By the Geneva conventions essentially all "insurgent" saboteurs, assassins etc. are subject to summary execution. I propose that to satisfy your criteria we give them an opportunity to talk, and if their information is actionable, then they will not be executed by next week.
Works for me. Just don't torture them.
You get that from the horses mouth, no doubt? Lucky thing that Shin Bet doesn't have to contend with the Washington Post or the NYT. They sure would have had fun with all the assassinations they've carried out.
No, I saw a news program where they interviewed a former CIA case officer who had 20+ years' experience running espionage operations in the Middle East. He claimed to have watched scores of prisoners tortured by various governments, and stated that the primary product, very nearly the sole product, of such interrogation techniques was false leads. He stated that he had not seen prisoners tortured by Shin Bet, and that when he asked why they told him, "Because it doesn't work."
It doesn't work!! Really? Wouldn't work on you I suppose? Well I'm supposed to be playing the tough guy here, but I suspect it would work on me.
That's not the problem. The problem is, people make **** up to make the pain stop. Like KSM claiming to have been involved with the Pearl kidnapping, which it was later shown he could not have had anything to do with. You'll notice the administration made a big deal about how KSM was involved with that, but you never heard about it after they found out he'd made it up.
:shrug: I haven't read it.
Somehow that doesn't surprise me.
Here you go. You can find copies of this manual all over the 'Net; it was released under FOIA. It's public domain. Here's an important quote from the relevant section, titled simply "Pain:"
"Interrogatees who are withholding but who feel qualms of guilt and a secret desire to yield are likely to become intractable if made to endure pain. The reason is that they can then interpret the pain as punishment and hence as expiation. There are also persons who enjoy pain and its anticipation and who will keep back information that they might otherwise divulge if they are given reason to expect that withholding will result in the punishment that they want. Persons of considerable moral or intellectual stature often find in pain inflicted by others a confirmation of the belief that they are in the hands of inferiors, and their resolve not to submit is strengthened.
Intense pain is quite likely to produce false confessions, concocted as a means of escaping from distress. A time-consuming delay results, while investigation is conducted and the admissions are proven untrue. During this respite the interrogatee can pull himself together. He may even use the time to think up new, more complex "admissions" that take still longer to disprove. KUBARK is especially vulnerable to such tactics because the interrogation is conducted for the sake of information and not for police purposes.
If an interrogatee is caused to suffer pain rather late in the interrogation process and after other tactics have failed, he is almost certain to conclude that the interrogator is becoming desperate. He may then decide that if he can just hold out against this final assault, he will win the struggle and his freedom. And he is likely to be right. Interrogatees who have withstood pain are more difficult to handle by other methods. The effect has been not to repress the subject but to restore his confidence and maturity."
Note that a primary goal of interrogation is to induce the subject to regress, and place judgment of right and wrong in the hands of the interrogator. Proper interrogation is a psychological process. The subject is induced to seek approval from the interrogator. Most criminals under police interrogation, contrary to TV shows, wind up revealing what they have done, sometimes inadvertently, sometimes not; and the methods used there are primarily if not exclusively psychological ones. The most effective interrogation technique is to "turn" the subject, convincing him that the interrogator could be convinced to be on his side and that he might be able to achieve the interrogator's approval if he can just convince him. This technique, and similar ones that use winning the subject's confidence, cannot be employed after torture has been used. These techniques have been proven over and over again to be the most effective available.
I will repeat, this has been known since the early 1960s. Only those who are incompetent at interrogation, because they have not been properly trained, can fail to know it. Torture is the refuge of the incompetent interrogator.
Obviously "torture" isn't going to produce non existing information, but if you know what you want to know, if you know what is likely known, if you know how to cross check it (say via someone else being interrogated) then some pressure points can elicit responses from most humans. Perhaps not from the most dedicated fanatic, or patriot for that matter, but certainly from most.
OK, so tell me this: why were the people who started the interrogation not people who had intelligence regarding KSM's activities prior to his capture? Such people were not brought in until 48 hours afterward.
Can you say "bungle?" I knew you could.
This is rank incompetence, nothing more. And it's at least partly driven by the desire for revenge. Comments by others on this thread make that clear.
Do you know the reason why physically coercive interrogation techniques are forbidden to law enforcement personnel? It is a very pragmatic one. A court of law is primarily about finding out the truth. The jury is empaneled to determine to the best of their ability what exactly happened. If a suspect has been subjected to physically coercive interrogation, there is no guarantee of the truth of any confession or other information obtained. It's just that simple, and just that pragmatic. It has nothing to do with morals or ethics.
Think about it.