What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

Assuming no FTL , either any spacefaring alien will have a very long life span, generation ships , or some form of temporary shutdown / suspended animation.

Or they will look a lot like machines.

Their mission will be to exterminate all biological life from known space to remove any future competitors much like we use weed killer on a field so beware those lights in the sky.:eek:
 
Their mission will be to exterminate all biological life from known space to remove any future competitors much like we use weed killer on a field so beware those lights in the sky.:eek:

Biological lifeforms are integral to the creation of more machines, so to exterminate them is more a product of biological fantasy/paranoia regarding conscious machine life forms.

Biological life forms are no 'competition'. They are bound to their prospective planet systems.
 
The premise of this question is flawed - it assumes that the traits of the "race" will remain the same once they became "spacefaring" as when they've started.

Once a stable, reproducing group of this "spacefaring race" begin to spend more time in space than their home planet they will evolve for the needs of their environment... at a technological rate. They'll discard what's useless and adopt what's useful.

Take humans and the kind of body implants, prosthetics and modifications we can already do. By the time we have qualify as a "spacefaring race" any physical feature - including any we can imagine from the animal kingdom - will be optional.
 
The premise of this question is flawed - it assumes that the traits of the "race" will remain the same once they became "spacefaring" as when they've started.

I had been thinking in terms of what the original species was like when they initially became an industrial, techological race, which would make the premise reasonable. I don't know if the OP (or anyone else, for that matter) was thinking that way.

Once a stable, reproducing group of this "spacefaring race" begin to spend more time in space than their home planet they will evolve for the needs of their environment... at a technological rate. They'll discard what's useless and adopt what's useful.

Take humans and the kind of body implants, prosthetics and modifications we can already do. By the time we have qualify as a "spacefaring race" any physical feature - including any we can imagine from the animal kingdom - will be optional.

I agree that this is likely the case.

I was an avid science fiction fan for my first few decades, but I've become less avid because, using reasoning similar to yours, I suspect that the future 'humanity' will be very different from modern humanity. That makes most of SF much less plausible to me, and, unfortunately, makes it much harder to identify with the characters in any plausible-seeming SF. With some exceptions, of course.

I'd expect that humanity will diversify rapidly. Over time, most of the human variants will have more and more non-biological (mechanical/electronic) components, and the variety of body forms, augmentations, and minds will increase exponentially.

It follows that if you were to find a 'human'-crewed starship in the year 2400, I'd expect that the 'humans' would have extensive adaptations for crewing a starship. In this context, having four arms rather than two arms/two legs would be a minor adaptation.

And then there's the 'pure' machine intelligence issue; 'pure' to distinguish it from human-derived intelligence, which may have an awful lot of machine augmentation. But likely there will be so much overlap that there's no good distinction.

I'd expect our spacefaring aliens to go the same route. Of course, we can come up with reasons why such diversification might not take place for humans or aliens, and we could speculate a great deal about the specifics and prospects for such diversification, but that would be another thread.
 
That makes most of SF much less plausible to me, and, unfortunately, makes it much harder to identify with the characters in any plausible-seeming SF.

Most science fiction is inherently implausible, because very few works of science fiction are based around actual science. In many cases, science fiction is little more than fantasy fiction in a futuristic setting, with the magic being thinly disguised as technology. (Such as the transporters in Star Trek. No science behind them. The transporter pads may as well be magic circles for a spell that sends people to distant locations.)

[/derail]

It follows that if you were to find a 'human'-crewed starship in the year 2400, I'd expect that the 'humans' would have extensive adaptations for crewing a starship. In this context, having four arms rather than two arms/two legs would be a minor adaptation.

I think it'd be far more likely that humans would design their ships to suit their bodies rather than redesign their bodies to suit their ships.
 
Most science fiction is inherently implausible, because very few works of science fiction are based around actual science. In many cases, science fiction is little more than fantasy fiction in a futuristic setting, with the magic being thinly disguised as technology. (Such as the transporters in Star Trek. No science behind them. The transporter pads may as well be magic circles for a spell that sends people to distant locations.)

Agree. I've never much cared for most sci fantasy books, though I often like the movies for the special effects (starting with Star Wars . . . ) As time passes, the fraction of plausible SF has dwindled for me, due to my changing perspective.

I think it'd be far more likely that humans would design their ships to suit their bodies rather than redesign their bodies to suit their ships.

I'm not picturing a world of humans that look like us launching a starship crewed by bizarrely changed humans. I'm picturing a world of a bewildering variety of inhabitants, and a starship crewed by varieties that are better suited to working on a starship. I think that, for them, making such adaptations won't be much more dramatic than, say, one of us putting on a coat before going out in cold weather, or taking Lactaid before eating ice cream, or building up a base tan before taking a tropical vacation.
 
You have missed the most obvious. While the US has sent men to the moon and flew space shuttles and orbited telescopes our European scientist friends have not been idle. They have come up with a way to detect aliens because they all do this.
 
You have missed the most obvious. While the US has sent men to the moon and flew space shuttles and orbited telescopes our European scientist friends have not been idle. They have come up with a way to detect aliens because they all do this.

This assumes that extraterrestrial life will have similar chemistry to ours. That may well be the case, and we don't know what other chemical bases for life (if any) are possible, but I certainly wouldn't rule out the possibility that life with a radically different chemistry exists.

ETA: I'm also reminded that the late Captain Phil Harris on "Deadliest Catch" claimed to be able to detect the presence of crabs at the bottom of the ocean by smelling their farts bubbling to the surface.
 
Last edited:
This assumes that extraterrestrial life will have similar chemistry to ours. That may well be the case, and we don't know what other chemical bases for life (if any) are possible, but I certainly wouldn't rule out the possibility that life with a radically different chemistry exists.
More general case is looking for an atmosphere in chemical disequilibrium. Large amounts of free oxygen pretty much scream "life" because oxygen is a very reactive gas, and left to its own devices it would quickly combine with other things[1]. But so would large amounts of free chlorine, complicated polysaccharides, or any other low-entropy substance.

[1] Note that presence of free oxygen does not imply the existence of animals which make use of it. It does not even imply photosynthesis. Just some process which produces oxygen as a byproduct, and thus by definition reduces entropy.
 
Any exothermic chemical reaction increases entropy. Oxygen combining with stuff (a.k.a. "burning") increases entropy. Breaking oxides apart and releasing molecular oxygen is the opposite of that.
 
Any exothermic chemical reaction increases entropy. Oxygen combining with stuff (a.k.a. "burning") increases entropy. Breaking oxides apart and releasing molecular oxygen is the opposite of that.
I still don't know why you think that is "definitional" but let's put that aside.

So you're telling me that during the electrolysis of water, for example, that entropy is consumed and disappears?
 
I still don't know why you think that is "definitional" but let's put that aside.

So you're telling me that during the electrolysis of water, for example, that entropy is consumed and disappears?
I don't think consuming is a thing you can do with entropy, but yes, I'm pretty sure entropy decreases in the electrolysis of water.
 
I don't think consuming is a thing you can do with entropy, but yes, I'm pretty sure entropy decreases in the electrolysis of water.
If there is so obvious an example of a violation of the second law of thermodynamics why do think the law hasn't been modified?

In conversations about detecting life, I see a lot of claims about how life could be recognized by a planet being "out of equilibrium" or "at lower entropy" than it "should" be that I just can't make sense of. Not sure if they are wrong or if my understanding is off.
 
OK, I will try to explain.

All natural processes go in the direction of increasing entropy, which is another way of saying "lower potential energy state". A rock on top of a cliff is in higher potential energy state than a rock at the bottom of the cliff, which is why random events like storms and earthquakes tend to move rocks from top to bottom instead of other way around. Likewise, free oxygen and pure iron together are at higher energy state than iron oxide, which is why iron rusts, and rust does not spontaneously turn into iron.

Now, processes we call "life" involve local decrease of entropy. A baby is very complex structure, much more so than proteins and sugars the mother ingests over the course of her pregnancy. Does this mean pregnant woman (or growing plant) violates second law of thermodynamics? Not at all, because this local decrease of entropy is more than balanced by all carbon oxidation she does in that time. And production of that oxygen by green plants, which is also local decrease of entropy, is more than balanced by all the visible light (high frequency = low entropy) these plants have absorbed, ultimately re-radiates as heat (low frequency = high entropy).

So, life does not violate second law of thermodynamics -- it does not decrease overall entropy of the universe (it actually increases it a tiny bit). But on local scale, such as on the scale of a planet, life uses energy to decrease entropy. Think of building a domino castle. Moving your fingers, picking up dominoes, and stacking them together takes energy. In the process you create a local order -- but the amount of sugar you oxidize in the process more than makes up for that order. Granted, it would not be practical to search for life by looking for domino castles, but trees are not too different. Trees are top-heavy structures. Left to laws of physics alone, without life processes, they crack and fall down. Yes, life is not the only way to make top-heavy structures -- here are some pretty spectacular examples made by erosion -- but they are spectacular precisely because they are rare. If we ever find a planet full of top-heavy structures, I would suspect that some entropy-lowering process, i.e. "life" is involved. Even if the structures are all rock and the process does not involve carbon.

Same with free oxygen or any other highly reactive element or highly unstable compound. Something must constantly replenish it, or it would have been gone long time ago. Does this explain it?
 
If there is so obvious an example of a violation of the second law of thermodynamics why do think the law hasn't been modified?

In conversations about detecting life, I see a lot of claims about how life could be recognized by a planet being "out of equilibrium" or "at lower entropy" than it "should" be that I just can't make sense of. Not sure if they are wrong or if my understanding is off.
Entropy does always increase in a closed system. A planet isnot a closed system, though, as it receives massive amounts of energy from its star. But the entropy in the star must increase more than it decreases anywhere else.
 
Does this explain it?
It's a mostly nice explanation of entropy but it doesn't explain the original claim of why oxygen "screams life" or why an atmosphere in chemical disequilibrium is a sign of life (I also don't see why you think our atmosphere is in chemical disequilibrium).

We've already identified non living processes that can locally decrease entropy and produce oxygen.
Left to laws of physics alone, without life processes, they crack and fall down.
So what do you think is at work besides physics?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom