Split Thread War in Afghanistan

In recent news from Kunduz
The RoE finally let the US strike the real enemy, I suppose. :eek:
Video of the aftermath shows machine guns in the hospital windows. It was being used as a fighting position by the Taliban, making it a legitimate target. MSF is lying about the entire incident.
 
Looks like charred debris from the window frame, just like the AP had to admit. This is what you called MSF liars over? I could go on but, this is nonsense.
 
Look at the windows nearest the corner of the building at the 16-25 second mark.

That is the "evidence" you're using?

Nice work. Thankfully, people far more sensible than me have already pointed out your attempt to portray the attack as justified is utter baloney.
 
That is the "evidence" you're using?

Nice work. Thankfully, people far more sensible than me have already pointed out your attempt to portray the attack as justified is utter baloney.

The worst part of it all is the amount of BS that has flown since the attack - so much BS that it's wearisome to try to figure out what is really know - so wearisome that it make one want to give up trying to determine the truth.

And I guess that's the function of BS - to make the issue so opaque that one will accept anything plausible just to get an answer and move on.

Man...that sucks. BS is so dangerous.
 
You'd do yourself a favor by not paying attention to the sensationalist news, blogs and commenters out there, haven't you noticed that their mental health isn't all there? Since there has been nothing from the government or authoritative sources on this, I think you only have yourself to blame for the effect of the "BS"
 
You'd do yourself a favor by not paying attention to the sensationalist news, blogs and commenters out there, haven't you noticed that their mental health isn't all there? Since there has been nothing from the government or authoritative sources on this, I think you only have yourself to blame for the effect of the "BS"

Joey,

You are RIGHT....and you are WRONG.

Generally, it's the initial narrative that most people remember...not the hard-won truth. (Most people just don't have the time and energy to dig for the truth - they got Families, and Jobs and ****)

Don't believe me? Then go ask some people 60-and-over why Watergate was such a bad thing. Hell...they won't even know what Watergate was really about.

Sorry Joey, I disagree to an extent...but I really appreciate your posts. I'll certainly apply your recommendation to myself.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
The visual evidence shows that no bombs struck the hospital. Even a single bomb hit would have flattened much of it.

The visual evidence also shows that there was a fire inside the hospital. I would be curious to know how the fire was started.
 
Last edited:
The visual evidence shows that no bombs struck the hospital. Even a single bomb hit would have flattened much of it.

The visual evidence also shows that there was a fire inside the hospital. I would be curious to know how the fire was started.

Modern militaries have many kinds of ordinance.
 
Shells would be a more accurate term, since it wasn't a "bombing" it was being hit by an AC-130 which fires 105mm and 40 mm shells and it's entirely possible that it was all or mostly 40mm which would explain the footage we've seen and the testimony from the MSF people.

Anyways, it won't be that many days before a statement comes out.
 
Video of the aftermath shows machine guns in the hospital windows. It was being used as a fighting position by the Taliban, making it a legitimate target. MSF is lying about the entire incident.

Compare that against the President of the United States:

Barack Obama has apologised to the medical aid charity Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) for what the White House described as a “terrible, tragic accident”.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/w...-that-killed-12-aid-workers-and-a6685341.html
 
Having been in that business about a decade ago, I am curious how that particular building got onto the target list.

I'll give any further comment another 48 hours before assessing what can be known beyond "someone screwed up, and some people got blown up for all of the wrong reasons."
 
You seem very confident of that. The Taliban did it before... what makes you think that they can't do it again.. once the American's have left ?

No, they didn't do it before. They took over more than half the country, but they never took over the whole country. The Northern Alliance always held a significant amount of territory against the Taliban.

If we left now, they might indeed take over the majority of the country again, and that would be a bad thing, but they would be unlikely to take over all of the country.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom