Split Thread War in Afghanistan

So should Afghanistan give into the Taliban like you think Britain should have given in to the Nazis?
 
It's a shame. It was all so good before we wrecked it................:rolleyes:

No, it was about the same.

The difference is the civilians and "coalition" soldiers killed since the invasion.

My point is entirely that Afghanistan was a balls-up before the invasion and a balls-up now.

What purpose did the invasion serve?

A list of a few things will do. I sure can't see any - unless you want to count the profits made by arms manufacturers?
 
What purpose did the invasion serve?

As far as I can see, none.

A list of a few things will do. I sure can't see any - unless you want to count the profits made by arms manufacturers?

That's interesting. How exactly do you define "profit"? Would they have profited less without this action?

Numbers please............
 
No, it was about the same.
So the health services access and the quality of life index and the infant mortality rates and the education rates and the thousands of miles of roads and internet cables mean nothing to you huh... *********** disgraceful....
 
That's interesting. How exactly do you define "profit"? Would they have profited less without this action?

Numbers please............

Profit is very simple: income less costs = profit.

As to finding the exact numbers, I imagine that is impossible, however it's fairly safe to say that their income and profits both increased due to increased sales, which clearly happened.

So the health services access and the quality of life index and the infant mortality rates and the education rates and the thousands of miles of roads and internet cables mean nothing to you huh... *********** disgraceful....

And exactly how long do you think those improvements will last with Taliban back in the driver's seat?

Give it ten years and A'stan will be right back where they were.

All those lives expended for nothing, but you'll still be there defending the invasion.
 
Profit is very simple: income less costs = profit.

As to finding the exact numbers, I imagine that is impossible, however it's fairly safe to say that their income and profits both increased due to increased sales, which clearly happened.



And exactly how long do you think those improvements will last with Taliban back in the driver's seat?

Give it ten years and A'stan will be right back where they were.

All those lives expended for nothing, but you'll still be there defending the invasion.

Nuking Afganistan was not an option, the People of Afganistan are now responsible for their own countries success or failure.
 
Profit is very simple: income less costs = profit.

As to finding the exact numbers, I imagine that is impossible, however it's fairly safe to say that their income and profits both increased due to increased sales, which clearly happened.

So you assume it must be so.

Producing more does not mean more profit. Increasing production increases cost and unless the demand is maintained equals a net loss. I asked about numbers and you gave me ....................?
 
And exactly how long do you think those improvements will last with Taliban back in the driver's seat?
So you admit you're talking out of your ass again for politically motivated purposes? You just said it was no different! Evidence? The Taliban isn't back in the driver's seat, that's laughable nonsense!
All those lives expended for nothing, but you'll still be there defending the invasion.
For someone who accuses people of using crystal balls... just profoundly stupid...
 
Last edited:
Afghanistan was where Al Qaeda was in 2001-2002.

Our mistake was being stupid about what happened next, that and trusting Pakistan.

We went in small and should have kept the force small and help the Afghans learn to work together, and form their own system of government. Instead we back Karzai, who on a good day was a crook, and likely bi-polar. We threw money around without accounting for 90% of it, and we ignored the Soviet experience in parts of the country leading to similar outcomes.
 
So you assume it must be so.

Nope.

I made a presumption based on enormous evidence of corporate activity over many years.

That's how business works.

Producing more does not mean more profit.

Correct.

However, when you have a captive US Government as a client, I would be astonished if any company managed to lose money on increased orders. Company management would need to be certifiably insane to lose money and I don't believe they are in that industry.

Increasing production increases cost and unless the demand is maintained equals a net loss.

You have no clue how production works, do you?

Companies deal with peaks and troughs all the time, and any manufacturer that does not have excellent plans in place is not going to last long. It would be again appallingly inept management.

Also, the orders would be well signalled, because the US armed forces already have stores and supplies. Lead times would be very generous and easy to organise to maximise profit.

I asked about numbers and you gave me ....................?

All that shows is that as well having no idea about manufacturing, you know even less about business.

I am happy to educate, however:

Companies produce financial information.

In private companies that information is not available to the public, however I think all of the major manufacturers would be public companies, so the information is available.

That information contains the accounts for the company operating as a whole and are very rarely issued to the public in detail that includes a breakdown of divisions within the main group.

Even if that information is issued, you can cast-iron guarantee that no company will break down its public accounts to reflect individual product lines, which is what would be needed to show that the US gov't orders increased profit.

Your clever argument asking me to provide evidence is absurd. The evidence does not exist in the public realm.

In that case, it it is perfectly rational to use known facts and business history to presume those profits exist.
 
Nope.

I made a presumption based on enormous evidence of corporate activity over many years.

That's how business works.



Correct.

However, when you have a captive US Government as a client, I would be astonished if any company managed to lose money on increased orders. Company management would need to be certifiably insane to lose money and I don't believe they are in that industry.



You have no clue how production works, do you?

Companies deal with peaks and troughs all the time, and any manufacturer that does not have excellent plans in place is not going to last long. It would be again appallingly inept management.

Also, the orders would be well signalled, because the US armed forces already have stores and supplies. Lead times would be very generous and easy to organise to maximise profit.



All that shows is that as well having no idea about manufacturing, you know even less about business.

I am happy to educate, however:

Companies produce financial information.

In private companies that information is not available to the public, however I think all of the major manufacturers would be public companies, so the information is available.

That information contains the accounts for the company operating as a whole and are very rarely issued to the public in detail that includes a breakdown of divisions within the main group.

Even if that information is issued, you can cast-iron guarantee that no company will break down its public accounts to reflect individual product lines, which is what would be needed to show that the US gov't orders increased profit.

Your clever argument asking me to provide evidence is absurd. The evidence does not exist in the public realm.

In that case, it it is perfectly rational to use known facts and business history to presume those profits exist.

The information is available to anyone who knows where to look, it's in the stock price.
 
The information is available to anyone who knows where to look, it's in the stock price.

No, and not even close.

1 Profits will only affect share price if the increase is large and unexpected.

2 Many arms manufacturers have only a small part of their business supplying weapons to US military, so it wouldn't affect share prices at all.

3 Shares are subject to considerable movement outside profit & loss.

4 Unless you know which company received orders for which weapon at what time, you have nothing to start with, and I can't see that being publicly available information. If it is, show me where it is and I'll gladly do a little research on the companies that supplied the materiel.

Next brilliant idea?
 
No, and not even close.

1 Profits will only affect share price if the increase is large and unexpected.

2 Many arms manufacturers have only a small part of their business supplying weapons to US military, so it wouldn't affect share prices at all.

3 Shares are subject to considerable movement outside profit & loss.

4 Unless you know which company received orders for which weapon at what time, you have nothing to start with, and I can't see that being publicly available information. If it is, show me where it is and I'll gladly do a little research on the companies that supplied the materiel.

Next brilliant idea?
http://www.zacks.com/stock/news/154715/northrop-grumman-noc-wins-116m-us-military-contract
 
Afghan forces ready to take Kunduz back from Taliban, official says

http://www.cnn.com/2015/09/29/asia/afghanistan-kunduz-taliban-attack/

A lot of people are going to die today in this battle. AA commanders says they are ready to fight to the last drop of blood. Taliban says they are going to set up Sharia law. I wonder how many days it will take them to retake the city? I wish them the best of luck.

Back in the driver's seat because they took over part of a city... they should just let the Taliban take over... right? Just like Britain should have let the Nazis take over... smh
 
A lot of people are going to die today in this battle. AA commanders says they are ready to fight to the last drop of blood. Taliban says they are going to set up Sharia law. I wonder how many days it will take them to retake the city? I wish them the best of luck.

Back in the driver's seat because they took over part of a city... they should just let the Taliban take over... right? Just like Britain should have let the Nazis take over... smh

Then they can go back to using soccer pitches for the true and right purpose as a forum for putting a bullet into the back of the head of women who dared to be educated.
 
300 walmarts in Afghanistan would bring them up to the store per capita density of Idaho.

300 walmarts is my peace plan. Jobs, consumer goods availability and motivation to keep the roads free of bombs.
 
"Your clever argument asking me to provide evidence is absurd."


A stundie like mother used to make!
 
However, when you have a captive US Government as a client, I would be astonished if any company managed to lose money on increased orders. Company management would need to be certifiably insane to lose money and I don't believe they are in that industry.

You're clueless.

I'm sure that all the arms manufacturers made a profit on their sales. I'm sure that the Afghan war increased the demand for certain arms.

But what you don't seem to even consider is the possibility that this increased demand for some arms might lead to a decrease in demand for other arms. And this was in fact the case. The Bush administration cancelled two major arms projects, the Crusader mobile artillery and the Comanche helicopter. These would have been extremely profitable for their manufacturers, had they gone into production.

So it's not enough for you to claim that every arms sale is profitable, and therefore arms manufacturers made a profit off of war. The latter does not follow from the former, because arms manufacturers make a profit during peace time too, and they may be making far better margins during peace time than during war time. So you need to be able to demonstrate that what you claim happened was what actually happened. And you have failed to do so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom