of the project of the NASA is to capture an asteroid right ?

2014 Budget Proposal

"NASA's FY2014 budget proposal includes a plan to robotically capture a small near-Earth asteroid and redirect it safely to a stable orbit in the Earth-moon system where astronauts can visit and explore it."


Then you would have to mine and hollow out the asteroid, a slow and doubtlessly dangerous undertaking as well as enormously difficult. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

On the other hand if you capture a comete as well, you have reaction mass and an habitat. You are jsut hand waving , you realize ?

And then you would have to fit life support systems to make the inside livable, which is enormously more difficult then having a normal spaceship with the same requirements. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

I fail to see how fitting living support inside an asteroid would be much harder than in a ship. In fact I hold it would be much easier :micro meteorite and other impact would be deadly for a ship. Much less for an asteroid at the same speed. Once you emptied the asteroid, fitting a living system as as easy as for a ship. And you have much more place.


And finally you would have to design, build, and install a suitable power plant and rig sufficient propulsion for your asteroid. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

All of which can also fit an asteroid, and use the reaction mass you get at disposition, water, and so forth.

Your cramped ship will not go far.


Hardy har-har.[/QUOTE]
 
First of all, depends on the exact definition of "space-faring" and the reason that particular species and specimens would be in space.

Are we talking about interstellar or interplanetary voyages?
The species, it lives at a planet, sometimes sending missions to space or it actually lives in space (ex.: Rama-like ships travelling between stars, large fixed structures such as the orbitals from the Culture or smaller stations)?

What are purposes of the missions? Science? Colonization? Warfare? Tourism?

If we are talking about interstellar missions, some form of AI (or some type of integration between organic life and AI) seems to be most likely. The ships would be the aliens.

Another possibility would be genetically-engineered crew, adapted to space conditions and/or to be "built" upon arrival to the ship's destiny. Genetically-engineering and a hig degree of integration with technologic systems (computers, sensors, etc.) by the way, are to be expected in species living in artificial spaceborne structures. No humanoid aliens expected, again.

I remember a book ("Silent Galaxy") where mankind colonized the Solar system and adpated itself to its worlds. One of its offspring lived in space stations without gravity and evolved or genetically altered themselves to become creatures with four arms extending radially from a flattened torso with the head located in centre and slightly above the torso. Aliens (non-humanoid and also engineered on purpose IIRC) visit the system; they stay as dormant pods or embryos through the whole trip. When reaching the destination the ships' systems start the process of embryo or pod development followed by education. Both seem to be reasonable courses of action.

Restricting the possibilities to mammalian humanoids, at this point, seems to be hubris. Pierson's Puppeteers or Outsiders might be just around the galaxy's corner. Or not.
 
Sigh... It's like this, the bioluminescent pulses would have to be sufficiently long enough for the receiver to see and decipher whatever intended meaning behind the pulse would be. A language like this would be more like Morse code. Good for communicating short messages, but terrible for anything else.

But humans don't use Morse code much any more for digital communications, either. Once you master the simple on/off, you can move on to an alien version of RTTY, ASCII, SSTV, and spread-spectrum, just like we humans have. It wouldn't take much evolutionary time for such a race to get to the point where they could communicate with each other at whatever rate their thinking processes could process the data, just like us. After all, a Nook is just a variable matrix of on and off liquid crystals.
 
But humans don't use Morse code much any more for digital communications, either.
And Mudcat seems to be assuming that these aliens would have the same Broca's area and visual cortex that we do rather than devoting large parts of their brain to their own native mode of communication.
 
And Mudcat seems to be assuming that these aliens would have the same Broca's area and visual cortex that we do rather than devoting large parts of their brain to their own native mode of communication.
Which is what I was saying about "human limitations"
 
The mission is easy : go from a star to another star hundred of light year away, and come back with information about the local life.

FWIW, I wasn't criticizing your post for failing to state a mission; your post simply pointed out a different vision of the alien ships, and it didn't depend on a specific mission to be a plausible concept.

Frankly the more i think about it, unless you want to colonize, there is no reason whatsoever to send a "cramped" mudcat ship or a generation ship. Just send an automated sonde.

Agree. Certainly, if we're doing relatively modest extrapolations of current technology, a colony ship would necessarily be a very large thing and an automated exploration probe should be orders of magnitude smaller and cheaper.

Interesting to speculate about intermediate-sized missions, though. What if there's a developing civilization that you want to destroy (and don't know much about, when you launch the mission), or what if you wanted to terraform a planet? Again, of course, a lot of it will depend on what you assume for available technology.
 
Actually, the best argument against OP is the unlikelyhood of human-like intelligent species at all, never mind a spacefaring one. Human genome is a product of huge number of evolutionary accidents, any one of which could have gone differently -- ancestral chordates could easily have been outcompeted by mollusks for example, leading to Earth with no vertebrates at all, let alone mammals, let alone humans. If you started evolution anew at some planet identical to Earth 3.8 billion years ago, the chances of something closely resembling human -- or any specific animal you care to name, -- are pretty much nil. Sure there are environmental constraints -- aquatic predators would by necessity resemble torpedoes with fins, and brachiating tree-dwellers would have stereoscopic vision, -- but there is no reason for said torpedoes to have bones (squid do not, and they qualify), nor for tree-dweller to have mammal-like eyes (sonar is actually better for making 3-dimensional picture).

Mudcat's astonishing lack of imagination, combined with belligerent attitude and repeatedly calling anyone who disagrees as "small-minded" makes me wonder if OP is in fact a troll.
 
Warfare, I think, would be the easiest mission. No need for sophisticated AI. If you have the tech and the resources to send something across the space between stars at a considerable fraction of c, just aim it at the target planet/orbitals/O'Neill cylinders, whatever. A shower of small kinetic impactors at say, 1/3c should be enough to bring them back to the stone age.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom