What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.

I strongly disagree with this. Some psychic abilities like telepathy are little different from our internet. The fact this hasn't evolved in any plant or animal - and I could even add "that we know of" here - doesn't mean they couldn't have evolved elsewhere.

I also disagree with insects and hive mind. Of course it could be done with a hive mind, but the species would have to evolve with far, far more specialized subsets than seen on Earth. It could have breeders, thinkers and drones, for instance. Breeders breed, drones work, and thinkers rule the whole thing. Creativity and ingenuity aren't a problem here, it wouldn't be too different from a human feudal society.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
But smelting metal was just one example. The ability to work metal is very, very, very useful for creating a high-tech society.

It was extremely useful for us, but I don't see why our path to technology would be the only one. As for metal work, I can imagine that specialized individuals could live by the hydrothermal seeps, smelting a number of metals in the incredibly high temperatures just a few centimeters away, and thinking how lucky they are, since smelting would be impossible out of water... the heat transfer is so big it would kill you!

Fire itself is also extremely important as a means of a controllable heat source useful for many kinds of processes.

Heat is important. Fire, not so much.

How do your early chemists do their experiments underwater when water gets mixed in with everything?

How did they do the earlier experiments that needed water? Get a bucket of it a bring it home. Think of the same thing upside down.

How well do the first experiments in using electricity work when your Leyden jars are full of water and your dynamos short themselves out?

You're assuming that their path to technology would have to be the same as ours. They could ask how do you even start to do chemistry in an oxygen atmosphere? It's insane!
Or maybe different obstacles lead to different solutions.

And by that time any gentleman scientist would be have air piped straight to their labs :)

How do you invent the printing press and movable type when your paper is all soggy and your ink is floating away?

No particular reason why paper and ink are indispensable to technology.

How do you invent the steam engine, or internal combustion engine when you're underwater? How do you shape glass or fire pottery?

Again, you're falling into the trap of thinking that our way to progress is the only way. Materials for everyday use don't need to be as good as ours, just good enough. Energy doesn't need to come from the same sources, just to be there. If there's intelligence, and a long enough lifespan to tackle big problems, different solutions will arise.

"See, we just have to pipe in to the same concrete chamber methane and air, and we get a lot of heat. If you refine the air into oxygen it's even more heat. And you can leave that black stuff to soak in air for a while, and then it burns too... Fantastic!"

You probably wouldn't even make it to the industrial revolution, let alone space travel.

Yup, they would have died flapping in the streets of London :)
 
Fire itself is also extremely important as a means of a controllable heat source useful for many kinds of processes.
It is not the only one. Some rocks react to water with an exothermic reaction. Put clay all over it to stop the reaction and you have a portable heat source you can turn on whenever you decide to break open the clay.

How do your early chemists do their experiments underwater when water gets mixed in with everything?
How do our physicists do their vacuum experiments when air gets mixed in with everything? Answer: they make a closed thing not containing it. Smart fish may do chemistry like this: they use use balls of wet clay, and use something like a syringe to blow air in the middle so that they get an enclosed space without water.

How well do the first experiments in using electricity work when your Leyden jars are full of water and your dynamos short themselves out?
I'm pretty sure Leiden jars are supposed to be full of water.

How do you invent the printing press and movable type when your paper is all soggy and your ink is floating away?
They may use the skins of other animals to write on, and different ways to discolour them. Or they write in relief, like braille.
 
With regard to communication by bioluminescence, there's no reason to assume it's a single blinking pixel. Consider a skin surface covered with the equivalent of cephalopod chromatophores, thousands of individually controllable 'pixels' that can display complex camouflage patterns and social signals. Such a surface, evolved for complex social communication could communicate entire concepts as images, in a fraction of a second; potentially way superior to our simplistic linear communications.
 
If it's animalistic in nature, then if some of the strange and baffling creatures that call earth home is any indication then it can be just about anything.
True.

That alien life would most likely be very different from human beings.
Define what you mean by "very different". Your assumptions below seem to be heavily biased in favour of humanoid structure.

In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts.
Accepted
They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language.
No. They need a method of exchanging and storing ideas. Not a "language" as we use the term.

Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.
Like humans? What exactly do you mean by "animalistic"? Un-intelligent, non-sentient, what?

Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.
Also not accepted. Why can a hive mind not be creative? In fact, given their potentially superior ability to exchange data and ideas they could be more likely to develop technological solutions to their problems.

They must also be tool users.
If by tool users you mean use, create and modify artifacts to manipulate their environment I agree.

Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs.
Hell no. This is a ridiculous over-generalisation. A technological alien species would require the ability to manipulate their environment; going from this to assuming limbs, bones and fingers is an enormous stretch.

We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs.
Assuming they require a gaseous atmosphere. They'd require an artificially maintained environment.

And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet.
:confused:

So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments.
Humans can't survive on most of this, their home planet, without artificial aids.

This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.
Why?

We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships.
Two assumptions, why would they need to be mobile? And why would their space craft, especially if intended from interstellar travel, be cramped. Hollow out an asteroid.

This eliminates plantoids.
Again no. You're over-extrapolating based on your mammalian prejudices.

This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal.
This is just silly. Why would your putative alien species need to be upright or skeletal, let alone bipedal?

This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.
Again, why?

We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.
Yes. It doesn't exclude biological radio, electric or magnetic senses, light sources, even potentially lasers.
It also doesn't exclude Q-Rays.
 
To answer the question posed in the OP: "NOTHING".

I base this on having a reasonable education, years of continuous learning and having read a few thousand Science Fiction stories. Some of which were written by people even smarter than me. ;)

I'm trying to dig out of my failing memory a John W Campbell quote along the lines of "it all seems so obvious afterwards" but haven't succeeded as yet.

YMMV and etc.

:th:
 
With regard to communication by bioluminescence, there's no reason to assume it's a single blinking pixel. Consider a skin surface covered with the equivalent of cephalopod chromatophores, thousands of individually controllable 'pixels' that can display complex camouflage patterns and social signals. Such a surface, evolved for complex social communication could communicate entire concepts as images, in a fraction of a second; potentially way superior to our simplistic linear communications.
You beat me to this.

Basically, OP assumes an alien species would have all the limitations of the human form, and proceeds to show how without our advantages (opposable thumbs, speech, bipedalism), these limitations make space technology impossible. Once you think past the limitations, it becomes silly. A cuttlefish can play its entire skin like a psychedlic light show, and sizable chunks of its brain are dedicated to both controlling thousands of chromatophores, and interpreting in real time the display of other cuttlefish. An intelligent species with similar brain machinery could communicate a FAR greater bit rate than humans talking, and would not even need to invent new words for new concepts -- you show a new concept.

As for Mudcat's claim that multiple limbs are a disadvantage in cramped spaces... this just baffles me. Who do you think can crawl better in tight confines -- human with his two hands and two feet, chimpanzee with his four hands, or a hypothetical human-size centipede?
 
Last edited:
As promised I will now address the motivations of a spacefaring civilization. But first, by what do I mean by animalistic life? To answer it would be any life that, like whales, have intelligence but no sentience. Creatures that have evolved in the depths of space would also likely be animalistic intelligences.

But what can we assume about animalistic intelligences, spacefaring or otherwise? That those motivations would be extremely simple and likely largely consist of food and mating.

And what then can we assume about an alien civilization capable of journeying into space? Certain small minded individuals would say that we can't assume anything about their motivations and that they may be ultimately unknowable to us, to which I say bullocks.

Any civilization capable of interstellar travel would have likely developed such technology themselves and the process of developing such technology is unlikely to have happened overnight. But what motivates such a civilization? That would, to some degree, depend on the individual. But they would likely be motivated by the full range of needs and ambitions that humans are.

What can we assume about their morales? Once again that would depend on the individuals and as such there would be saints and there would be sinners and everything in between. But since we're talking about an advanced civilization we can assume that their society have laws developed over the course of their history that encourages desired behaviors and punishes undesired behaviors.

...I'm sorry but am I the only one who fails to see how any of this is radically different from humanity?
 
And what then can we assume about an alien civilization capable of journeying into space? Certain small minded individuals
Irony
But what motivates such a civilization? That would, to some degree, depend on the individual. But they would likely be motivated by the full range of needs and ambitions that humans are.
At least half of human motivations are based on the fact that we have two sexes, with one doing bulk of biological investment on offspring. At least half of the rest of human motivations are based on us being hierarchical pack apes.

Drop the above constraints, and motivations will be VERY different. A hermaphroditic species which spawns thousands of young and eats most of them before they develop sentience and can be accepted into tribe, will behave very differently than humans.

Primate hierarchy is all about access to mating privileges, which is very parochial -- not all mammals, not even all social mammals, operate on this principle. Ambitions of alien species which is not driven by "social standing => sex" will again be very different.
 
Last edited:
At least half of human motivations are based on the fact that we have two sexes, with one doing bulk of biological investment on offspring. At least half of the rest of human motivations are based on us being hierarchical pack animals.

Did I suggest otherwise?

Mark6 said:
Drop the above constraints, and motivations will be VERY different.

I most certainly won't.

Mark6 said:
A hermaphroditic species which spawns thousands of young and eats most of them before they develop sentience and can be accepted into tribe, will behave very differently than humans.

And this makes sense to you?
 
Why not? We produce millions of sperm and hundreds of eggs, only small fraction of which "get accepted into society". The rest are culled. I just posited a species in which the culling process takes place outside parent's body instead of inside.

And two sexes are just an accident of evolution. There are many hermaphroditic species. There are species with more than two sexes.
 
Primate hierarchy is all about access to mating privileges, which is very parochial -- not all mammals, not even all social mammals, operate on this principle. Ambitions of alien species which is not driven by "social standing => sex" will again be very different.

And this makes sense to you?

A non-human species with different biological and social constructs will exhibit different behaviors and motivations than humans? Makes sense to me.
 
Could you imagine the size of the spaceships required to lift a crew of elephant sized humanoids into space? It might not even get off the ground, never mind get them into orbit.

Saturn Vs could deliver 118,000 kg payloads to low Earth orbit and we build those things over 40 years ago.
 
Last edited:
We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet. So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.
Cold-blooded is BETTER suited for prolonged space travel than warm-blooded. They need less food and less oxygen, especially at low temperatures -- which also decrease the need for energy (warm-blooded need MORE food at low temperature). A spaceship on multi-month or multi-year mission would have its temperature set near freezing, and its crew of reptiles will almost hibernate, using minimum of resources. Whoever is on watch will keep to a 70-80 F room in order to remain alert. At destination, or in case of emergency, rapidly raise temperature to 120 F, and entire crew will go into overdrive.
 
In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts. They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language. Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.

As human, we are animals you know. We are not something "special". We are mamals animals. All you can say is that a certain intelligence level is required. You cannot draw any conclusion from that about which life form that implies. ETA: and comms can be as per image (see below) or color or whatever. We have example of species which basically communicate without words. Like bee : their dance shows direction and distance to flower. Etc...

Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.

Noper. If the hive mind is advanced enough, to innovate, then it does not matter it is a hive mind.

They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.

Nope. Tentacle with sucker or similar.

We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet. So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.

Nope. Pure aquatic or amphibian , maybe even travelling in water capsule rather than air capsule. Granted it would take much more energy to accelerate or decelerate, but hey it is not a limitation.

We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids. This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.

Nope. it is an assumption of yours. they could travel in a generation ship with enormous space. Like an emptied asteroid. In fact it is much much more likely , than in a normal cramped ship, consdiering FTL is impossible, and considering they would spend a LOT of time in it => need a lot of resource. Solution. generation shi. An humongus asteroid emptied, isolated from space, full of resource, with a small group genetic diverse enough to travel and reproduce among the 1000000 of years of travel. Incidentally that also kill again your aquatic objection.


We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.

*shrug* they could have developped radio communication. Or communciate through visible change on their body thru IR. Open your mind ;).
 
Last edited:
Why not? We produce millions of sperm and hundreds of eggs, only small fraction of which "get accepted into society". The rest are culled. I just posited a species in which the culling process takes place outside parent's body instead of inside.

Plenty of species do the majority of their reproduction outside of their bodies. Most don't eat their young.

Mark6 said:
And two sexes are just an accident of evolution. There are many hermaphroditic species. There are species with more than two sexes.

I wasn't objecting to the possibility of a hermaphroditic species, in fact it would certainly be an evolutional advantage over our mode of reproduction and would likely be more beneficial towards their society than having the race divided between two sexes.

It was the whole devouring their young that I objected. Most species don't do that sort of thing and I think it would be unlikely behavior of higher lifeforms.
 
A non-human species with different biological and social constructs will exhibit different behaviors and motivations than humans? Makes sense to me.

I object to that line of reasoning and I spelt out clearly why. Individual motivations might be different to a certain degree, and we might not understand those motivations right away. But you could say thing about human motivations.
 
Did I suggest otherwise?
The central principle of your analysis seems to be that it refuses to even consider that it could be otherwise.

I most certainly won't.
Why not? Why must we insist on assuming that all alien spacefaring races will have those constraints?

And this makes sense to you?
Asked and answered.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom