What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

Originally Posted by fuelair
Why not tentacles?
I asked got some hand waving back as answer.
I saw what you did there...

2661522e8ff6d63a4.gif
 
I don't understand why chromatographic species is dismissed so handily.

So what you're saying is that you failed to consider that I dismiss it so easily because it's so easy to dismiss?

First thing you have to remember is since this is something that supposed to be used for communication, the light emitting organ has to be somewhere that is easily seen and the sensory organ has to be somewhere that can easily see it.

Which brings up a glaringly obvious flaw in line-of-sight communications that the navy figured out back in the forties: You have to be in the line of sight. And depending on how strong the bioluminescent pulses are you might not get even as much distance for communication as you would a loud shout.

Plus it would be visible to everything else in their environment including potential predators or prey unless you're suggesting everything else in their environment is fudging blind as a bat.

And if they don't have articulating hands with opposable thumbs 'silent' communications (IE: Sign language) would be impossible.

The problems with this form of communication gets significantly worse if that riddiculous idea of infrared idea is how they communicate.



SGM said:
I pass an electronic billboard on my way home from work every day, a rapidly-changing display of light and color that transmits information in pictures and words (which are also pictures). Even just a simple message like Eat at Joe's or Looking For a Mate would be a huge adaptation and strongly selected for.

Those are simple messages. Can you imagine trying to instill complicated messages involving difficult and abstract ideas like those involved with (for example) quantum mechanics?
 
So what you're saying is that you failed to consider that I dismiss it so easily because it's so easy to dismiss?

First thing you have to remember is since this is something that supposed to be used for communication, the light emitting organ has to be somewhere that is easily seen and the sensory organ has to be somewhere that can easily see it.

Which brings up a glaringly obvious flaw in line-of-sight communications that the navy figured out back in the forties: You have to be in the line of sight. And depending on how strong the bioluminescent pulses are you might not get even as much distance for communication as you would a loud shout.

Plus it would be visible to everything else in their environment including potential predators or prey unless you're suggesting everything else in their environment is fudging blind as a bat.
Explain these guys then:

Cuttlefish light show

Information density can be much higher than human speech.
And if they don't have articulating hands with opposable thumbs 'silent' communications (IE: Sign language) would be impossible.
Sigh. You are talking human limitations again. Think of full-body communication possible for an octopus.
Those are simple messages. Can you imagine trying to instill complicated messages involving difficult and abstract ideas like those involved with (for example) quantum mechanics?
As others already said, we do not really use spoken language to convey quantum mechanics either. We use written math. A cuttlefish can use its entire body as a blackboard.
 
Last edited:
A vocal communication is such a stupid concept... imagine trying to transmit highly abstract concepts with your mouth, flapping your mouth and tongue while pushing air though them! And think of the limitations! You would have to be really close to hear the modulations, because any sound loud enough to be heard at a distance could easily attract predators.

Now seriously, when was the last time you had a conversation that wasn't closer than line-of-sight?
 
And if they don't have articulating hands with opposable thumbs 'silent' communications (IE: Sign language) would be impossible.

The reason why human sign language requires the use of thumbs is because it was designed by humans for humans and humans happen to have thumbs.

A species without thumbs would naturally design their sign language so that it doesn't require the use of thumbs.

Hell, if didn't have hands (eg, they were chopped off in an accident) you could still communicate without speaking by using your arms to communicate in semaphore. (If someone were in speaking distance, it wouldn't matter that you weren't holding the little flags, they'd be able to see the position of your arms clearly enough.)
 
Steven Hawkins and Neal Degrasse think aliens arriving on earth would be a disaster for the human race in much the same way that Europeans arriving in the new world was a disaster for the native americans except worse.
 
Steven Hawkins and Neal Degrasse think aliens arriving on earth would be a disaster for the human race in much the same way that Europeans arriving in the new world was a disaster for the native americans except worse.

Hawking. Tyson.

It's a possibility that should be seriously considered, but I wouldn't go so far as to say it's an assumption that should be made.
 
Steven Hawkins and Neal Degrasse think aliens arriving on earth would be a disaster for the human race in much the same way that Europeans arriving in the new world was a disaster for the native americans except worse.

Like many, I believe that any first contact we would have would be done via an automated probe rather than directly with the race themselves.
 
A species without thumbs would naturally design their sign language so that it doesn't require the use of thumbs.

This falls back on my prerequisite of needing opposable thumbs and articulating fingers. Lets assume that somewhere out there there is a race of beings that instead of hands they have claws. Obviously they wouldn't be able to use anything other than simple tools regardless of how brilliant they may be and a sign language would be all but impossible for them because of the lack of articulation (admittedly, they could communicate through a series of clacking and it could be virtually inaudible). Beaks are just as limited, for the same reason.

Trunks and tentacles are abviously more articulated but are unsuited for the kind of tool making needed for building starships.

Opposable thumbs, or bust.
 
This falls back on my prerequisite of needing opposable thumbs and articulating fingers. Lets assume that somewhere out there there is a race of beings that instead of hands they have claws. Obviously they wouldn't be able to use anything other than simple tools regardless of how brilliant they may be and a sign language would be all but impossible for them because of the lack of articulation (admittedly, they could communicate through a series of clacking and it could be virtually inaudible). Beaks are just as limited, for the same reason.

Trunks and tentacles are abviously more articulated but are unsuited for the kind of tool making needed for building starships.

Opposable thumbs, or bust.

So, you're saying that because humans have never built a starship, any species that does build a starship must be like us?

ETA: Slightly more seriously, let's talk about our tools for a minute. I'm using a computer right now; it's functioning relies on billions (literally billions) of tiny, precise features. Nobody made the tricky bits with their hands. They used previously-built tools to make this tool. And those previously-built tools were not, by-and-large, made by hand; they were also built using previously-built tools. Humans build tools, then use those tools to make more-sophisticated tools, and use those tools to make yet-more-sophisticated tools, etc. It took many, many generations of tools-to-build-tools for us to get to this computer, or, for that matter, to the spacecraft factory down the street.

I believe that an intelligent species equipped with tentacles, or trunks, or claws, or jaws, etc, would go through the same process. Oh, the individual tools would be different, of course, but that process - simple tools to make slightly-less-simple tools, ad infinitum, would still apply.

Is it your contention that, without opposable thumbs, this tool evolution process would necessarily hit an early dead-end?
 
Last edited:
This falls back on my prerequisite of needing opposable thumbs and articulating fingers. Lets assume that somewhere out there there is a race of beings that instead of hands they have claws. Obviously they wouldn't be able to use anything other than simple tools regardless of how brilliant they may be and a sign language would be all but impossible for them because of the lack of articulation (admittedly, they could communicate through a series of clacking and it could be virtually inaudible). Beaks are just as limited, for the same reason.


Instead of hands they have claws? You mean that each arm terminates in a single claw?

Strange how you would argue that a species without hands would be unable to use some form sign language in response to a post where I gave an example of how sign language could be achieved without using hands at all. It's as if you didn't even bother reading the post.

Trunks and tentacles are abviously more articulated but are unsuited for the kind of tool making needed for building starships.

Opposable thumbs, or bust.


Everyone is agreed that this race would need some form of manipulatory appendages capable of versatile tool use, but I don't see why you keep insisting that opposable thumbs are necessary.

Let's take a hypothetical example. Let's say that a species doesn't have a hand at the end of their wrist, but instead their arm tapers off into four short tentacles that form an X shape when extended outwards. They'd have two pairs of opposable "fingers" instead of an opposable thumb, and would certainly be capable of creating and using a wide variety of tools.
 
Everyone is agreed that this race would need some form of manipulatory appendages capable of versatile tool use, but I don't see why you keep insisting that opposable thumbs are necessary.

He said opposable thumbs or bust. I agree that busts can be used to manipulate.
 
So, you're saying that because humans have never built a starship, any species that does build a starship must be like us?

ETA: Slightly more seriously, let's talk about our tools for a minute. I'm using a computer right now; it's functioning relies on billions (literally billions) of tiny, precise features. Nobody made the tricky bits with their hands. They used previously-built tools to make this tool. And those previously-built tools were not, by-and-large, made by hand; they were also built using previously-built tools. Humans build tools, then use those tools to make more-sophisticated tools, and use those tools to make yet-more-sophisticated tools, etc. It took many, many generations of tools-to-build-tools for us to get to this computer, or, for that matter, to the spacecraft factory down the street.

I believe that an intelligent species equipped with tentacles, or trunks, or claws, or jaws, etc, would go through the same process. Oh, the individual tools would be different, of course, but that process - simple tools to make slightly-less-simple tools, ad infinitum, would still apply.

Is it your contention that, without opposable thumbs, this tool evolution process would necessarily hit an early dead-end?

I guess we can assume that an alien spacefaring race will either have opposable thumbs, or else several basic patents on opposable thumb methods.

There's probably an alien race out there somewhere, with natural bluetooth communication, speculating that we must either have natural bluetooth ourselves, or else several basic patents on the method. Which we do.
 
This falls back on my prerequisite of needing opposable thumbs and articulating fingers. Lets assume that somewhere out there there is a race of beings that instead of hands they have claws. Obviously they wouldn't be able to use anything other than simple tools regardless of how brilliant they may be and a sign language would be all but impossible for them because of the lack of articulation (admittedly, they could communicate through a series of clacking and it could be virtually inaudible).

Opposable thumbs, or bust.

Grady Stiles Jr had claws, and it didn't stop him from using tools or guns (to murder people).
 
I also disagree with insects and hive mind. Of course it could be done with a hive mind, but the species would have to evolve with far, far more specialized subsets than seen on Earth. It could have breeders, thinkers and drones, for instance. Breeders breed, drones work, and thinkers rule the whole thing. Creativity and ingenuity aren't a problem here, it wouldn't be too different from a human feudal society.

McHrozni
...or a human body, for that matter. I mean, what is a human body other than a hive of cells? A brain basically is a hive mind.

I find this thread fascinating, but have a hard time assuming anything about aliens. Imagine aliens on a scale or a timescale we're not familiar with. A hive mind the size of a star system, composed of tiny light-sailing beings with the agency of a neuron; processing its thoughts over millions of years, it could travel between stars in the blink of its eye, gravity-slinging from star to passing star, but we would never even recognize it.
 
Assuming no FTL , either any spacefaring alien will have a very long life span, generation ships , or some form of temporary shutdown / suspended animation.

Or they will look a lot like machines.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom