Split Thread War in Afghanistan

What did they give the soldiers in the UK that refused to fight in the two world wars? Was it not a white feather? I have two nephews and a niece in service possibly in action, and we get a coward and a proven liar posting on this site. By allowing this person to say what he likes with no censure, we should ALL be ashamed of ourselves.
 
What did they give the soldiers in the UK that refused to fight in the two world wars? Was it not a white feather? I have two nephews and a niece in service possibly in action, and we get a coward and a proven liar posting on this site. By allowing this person to say what he likes with no censure, we should ALL be ashamed of ourselves.

Well, you haven't been reading the threads I have been reading I see censure. Plus, why shouldn't he post on the site? he has been here a long time and has a good post count, he can say what he wants. You wouldn't want to censor him would you?
 
TA, I notice that the amusement that you accrue from the occasional grenade tossed into the room has not abated.

I'll give the fight in Kunduz another 48 hours before I comment.
 
TA, I notice that the amusement that you accrue from the occasional grenade tossed into the room has not abated.

It's either that or sit in the corner and weep for mankind.

You know which one I'm gonna take!

I'll give the fight in Kunduz another 48 hours before I comment.

Last I saw, both sides are claiming victory.

One of them may be right.

Quite interesting the Taliban have allegedly undergone some public relations training.
 
So you're rooting for the Taliban so your narrative can be more true?

I have also observed him predicting a future course of events in which his assertions will be shown to be correct.

Argument by prediction of future correctness of the argument. Not really an invalid form of argument, so long as the future verification arrives in a timely manner.

And if verification does not arrive in a timely manner, the whole thing can be swept under the rug and forgotten.
 
Last edited:
So you're rooting for the Taliban so your narrative can be more true?

Nice work yet again.

I'm no more rooting for the Taliban than the USA. In case you hadn't noticed, I think all of the sick clowns with guns should put them away and grow some actual balls instead of having to have a gun to prove it.

I've said on numerous occasions also that all violence is bad.

The only reason this thread even exists is because you tried to raise a nonsensical position that Afghanistan is better off since the invasion by USA in 2001.

I am now proving my point that it is not by posting evidence of the monumental mess Afghanistan is still in, despite 14 bloody years of morons from USA trying to sort it out.

The Brits couldn't do in the 19th century.

The Russians couldn't do it in the 20th century.

USA couldn't do it in the 21st century.
 
I'm no more rooting for the Taliban than the USA. In case you hadn't noticed, I think all of the sick clowns with guns should put them away and grow some actual balls instead of having to have a gun to prove it.
I think it's amazing that someone in the world thinks things that are this stupid. It must have taken a lot of time and effort to get this far. So Americans go to war not because they want to prevent evil, but because they think no one will think they have balls if they don't go kill people. Amazing.
The only reason this thread even exists is because you tried to raise a nonsensical position that Afghanistan is better off since the invasion by USA in 2001.
It's a proven fact. You reject statistics in favor of emotional reasoning which is how you maintain these incredibly stupid beliefs. Also, the Afghan public supported the overthrow of the Taliban as a good thing. You're completely full of ****.
I am now proving my point that it is not by posting evidence of the monumental mess Afghanistan is still in, despite 14 bloody years of morons from USA trying to sort it out.
No, you're trying to say that because things still aren't perfect, they aren't better, that's super stupid.

Kunduz will be retaken eventually. I hope you cry when it happens.
 
Oh dear gods and monsters please spare us from the naive idealism of youth and privilege.

I can be absolutely certain neither of those apply to me, so whatever you were trying to imply is incorrect.

No, you're trying to say that because things still aren't perfect, they aren't better, that's super stupid.

A'stan appears to be in a state approaching civil war right now.

That's no improvement on the state prior to 9/11, and I would certainly call it a deterioration. What do you call it?

Some things improved while the Doughboys were there with their fancy guns, and I admitted that, but as always, they come creeping out of the mountains when the big guns are gone. Even your planes and drones seem to be unable to stop the Taliban at the moment.

Kunduz will be retaken eventually. I hope you cry when it happens.

That is a really bad attempt to take some kind of moral high ground.

Why would I cry if the bad guys lose? Like I said to Darth yesterday, if I didn't throw electronic grenades at Yanks I'd be crying in the corner for both bloody sides.

At least they're mainly Afghans fighting Afghans, and while I despise both sides, at least they aren't being manipulated [too much] by their invaders.

I love the way you try to hide behind the fact that I am anti-US.

That's laughably incorrect. I am only anti US warfare. If they kept their weapons at home, I'd love you guys.
 
A'stan appears to be in a state approaching civil war right now.
You also believe the Taliban is "back in the driver's seat" you're completely out of it.
That's no improvement on the state prior to 9/11, and I would certainly call it a deterioration. What do you call it?
You have provided no evidence of this, it's incredibly delusional. I have provided evidence of the opposite, you choose to just ignore it, why do you even post on forums? Do you really think anyone cares what you have to say when you make claims without evidence and ignore evidence to the contrary?
Some things improved while the Doughboys were there with their fancy guns, and I admitted that, but as always, they come creeping out of the mountains when the big guns are gone. Even your planes and drones seem to be unable to stop the Taliban at the moment.
The town is back in Afghan hands, the AA and their special forces had no problem taking it back, US airstrikes helped. This was always without a doubt the only possible outcome. This much should have been obvious to you. But, you know nothing about war and Afghanistan, you never research anything you believe, you talk out of your ass and never provide evidence, I'm embarrassed for you honestly...
That is a really bad attempt to take some kind of moral high ground.
Why would I cry if the bad guys lose?
I think you would realize that there is something emotionally wrong with you that is causing you to hate the "warmongers" and that your disappointment that the US-backed Afghans took it back so easily would show you that the reason you have all of these fact-free positions says more about you than it does anything else.
Like I said to Darth yesterday, if I didn't throw electronic grenades at Yanks I'd be crying in the corner for both bloody sides.
So that's why you can't help yourself from these hate-based rants and incredibly stupid claims with no evidence... because you're so mad at the Americans for causing you to be sad over war you lash out?
At least they're mainly Afghans fighting Afghans, and while I despise both sides, at least they aren't being manipulated [too much] by their invaders.
So you admit you just have emotional problems with war no matter what good it brings about?
I love the way you try to hide behind the fact that I am anti-US.

That's laughably incorrect. I am only anti US warfare. If they kept their weapons at home, I'd love you guys.
You don't know what your for and against, you're anti-war for emotional reasons, your claims and beliefs make no sense.
 
You also believe the Taliban is "back in the driver's seat" you're completely out of it. You have provided no evidence of this, it's incredibly delusional.

Heck, an awful lot of reports coming out of A'stan in the past 24 hours show the Taliban kicking a lot of A'stan army butt, and it appears from conspiracist sources like New York Times that they are still a major problem or control a very large part of the country.

Delusional NYT.
 
Does the NYT support your belief that they are "back in the driver's seat"? Absolutely not. All they say on this page is that "Insurgents continue to attack and move freely in other areas, mostly rural" Mostly rural so, nothing important. The Taliban tried to take over a city and set up religious schools and Sharia law, those guys are mostly dead now. That's what happened. So, they are clearly still weak. Your narrative has no support from evidence, or from respectable sources, and your only attempt to show this was incredibly stupid.
 
So in 2001 before the invasion the Taliban controlled 90% of the country and looked on to take the rest. Today they control 15% of the country and have managed to retake 1 city from a democratically elected Afghani Government, yet this somehow makes the current situation worse than it was when they controlled 90% of the country, banned girls from getting educated, banned women from work or even appearing in public without being in a full burqua, banned kite flying, humming, singing, painting, western goods, and imposed a strict sharia law on the people.... Hmmmm...ok. :rolleyes:
 
So in 2001 before the invasion the Taliban controlled 90% of the country and looked on to take the rest. Today they control 15% of the country and have managed to retake 1 city from a democratically elected Afghani Government,...

How many people were dying in Afghanistan before the invasion?

How long before the Taliban re-take the entire country?

They control 15% but are influencing much larger areas.

I will gladly (and have already) stated that as of this minute, most Afghans are better off than pre-2001. That is balanced by the lack of war inside the country at that time. As usual, it depends what you think it "better" an evil government that nevertheless allows people to live a life, or be in constant danger of bombing? (from either side)

...yet this somehow makes the current situation worse than it was when they controlled 90% of the country, banned girls from getting educated, banned women from work or even appearing in public without being in a full burqua, banned kite flying, humming, singing, painting, western goods, and imposed a strict sharia law on the people.... Hmmmm...ok. :rolleyes:

While I despise them, I don't believe any of those crimes against humanity rate the death penalty.
 
How many people were dying in Afghanistan before the invasion?
A lot, between the massacres and the civil war.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_war_in_Afghanistan_(1996–2001)

Why do you pretend to know what you're talking about?

How long before the Taliban re-take the entire country?
Never. This has a zero percent chance of happening.

I will gladly (and have already) stated that as of this minute, most Afghans are better off than pre-2001. That is balanced by the lack of war inside the country at that time.
You really think that that there was no war in Afghanistan before the invasion? That's mindbogglingly ignorant...

As usual, it depends what you think it "better" an evil government that nevertheless allows people to live a life, or be in constant danger of bombing?
We know that the Afghan public overwhelmingly supported the invasion and overthrow of the Taliban as a good thing, if you ever met a real Afghan and told them what you think, they'd laugh in your face! And the facts of quality of life don't lie.

While I despise them, I don't believe any of those crimes against humanity rate the death penalty.
Empty moral posturing...

How about you take a year off, educate yourself on the war, and then come back and try and defend your opinion?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom