What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

Entropy does always increase in a closed system. A planet isnot a closed system, though, as it receives massive amounts of energy from its star. But the entropy in the star must increase more than it decreases anywhere else.
Perfectly correct, but what does that have to with the claim that electrolysis of water lowers entropy or the more genereal conversation that something related to entropy or chemical disequilibrium can be used as a sign of life?
 
Last edited:
Perfectly correct, but what does that have to with the claim that electrolysis of water lowers entropy or the more genereal conversation that something related to entropy or chemical disequilibrium can be used as a sign of life?
It has to do with that claim in that the entropy of the hydrogen and oxygen decreases, but the collective entropy of the water, hydrogen, oxygen and electric energy source increases.
This relates to the general discussion because an atmosphere containing large amount of oxidizers is very unlikely because of its low entropy.
 
Since we've established there are natural processes that lower entropy and that planets like Earth are open systems I'm not sure how you get to a judgement of "unlikely" or that such "unlikeliness" would be an indicator of life. Just doesn't add up for me.
 
It's a mostly nice explanation of entropy but it doesn't explain the original claim of why oxygen "screams life" or why an atmosphere in chemical disequilibrium is a sign of life (I also don't see why you think our atmosphere is in chemical disequilibrium).
If all photosynthesizing plants on Earth died, pretty much all oxygen would bind up within few tens of thousands years.
We've already identified non living processes that can locally decrease entropy and produce oxygen.
In tiny quantities.
So what do you think is at work besides physics?
I *knew* that was poor choice of words!

What is at work keeping tree branches from decaying and falling off? Life, of course -- more specifically, constant repair processes in the tree's cells. Tree uses energy (sunlight, ultimately) to increase its own complexity.
 
Since we've established there are natural processes that lower entropy and that planets like Earth are open systems I'm not sure how you get to a judgement of "unlikely" or that such "unlikeliness" would be an indicator of life. Just doesn't add up for me.
Because processes which lower entropy are "life" by definition. Very broad definition, as it includes computer viruses and other self-replicating software, but lets be generous. Nobody ever came up with non-living process which could produce anywhere near the amount of free oxygen in Earth's atmosphere.
 
If all photosynthesizing plants on Earth died, pretty much all oxygen would bind up within few tens of thousands years.
This would also be true if it were a non living process creating the oxygen.
In tiny quantities.
How do you justify that assertion? Is there some cosmic cap on other chemical processes?
I *knew* that was poor choice of words!

What is at work keeping tree branches from decaying and falling off? Life, of course -- more specifically, constant repair processes in the tree's cells. Tree uses energy (sunlight, ultimately) to increase its own complexity.
So you still haven't explained how you think life goes beyond physics.
Because processes which lower entropy are "life" by definition.Very broad definition, as it includes computer viruses and other self-replicating software, but lets be generous.
That definition is not just broad it's clearly wrong.
Nobody ever came up with non-living process which could produce anywhere near the amount of free oxygen in Earth's atmosphere.
So? I really don't get what you're going for here. Is the Earth alive because no one has ever built a rock that big? Just not following the conneciton here.
 
Huh? You're claiming we don't know of non-living processes that can create oxygen? Do I understand you correctly?
 
Just about, yes. The only non-living, non-artificial process which generates molecular oxygen is photodissociation of water, and amounts it creates are tiny -- because oxygen and hydrogen quickly come back together or, if hydrogen is removed by other processes, oxygen binds up with something else. That's where Europa's "atmosphere" comes from -- its surface pressure is about 10-12 atmosphere, and it is all oxygen. Europa is so cold that despite its low gravity oxygen does not escape into space -- and still there is hardly any of it.

If you want to be pedantic, all oxygen is "created" in stars via fusion, but as soon as it gets far enough from the star to cool off sufficiently to form molecules, these molecules are overwhelmingly oxides -- mostly water since hydrogen is the most common element in existence, -- not molecular oxygen.
 
Entropy does always increase in a closed system.
Terminology nitpicks:

a) Many of us were trained to distinguish between closed systems (no mass transfer) and isolated systems (neither mass nor energy transfer). Lack of the latter kind doesn't detract from the utility of the more abundant former kind. I realize you meant what I would call an "isolated" system. By extracting energy, it's easy to decrease entropy of what what I would call a "closed" system (and increase entropy of the rest of the [presumably isolated?] universe by at least the same amount).

b) The second law forbids decreasing entropy in an isolated system; it does not does not require increasing entropy in an isolated system. Inability to achieve adiabatic, reversible, isentropic process is a practical implementation detail rather than a fundamental limitation.

Now that I've stuck my engineer neck out, I'm sure a physicist will come along to chop it off with some axe from beyond my domain.
That's OK, too.
 
Terminology nitpicks:

a) Many of us were trained to distinguish between closed systems (no mass transfer) and isolated systems (neither mass nor energy transfer). Lack of the latter kind doesn't detract from the utility of the more abundant former kind. I realize you meant what I would call an "isolated" system. By extracting energy, it's easy to decrease entropy of what what I would call a "closed" system (and increase entropy of the rest of the [presumably isolated?] universe by at least the same amount).

b) The second law forbids decreasing entropy in an isolated system; it does not does not require increasing entropy in an isolated system. Inability to achieve adiabatic, reversible, isentropic process is a practical implementation detail rather than a fundamental limitation.

Now that I've stuck my engineer neck out, I'm sure a physicist will come along to chop it off with some axe from beyond my domain.
That's OK, too.
I never heard the first distinction, but then my education in thermodynamics wasn't in English. The other thing is something I know, and I thought about using "monotonically increasing", but that wouldn't have changed the argument much and could have been confusing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom