Split Thread War in Afghanistan

Your contradictions are killing you.

Right now, you said Taliban only control 15%, so wasn't as bad as 2001.

Now, where you say the NA controlled 10% in 2001 it was still civil war and worse than right now.

You are tying yourself in knots mate.

You really are trolling right?

You honestly don't believe that there is any difference between 90% of Afghanistan living in a Taliban controlled tyranny under their death cult sharia law, and 85% of Afghanistan living under a democratically elected government with rights and freedoms that you can claim without being executed for it?

It seems to me that in these threads that you honestly believe that there is no difference between living under tyranny with the likes of the Third Reich, ISIS, The Taliban, Stalinist Russia, or North Korea, and living under a democratically elected secular government with all the rights and privileges of doing so.
 
Last edited:
1) So why did you bring them up? What have they done lately that makes them deserving of attack?

Helping the people avoid the famine caused by a despotic dictator.

You obviously hadn't heard of it.

In actual fail the mission didn't fail,...

Freud loves you, man.

You really are trolling right?

I love the way so many people call troll when someone disagrees with a popular opinion and they don't have a rational response.

You honestly don't believe that there is any difference between 90% of Afghanistan living in a Taliban controlled tyranny under their death cult sharia law, and 85% of Afghanistan living under a democratically elected government with rights and freedoms that you can claim without being executed for it?

You are treating the numbers with complete dishonesty.

It isn't a case of 90% living in some paradisical A'stan where they grow roses and sip tea while watching the U20 cricket team - 10% is completely controlled and about a further 40% is disputed. Almost half the country is anything but at peace.

Why don't you open your eyes and see what is actually going on?

Kabul is such a nice, settled place these days.

Oops, there's that nice game of cricket.

Just your typical 4 dead, 13 injured scenario.

3 dead, 21 injured in two blasts.

Just in the past couple of weeks.

Afghanistan is safer!

Betcha hotels are dirt cheap there.

It seems to me that in these threads that you honestly believe that there is no difference between living under tyranny ...

And you clearly have not been following the thread or are making it up. I have said the exact opposite of what you're claiming on many occasions.
 
"I love the way so many people call troll when someone disagrees with a popular opinion and they don't have a rational response."

Deep down no one wants to believe that it's possible for other people to be that stupid and ignorant.
 
Helping the people avoid the famine caused by a despotic dictator.

You obviously hadn't heard of it.

So you are advocating that the US should be attacking anywhere that people are starving, great idea. Perhaps they'll add South Auckland to the list.

You are treating the numbers with complete dishonesty.

It isn't a case of 90% living in some paradisical A'stan where they grow roses and sip tea while watching the U20 cricket team - 10% is completely controlled and about a further 40% is disputed. Almost half the country is anything but at peace.

Why don't you open your eyes and see what is actually going on?

Kabul is such a nice, settled place these days.

Oops, there's that nice game of cricket.

Just your typical 4 dead, 13 injured scenario.

3 dead, 21 injured in two blasts.

Just in the past couple of weeks.

Afghanistan is safer!

7 dead and 40 odd injured in 2 weeks? When the Taliban were in charge they were killing more people in a day, so yes, it is safer now. This is what you don't seem to comprehend. The Taliban conducted massacres, and mass executions of people not following its rules. Plus they had bombs going off and war. Now the Government isn't systematically killing it's own people, and they have freedoms they didn't under the Taliban, thus, yes it is better. You seem to have a warped view that better can only mean perfect. It doesn't, it means it is better than it was.

And you clearly have not been following the thread or are making it up. I have said the exact opposite of what you're claiming on many occasions.

The problem is that you claim this, and then turn around and oppose what you claimed by saying that living under a democratically elected government where you are free to live as you want, is worse than living under a tyranny that was slaughtering people and forcing them out into the wilderness in the middle of a famine they helped create so they'd all stave, just because there are occasional bombings. There are nearly 3 million people living in Kabul, there are an estimated 10,000 road deaths in Afghanistan every year. This year is looking at about 3,000 civilians killed. You have 3x more likely to die in a traffic accident in Afghanistan than you are in a bombing or shooting.

In 2000 there was 20 million people in Afghanistan. 10 million were suffering from a famine that the Taliban exacerbated with their policies and actions. That was 50% of the population with an estimated 5-10% of them likely to die had their not been intervention. So if you lived in in Afghanistan in 2000, you'd have had a 1 in 2 chance of struggling to find your next meal, and a 1 in five chance of starving to death, if you weren't killed in all the other ways, massacres, executions, bombings, fighting. Now you would have a 0.01% chance of being killed by a bomb or in a shooting, and yet this is somehow worse. And you wonder why people think you are trolling? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
So you are advocating that the US should be attacking anywhere that people are starving, great idea. Perhaps they'll add South Auckland to the list.

Would sure as hell improve it.

7 dead and 40 odd injured in 2 weeks?

There were a lot more than that in just the links I gave you, plus I wasn't trying very hard - I just picked the first three that came up.

And if you think those were the only attacks in that period, you are seriously deluded. Most of them never make the press. Like USA - we hear of the murders with 10 dead, but not a word about the 88 who die from gunshot wounds every day of the week.

Do you seriously think a few news reports accurately portray what's going on in A'stan?
 
And you wonder why people think you are trolling? :rolleyes:

No, I don't wonder at all - I find it absolutely hysterically funny.

People get called trolls when the residents have neither the argument nor ability to counter the argument made.

Seriously - trying to convince someone like in A'stan is a bunch of roses thanks to the wonderful American saviours is more trolling than the opposite.

Oh yeah, but, but surveys....

Taken any lately?

2014 - ranked 96th out of 96 countries in lifestyle of the aged, losing to such magnificent places as West Bank and Malawi.

And that's after 13 whole years of that improvement in lifestyle you keep chirping about.

I'm happy to let Afghans speak for themselves:

In 2014 a majority of Afghans (65.4%) report always, often, or sometimes fearing for their safety or security or that of their family. Fear for safety has increased since 2013 (59.0%), and since 2006 fear for safety has been on an overall upward trend.

The provinces reporting the highest levels of fear for personal safety are Faryab (92.1%), Wardak (89.2%), Farah (87.5%), and Kunduz (87.5%).

The provinces most likely to report never or rarely experiencing fear are Panjshir (98.5%), Badakhshan (81.7), and Bamyan (74.9%). Around three quarters of Afghans say they would be afraid when traveling within Afghanistan (76.4%).

A clear majority would be afraid to participate in a peaceful demonstration (69.4%), run for public office (70.8%), and encounter international forces (76.6%).

https://asiafoundation.org/resources/pdfs/Afghanistanin2014final.pdf

Clearly a good place - my apologies for doubting your word.
 
Last edited:
Clearly a good place - my apologies for doubting your word.

The choice was never between Afghanistan being a good place to live and being a bad place to live. The choice was between bad and worse. Wonder why there aren't such surveys showing how much life sucked under the Taliban? Because it wasn't even safe enough to conduct such surveys.

People vote with their feet. What happened to the number of Afghan refugees after our invasion?
http://www.unhcr.org/421316072.html
 
My smart answer to the whole area is build an enormous wall around the whole ME and leave them to it.

Pity it's not very practical.
Amigo:
The wall the Russians built worked for about a generation.
The wall the Israelis have built isn't making things much better for them.
That stupid wall some of our pols have supported vis a vis Mexico has done BloodyForkAll to deal with the problem to hand, which is a bizarre immigration policy.
A wall around the middle east? Nah, waste of good brick.
 
The choice was never between Afghanistan being a good place to live and being a bad place to live. The choice was between bad and worse. Wonder why there aren't such surveys showing how much life sucked under the Taliban? Because it wasn't even safe enough to conduct such surveys.

People vote with their feet. What happened to the number of Afghan refugees after our invasion?
http://www.unhcr.org/421316072.html

I've already said things improved for a while.

That seems to have turned.

It's not just me, either.

Boston Globe, National Post, Bloomberg - no matter where you look, the analysis is pretty consistent.

Amigo:
The wall the Russians built worked for about a generation.
The wall the Israelis have built isn't making things much better for them.
That stupid wall some of our pols have supported vis a vis Mexico has done BloodyForkAll to deal with the problem to hand, which is a bizarre immigration policy.
A wall around the middle east? Nah, waste of good brick.

Yeah, I know - I was being disingenuous myself.

It doesn't even need a wall in reality - they're pretty well cut off from the rest of the world anyway. If you leave them alone long enough, they'd most likely kill themselves off in no time.

Now, if we can just get Scotty back to build us a forcefield, we'd be fine.
 
I

It doesn't even need a wall in reality - they're pretty well cut off from the rest of the world anyway. If you leave them alone long enough, they'd most likely kill themselves off in no time.

Now, if we can just get Scotty back to build us a forcefield, we'd be fine.
Just keep pumpin' the oil outta there. It will eventually run out.
And then
Nobody will care about them, at all.
As it should be.
 
https://asiafoundation.org/resources/pdfs/Afghanistanin2014final.pdf

Clearly a good place - my apologies for doubting your word.

I find it interesting that you didn't note how 54.7% believe that the country is moving in the right direction, which has trended upwards since 2006, or that 32.8% claim that reason for optimism is good security (only 5.5% less then the 38.3% that felt that security was bad.) I also noted you missed out that on a local level on 14.1% considered security to be the biggest issue, most putting the likes of Unemployment and services well ahead of it.

You also managed to avoid that 78.6% say that they are happy. You also missed out that there are provinces extremely high in the lack of fear... provinces most likely to report never or rarely experiencing fear are Panjshir (98.5%), Badakhshan (81.7), and Bamyan (74.9%).

You seem to have missing that only 15.6% of the respondents had actually suffered from violence or crime, meaning that 84.4% had not.

You also missed that they are more confident in their own forces abilities - Using a composite measure of overall confidence, 86.5% of Afghans are confident in the ANA, and 73.2% are confident in the ANP. Overall perceptions of the ANA and ANP have improved over time, and more so for the ANA than the ANP.

Most Afghanis are happy with their Government - 75.3% of Afghans say the national government does a somewhat good or very good job. Around two-thirds say provincial government is doing a good job (67.6%), followed by municipal authorities (58.5%) and district government (56.7%). Views in 2014 are quite similar to 2013.

When asked if they are satisfied with the way democracy works in Afghanistan, 73.1% say they feel somewhat satisfied or very satisfied

And yes they do feel less safe running or going to protests, but over all - In 2014, 67.4% of Afghans surveyed said they feel very safe or somewhat safe expressing their opinions about the government in public. Residents of Parwan (94.3%), Panjshir (91.9%), and Samangan (86.0%) provinces are most likely to say they feel safe criticizing the government. !e provinces where people feel the least safe doing so are Uruzghan (43.9%), Ghor (49.2%), Herat (51.3%), and Zabul (51.9%). Afghans living in urban areas (76.2%) are more likely to feel safe speaking out about the government in public than those in rural areas (64.5%).

Wow, they can actually express their opinions of the Government in public without being executed for it, and they like it, astonishing. 70% might be afraid of participating in a peaceful demonstration, but what do you think that figure was under the Taliban? I'm going to go with about 100%.

And while over half (61.6%) of Afghans surveyed say that they were somewhat or very concerned about security threats during the election, in actual fact of only 11.6% [of those who did not vote] say they did not vote due to insecurity. How many didn't vote under the Taliban? Oh that's right, they didn't get to vote!

Television ownership has risen from 36.9% in 2007 to 58.3% in 2014, while the use of television as a source of news and information increased from 54.8% in 2013 to 58.4% in 2014. Internet use also increased from 3.2% in 2013 to 5.6% in 2014, and has nearly doubled in urban areas over the past year.

Remember the Taliban banned Television and shut down all broadcasting, even made it illegal to own a TV set.

Around two-thirds of Afghans (64.0%) say they believe the result of the presidential election will make their lives better, a significant increase from 56.4% in 2013.

Interesting that you cherry picked your data from the survey, and more interesting that in trying to show how bad it was now, you failed to actually show a comparison to how it was pre-2001. Or have you forgotten your claim that it was better under the Taliban then than it is under the Afghani Government now?
 
Last edited:
@Ziggurat: I am not convinced that the wall is what has slowed that down. Such simplified cause and effect conclusions get the hairs up on the back of my neck.
 
Just keep pumpin' the oil outta there. It will eventually run out.
And then
Nobody will care about them, at all.
As it should be.

No problem with that - just a pity it's taking so long!

I find it interesting that you didn't note how 54.7% believe that the country is moving in the right direction, which has trended upwards since 2006, ...

This is when I know you have nothing at all.

That survey was in 2014 - a whole year ago.

Even then, a lousy just-over-half thought things were going ok.

I am willing to bet plenty if you asked that question today it would be a great deal different.
 
This is when I know you have nothing at all.

That survey was in 2014 - a whole year ago.

Even then, a lousy just-over-half thought things were going ok.

I am willing to bet plenty if you asked that question today it would be a great deal different.

Seriously, you have lost your focus so much on trying to win, you seem to have forgotten what it was you are arguing about. Let me remind you since your short memory has faded.

The Atheist said:
That's no improvement on the state prior to 9/11, and I would certainly call it a deterioration

Do you honestly believe that over 50% of Afghanis in 2001 would have freely claimed that their country was headed in the right direction? Seriously? This seems to be where you go off the planet. Rather then trying to show what you actually claimed, that the people of Afghanistan were better off under the Taliban, you are merely showing that life isn't perfect there and then somehow expecting that to equal your argument. It doesn't Life in Afghanistan currently might not be perfect, but it is considerably better than it was under the tyrannical hellish leadership of the Taliban. You seem to fail to grasp this very simple fact. It's like you are trying to claim that the Jews were better off under Nazi Germany than they are living in Israel today because Hamas keeps firing rockets over the border at them. You're totally delusional.

Oh, and by the way. In December 2014, a whole 3.3% more of New Zealanders, (58%) stated that they believed that New Zealand was headed in the right direction. In September of 2013 it was at just 48% with 41% believing it was heading in the wrong direction. Those stats are worse than Afghanistan's. Perhaps we should invite the Taliban to take over here so we can be better off to, right?
 
Last edited:
In recent news from Kunduz
Aerial bombardments blew apart a Doctors Without Borders hospital in the battleground Afghan city of Kunduz about the time of a U.S. airstrike early Saturday, killing at least 19 people, officials said.
The RoE finally let the US strike the real enemy, I suppose. :eek:
 
Seriously, you have lost your focus so much on trying to win, you seem to have forgotten what it was you are arguing about. Let me remind you since your short memory has faded.

No worries - I'll gladly admit to being hyperbolic, and deliberately so.

The point is, 14 years - yes fourteen years - after the great US invasion, Afghanistan is still a huge, ugly mess, virtually on the brink of civil war.

So, it was better for a while.

I'll bet that's a great comfort to the families of the dead.

I'm not even going to bother arguing that the data we're using is outdated and not likely to bear relationship to how people feel there today.
 
Well, I read it and appreciated it, Wolf.

There is a new book out called Superforecasting. For a certain kind of person who is interested in current and future events, I believe it is indispensable. Certain learnable mental habits are prescribed that would counter certain lazy and emotional habits certain people have. I mean, for those who are willing to be honest, and do their due diligence, etc.

http://www.economist.com/news/books...nt-luckily-it-can-be-learned-unclouded-vision
 
No worries - I'll gladly admit to being hyperbolic, and deliberately so.

The point is, 14 years - yes fourteen years - after the great US invasion, Afghanistan is still a huge, ugly mess, virtually on the brink of civil war.

So, it was better for a while.

But only the perfect is good.

Right?

Just hoping I'm following your lecture correctly.


I'll bet that's a great comfort to the families of the dead.

That imperfect good is worthless?

Frankly, I doubt anyone would be comforted by that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom