What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

Seems like the title of this thread should be "if you don't agree with mudcat's assumptions, you're wrong".

You have it all backwards. It's "Whomever Mudcat disagrees with is wrong" :cool:

I can see why the individual drones wouldn't be terribly creative; it's not clear to me why the hive as a whole (or the ruling caste) couldn't be.

While you bring up a good point I can't see anything with a hive mentality developing much beyond an agrarian society because they lack individual initiative.

dasmiller said:
I'm not ready to rule out other approaches simply because us opposable-thumbers got there first.
I am, because (as another poster has pointed out) you have to look at what you're working on.



dasmiller said:
Wouldn't they build their spaceships to accommodate themselves?

Sure, but the main biological/evolutionary disadvantage to aquatic lifeforms is that they require specific water temperatures/pressures in order just to survive. Constantly maintaining a specific temperatures of water requires more resources than what's feasible for prolonged voyages and water is (for intents and purposes) non-compressible. Meaning no space-faring fishies. And by extension, most likely no spacefaring cold blooded life (such as lizards, for example).



dasmiller said:
I suspect that the environments in human-built manned spacecraft have far, far less variation than we see in the nature, even among the areas inhabited by humans.

There aren't any naturally occurring environments like you would find on the ISS, to the best of my knowledge. And I doubt you would be able to find a space ship or station that has an environment like what naturally occurs, either. This is a practical limitation, more than anything else, and it's one that would be normal to find on any spacecraft, regardless of origin.




dasmiller said:
Again, I suspect that they'd design their ships to accommodate themselves. Also, I have lived in houses (designed for humans) that had inhabitants that were not bipedal and definitely had tails, and they were able to move about quite freely.

True, but the majority of those animals are smaller than the people that built the houses, which are ultimately built to accommodate humans.



Followed, of course, with your humanoid set of assumptions.

A human point of view is the only one that I have or is even possible at this stage. To say otherwise is dishonest.

Slimething said:
Followed by your ridiculing the first few posters who disagreed with your assumptions.

How have I ridiculed anyone?

This is not a given. it's easy to imagine an organism that launches their pods high and far, and occasionally one of those pods escapes the thin atmosphere... There you have it, space travel without spaceships.

I somehow doubt that classifies as spacefaring, but it's certainly possible and worth considering.



Megalodan said:
If they had a communication system that allowed them to effectively unite their brains (think biological Internet), via pheromones, or small electric charges, or even bioluminescence, then they could dominate very difficult concepts very fast, even with relatively small brains.

With communications like that, the question becomes "Can they carry meaningful communications or relate abstract ideas?" And I think the answer to that is a resounding no.


Megalodan said:
And the idea that a bowerbird can produce monuments that are more advanced than anything some of our much brainier ancesters ever did is nothing short of awesome.

In my search for ancient monuments, the most primitive I could find were standing stones. Even just that requires tool use, dexterity, and sophisticated reasoning skills that bowerbirds are incapable of. And bowerbird nests, as impressive as they are, aren't that much more advanced than any other bird's nest which are far outclassed by our ancestors whenever the wove a simple basket.



Megalodan said:
Unless they can just freeze-dry themselves without damage, like tardigrades. Actually, highly intelligent tardigrades would be one of the most formidable species I can imagine.

You bring up a very good point I failed to consider. Thank you.


Megalodan said:
Yes, elephant sized humanoids would not be space faring because ships are so small... if only there was a way to compensate for size when building the damn things.

Could you imagine the size of the spaceships required to lift a crew of elephant sized humanoids into space? It might not even get off the ground, never mind get them into orbit.



Megalodan said:
For instance, fast pulse bioluminescence could easily be confused with telepathy.

Already addressed, but bioluminescence might be okay for simple communication but I highly doubt you would be able to communicate abstract ideas or meaningful concepts with it.

Megalodan said:
What I get from your post is that your knowledge of the world you live in is lacking, and so is your imagination.

I actually have a very good imagination and can easily imagine strange creatures that would be freakish even by comparison to creatures that live here on earth. I'm also a practical man and as such I can't envision any of those achieving any kind of advanced civilization.

Megalodan said:
Great topic, though :)
Thank you!
You didn't ask for an accurate comparison.

Since you want me to be mocking so badly... What the heck do you think I meant when I said that?


MikeG said:
Tiresome semantics.
Important distinction, actually.


MikeG said:
Please tell me you're joking.

Mistaken, yes. Joking, no. It's still undeniable that birds have been around a lot longer than humans.
 
Last edited:
More interesting and imaginative replies.

Well, obviously. A spacefaring race implies spaceships. Spaceships don't grow on trees, so you need tools to build them.
Or trees upon which spaceships grow...

Aquatic lifeforms probably wouldn't be be capable of a high-tech civilization anyway, because it's hard to build fires hot enough to smelt metal when you live underwater.
Maybe they can use chemical or mechanical processes instead? Tidal surges driving work surfaces together at great pressures, then 'eating' and 'digesting' the intermediate work product in specialized processing organs?

I dunno... Just wondering if we really need to assume "fire" as a requirement proto-spacefaring civilization.

You have a point with plants, but they could possibly build remote-controlled drones. In fact, they'd probably have to build remote-controlled drones in order to construct the space-ships for them. (Not that this would be likely, given that plants don't have brains.)
A plant and a symbiotic insect colony might evolve together into a spacefaring joint venture.
 
Last edited:
  1. In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts. They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language. Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.
  2. Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.
  3. They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.
  4. We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet. So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.

    We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids. This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.
  5. We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.

  1. Humans are 'animals' too. Great apes!
    So perhaps you are saying spacefarers would have to be 'humanoid'?
  2. Hive mindedness would actually be an advantage to any species in whatever they put their mind to, including traveling interstellar.

  3. Or something akin to thumbs. Importantly they have to be able to make tools.
  4. It is highly unlikely that biological forms could survive the rigors of interstellar travel.
    What is more likely is that biological forms would create machines which would be able to accomplish this on behalf of the home planet tool making biological creators.
    The best the creators could hope for is that the biological seed is sent with the ship and that when the ship encounters a viable planet in which the seed can survive, it can grow the fetuses on-board, educate the beings into maturity and place these on the planet and watch over them for a time until it is proven that they reproduce and survive adequately, thus giving the maximum possible chance for those beings to advance into technological prowess eventually to repeat the process of making machines to travel interstellar space with their seed.
  5. Thus we can assume that the process is being repeated throughout the universe where biological life has evolved and succeeded enough to get to the point of creating machines to help seed the universe.
 
I somehow doubt that classifies as spacefaring, but it's certainly possible and worth considering.

Well, a coconut doesn't care if you call it a seafarer, it just crosses oceans to colonize new lands.



With communications like that, the question becomes "Can they carry meaningful communications or relate abstract ideas?" And I think the answer to that is a resounding no.

Only if you have no idea what you're talking about. All your thoughts are chemical reactions and electrical impulses. It's just a matter of scale. As for bioluminescence, sufficiently short pulses could make our communication look like entish...

In my search for ancient monuments, the most primitive I could find were standing stones. Even just that requires tool use, dexterity, and sophisticated reasoning skills that bowerbirds are incapable of. And bowerbird nests, as impressive as they are, aren't that much more advanced than any other bird's nest which are far outclassed by our ancestors whenever the wove a simple basket.

Was referring to farther down time... well before Sapiens.

You bring up a very good point I failed to consider. Thank you.

Very welcome...

Could you imagine the size of the spaceships required to lift an elephant sized humanoid into space? It might not even get off the ground, never mind get them into orbit.

Of course, an elephant-sized humanoid might just have evolved in a planet with lower gravity, making the problems go away... both the liftoff and the physiological difficulties.

Already addressed, but bioluminescence might be okay for simple communication but I highly doubt you would be able to communicate abstract ideas or meaningful concepts with it.

You were wrong before, and you still are. Pulses can spell patterns as much as sounds. What you are saying is that there is no way you could use vocalizations to communicate abstract ideas.

I actually have a very good imagination and can easily imagine strange creatures that would be freakish even by comparison to creatures that live here on earth. I'm also a practical man and as such I can't envision any of those achieving any kind of advanced civilization.

Now its my turn to have doubts...
 
But a disadvantage in enclosed spaces.

Octopi don't seem to think so.

And have you ever tried to maneuver your legs from the passenger seat to the driver's seat of a compact car? Legs can go from being plain useless to being actually counter-productive in cramped spaces.

And in zero-g, what are they good for, except pushing off? In a cramped space, how much of that are you going to need. Better to have a few extra hands, the better to grasp handholds, carry things, and manipulate tools. In a cramped space with no gravity, an arm is just as good as a foot for pushing off.
 
But a disadvantage in enclosed spaces.

So you continue with your objection that non-humanoids couldn't build ships because they would have problems in ships built by humanoids, for humanoids.

Better think that one over a bit better.
 
In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts.
Most of your suggestions assume that these lifeforms evolved in an environment very similar to ours here on Earth, and had to come up with technology to cope with outer space. There is another possibility: lifeforms who evolved in outer space and whose phenotypes are adapted to outer space conditions. Living spaceships.

The problem with your assumptions is that they are based on a dataset of none. We know of exactly zero species that have managed to become a space-faring civilisation in the way you are suggesting. I don't think there is much evidence that human like beings living on an Earth like planet are likely to overcome the challenges of transitioning to life away from the biosphere they're from. Living spaceships on the other hand -- no matter how unlikely they are -- wouldn't have to face such a transitioning challenge.

They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language.
Depends on what you mean with written and spoken language. If you mean a language that consists of noises and smearing coloured liquids over flat sheets, I see no reason for it. Communication through bioluminescence, changing colour patterns or gestures have a few really neat advantages for a space-faring species: all communication through vision can be carried across great distances, even through the vacuum of space. At light speed.

Some form of "writing" is likely necessary; that is to say storing information compactly and accurately to be used in the future or by someone else. It may not take the form we would recognise today; in fact we are now on this very forum using a method that is very different than the old scribbling stuff on paper our ancestors knew about.

Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.
The "hive mind" of social insects is a bit of a myth. Every ant has its own little mind and is pursuing its own goals, its just that ant society continues to function with a lot of individuals goofing off.

A hive mind like that of Star Trek's Borg; now that would be incredibly useful in a highly advanced technological society: knowledge and mental skills can be instantly transmitted and copied to many individuals, individuals with potentially destructive thoughts can quickly be identified and reformed or eliminated. No one fearing individual death because their mind can stored, transmitted and reused in another body.

To keep spontaneity, creativity and innovation some sense of individualism may exist together with a communal hive mind; it certainly wasn't the Borg's smartest move to eliminate that completely and become entirely dependent on assimilation of other species in order to gain new knowledge.

Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs.
Or anything else with a similar function.

And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet.
I think space engineers actually try to replicate the Earth's atmosphere on board the international space station, as best as they can. I don't think it reasonable to assume it will be "far different".

So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.
Being cold blooded would be a huge advantage in space. One of the big problems that space stations or space suits have to solve for humans is cooling. Warm blooded animals keep their temperature by burning lots of fuel and have convection move the heat away. It's like keeping the temperature in your house constant by putting the heater on its max and opening all the windows; it works but it is not energy efficient. And it doesn't work in space: heat dissipates very poorly in a vacuum.

If we were cold blooded, we wouldn't need to bring as much food on board a spaceship, and there would be much less an issue of getting rid of excess heat.

This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.
In Zero G, I think it would be pretty useful to be a monkey with a prehensile tail, and a pair of hand-like feet.
 
I strongly disagree with your disagreement, and here is why (I hope you won't label me a "sad individual"):

I won't label you as a sad individual as long as you have an intelligent and well reasoned reason for disagreeing with my disagreement. Not going beyond "Alien life has to be different than life here", with no forethought is sad. But your post is insightful and thought provoking so you're far from sad. Even if I disagree with you.


theprestige said:
We can eliminate "animalistic life forms" as we know them. It may well be that the perceptions, motivations, and modes of thought of these spacefarers is so inscrutable, so--well, alien--to us as to be unrecognizable as meaningfully sentient.

I don't think that the perceptions, motivations, or modes of thought of any sentient race would be too far alien as all that. But this goes into motivations rather than their resemblance to anything we can recognize.

That brings up a new tangent, which I'll address in a separate post.

theprestige said:
Maybe the capability evolved naturally.

I'm not sure by what you mean.


theprestige said:
Unless the hive mind is of a type that increases in spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, the more individuals join the hive. Maybe their entire history of civilization is a story of incrementally expanding the upper limits on hive membership, each generation larger than the last, and each bootstrapping themselves to the next level of intelligence and technology.

That would be highly unwieldy, but I can see what you mean.


theprestige said:
Imagine an aquatic life form that manufactures by secreting layers of specially-formulated ceramics and glues from specialized glands, and finishes them against pods and protusions evolved for this purpose.

Ignoring fire, the wheel, and the internal combustion engine, they might skip straight to a technology based on organically-formed resistors, transistors, capacitors, etc. They'd become masters of magnetohydrodynamic effects.

They'd secrete outer carapaces that function as pressure vessels, environment containers, and radiation shields. Their ship would need no atmosphere, as each of them, snail-like, would already be carrying his home on his back all the time. They could brachiate about the vacuum-exposed scaffolding of their vessel on thought-controlled prosthetic pseudopods (see "psychic abilities", below), and plug into tanks of gases, liquids, and nutrients as necessary.

As long as their outer shell is adapted to a variety of environments, that's all the adaptation they need.

Sounds like something out of the Star Trek: Titan novels. But what you're suggesting is definitely fascinating and interesting... But unlikely.



thepresige said:
What about creatures that have already evolved built-in bluetooth circuits in their heads?

It would have to shift through all the myriad, random impulses of a developed brain to get what the individual wishes to communicate, transmit it, and be received where the next individual does all that in reverse.

Might as well suggest telepathy or magic while you're at it.
 
Mistaken, yes. Joking, no. It's still undeniable that birds have been around a lot longer than humans.
But that's a very lopsided comparison. "Birds" is "Class" level classification on the taxonomic scale. "Humans" is genus level. "Birds" should be compared to something like "mammal" and "humans" should be compared to something like "geese". If you do that you'll find the comparison you're making becomes meaningless. Mammals and birds didn't appear all that far apart, and there are likely a lot of genera of birds that are more recent than our genera.

But is your line of reasoning reasonable? If so, what is the time limit for a biological clade to produce intelligence? If mammals hadn't done it about 2 million years ago would they have missed their shot?
 
Sure, but the main biological/evolutionary disadvantage to aquatic lifeforms is that they require specific water temperatures/pressures in order just to survive.
Cold blooded animals are so much more dependent on the outside temperature that they actually to be able to survive much greater differences in temperature than warm blooded animals; many of them even have vastly more DNA to encode for different enzymes to do the same jobs but at different temperatures. Aquatic lifeforms also are more capable of withstanding changes in pressure; some can live just as easily near the surface of the water and dive deeper than most of our submersibles dare to go.

Constantly maintaining a specific temperatures of water requires more resources than what's feasible for prolonged voyages and water is (for intents and purposes) non-compressible.
Maintaining a constant temperature isn't that hard in space. A space ship is basically in the universe's biggest thermos: a vacuum flask with walls the size of the universe. It only gets difficult to keep the temperature constant if there are heat sources inside, such as warm blooded humanoids. Constantly burning huge amounts of calories for no good reason.

The mass and non-compressibility of water may be an issue, but if humans can invent oxigenated fluids they can breath with their lungs, smart fishes should be able to come up with a gas they can breath through their gills.

With communications like that, the question becomes "Can they carry meaningful communications or relate abstract ideas?" And I think the answer to that is a resounding no.
I think the answer to that is a resounding yes. Even humans have figured out already that communication through grunts, hisses and lip smacking kind of sucks. Whenever we want to really communicate complex and abstract ideas we tend to use things like pulses of light (sometimes through glass cables) or rather similar radiowaves. Meaningful communication of complex abstract ideas can be done through even the most primitive forms of communication (for example the electric telegraph using Morse code). Bioluminescence can use different pulses, colours and shapes of light, even many at the same time. It is not as primitive as Morse code.

Could you imagine the size of the spaceships required to lift a crew of elephant sized humanoids into space? It might not even get off the ground, never mind get them into orbit.
Yeah, elephants would never get into space. Even just the G-Forces of a launch would be too great for them. Of course on a planet with less gravity things might start to look different. I'm not convinced though that humans are the right size for space travelling. With the effort an resources needed to get them in orbit, they seem to me just way too big.
 
Well, a coconut doesn't care if you call it a seafarer, it just crosses oceans to colonize new lands.

But we aren't talking about coconuts, we're talking about intelligent races and spacefaring aliens.



Megalodon said:
It's just a matter of scale. As for bioluminescence, sufficiently short pulses could make our communication look like entish...

Sigh... It's like this, the bioluminescent pulses would have to be sufficiently long enough for the receiver to see and decipher whatever intended meaning behind the pulse would be. A language like this would be more like Morse code. Good for communicating short messages, but terrible for anything else.



Megalodon said:
Of course, an elephant-sized humanoid might just have evolved in a planet with lower gravity, making the problems go away... both the liftoff and the physiological difficulties.

Or they might have developed on a planet with higher gravity. Both of the objections are equally meaningless.

Megalodon said:
Now its my turn to have doubts...

I once conceived of a number of alien lifeforms that had evolved in the atmosphere of Jupiter. Your doubt has just been made invalid.

Most of your suggestions assume that these lifeforms evolved in an environment very similar to ours here on Earth, and had to come up with technology to cope with outer space.

That is because I am a human being, descended of other human beings that have had born and died here on earth. What other perspective could I possibly have?

Earthborn said:
There is another possibility: lifeforms who evolved in outer space and whose phenotypes are adapted to outer space conditions. Living spaceships.

That's certainly possible. I believe that such creatures might exist in stellar nurseries and such.

Earthborn said:
I think space engineers actually try to replicate the Earth's atmosphere on board the international space station, as best as they can.

"Try" being the key operative word there.

Earthborn said:
I don't think it reasonable to assume it will be "far different".

I'd agree with you, assuming that said alien species come from a world like ours. But certain sad individuals won't have any of that. So what if the race came from a pyroclastic planet or from some other world with extreme environments? Or from a gaseous giant? Or a pelagic world?
 
Last edited:
I won't label you as a sad individual as long as you have an intelligent and well reasoned reason for disagreeing with my disagreement. Not going beyond "Alien life has to be different than life here", with no forethought is sad. But your post is insightful and thought provoking so you're far from sad. Even if I disagree with you.
It's not that alien life has to be different, it's that there's no good reason for it to be similar.

I don't think that the perceptions, motivations, or modes of thought of any sentient race would be too far alien as all that. But this goes into motivations rather than their resemblance to anything we can recognize.

That brings up a new tangent, which I'll address in a separate post.
Fair enough. I look forward to it.

I'm not sure by what you mean.
I mean that instead of building tools for space travel, maybe they grew organs for space travel, or something. I think that "tools" is an unwarranted assumption, given our sample size.

That would be highly unwieldy, but I can see what you mean.
Maybe, maybe not. "Unwieldy" is probably a relative term, anyway. There's a lot about humans that's unwieldy for space travel, but we seem to be bent on giving it a go anyway.

A superintelligent hive mind could come up with all sorts of clever workarounds. One I already mentioned is sending dumb individuals with prosthetic brains to do their advanced thinking for them. That allows for some spacefaring, without having to transport an entire city-sized hive intellect.

Sounds like something out of the Star Trek: Titan novels. But what you're suggesting is definitely fascinating and interesting... But unlikely.
I think "unlikely" is an unwarranted assumption, given our sample size.

An alien civilization that evolved in a rich soup of nutrients and manufacturing materials might find the concept of stick-men propping themselves up on wobbly limbs, against the full force of gravity, in a laughably thin gaseous atmosphere, optimistically trying to harness naked combustion for useful purposes, to be unlikely to the point of absurdity.

In all the wide universe, who can say which is more unlikely?

It would have to shift through all the myriad, random impulses of a developed brain to get what the individual wishes to communicate, transmit it, and be received where the next individual does all that in reverse.
The two halves of the brain communicate with each other. The eye and the visual cortex seem to talk just fine. The impulses of the brain aren't actually myriad and random--quite the opposite (this should be obvious).

Might as well suggest telepathy or magic while you're at it.
Done and done.
 
But we aren't talking about coconuts, we're talking about intelligent races and spacefaring aliens.

But there's the thing. Why do they have to be intelligent?

A non-intelligent multicellular organism may live in space by eating asteroids, somewhat like rock-eating bacteria on earth. They colonize new rocks in collisions. They live inside the rock so they can survive entry and impact with a planet and then live on that planet.

They might have evolved on a planet in the first place and the rocks they were living in were launched into space by a large comet impact.
 
Sure, but the main biological/evolutionary disadvantage to aquatic lifeforms is that they require specific water temperatures/pressures in order just to survive. Constantly maintaining a specific temperatures of water requires more resources than what's feasible for prolonged voyages and water is (for intents and purposes) non-compressible. Meaning no space-faring fishies. And by extension, most likely no spacefaring cold blooded life (such as lizards, for example).

Maintaining a constant temperature isn't that hard in space. A space ship is basically in the universe's biggest thermos: a vacuum flask with walls the size of the universe. It only gets difficult to keep the temperature constant if there are heat sources inside, such as warm blooded humanoids. Constantly burning huge amounts of calories for no good reason.

The mass and non-compressibility of water may be an issue, but if humans can invent oxigenated fluids they can breath with their lungs, smart fishes should be able to come up with a gas they can breath through their gills.
Seems to me the biggest difference between putting a thermos full of air into orbit and putting a thermos full of water into orbit is weight. It would take a lot more effort to get the water out of the gravity well.
 
There aren't any naturally occurring environments like you would find on the ISS, to the best of my knowledge.

Isn't that a warm, low pressure, low humidity environment? Sounds like the type of environment you'd naturally find at a high altitude mountainside in the summer.

Lots of animals have been sent into space and survived just fine. Monkeys, mice, dogs, guinea pigs, frogs, rats, cats, insects, tortoise, fish, spiders, newts, ect. There's nothing special about humans that make us uniquely suited to survive the environmental conditions aboard a space vessel. It looks like just about any living thing can survive the conditions inside a spacecraft.

Already addressed, but bioluminescence might be okay for simple communication but I highly doubt you would be able to communicate abstract ideas or meaningful concepts with it.

Assuming that they could rapidly switch the bio-luminescence on and off, they could use it like Morse code to communicate whatever they want.

(ETA: I see that I've been beaten to the Morse Code analogy more than once.)
 
Last edited:
If we were cold blooded, we wouldn't need to bring as much food on board a spaceship, and there would be much less an issue of getting rid of excess heat.

Plus since they're using less food they're also using less oxygen, which would be another great advantage to being cold blooded in space.

Maybe they can use chemical or mechanical processes instead? Tidal surges driving work surfaces together at great pressures, then 'eating' and 'digesting' the intermediate work product in specialized processing organs?

I dunno... Just wondering if we really need to assume "fire" as a requirement proto-spacefaring civilization.

It's highly unlikely that they'd have evolved internal organs capable of producing metal cogs and gears.

But smelting metal was just one example. The ability to work metal is very, very, very useful for creating a high-tech society.

Fire itself is also extremely important as a means of a controllable heat source useful for many kinds of processes.

But think about all the other difficulties an underwater species would have in developing a high-tech society.

How do your early chemists do their experiments underwater when water gets mixed in with everything? How well do the first experiments in using electricity work when your Leyden jars are full of water and your dynamos short themselves out? How do you invent the printing press and movable type when your paper is all soggy and your ink is floating away?

How do you invent the steam engine, or internal combustion engine when you're underwater? How do you shape glass or fire pottery?

You probably wouldn't even make it to the industrial revolution, let alone space travel.
 
But think about all the other difficulties an underwater species would have in developing a high-tech society.

How do your early chemists do their experiments underwater when water gets mixed in with everything? How well do the first experiments in using electricity work when your Leyden jars are full of water and your dynamos short themselves out? How do you invent the printing press and movable type when your paper is all soggy and your ink is floating away?

How do you invent the steam engine, or internal combustion engine when you're underwater? How do you shape glass or fire pottery?

You probably wouldn't even make it to the industrial revolution, let alone space travel.

I, too, am very dubious about the possibilities for an aquatic technological civilization, but consider: A number of fish have electroreception. An intelligent aquatic species with electroreception might well develop basic electronics before the wheel; their technological development would look very, very different from ours.
 
But think about all the other difficulties an underwater species would have in developing a high-tech society.

How do your early chemists do their experiments underwater when water gets mixed in with everything? How well do the first experiments in using electricity work when your Leyden jars are full of water and your dynamos short themselves out? How do you invent the printing press and movable type when your paper is all soggy and your ink is floating away?

How do you invent the steam engine, or internal combustion engine when you're underwater? How do you shape glass or fire pottery?

You probably wouldn't even make it to the industrial revolution, let alone space travel.
Well, I'm skeptical that an aquatic species could become technological too, but can't get past the idea that I have no experience at all being an aquatic species. None of the things you mentioned is required to be considered technological. An aquatic species may not do any of those things, but there could be a technological path suitable to an aquatic life that would just never occur to us.
 
But we aren't talking about coconuts, we're talking about intelligent races and spacefaring aliens.

I'm showing that intelligence is not required for purpose.

Sigh... It's like this, the bioluminescent pulses would have to be sufficiently long enough for the receiver to see and decipher whatever intended meaning behind the pulse would be. A language like this would be more like Morse code. Good for communicating short messages, but terrible for anything else.

No, it's not like this. You are assuming that reception would be made by eyes that can only process at human speed, because that is only the way a monkey would do it. even a pigeon would be able to process variations in shade and intensity that humans wouldn't be able to see, so to presume to know what would be the capabilities of organisms that evolved for that is just silly.

BTW your own language is not much faster than morse, for someone who was trained for it.

Or they might have developed on a planet with higher gravity. Both of the objections are equally meaningless.

No, they couldn't unless their atmosphere was incredibly dense. In which case flying something out of the atmosphere would be different from what we do, but potentially less energy consuming. There are physiologic constraints to body shapes.

And, of course, a spaceship doesn't need to reach space in one piece, it can be assembled there.

I'd agree with you, assuming that said alien species come from a world like ours. But certain sad individuals won't have any of that. So what if the race came from a pyroclastic planet or from some other world with extreme environments? Or from a gaseous giant? Or a pelagic world?

Again with the name calling... nobody called you a dunce for not grasping even the basics of the things you presume to be an authority in. You asked a good question, and found people that obviously can see farther than you, so enjoy the ride and learn something.

You are trying to box everything in to the "humans are the best, everything else sucks" category, when we ourselves are definitively not ready for interstellar journeys. It works as an artifice in Star Trek (It's notoriously difficult to find super-intelligent squadrons of space hornets on such a tight budget) but if we ever find alien lifeforms we are probably in for a surprise. We might be able to find a crude equivalent on Earth, assuming they come from a similar enough planet, but humanoids are a longshot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom