Split Thread War in Afghanistan

Were you replying to me?

You said this previously:

I'm curious how you know it was a war crime?

I then asked you for examples of equivalent or worse war crimes.

None are forthcoming, and I fully understand why.

Intentionally targeting a hospital is not necessarily a war crime.

Ah, you're in upside-down land. Now I see the problem.

As we're never going to get past that statement, the discussion is a bit pointless from here on. By "hospital" I mean a functioning hospital not being run as a front - actual hospitals, like the Kunduz one.

Can we at least agree on whether or not it was a crime, ...

I have already. It was a war crime.

Geneva Convention IV

Article 16


Article 17


Article 18

Civilian hospitals organized to give care to the wounded and sick, the infirm and maternity cases, may in no circumstances be the object of attack, but shall at all times be respected and protected by the Parties to the conflict.

Article 19

and Article 20 seem to cover the possibilities, because the attack broke all of those rules.
 
The flippant & sarcastic responses to comments on one of - if not the worst - war crimes in history is so heartening to me you wouldn't credit it.
...


Not even in the top 100,000 war crimes, if it was a war crime. Your hyperbole deserves nothing more than flippant sarcasm.

Since you chose to milk the last drop of indoctrinational value out of the victims of My Lai, and dishonestly ranked the massacre ridiculously high on the war crimes list, I was moved to inform you that My Lai was but a drop in the bucket compared to the thousands of war crimes committed by the communists in Vietnam. Here is just one of many well known and documented examples:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_at_Huế

Without the era of communist aggression which took an estimated 80 million lives and gave rise to the containment strategy of which the Vietnam intervention was a part, there would have been no Vietnam war, no My Lai massacre, no Hue massacre, and the list goes on and on.

And much the same can be accurately attributed to the Taliban in Afghanistan.

The real causes of these wars get a pass from you, though they are serial war criminals, having committed numerous war crimes as a matter of policy, with malice aforethought.
 
Last edited:

Hardly worse than ISIS.

Nowhere near the same as targeting a hospital. No matter how misguided, even massacres like the one you link have a point. To terrorise the population.

Bombing hospitals and shooting doctors running for cover is a level beyond mere genocide.

... and gave rise to the containment strategy of which the Vietnam intervention was a part,...

:dl:

Tell me, how did that turn out?

The real causes of these wars get a pass from you, though they are serial war criminals, having committed numerous war crimes as a matter of policy, with malice aforethought.

No, they don't get a pass at all.

I can understand those war crimes, however. One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter.
 
Hardly worse than ISIS.

Nowhere near the same as targeting a hospital. No matter how misguided, even massacres like the one you link have a point. To terrorise the population.
Bombing hospitals and shooting doctors running for cover is a level beyond mere genocide.

Some of your statements are so meaningless that there is no meaningful response to them. One can only highlight them.


Tell me, how did that turn out?

It succeeded. Western Europe was saved. South Korea is now a thriving democracy. Communist designs on Iran and Iraq were thwarted. Soviet proteges in the ME were clobbered by Israel. Communist designs on South America were thwarted. Unable to seize more countries to loot, the chronically nonproductive Soviet Union collapsed and released Eastern Europe from bondage.

Vietnam was just one battle in the "twilight struggle". One that ended rather badly for the former and unlamented Soviet Union and Red China, one of which was told to stuff it, and the other repelled when it attempted an invasion of Vietnam after Vietnam clobbered it's genocidal Khmer Rouge protege.

I can understand those war crimes, however. One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter.

What freedom? The freedom of the Taliban to throw acid into the faces of schoolgirls, and shoot them in the head?

Well, if you can understand that, then perhaps there may be the slightest glimmer of possibility that you can understand this:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...s_flash_the_taliban_violate_human_rights.html

The next stage—may it come soon—will be the realization that the Taliban does not "violate" human rights, but entirely lacks the concept of their existence.
 
Last edited:
I've not been following this story, but having read some of the links here, I am horrified.

The event was over a month ago; has there been any "official" US explanation of how the hospital came to be targetted like this ?

The concept of "accident" is strained, when you consider how specific the attack was. The Traume Centre was leveled, but adjacent buildings seem hardly damaged. The attack was remarkably specific, and very sustained.

The US military knew this was a long-established MSF facility, and one with an extensive track record of humanitarian work, and strict discipline. (no weapons allowed on site, with unarmed internal security ensuring that no group stationed troops or weapons in the compound). The idea that the large MSF staff where somehow supporting the Taliban is ridiculous.

Granted that the number of dead and wounded is small by the "standards" of massacres. But to target Medicine Sans Frontiers ?
It's almost as though the Americans wanted their military to be held in contempt throughout the civilized world. Whats next; bomb the vatican ?

I don't understand it.
 
Last edited:
Classic agitator claptrap. The idea that anyone knowingly targeted Doctors Without Borders is ludicrous. It doesn't matter what the US investigations conclude, or when they do, many people will take their beliefs that it was intentional to their graves. A serious conversation can't be had with such people. Indeed, it's not their intention to have one. Moral shaming, posturing and agitation, that is the name of the game. There is not one conspiracist website on the internet that isn't pushing the theory it was intentional. All of them equally sure of themselves. It's shameful, but it's really your problem.
 
I can envision a dozen scenarios on why/how this happened, but I would bet the farm that "the Chain-of-Command wanted MSF dead" is not among any of the plausible ones. But that doesn't mean there wasn't some culpable malfeasance somewhere in the chain. MSF is not the most popular group in the US military, and if there were cultural run-ins with this group before, it is conceivable that someone placed appropriately tilted the targeting assessment in the desired direction.

Frankly, that would almost be an easier issue to fix than a finding that the system of target nomination and validation is sloppy.
 
And all of that said, I agree with all the others here that The Atheist's rants about this being among the worst war crimes are beyond ludicrous, and if he actually believes that then I find it impossible to take any of his posts seriously.
 
The Atheist also thinks we should have given in to the Nazis to prevent human suffering.
 
The idea that anyone knowingly targeted Doctors Without Borders is ludicrous.

This is why I love you - there is no doubt whatsoever that someone did exactly that.

Maybe as a result of a string of errors; maybe because there were two senior Taliban there; maybe because grunts are morons, but whatever the reason, the fact stands that the hospital was deliberately targeted. The exact co-ordinates of a known hospital were the attack point.

And as to the idea that only conspiracist sites are all over this, you're right!

Sydney Morning Herald

Guardian

And worst of all, the Commie pinkos at New Yorker.
 
It says right in your link "It's unclear whether commanders who unleashed the AC-130 gunship on the hospital – killing at least 22 patients and hospital staff – were aware that the site was a hospital or knew about the allegations of possible enemy activity." Everyone but you realizes that the fact that they were given the coordinates doesn't mean that the party who decided on the attack knew what they were shooting at. So you saying that "there is no doubt" that it was knowingly targeted is complete nonsense. This is classic conspiracist stupidity. "Look! The mainstream news is admitting it!" complete comprehension fail.
 
Hmmm...

So what you are basicly suggesting, Joey McGee, is that the US Military command structure is dangerously incompetent, to the point of criminality ?

You're implying that the worlds largest, most expensive, and most technologically sophisticated Military organisation has a command-and-control system equivelent to a banana republic ?

A multi-trillion dollar organisation has "gaps" that result in "the party who decided on the attack (didn't) know who they where shooting at" ?

In that scenario, the "party" in question - and their commanding officers - should, under the USA Uniform Code of Military Justice - be SHOT ! (or at least, be subject to either the Electric Chair, or a Lethal Injection; I'm not sure how the military handle the death penalty these days).

Moreover, the Chief of the General Staff responsible for the branch in question should be cashiered, and the Commander in Chief required to attend Congress to answer questions relating to dereliction of duty, in that the armed forces under his pervue had been demonstrated to be unfit for purpose.

THAT is what should happen if "...the party who decided on the attack (didn't) know what they where shooting at".

Are you SURE you wan't to continue with that proposal ?
 
You realize that it is a long way from "didn't cross reference the target co-ordinates with the co-ordinates of hospitals" to "neglect to the prejudice of good order and discipline"? And just a little further yet to summary field executions?
 
You realize that it is a long way from "didn't cross reference the target co-ordinates with the co-ordinates of hospitals"...

Except that is clearly not the case, and admittedly so in the official US statement by General John Campbell, or did you miss the link in New Yorker.
 
Hmmm...

So what you are basicly suggesting, Joey McGee, is that the US Military command structure is dangerously incompetent, to the point of criminality ?
Every military in the world has it's own history of friendly fire and accidental targeting of noncombatants. This isn't the first time an AC-130 gunship has fired on the wrong target, soldiers have died. Every military is going to have incidents eventually. It's not acceptable, but neither is waging no war at all because of the risks.

You're implying that the worlds largest, most expensive, and most technologically sophisticated Military organisation has a command-and-control system equivelent to a banana republic ?

A multi-trillion dollar organisation has "gaps" that result in "the party who decided on the attack (didn't) know who they where shooting at" ?
blah blah blah blah

In that scenario, the "party" in question - and their commanding officers - should, under the USA Uniform Code of Military Justice - be SHOT ! (or at least, be subject to either the Electric Chair, or a Lethal Injection; I'm not sure how the military handle the death penalty these days).
People don't get shot for friendly fire and other accidents that get people killed. That's kind of sick and stupid.

Moreover, the Chief of the General Staff responsible for the branch in question should be cashiered, and the Commander in Chief required to attend Congress to answer questions relating to dereliction of duty, in that the armed forces under his pervue had been demonstrated to be unfit for purpose.

THAT is what should happen if "...the party who decided on the attack (didn't) know what they where shooting at".

Are you SURE you wan't to continue with that proposal ?
I don't get it. Shouldn't you wait until you understand exactly what happened before you decide who should be punished for it and what should be done about it?

Except that is clearly not the case, and admittedly so in the official US statement by General John Campbell, or did you miss the link in New Yorker.
He doesn't say anything that supports your narrative whatsoever. I can tell that without looking at it. I did look at it, and of course, you can't read.
 
The problem with trying to take tragedies and twist them to support your agenda is that everyone (except for you and the people who agree with you) sees right through your posturing and logical leaps.
 
I can understand those war crimes, however. One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter.


What freedom? The freedom of the Taliban to throw acid into the faces of schoolgirls, and shoot them in the head?

Well, if you can understand that, then perhaps there may be the slightest glimmer of possibility that you can understand this:
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...s_flash_the_taliban_violate_human_rights.html



Looks like they're trying hard to emulate the brave soldiers of the Coalition.

They have some way to go yet. Note they didn't attempt to murder the doctors at the MSF hospital.



As expected, you did not understand any of that at all.

I wonder if you have the self awareness to understand how revealing it is that you excuse the war crimes you "understand". And the ones you understand are invariably the ones committed by enemies of the U.S.

I think the only way you could logically have that level of self awareness would be if you are in fact a Poe as Garrette suspects.

Are you a Poe, out to waste our time with silly little head games?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EItka8KXeq0
 
Last edited:
Hardly worse than ISIS.

Nowhere near the same as targeting a hospital. No matter how misguided, even massacres like the one you link have a point. To terrorise the population.

This is just bizarre. If I randomly slap some stranger while walking down the street, that may make no sense, while if I kill someone to steal their money, that has a purpose. But which is worse? Whether or not there's a "point" is hardly the important factor, is it? And terrorizing the population is itself a bad thing, so that doesn't mitigate the actions the VC and NVA.

Bombing hospitals and shooting doctors running for cover is a level beyond mere genocide.

Yeah, no, it isn't. Not even close.

Plus, what's with the plural? This was one hospital, not multiple hospitals.

No, they don't get a pass at all.

I can understand those war crimes, however. One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter.

ISIS and the Taliban are explicitly not fighting for freedom. Neither were any of your commie friends. And yes, actually, you are giving them a pass with your cheap moral relativism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom