Mudcat
Man of a Thousand Memes
- Joined
- Apr 6, 2011
- Messages
- 6,474
Seems like the title of this thread should be "if you don't agree with mudcat's assumptions, you're wrong".
You have it all backwards. It's "Whomever Mudcat disagrees with is wrong"
I can see why the individual drones wouldn't be terribly creative; it's not clear to me why the hive as a whole (or the ruling caste) couldn't be.
While you bring up a good point I can't see anything with a hive mentality developing much beyond an agrarian society because they lack individual initiative.
I am, because (as another poster has pointed out) you have to look at what you're working on.dasmiller said:I'm not ready to rule out other approaches simply because us opposable-thumbers got there first.
dasmiller said:Wouldn't they build their spaceships to accommodate themselves?
Sure, but the main biological/evolutionary disadvantage to aquatic lifeforms is that they require specific water temperatures/pressures in order just to survive. Constantly maintaining a specific temperatures of water requires more resources than what's feasible for prolonged voyages and water is (for intents and purposes) non-compressible. Meaning no space-faring fishies. And by extension, most likely no spacefaring cold blooded life (such as lizards, for example).
dasmiller said:I suspect that the environments in human-built manned spacecraft have far, far less variation than we see in the nature, even among the areas inhabited by humans.
There aren't any naturally occurring environments like you would find on the ISS, to the best of my knowledge. And I doubt you would be able to find a space ship or station that has an environment like what naturally occurs, either. This is a practical limitation, more than anything else, and it's one that would be normal to find on any spacecraft, regardless of origin.
dasmiller said:Again, I suspect that they'd design their ships to accommodate themselves. Also, I have lived in houses (designed for humans) that had inhabitants that were not bipedal and definitely had tails, and they were able to move about quite freely.
True, but the majority of those animals are smaller than the people that built the houses, which are ultimately built to accommodate humans.
Followed, of course, with your humanoid set of assumptions.
A human point of view is the only one that I have or is even possible at this stage. To say otherwise is dishonest.
Slimething said:Followed by your ridiculing the first few posters who disagreed with your assumptions.
How have I ridiculed anyone?
This is not a given. it's easy to imagine an organism that launches their pods high and far, and occasionally one of those pods escapes the thin atmosphere... There you have it, space travel without spaceships.
I somehow doubt that classifies as spacefaring, but it's certainly possible and worth considering.
Megalodan said:If they had a communication system that allowed them to effectively unite their brains (think biological Internet), via pheromones, or small electric charges, or even bioluminescence, then they could dominate very difficult concepts very fast, even with relatively small brains.
With communications like that, the question becomes "Can they carry meaningful communications or relate abstract ideas?" And I think the answer to that is a resounding no.
Megalodan said:And the idea that a bowerbird can produce monuments that are more advanced than anything some of our much brainier ancesters ever did is nothing short of awesome.
In my search for ancient monuments, the most primitive I could find were standing stones. Even just that requires tool use, dexterity, and sophisticated reasoning skills that bowerbirds are incapable of. And bowerbird nests, as impressive as they are, aren't that much more advanced than any other bird's nest which are far outclassed by our ancestors whenever the wove a simple basket.
Megalodan said:Unless they can just freeze-dry themselves without damage, like tardigrades. Actually, highly intelligent tardigrades would be one of the most formidable species I can imagine.
You bring up a very good point I failed to consider. Thank you.
Megalodan said:Yes, elephant sized humanoids would not be space faring because ships are so small... if only there was a way to compensate for size when building the damn things.
Could you imagine the size of the spaceships required to lift a crew of elephant sized humanoids into space? It might not even get off the ground, never mind get them into orbit.
Megalodan said:For instance, fast pulse bioluminescence could easily be confused with telepathy.
Already addressed, but bioluminescence might be okay for simple communication but I highly doubt you would be able to communicate abstract ideas or meaningful concepts with it.
Megalodan said:What I get from your post is that your knowledge of the world you live in is lacking, and so is your imagination.
I actually have a very good imagination and can easily imagine strange creatures that would be freakish even by comparison to creatures that live here on earth. I'm also a practical man and as such I can't envision any of those achieving any kind of advanced civilization.
Thank you!Megalodan said:Great topic, though![]()
You didn't ask for an accurate comparison.
Since you want me to be mocking so badly... What the heck do you think I meant when I said that?
Important distinction, actually.MikeG said:Tiresome semantics.
MikeG said:Please tell me you're joking.
Mistaken, yes. Joking, no. It's still undeniable that birds have been around a lot longer than humans.
Last edited: