Split Thread War in Afghanistan

How very subtle!

CNN:
Doctors Without Borders staff also reported seeing people shot from the air as they ran between buildings during the hourlong attack October 3 in Kunduz, it said.
http://edition.cnn.com/2015/11/05/a...rs-without-borders-kunduz-hospital/index.html

MSF report they are referring to:
others were shot by the circling AC-130 gunship while fleeing the burning building.
http://www.msf.org.uk/sites/uk/files/msf_kunduz_review_041115_for_public_release.pdf

Nice.
Of course you can't write that the good guys shot at people fleeing! Next you have to write about
MSF received a question from a US Government official in Washington D.C., asking whether the hospital or any other of MSF’s locations had a large number of Taliban“holed up” and enquired about the safety of our staff. MSF replied that our staff were working at full capacity in Kunduz and that the hospital was full of patients including wounded Taliban combatants some of whom had been referred to the MSF medical post in Chardara. MSF also expressed that we were very clear with both sides to the conflict about the need to respect medical structures as a condition to our ability to continue working.
(Same report)

So before accidently shooting up the hospital they accidently asked if it would be ok to shoot up the hospital because of taliban, and after being told no, decided to accidently shoot up the hospital anyway, on accidental orders by the afghanis, and accidently shoot fleeing survivors.
 
Last edited:
Interesting.. thanks for that Ziggurat.

I was under the impression that the Taliban WHERE on the ascendancy up until 2001. They DID take over the capital, and where pushing the Northern Alliance back. (albeit with help from the Pakistani army, and money from the Saudi's). They only went into decline when the Americans invaded ?

If they had that assistance again, AFTER the Americans leave, then can we really say that there is "zero chance" of them replicating their earlier success, but taking it further ?

(actually... with the Taliban hatred of Shia Islam, I wonder whether the Iranians would be tempted to intervene ? In the hypothetical scenario wherein the Taliban DO take over the entire territory, it would put them on the Iranian border... which I don't think the Iranians would be too chuffed about ? But that's another discussion. )
 
Last edited:
If they had that assistance again, AFTER the Americans leave, then can we really say that there is "zero chance" of them replicating their earlier success ?

Let's go back for a second. This is the statement that The Atheist made that Joey objected to:

How long before the Taliban re-take the entire country?

They cannot re-take the entire country, because they never had the entire country before. Now the distinction between, say, 75% of the country and 100% of the country may not be of much comfort to us, but it's still true that to get to 100% they would have to do what they have not done before. So even if they manage to conquer all of Afghanistan (and I doubt they can), it wouldn't be a re-taking of the entire country but the very first taking.

And given the trouble that the Taliban has caused within Pakistan since 2001, they are unlikely to get the level of support from Pakistan that they previously had, though I wouldn't be surprised if they still got some support.
 
How very subtle!

CNN:

http://edition.cnn.com/2015/11/05/a...rs-without-borders-kunduz-hospital/index.html

MSF report they are referring to:

http://www.msf.org.uk/sites/uk/files/msf_kunduz_review_041115_for_public_release.pdf

Nice.
Of course you can't write that the good guys shot at people fleeing! Next you have to write about

(Same report)

So before accidently shooting up the hospital they accidently asked if it would be ok to shoot up the hospital because of taliban, and after being told no, decided to accidently shoot up the hospital anyway, on accidental orders by the afghanis, and accidently shoot fleeing survivors.

Thanks for posting that - from an information perspective. From a humanitarian perspective, I think it's the most revolting thing I've read in my life, so no thanks for that.

This is a war crime worse the My Lai.

Nobody will ever face charges over it.

Excuse me while I go and weep for humankind.

Sick, sick, sick *********** Americans.
 
Thanks for posting that - from an information perspective. From a humanitarian perspective, I think it's the most revolting thing I've read in my life, so no thanks for that.

This is a war crime worse the My Lai.

Nobody will ever face charges over it.

Excuse me while I go and weep for humankind.
Sick, sick, sick *********** Americans.

And thank you for continuing to milk that hospital strike for all it's worth. And for continuing to milk My Lai.

To show my appreciation, here's some music to accompany your sobbing.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fTkHFQC3wow

Almost forgot. Here's you some more hospital strikes to cry over.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...rstrikes-as-Russian-jets-bombard-country.html

And while you're at it, why not try to squeeze out a few tears for these victims as well?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_killings_under_Communist_regimes

Looks like it's definitely "your turn to cry".
 
Last edited:
Thanks for posting that - from an information perspective. From a humanitarian perspective, I think it's the most revolting thing I've read in my life, so no thanks for that.

This is a war crime worse the My Lai.

Nobody will ever face charges over it.

Excuse me while I go and weep for humankind.

Sick, sick, sick *********** Americans.
When confused conspiracy theorists angry at America cry all most people feel is pity.
 
The flippant & sarcastic responses to comments on one of - if not the worst - war crimes in history is so heartening to me you wouldn't credit it.

Whatever your colour, creed or race, whether dove, hawk, aggressor or coward, no moral human being could do anything other than be revolted by what happened in Kunduz.

To see that there are people brave enough to sit down at a computer keyboard and scorn those revolted by it firms my faith in our species.

Thanks guys.
 
A hospital was shot up accidentally, this is sad. You think it was on purpose, there is a cover-up, the fact they had been given the coordinates means that it was on purpose, mistake is impossible, so, you are conspiracy theorist, and you weep for humanity over what are in my mind, sad delusions. You jump from your total belief in this narrative to saying it's worse than My Lai, where crazed men slaughtered civilians, quite on purpose, and we know what happened there... So because I reject your stupid, emotionally demented theory, suddenly I'm heartless... This is why no one takes you seriously, ever.
 
It just occurred to me: these are the people who are anti-genocide*.


funny.gif







8by other countries.
 
A crazy conspiracy theory that the US blew up Doctors Without Borders on purpose is making people cry. I learn things every day.
 
The flippant & sarcastic responses to comments on one of - if not the worst - war crimes in history is so heartening to me you wouldn't credit it.

Whatever your colour, creed or race, whether dove, hawk, aggressor or coward, no moral human being could do anything other than be revolted by what happened in Kunduz.

To see that there are people brave enough to sit down at a computer keyboard and scorn those revolted by it firms my faith in our species.

Thanks guys.
I'm curious how you know it was a war crime? Usually such crimes are determined only after a thorough investigation into what decisions were made based on what available information. Third-hand reports in the media seem to be insufficient to make such a determination. Are you leaping to conclusions? Do you have additional information? Is this one of those pacifist "all war is crime" type war crimes?
 
The flippant & sarcastic responses to comments on one of - if not the worst - war crimes in history is so heartening to me you wouldn't credit it.

Whatever your colour, creed or race, whether dove, hawk, aggressor or coward, no moral human being could do anything other than be revolted by what happened in Kunduz.

To see that there are people brave enough to sit down at a computer keyboard and scorn those revolted by it firms my faith in our species.

Thanks guys.

Even if it had been an intentional attack on a hospital because it was a hospital, that you would consider that even remotely possible as the worst war crime in history speaks libraries.
 
I'm curious how you know it was a war crime?

The hospital was deliberately targeted. The people running from the hospital were fired upon and killed.

Whether the targeting was deliberate or some kind of coincidence of stupidity due to having an army of morons does not change the fact that the hospital was targeted.

If I shoot a person while out hunting because I have failed to identify my target, I commit a crime.

The attack on the hospital is a war crime.

Even if it had been an intentional attack on a hospital because it was a hospital, that you would consider that even remotely possible as the worst war crime in history speaks libraries.

Nominate a better suggestion - I'm open to them.

All you need to come up with a single instance that matches the MSF hospital attack in immorality. The best I can come up with is My Lai, and I think this surpasses it, so over to you.
 
A hospital was shot up accidentally, this is sad.

Your assumption that it was accidental is noted.

Given the attacking force knowing the co-ordinates matched a hospital, the "accident" part is difficult to believe. As I noted in the post above, I accept that the crass stupidity of the scum that are employed by US military are sufficiently moronic to screw up a simple set of instructions and attacked the hospital in the mistaken belief it was a target.

That would be an error of monumental proportions, but not within any reasonable description of "accidental".

However, your immediate defensive position of screaming "conspiracy" again speaks volumes as to your zeal and error. The following is pure nonsense, and breaks so many fallacies I wouldn't want to list them all*:

You think it was on purpose,

Incorrect.

there is a cover-up,

Incorrect.

the fact they had been given the coordinates means that it was on purpose, mistake is impossible,

Incorrect.

so, you are conspiracy theorist,

Incorrect.

and you weep for humanity over what are in my mind, sad delusions.

Incorrect.

I weep for humanity over an incident that should be the final nail in the rotting corpse of the idea that war is cool, but won't even create a ripple.

*strawman, poisoning the well, false premises...
 
So basically you redefine accident, war crime and conspiracy theory to suit your purpose, hedge anyway by saying "knowing the co-ordinates matched a hospital, the "accident" part is difficult to believe" and continue on blathering about how war is evil, this proves it, it's massacre, you're all heartless, blah blah blah, not much I can say but you're completely out to lunch, intellectually dishonest, both or trolling.
 
Last edited:
So basically you redefine accident, war crime and conspiracy theory to suit your purpose....

No.

We stopped calling car crashes "accidents" many years ago, because they are almost never accidents. in 99.9+% of cases, the driver of at least one vehicle is at fault. An accidental crash is a rock falling onto a car - a driver going too fast is not.

The MSF attack is demonstrably - and admitted by US - as being someone's fault.

That is not an accident.
 
The hospital was deliberately targeted. The people running from the hospital were fired upon and killed.

Whether the targeting was deliberate or some kind of coincidence of stupidity due to having an army of morons does not change the fact that the hospital was targeted.

If I shoot a person while out hunting because I have failed to identify my target, I commit a crime.

The attack on the hospital is a war crime.
You do know that intentionally targeting a hospital is not always a war crime, right?
 
So, no instances you can think of, then.
Were you replying to me? Intentionally targeting a hospital is not necessarily a war crime. Can we at least agree on whether or not it was a crime, before we move on to determining how horrible of a crime it was (if it was, in fact, a crime)?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom