Split Thread War in Afghanistan

Perhaps most telling, 82% said that overthrowing the Taliban government was a good thing for Afghanistan, with just 11% saying it was a bad thing. In the war zone, 71% endorsed the Taliban’s overthrow while 16% saw it as a bad thing; in the north, 18% saw it as a bad thing.
Equally large percentages endorse the US military presence in Afghanistan. Eighty-three percent said they have a favorable view of “the US military forces in our country” (39% very favorable). Just 17% have an unfavorable view.
Afghans were also asked whether they approve or disapprove of US military forces “conducting operations to capture or kill al-Qaeda fighters in Afghanistan.” This has been controversial, as Afghan civilians have at times been killed or wounded in these efforts. Nonetheless, overall 79% said they approve, with just 13% disapproving. In the east and south-central regions where most US operations take place, approval was 10 points lower at 69%, while one in five (20%) said they disapproved.

http://www.worldpublicopinion.org/pipa/articles/brasiapacificra/155.php?lb=bras

So basically, everything you believe about Afghanistan is wrong.
 
How many people were dying in Afghanistan before the invasion?

A lot, the difference was that no-one was counting them all like they do now.

Wiki said:
According to a 55-page report by the United Nations, the Taliban, while trying to consolidate control over northern and western Afghanistan, committed systematic massacres against civilians. UN officials stated that there had been "15 massacres" between 1996 and 2001. They also said, that "[t]hese have been highly systematic and they all lead back to the [Taliban] Ministry of Defense or to Mullah Omar himself." The Taliban especially targeted Shias or Hazaras.

The Taliban would go into an area kill people, smash the water systems, destroy the crops, and chase the people out of their villages into the wilderness. At the time the US went in the UN was predicting that millions of people would die of starvation and hypothermia in the winter of 2001/2.

Seems people have short memories.

How long before the Taliban re-take the entire country?

Hopefully they won't. If the Afghani government is given support to combat them, then they won't.

They control 15% but are influencing much larger areas.

It's easier to influence an area than control it.

I will gladly (and have already) stated that as of this minute, most Afghans are better off than pre-2001. That is balanced by the lack of war inside the country at that time.

wha..... speaking of short memories. There has been constant civil war in Afghanistan since 1978!

As usual, it depends what you think it "better" an evil government that nevertheless allows people to live a life, or be in constant danger of bombing? (from either side)

Seriously? Anyone that wasn't the right tribe or sect they massacred, they destroyed livelihoods, they destroyed food crops, irrigation and water systems. They stoned men and women who didn't follow their strict rules. Millions of people ended up living in the open wilderness because of them facing imminent starvation. More fled to Pakistan and the northern regions to get away from them. They serious did not allow people to live a life in any meaningful way of the word. So in answer to your question, and from what has been posted the people of Afghanistan agree, I'd take freedom with a chance of bombing over the slavery offered by the likes of the Taliban any day of the week.

While I despise them, I don't believe any of those crimes against humanity rate the death penalty.

Funny thing, the Taliban do. They were quite happy to execute people for doing those things.
 
Last edited:
wha..... speaking of short memories. There has been constant civil war in Afghanistan since 1978!

:dl:

You're trying to prove things have improved because there was a civil war before the invasion and also since the invaders have [largely] left?

Brilliant!

If you want short memories, I've already pointed out that A'stan has been at war with itself for centuries, not decades.

So, here we are in 2015, still at war with itself and you're falling over yourself to prove that things are better.

As to potential famine as justification for the invasion, that is patently untrue.

If 9/11 hadn't gone down, USA would not have attacked A'stan to save a few peasants, just as they didn't attack Zimbabwe, CAR, Uganda, Somalia, Chad, North Korea, Sudan, or Rwanda to save a few peasants.
 
Last edited:
The indoctrination is strong in that one.

Quite funny - that's exactly how I see people arguing against me on this.

How could anyone be so indoctrinated to support a war that their side cannot win, that is none of their damned business and which is still on at least half-burn after 14 years?
 
You clearly say that there was a lack of war before the invasion, then try to claim you said there was war for centuries. The only thing you had to point out I got wrong was a simple mistake with the link, so you did... Admit it, you're talking out your ass and can't get your lies straight. You know you don't know what you're talking about...

The people who live in Afghanistan, they're happy the Taliban's gone, they think it's a good thing... not you! Armchair historian who knows jack **** about the country is such a moral genius and epic keyboard warrior, doesn't even have to research his claims! You'll be the one to tell the Afghan people they should be horrified the big bad Americans came to take out the group that attacked them...

In your mind, the presence of war is like a binary yes or no good and bad thing. Things can't possibly be better... they are still shooting each other! This is so anti-intellectual and juvenile, of course people think you're a Poe.
 
Last edited:
You clearly say that there was a lack of war before the invasion, then try to claim you said there was war for centuries.

I would contend that prior to the invasion, in 2000-2001, that era of civil war was over, with Taliban in control of the entire country.

If that's wrong, and you can show that with some evidence, I will gladly withdraw my comment.

It's not going to change the glaring point that Afghanistan is no better off now than in 2001, 1991, 1981, or even 1781.

Aside from some improvements made during the occupation that I think are extremely unlikely to last, in the face of an enemy which will not give up.
 
How about you try to find evidence for your braindead theories all by yourself? Onus on the claimant after all...

Didn't you know one of the main things about the skeptics movement is fighting against motivated reasoning in oneself? Why have you missed this important lesson?
 
You're trying to prove things have improved because there was a civil war before the invasion and also since the invaders have [largely] left?

Things have improved. People can live in their homes without being rounded up and shot. They have new power stations, water treatment, irrigation for crops, they can grow crops. Most Afghani's who actually live there are saying things have improved and are far better now then under the Taliban.

If you want short memories, I've already pointed out that A'stan has been at war with itself for centuries, not decades.

You were the one that said there was no war before the invasion in 2001

So, here we are in 2015, still at war with itself and you're falling over yourself to prove that things are better.

I don't have to fall over myself, the people actually living there are saying that things are better. Who to believe? Those that live in the country and have to deal with it on a daily basis, or someone on the internet that lives half a world away and has never set foot in the country.... gee, hard choice that.

As to potential famine as justification for the invasion, that is patently untrue.

Learn to read. It was never used as a justification for invasion. It was stated as a fact. Had the US not invaded 1.5 to 2 million people would have died directly because of the Taliban's actions against them. The US didn't go in to save them, but it was a consequence of the US invading that they were able to return to their homes and survive the winter rather then facing starvation in the wilderness which was and would have been their reality under the Taliban. How in the world is that better than now?

If 9/11 hadn't gone down, USA would not have attacked A'stan to save a few peasants

No one said they did. The US attacked the Taliban because they were sheltering Al Qaeda.

just as they didn't attack Zimbabwe, CAR, Uganda, Somalia, Chad, North Korea, Sudan, or Rwanda to save a few peasants.

You are aware that the US actually did attack North Korea? Right... the whole Korean War thing? M*A*S*H... ring any bells

France has taken the lead in CAR and Chad, as noted previously, so yes Western Nations are there.

The US did go into Somalia, you might remember the whole Blackhawk down thing? They even made a movie about it.

The US Backed African Union has taken the lead in Sudan and Darfur, again previously noted and also Somalia and Uganda, in fact, oh look, US Officials going there and discussing it just the other day :rolleyes:

Rwanda actually had UN forces in it before the massacre, and that was a total pooch screw by the UN because they knew what was coming and fled, allowing it to occur. I'm not sure how this was the US's fault, but I'm sure you'll figure it out since you believe everything is.

As for Zimbabwe, while bad and extremely messed up with pro-government mobs and a destroyed economy, the Mugabe government isn't mass murdering its citizens at the present time, nor recently. Yes that was done back in the 1980's under Mugabe's orders, but other then the country being an economic disaster zone, with all the incumbent issues that comes with that, I'm unsure why you think the US should attack it.
 
Last edited:
I would contend that prior to the invasion, in 2000-2001, that era of civil war was over, with Taliban in control of the entire country.

Umm, no, they controlled at maximum 90% of the country

If that's wrong, and you can show that with some evidence, I will gladly withdraw my comment.

So you were and are totally unaware that the Northern Alliance, you know the guys the US supported and had do most of the ground fighting in 2001 were still at war with the Taliban? Seriously, if you didn't know that, well...

It's not going to change the glaring point that Afghanistan is no better off now than in 2001, 1991, 1981, or even 1781.

And yet the crazy people that live there say that it is. I mean, gee how could it possibly be better right? Having freedom to do what you want to do, say what you want to say, worship your god as you want to, or not, all rather than having to live under the tyranny of Communism or Sharia Law, that dictates your every move with a sentence of death is you get it wrong. Nope, can't see how it could possibly be better now.

Aside from some improvements made during the occupation that I think are extremely unlikely to last, in the face of an enemy which will not give up.

So your option is to give up your freedom and live as a slave of you are lucky enough to be of the ones allowed to live?
 
You are aware that the US actually did attack North Korea? Right... the whole Korean War thing? M*A*S*H... ring any bells

Since my old man was an active participant, sure.

1 It was in the '50s, which is hardly relevant to USA lack of action during famines that have killed millions.

2 It was a UN action, not a US action, or maybe you don't know that?

France has taken the lead in CAR and Chad, as noted previously, so yes Western Nations are there.

Excellent choices!

CAR has just delayed elections due to ongoing violence.

Been to Chad lately?

Efforts there don't seem to be going too well.


The US did go into Somalia, you might remember the whole Blackhawk down thing? They even made a movie about it.

:dl:

One mission: failed so badly they had to make a movie about it, containing so much lying propaganda it was hysterically funny.

USA took action in Somalia.

Are you writing for Tui now?

... the Mugabe government isn't mass murdering its citizens at the present time, nor recently. Yes that was done back in the 1980's under Mugabe's orders, ....

So, the 1950s is relevant, but not the 1980s.

Selective much?
 
Umm, no, they controlled at maximum 90% of the country



So you were and are totally unaware that the Northern Alliance, you know the guys the US supported and had do most of the ground fighting in 2001 were still at war with the Taliban? Seriously, if you didn't know that, well...

Your contradictions are killing you.

Right now, you said Taliban only control 15%, so wasn't as bad as 2001.

Now, where you say the NA controlled 10% in 2001 it was still civil war and worse than right now.

You are tying yourself in knots mate.
 
One mission: failed so badly they had to make a movie about it, containing so much lying propaganda it was hysterically funny.

USA took action in Somalia.

Are you writing for Tui now?
Actually, there was more action in Somalia than the infamous Day of the Ranger. There was stuff going on when I was working some ops in CENTCOM in 2004, and stuff before and after that as well.

It's a different sort of effort there, now that the somewhat heavy handed means begun by Bush 41 has been replaced by another approach. It's had mixed results, some good and some not so good.

One of the groups of folk I worked with was called "Task Force HOA" but we of course pronounced it in the smart arsed way. (HOA for Horn of Africa)
 
Last edited:
Actually, there was more action in Somalia than the infamous Day of the Ranger. There was stuff going on when I was working some ops in CENTCOM in 2004, and stuff before and after that as well.

It's a different sort of effort there, now that the somewhat heavy handed means begun by Bush 41 has been replaced by another approach. It's had mixed results, some good and some not so good.

One of the groups of folk I worked with was called "Task Force HOA" but we of course pronounced it in the smart arsed way. (HOA for Horn of Africa)

Thanks for that - you know I can always take you at your word.

I knew they'd done a little more than the one mission, but when that film gets mentioned, I always have a bit of a snark.

Still an absolute mess. Beggars belief how this crap keeps happening.

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/oct/01/britain-meddles-somalia-peril

My smart answer to the whole area is build an enormous wall around the whole ME and leave them to it.

Pity it's not very practical.
 
Since my old man was an active participant, sure.

1 It was in the '50s, which is hardly relevant to USA lack of action during famines that have killed millions.

2 It was a UN action, not a US action, or maybe you don't know that?

1) So why did you bring them up? What have they done lately that makes them deserving of attack?

2) Yes I am aware, I'm also aware the it was US Lead and the bulk of the forces were US.


So because Western troops being there doesn't stop the violence instantly.... what?

One mission: failed so badly they had to make a movie about it, containing so much lying propaganda it was hysterically funny.

USA took action in Somalia.

You clearly don't know a lot about what happen. In actual fail the mission didn't fail, and even in the Battle of Mogadishu, it was a victory for the US armed forces. The issue was political. Americans at the time weren't willing to allow their troops to be killed in overseas actions, especially after the loses in Vietnam and then so few loses in Desert Storm/Shield. It was the political fall out the killed the mission, but any military failures.

So, the 1950s is relevant, but not the 1980s.

Selective much?

You were the one that selected North Korea and Zimbabwe, I just pointed out the facts that the US had attacked NK, and had no reason to attack Zimbabwe today. They have no reason to attack NK today either, which is why they don't.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom