Only if your a short sighted twit
You've used abusive language gratuitously throughout this thread. This personal insult has been reported.
unable to move past "They're not from here so they can't possibly be anything familiar to us."
Why do you keep assuming they're familiar to us? They
could be, but they don't
have to be.
I have no objection to assuming that they
could be like us.
I do object to your apparent assumption that they
must be like us. My counter-examples aren't intended to argue that they can't possibly be anything familiar to us.
My counter-examples are intended to argue that it's wrong to assume they must be familiar to us. Why do you always assume they must be familiar to us?
Any species capable of developing a society capable of developing a civilization would have to have a sense and desire for community, and you can't have a community with out a set of standards of right and wrong or without a hierarchy.
What about a hive mind that isn't a society but just a single individual (collective) consciousness? What if it's effectively just one person, and has no concept of hierarchy because it has no experience of community? What if it has no standards of right or wrong, other than its own personal tastes and preferences, measured not against the values of the rest of the community (for there is no community), but measured only against itself?
To paraphrase Protagoras, what if "the hive is the measure of all things"?
Such a being might have no more concern about discarding or recycling its individuals than we have about shedding skin cells or cutting our hair.
Such a being might be baffled by the apparently dysfunctional nature of our own "hives" where each individual insists on believing it's an independent Mind in its own right, and there exists no natural, proper mechanism for harmoniously organizing all the individuals under a single commanding will.
Such a being might think we were abominations, defective hives, and that the most moral choice would be to exterminate us and recycle our biomass for healthier purposes. Or it might think we were lower life forms, "animalistic" since we clearly had never evolved the higher consciousness of the hive mind.
I'm not saying alien spacefarers
must be like this. I'm just saying they don't
have to be like humans. It's
possible that they will have very different perceptions, and very different values. It's
wrong (in my opinion) for you to insist on ignoring this possibility in your assumptions.
I think you're over-simplifying. I think your analysis forms a good starting point, but fails to imagine many other possibilities. I think that when other possibilities are pointed out, you then refuse to even consider them. Why?
Because most creatures seek to protect their young, some quite violently at that. Sure, you get the odd example of parents devouring their offspring but those are atypical examples that occur in extreme situations.
Most creatures
that we know of. I think that it's a mistake to assume the same about spacefaring aliens, given the limited size of our sample.
It's the same whether we're talking about something animalistic or highly developed and I doubt that a race capable of developing a civilization having the ritual or habit of devouring their young.
You personally doubt it. This is not a compelling argument. I already pointed out that it's possible that under different evolutionary pressures, a race might only become capable of developing a civilization because it evolved the trait of devouring excess young.
Why do you assume that any spacefaring race must emerge from the same evolutionary circumstances as are on earth, and that they will evolve the same adaptations as we have observed on earth? These are very limited, narrow assumptions. Why have you chosen them?
This has nothing to do with my personal prejudices or morales.
Your gratuitous use of abusive language, your insistence on a narrow set of assumptions, and your refusal to consider (or, increasingly, even acknowledge) other ideas or possibilities, make it pretty obvious that this thread has
everything to do with your personal prejudices and morals.