What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

Cold-blooded is BETTER suited for prolonged space travel than warm-blooded. They need less food and less oxygen, especially at low temperatures -- which also decrease the need for energy (warm-blooded need MORE food at low temperature). A spaceship on multi-month or multi-year mission would have its temperature set near freezing, and its crew of reptiles will almost hibernate, using minimum of resources. Whoever is on watch will keep to a 70-80 F room in order to remain alert. At destination, or in case of emergency, rapidly raise temperature to 120 F, and entire crew will go into overdrive.

I love this cold-blooded protocol, using variable temperature to manage resource consumption and incident responsiveness.

Makes me think that probably if humans ever do become spacefarers, it'll be a genetically-engineered cold-blooded or pseudo-cold-blooded variant of the species.

Perhaps we should assume that an alien spacefaring race will be capable of intentionally modifying its form and function to match its concept of optimal spacefaring qualities. This assumption makes sense if we first assume that it originally evolved to match conditions other than space travel.

I mean, humans have evolved to stand upright on plains, and observe from a higher vantage point. So we have support limbs at one end, and a sensory cluster at the other.

In space, a central sensory cluster, surrounded by manipulator limbs, might make more sense.
 
It was the whole devouring their young that I objected. Most species don't do that sort of thing and I think it would be unlikely behavior of higher lifeforms.

Only if your definition of "higher lifeforms" is "lifeforms that share Mudcat's sense of morality and practicality".

Maybe, in their home environment, devouring excess young was exactly the evolutionary advantage they needed to develop to a "higher" level. Maybe--unlike humans--Communism is in their very genes, and it is the height of good citizenship to recycle the biomass of excess young before they reach maturity and become a burden on the collective.

Again and again, it seems that the answer to your question is, "we can assume they are essentially human, but we don't have to assume that, and there's no reason we should assume that."
 
Only if your definition of "higher lifeforms" is "lifeforms that share Mudcat's sense of morality and practicality".

<SNIP>

Edited by LashL: 
Edited for civility.


Any species capable of developing a society capable of developing a civilization would have to have a sense and desire for community, and you can't have a community with out a set of standards of right and wrong or without a hierarchy.

It is that simple.

Why do you think that? How unlikely?

Because most creatures seek to protect their young, some quite violently at that. Sure, you get the odd example of parents devouring their offspring but those are atypical examples that occur in extreme situations.

It's the same whether we're talking about something animalistic or highly developed and I doubt that a race capable of developing a civilization having the ritual or habit of devouring their young.

This has nothing to do with my personal prejudices or morales.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Birds have been around for a few billion tens of millions of years and they haven't yet. I think it's a safe bet to say that they never will.
Error of 2 orders of magnitude fixed.

You know, a million or two years ago, the same argument could have been made regarding mammals.
 
Because most creatures seek to protect their young, some quite violently at that. Sure, you get the odd example of parents devouring their offspring but those are atypical examples that occur in extreme situations.

Not even close to correct. While eating their young isn't terribly common (but not real uncommon either), there's a whole lot of animals that lay eggs, abandon them, and let their young fend for themselves after hatching; many of these lay a whole lot of eggs, with only a small fraction surviving to adulthood.

While I suspect that a more nurturing strategy is more likely in a technological species, I wouldn't say that it's necessarily the only possibility.
 
Last edited:
Only if your a short sighted twit
You've used abusive language gratuitously throughout this thread. This personal insult has been reported.

unable to move past "They're not from here so they can't possibly be anything familiar to us."
Why do you keep assuming they're familiar to us? They could be, but they don't have to be.

I have no objection to assuming that they could be like us.

I do object to your apparent assumption that they must be like us. My counter-examples aren't intended to argue that they can't possibly be anything familiar to us.

My counter-examples are intended to argue that it's wrong to assume they must be familiar to us. Why do you always assume they must be familiar to us?

Any species capable of developing a society capable of developing a civilization would have to have a sense and desire for community, and you can't have a community with out a set of standards of right and wrong or without a hierarchy.
What about a hive mind that isn't a society but just a single individual (collective) consciousness? What if it's effectively just one person, and has no concept of hierarchy because it has no experience of community? What if it has no standards of right or wrong, other than its own personal tastes and preferences, measured not against the values of the rest of the community (for there is no community), but measured only against itself?

To paraphrase Protagoras, what if "the hive is the measure of all things"?

Such a being might have no more concern about discarding or recycling its individuals than we have about shedding skin cells or cutting our hair.

Such a being might be baffled by the apparently dysfunctional nature of our own "hives" where each individual insists on believing it's an independent Mind in its own right, and there exists no natural, proper mechanism for harmoniously organizing all the individuals under a single commanding will.

Such a being might think we were abominations, defective hives, and that the most moral choice would be to exterminate us and recycle our biomass for healthier purposes. Or it might think we were lower life forms, "animalistic" since we clearly had never evolved the higher consciousness of the hive mind.

I'm not saying alien spacefarers must be like this. I'm just saying they don't have to be like humans. It's possible that they will have very different perceptions, and very different values. It's wrong (in my opinion) for you to insist on ignoring this possibility in your assumptions.

It is that simple.
I think you're over-simplifying. I think your analysis forms a good starting point, but fails to imagine many other possibilities. I think that when other possibilities are pointed out, you then refuse to even consider them. Why?

Because most creatures seek to protect their young, some quite violently at that. Sure, you get the odd example of parents devouring their offspring but those are atypical examples that occur in extreme situations.
Most creatures that we know of. I think that it's a mistake to assume the same about spacefaring aliens, given the limited size of our sample.

It's the same whether we're talking about something animalistic or highly developed and I doubt that a race capable of developing a civilization having the ritual or habit of devouring their young.
You personally doubt it. This is not a compelling argument. I already pointed out that it's possible that under different evolutionary pressures, a race might only become capable of developing a civilization because it evolved the trait of devouring excess young.

Why do you assume that any spacefaring race must emerge from the same evolutionary circumstances as are on earth, and that they will evolve the same adaptations as we have observed on earth? These are very limited, narrow assumptions. Why have you chosen them?

This has nothing to do with my personal prejudices or morales.
Your gratuitous use of abusive language, your insistence on a narrow set of assumptions, and your refusal to consider (or, increasingly, even acknowledge) other ideas or possibilities, make it pretty obvious that this thread has everything to do with your personal prejudices and morals.
 
Last edited:
Like bee : their dance shows direction and distance to flower. Etc...
Can a sufficiently advance race use dance to communicate? Sure, bees do do that, as do humans to some degree. However, would it be practical for expressing difficult concepts such as used for engineering? Could it be reasonably be used to describe even the rudimentary basics of a fusion reactor?

The answer here is no.



Aepervius said:
Nope. it is an assumption of yours. they could travel in a generation ship with enormous space. Like an emptied asteroid. In fact it is much much more likely , than in a normal cramped ship, consdiering FTL is impossible, and considering they would spend a LOT of time in it => need a lot of resource. Solution. generation shi. An humongus asteroid emptied, isolated from space, full of resource, with a small group genetic diverse enough to travel and reproduce among the 1000000 of years of travel.

No. Such an undertaking would pose significantly more engineering difficulties than a normal, cramped ship as to be impractical in the extreme.




Aepervius said:
They could have developped radio communication.

Might as well suggest magic while you're at it.

Aepervius said:
Or communciate through visible change on their body thru IR.

And here I thought the bioluminescent pulse suggestion was ridiculous. Sure there are creatures that can see into the infrared spectrum. But heating up part of the body to the extent that it could be seen on the surface? Such a form of communication would be clumsy and ponderous, to say the least.

Aepervius said:
Open your mind ;).

I return that right back to you. Saying that any alien lifeform must be radically different from anything we're familiar with just because they originate from a different planet is remarkably closed minded, short sighted, and not very logical.
 
This is a thread intended to discus alien lifeforms and what they might look like, not the possibility that they may have visited us in the past. Hopefully everyone will enjoy, participate, and debate in all good fun.

Scientists recently-ish determined that much of the universe probably harbors life of one sort or another. If it's animalistic in nature, then if some of the strange and baffling creatures that call earth home is any indication then it can be just about anything.

But if it's intelligent life, maybe even one with a space faring civilization what then? What can we assume about it? A few sad individuals on the forums might say that we can't assume anything because we only have one data set to learn from and that it can be anything. That alien life would most likely be very different from human beings.

I strongly disagree, and here is why:

In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts. They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language. Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.

Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.
How do we know a hive mind isn't capable of those things? Given adequate means of communication among the individual units, I see no reason why it couldn't be.
They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.
If you said two or more high-precision manipulative organs, I'd be right with you. But why not a tentacle, or even something like an elephant's trunk? Elephants are handicapped by having only one manipulative organ, but their trunks are quite good at manipulating things. Something that has capabilities that equal or exceed those of the human hand is probably essential to developing technology, and I would say that a minimum of two are probably necessary. However, assuming that it has to look anything like a human hand shows a remarkable lack of imagination.
We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet. So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.
You haven't actually made a case that eliminates cold-blooded animals. Humans can only survive in a pretty narrow temperature range. A spacecraft is going to have to be temperature-controlled, whether its passengers are warm-blooded or cold- blooded. Cold-blooded animals require considerably less food, which would be an advantage for space travel. Aquatic animals would have to carry quite a it of extra mass in water for space travel. This would certainly be a drawback, but not necessarily an insurmountable one.
We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids. This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.
Because you say so? I'm not quite sure how to even begin to refute this, because you haven't really made a case at all. In fact, I see no reason whatsoever to assume that the human body plan is the only one suitable for space travel.
We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.
Perhaps the first sensible thing you've said. However, a species that communicates natively by radio might look a lot like they were telepathic. Their communication would, of course be limited by the speed of light and signal strength, though they could artificially amplify the signal strength.

On the whole, this seems to be a pretty weak case that any space-traveling entities will be very similar to us, and seems to be based more on a lack of imagination than anything else. While it would not greatly surprise me if the first extra-terrestrial intelligent creatures we encounter look something like us, neither would it surprise me if they were radically different.
 
Last edited:
No. Such an undertaking would pose significantly more engineering difficulties than a normal, cramped ship as to be impractical in the extreme.

If you could provide an example of a working 'normal' interstellar ship . . .

Neither you nor Aepervius have stated the mission of the purported ship, nor which technological advancements are assumed. Without a mission or technology base, I think it's very difficult to say which design philosophy is more practical. YMMV.
 
I think we can all assume that they have a thing for probing.
 
It's not that alien life has to be different, it's that there's no good reason for it to be similar.

Likewise, there is no good reason for it to be radically different.


theprestige said:
I mean that instead of building tools for space travel, maybe they grew organs for space travel, or something.

That would certainly be something to see.


theprestige said:
Maybe, maybe not. "Unwieldy" is probably a relative term, anyway. There's a lot about humans that's unwieldy for space travel, but we seem to be bent on giving it a go anyway.

I'm not talking about physical limitations making a hive mind unwieldy. The way you describe it would make it readily apparent that such a species would be slow to react, adjust, or adapt to changes. Coming up with new concepts would be a centuries long process, and putting them into action would take as long. Eventually they would hit a developmental dead end, but a lot sooner than a species without a hivemind.



theprestige said:
In all the wide universe, who can say which is more unlikely?

When you put it that way, I suppose that is in the eye of the beholder.


theprestige said:
The impulses of the brain aren't actually myriad and random--quite the opposite (this should be obvious).

That's not so obvious to me, and probably not very obvious to a great number of people. Including those people whose job it is to know those things.


theprestige said:
Done and done.

"Any technology sufficiently advanced" is not wisdom, it's an argument from magic.
 
Without a mission or technology base, I think it's very difficult to say which design philosophy is more practical.

The asteroid idea sounds good at first but we can safely conclude, even without having done it, that it's next to unworkable. It would present several engineering challenges that would have to be overcome.

First you have to locate, secure, and transport an asteroid that meets your criteria. Which should immediately raise red flags because doing so would be enormously difficult. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

Then you would have to mine and hollow out the asteroid, a slow and doubtlessly dangerous undertaking as well as enormously difficult. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

And then you would have to fit life support systems to make the inside livable, which is enormously more difficult then having a normal spaceship with the same requirements. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

And finally you would have to design, build, and install a suitable power plant and rig sufficient propulsion for your asteroid. Better to just build a spaceship in orbit.

I think we can all assume that they have a thing for probing.

Hardy har-har.
 
However, would it be practical for expressing difficult concepts such as used for engineering?
Not really, no (though I would argue that it is quite a bit better than just using written or spoken language, due to its inherent spacial character, which can help communicate even otherwise abstract concepts such as algorithms).

For expressing difficult scientific and engineering concepts we use many different methods of communication, by enriching written and/or spoken words with pictures, diagrams, schematics, sounds, moving images... It is safe to assume that a technologically advanced alien species also has many different methods of communication at its disposal, and tries to use them together to communicate ideas that are difficult to explain through a single method.
 
Can a sufficiently advance race use dance to communicate? Sure, bees do do that, as do humans to some degree. However, would it be practical for expressing difficult concepts such as used for engineering? Could it be reasonably be used to describe even the rudimentary basics of a fusion reactor?
Once again, for a species which has as much brain processing dedicated to dance interpretation as we have for sound interpretation, the answer is yes.

DANCER: "You expect me to believe that creatures who communicate by modulating sound waves can describe a fusion reactor?" (Entire concept, complete with notion of incredulity, done in less one second, with different body parts carrying different meaning. To a human it looks like a simple shudder, indistinguishable from any other shudder.)
 
The asteroid idea sounds good at first but we can safely conclude, even without having done it, that it's next to unworkable.
Compared to what? We've never built a crewed interstellar craft of any kind.

It would present several engineering challenges that would have to be overcome.

Granted. This is also true of 'conventional' designs.

First you have to <remainder snipped>

First, you described one approach to using an asteroid (not the way I'd suggest, btw), cited the issues, and then simply ignored any potential corresponding issues for the 'build a spacehip in orbit' option. That's not a compelling way to argue.

But, more significantly, my principle assertion was that you can't settle on the right approach for building X without first establishing what you want X to do, and what technologies are available. Your post discussed neither the mission nor the available technologies, yet still reached a conclusion about the right approach.

Do you dispute my assertion that we need to know the mission and technologies before we can establish the best approach?

Do you believe that we've already established the mission and technologies somewhere up-thread?
 
Actually, the reasoning is "They're not from here so they're not necessarily just like us." That's a very different line of reasoning.

And the reasoning of "They are most likely going to resemble us somewhat" is a far cry from "They must be just like us" which is more reasonable than "They must be radically different to the point that we have nothing in common beyond both being alive".
 
And the reasoning of "They are most likely going to resemble us somewhat" is a far cry from "They must be just like us" which is more reasonable than "They must be radically different to the point that we have nothing in common beyond both being alive".

Do you believe that anyone is actually claiming that "They must be radically different to the point that we have nothing in common beyond both being alive?"



ETA: okay, maybe I should step away from the thread for a bit.
 
Last edited:
I don't see why they couldn't.



What are you talking about birds that use sticks as tools to fish out bugs? So tell me, when is the last time you seen a monument or a rocket build by a society of birds? When is the last time you seen birds design, build, or maintain their tools?

Thumbs or bust.

Why not tentacles?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom