Torture memo...OMG

Feel free to cite scientific evidence that supports this claim.

Oh I disagree. Torture gets answers, all right. WRONG answers very often, but they are still answers. In fact, wrong answers are so common you can't tell them from the right answers.
 
It's my guess that torture only conveys the answers that the torturer wants to hear, not the truth.
 
Elind in post 155:
We won WWII by being much more brutal than how we fight today, but it did not corrupt everything about us. The truth is that civil society is more robust than you give it credit for.

We are talking about treatment of prisoners.
How we fought then or fight now is irrelevant.
No fighting. Fighting is done at this point.
Forget the fighting.
Not one more word about fighting.
Don't make me come back there.
 
By the Geneva conventions essentially all "insurgent" saboteurs, assassins etc. are subject to summary execution. I propose that to satisfy your criteria we give them an opportunity to talk, and if their information is actionable, then they will not be executed by next week.
Works for me. Just don't torture them.

You get that from the horses mouth, no doubt? Lucky thing that Shin Bet doesn't have to contend with the Washington Post or the NYT. They sure would have had fun with all the assassinations they've carried out.:rolleyes:
No, I saw a news program where they interviewed a former CIA case officer who had 20+ years' experience running espionage operations in the Middle East. He claimed to have watched scores of prisoners tortured by various governments, and stated that the primary product, very nearly the sole product, of such interrogation techniques was false leads. He stated that he had not seen prisoners tortured by Shin Bet, and that when he asked why they told him, "Because it doesn't work."

It doesn't work!! Really? Wouldn't work on you I suppose? Well I'm supposed to be playing the tough guy here, but I suspect it would work on me.
That's not the problem. The problem is, people make **** up to make the pain stop. Like KSM claiming to have been involved with the Pearl kidnapping, which it was later shown he could not have had anything to do with. You'll notice the administration made a big deal about how KSM was involved with that, but you never heard about it after they found out he'd made it up.

:shrug: I haven't read it.
Somehow that doesn't surprise me. Here you go. You can find copies of this manual all over the 'Net; it was released under FOIA. It's public domain. Here's an important quote from the relevant section, titled simply "Pain:"

"Interrogatees who are withholding but who feel qualms of guilt and a secret desire to yield are likely to become intractable if made to endure pain. The reason is that they can then interpret the pain as punishment and hence as expiation. There are also persons who enjoy pain and its anticipation and who will keep back information that they might otherwise divulge if they are given reason to expect that withholding will result in the punishment that they want. Persons of considerable moral or intellectual stature often find in pain inflicted by others a confirmation of the belief that they are in the hands of inferiors, and their resolve not to submit is strengthened.

Intense pain is quite likely to produce false confessions, concocted as a means of escaping from distress. A time-consuming delay results, while investigation is conducted and the admissions are proven untrue. During this respite the interrogatee can pull himself together. He may even use the time to think up new, more complex "admissions" that take still longer to disprove. KUBARK is especially vulnerable to such tactics because the interrogation is conducted for the sake of information and not for police purposes.

If an interrogatee is caused to suffer pain rather late in the interrogation process and after other tactics have failed, he is almost certain to conclude that the interrogator is becoming desperate. He may then decide that if he can just hold out against this final assault, he will win the struggle and his freedom. And he is likely to be right. Interrogatees who have withstood pain are more difficult to handle by other methods. The effect has been not to repress the subject but to restore his confidence and maturity."

Note that a primary goal of interrogation is to induce the subject to regress, and place judgment of right and wrong in the hands of the interrogator. Proper interrogation is a psychological process. The subject is induced to seek approval from the interrogator. Most criminals under police interrogation, contrary to TV shows, wind up revealing what they have done, sometimes inadvertently, sometimes not; and the methods used there are primarily if not exclusively psychological ones. The most effective interrogation technique is to "turn" the subject, convincing him that the interrogator could be convinced to be on his side and that he might be able to achieve the interrogator's approval if he can just convince him. This technique, and similar ones that use winning the subject's confidence, cannot be employed after torture has been used. These techniques have been proven over and over again to be the most effective available.

I will repeat, this has been known since the early 1960s. Only those who are incompetent at interrogation, because they have not been properly trained, can fail to know it. Torture is the refuge of the incompetent interrogator.

Obviously "torture" isn't going to produce non existing information, but if you know what you want to know, if you know what is likely known, if you know how to cross check it (say via someone else being interrogated) then some pressure points can elicit responses from most humans. Perhaps not from the most dedicated fanatic, or patriot for that matter, but certainly from most.
OK, so tell me this: why were the people who started the interrogation not people who had intelligence regarding KSM's activities prior to his capture? Such people were not brought in until 48 hours afterward.

Can you say "bungle?" I knew you could.

This is rank incompetence, nothing more. And it's at least partly driven by the desire for revenge. Comments by others on this thread make that clear.

Do you know the reason why physically coercive interrogation techniques are forbidden to law enforcement personnel? It is a very pragmatic one. A court of law is primarily about finding out the truth. The jury is empaneled to determine to the best of their ability what exactly happened. If a suspect has been subjected to physically coercive interrogation, there is no guarantee of the truth of any confession or other information obtained. It's just that simple, and just that pragmatic. It has nothing to do with morals or ethics.

Think about it.
 
First ask yourself if nation 2 was being vile while not in a state of war. Then ask if nation 1 was also. Then ask if you see no moral difference between the two, culturally and politically speaking.
What happened before is irrelevant to the immediate example. The point remains: you cannot claim to be the morally superior side in a fight by adopting tactics and actions which, if committed by anyone else, would be condemned.

A question: would you be fine with captured American personnel being subjected to the exact same interrogation techniques being applied to terror suspects? Yes or no.

We won WWII by being much more brutal than how we fight today, but it did not corrupt everything about us.
Much of that has to do with the technology available at the time. There were no GPS-guided bombs; if you wanted to put a factory out of action, you pretty much had to flatten everything within blocks and blocks of it in order to be sure you hit the factory.

The Third Reich had the Gestapo and S.S. to interrogate prisoners, and did so brutally; does that mean it was therefore acceptable for the U.S. to have used the same Gestapo/S.S. techniques on German prisoners?

As to all those who claim to fear too much toughness will corrupt our entire morality...
Toughness is not the issue. Using tactics and techniques which betray the very notions which one purports to be upholding is.

If you want to use such tactics and techniques, fine, but don't claim to be upholding the broader notions of freedom, justice, and democracy while doing so. Decribe the fight in purely dark and pragmatic terms and leave it at that.
 
Feel free to cite scientific evidence that supports this claim.

So you think you wouldn't talk if you didn't feel like it. Good for you toughie. The point is that taken to excess interrogation will generate fictitious information, not that it won't generate any. If you seriously think most people won't start talking under harsh circumstance you must be from another planet.
 
Elind in post 155:


We are talking about treatment of prisoners.
How we fought then or fight now is irrelevant.
No fighting. Fighting is done at this point.
Forget the fighting.
Not one more word about fighting.
Don't make me come back there.

We are talking of how our enemy is treated in general. With few exceptions our prisoners now are treated better than those we have in maximum security prisons at home.

There is no fighting now? Could have fooled me.

Please don't come back if you are so touchy. No offense taken here.
 
I will repeat, this has been known since the early 1960s. Only those who are incompetent at interrogation, because they have not been properly trained, can fail to know it. Torture is the refuge of the incompetent interrogator.


It has been known since 1631 when Friedrich von Spee published his Cautio Criminalis. It's really worrying that these findings are denied by people in the year 2007.

btw, the innocently kidnapped and tortured German skeptigirl was talking about earlier is NOW dangerous to himself and society - a broken man:

wikipedia said:
On May 17, 2007, El-Masri was arrested on suspicion of arson. According to Die Welt Online (in German) the problem arose over a dispute over an iPod that El-Masri had bought at a METRO warehouse club store back in April in the city of Neu-Ulm. He claimed the iPod malfunctioned just hours after purchase. When he tried to return it, the store refused, and the situation escalated into a shouting match. El-Masri spit in the face of a female employee, and was barred from the store.

On May 17th, El-Masri kicked in a door of the Metro store and used gasoline to start a fire. The fire caused over €500,000 ($678,000) in damages. Nobody was hurt. El-Masri was arrested near the scene of the crime. After arrest, a judge ordered him held in a psychiatric hospital for unknown reasons. On May 18, El-Masri's attorney, Manfred Gnjidic, conceded his client did burn down the store, but blamed it on his client's torture experiences and claimed that the German government did not provide enough therapy to him after his return from Afghanistan.

German Prosecutors in the arson case also revealed that El-Masri faced charges for allegedly attacking a truck driving instructor. They said Masri lost his temper after the instructor criticised him for failing to attend his lessons.
 
What happened before is irrelevant to the immediate example. The point remains: you cannot claim to be the morally superior side in a fight by adopting tactics and actions which, if committed by anyone else, would be condemned.

It's not irrelevant because you say we lose our morality if we fight to win in certain ways (and that includes aall actions taken), while you simultaneously seem to think it is possible to fight war the way police deal with criminals in a civilian society. As to what is condemnable; that depends on who is condemning and who is telling the story. Obviously we don't do certain things that our enemy does, I presume you agree with that, but I don't think torture is what some would call unpleasant or frightening in such circumstances and I think that if one is not prepared to do some things that one wouldn't do outside of war, then I don't think one has the will to win, and probably won't.
question: would you be fine with captured American personnel being subjected to the exact same interrogation techniques being applied to terror suspects? Yes or no.

It's a rhetorical question to me. We all know that they do much worse. Our military people are trained to deal with interrogation and it is expected, if not worse, although in this war there is little advantage the enemy can gain from that, whereas we can potentially gain much more. What they do, kill and maim, or maim and kill, is not comparable to what we do and what we do certainly has no effect on reciprocity from them, as it might have had in the case of wars between nations.


There were no GPS-guided bombs; if you wanted to put a factory out of action, you pretty much had to flatten everything within blocks and blocks of it in order to be sure you hit the factory. Much of that has to do with the technology available at the time.

Sorry, the worst we did then was try to destroy the people who worked in the factories, as their homes were easier to find than the factories. In any case many still argue that we should have risked much more death on our side than do that. Of course those people are another generation or two removed and can afford armchair theories.

The Third Reich had the Gestapo and S.S. to interrogate prisoners, and did so brutally; does that mean it was therefore acceptable for the U.S. to have used the same Gestapo/S.S. techniques on German prisoners?

They had some, although not all were treated like that, but there is a difference here that you miss every time we exchange. Namely that the Gestapo were already much different from the allies even before they had anyone to interrogate. They were goons who did it for pleasure as much as anything, just like the Islamists are, and their attitude was fully institutionalized. You seem to think doing anything that isn't nice is a formula for turning into Nazis. I disagree.



Toughness is not the issue. Using tactics and techniques which betray the very notions which one purports to be upholding is.

But I think that much of what you imply is such tactics, is not, and one is not simply fighting to uphold something. One is actually fighting to win, so that one can actually be in a position to uphold something.

If you want to use such tactics and techniques, fine, but don't claim to be upholding the broader notions of freedom, justice, and democracy while doing so. Decribe the fight in purely dark and pragmatic terms and leave it at that.

That's kind of what I thought I was doing. I'm sorry if it goes against some romantic ideal out there.

A world that we win in will be better than a world that they win in, for many fundamental reasons, in spite of how tough we are in fighting for it. This is one reason we have a military, to do what the rest of us are not prepared to do, and it's also a reason we have all the checks and balances that make it very difficult for those people who do our dirty work for us to do the same at home.
 
To Elind - reply to Post 168:

Now you've done it. No ice cream for you.

Prisoners are not fighting.
The fighting is done by soldiers, usually far from the prisoners.
The interrogator safely back at the detention center waterboarding a suspect is not doing any fighting.

However, the interrogater safely back at the detention center waterboarding a suspect is doing quite a bit to advance the cause of the other side. Thanks a lot.
 
You've got to wonder what these sort of anti-freedom and anti-law people on "our side" want to "fight" for, since they don't actually have any respect for the values of our civilization. Why would someone support illegal detention and illegal treatment of prisoners, unless they actually hate our laws and our way of life?
 
It has been known since 1631 when Friedrich von Spee published his Cautio Criminalis. It's really worrying that these findings are denied by people in the year 2007.
Nice to see there are still people who seriously know history around. You can't deny, however, that there is a certain degree of irony in quoting the CIA interrogation manual when discussing a botched CIA interrogation. Your point that it's been known since the seventeenth century is worth making, so thanks.

btw, the innocently kidnapped and tortured German skeptigirl was talking about earlier is NOW dangerous to himself and society - a broken man:
Very salient point, and another reason that judicial oversight is a requirement for such procedures. And again, morality and ethics aside, unless one considers the ethics of turning an individual with these symptoms loose in a civil society.

And to top it all off, yet another example of rank incompetence.
 
OK, Elind, given it doesn't work, and given that mistakes get made and society and the individual who was tortured get to pay rather than the incompetent interrogators, what precisely was the justification for this again?
 
Some of "you" think that feeling good about yourself is more important than winning and that is all you focus on, implying you already had little to feel good about.

The second mistake you make is thinking that being harsh with your enemies always amounts to torture.
Your first mistake is assuming the biggest guns always win and that winning over the population doesn't matter.

We had big guns in Vietnam. The NeoCon revisionists have fantasized that constraints on the military prevented winning the war. They have forgotten that in order to kill an enemy you have to know who the enemy is. We couldn't kill the enemy in Vietnam because we couldn't tell the good guys from the bad guys and the way we went about killing just turned more and more 'good guys' into 'bad guys'.

Russia could not win in Afghanistan and neither will we if we don't do something to make us more attractive to the people there than the Taliban and al Qaeda. We aren't doing that and the consequences are revealing.

And we can't win in Iraq by simply being the biggest guy on the block. Humans are adaptive little critters. If you have a bigger gun, I'll plant a roadside bomb when you aren't looking.

Your second mistake is assuming the supposed rough treatment isn't torture in this case, because the evidence says it is and Bush et al is downplaying it.

Your third mistake is assuming we are getting all this useful information by torturing people. Very few military experts agree (see my links above and/or do your own search for evidence). I cited quite a few experts from the military, Elind, not those armchair soldier draft dodgers which are currently running the show and their right wing draft dodging counterparts in the media who are cheering them on.
 
Considering there's been an almost constant daily stream of "leaks" I don't think they are too good at controlling info.
No, they aren't stopping the information from getting out. If you read what I said more carefully you'll see I said the information is out there but the administration is doing a good job of stopping it from snowballing. At least they were until their bad decisions just became too overwhelming to stifle.
 
Works for me. Just don't torture them.

Love it when someone agrees, given it's so rare:cool:

That's not the problem. The problem is, people make **** up to make the pain stop.

I agree. The distinction however is between "torture" (the definition being debatable) to gain confession and "torture" to gain information, not to mention how smart the interrogators are. My personal opinion is that it is tolerable when information may be new and actionable. After a time it is probably pointless.

Like KSM claiming to have been involved with the Pearl kidnapping, which it was later shown he could not have had anything to do with. You'll notice the administration made a big deal about how KSM was involved with that, but you never heard about it after they found out he'd made it up.

Bungles galore this administration has made, but that alone doesn't address the issue.

Somehow that doesn't surprise me. Here you go. You can find copies of this manual all over the 'Net; it was released under FOIA. It's public domain. Here's an important quote from the relevant section, titled simply "Pain:"

See, you haven't been listening to me, although I may not have been terribly clear. I don't believe in inflicting pain, as in nerve pain, either. Emotional pain, nervous pain, hunger pain perhaps, disorientation pain, fear of pain; but no rack, no scalpels no drills no needles.

My issue in these arguments is that putting someone in a blindfold is considered torture by some. Perhaps not you?

I will repeat, this has been known since the early 1960s. Only those who are incompetent at interrogation, because they have not been properly trained, can fail to know it. Torture is the refuge of the incompetent interrogator.

I take what you said above, snipped, at face value. You will note that I have always tried to talk of harsh or( devious) INTERROGATION, not inflicting pain as described. Some techniques might be borderline in that area, but my position is that you don't throw out all options in a time of war because some could be seen as such, and you certainly don't do so because of the naive opinion that this "would make us as bad as them".


OK, so tell me this: why were the people who started the interrogation not people who had intelligence regarding KSM's activities prior to his capture? Such people were not brought in until 48 hours afterward.

Can you say "bungle?" I knew you could.

I can say that many times, and have done so; in case you are tempted to think I'm a fan of Bush & Co.

This is rank incompetence, nothing more. And it's at least partly driven by the desire for revenge. Comments by others on this thread make that clear.

Revenge has no place in this beyond what is implied in locking them up, I agree. I don't agree that all that is called torture qualifies as such, and as much as I don't like anything I hear Bush say, I'm not going to make this a partisan issue, which I think many do.



Do you know the reason why physically coercive interrogation techniques are forbidden to law enforcement personnel? It is a very pragmatic one. A court of law is primarily about finding out the truth. The jury is empaneled to determine to the best of their ability what exactly happened. If a suspect has been subjected to physically coercive interrogation, there is no guarantee of the truth of any confession or other information obtained. It's just that simple, and just that pragmatic. It has nothing to do with morals or ethics.

Think about it.

I agree, except that too many seem to think that applies in spades during war. If you want to give yourself the luxury of dealing with every enemy combatant as you would a gang member, say, at home, then you can never win a war.
 
I rather think that actually shows how effective they have become. Whatever leaks, it doesnt seem to create any major stir. Its like braking wind in a discrete way, rather than holding in and then releasing in one dramatic brump. Everybody can smell it, but no one can prove who did it.
Right idea, not quite the right metaphor.

It's more like Kevin Trudeau out there selling yet another scam. He's been convicted of fraud, banned from selling another scam on the infomercials yet there he is on the air still, and there are yet more people who continue to believe.

"We just need to give the 'surge' time to work."
 
You can't deny, however, that there is a certain degree of irony in quoting the CIA interrogation manual when discussing a botched CIA interrogation.


Indeed. Even more ironic - and tragically absurd - is to point out that the values "the west" can be really proud of, and fought for in centuries of bloody history, are exactly the same values people want to throw over board now to fight "them". It could be seen as frightening, but fear seems to be THE driving force behind this madness so i decide to not be frightened but only disgusted.
 
Here we go again. One persons torture is another persons interrogation without saying please.
Only in Bush speak. Some of us are not as easily fooled by the tactics of manipulating thought.

Always this discussion seems to be with those who think the enemy should be treated with kids gloves, so they can feel good about themselves.
This is your attempt to fight a straw opponent. No one here is using this argument.

Sadistic gratification is entirely different from harsh interrogation. The former is what our enemy does with pride, the latter is what we need to do to win, and the two are not the same thing at all.
Here you are trying to make the case that we are "moral", we only torture for information. They are "immoral", they torture for pleasure. Why do you care what other people think of your morals?

The bottom line is that a brutal primitive enemy laughs at the agonizers about torture. They will gladly give up to fight another day when they know there are kind people in the West who will protect them from harsh treatment. They should instead fear us, and that can be achieved without maiming or cutting off heads.
Like I said, humans are adaptive little critters. We drop mother of all bomb bombs, they make videos of beheadings. Who fears whom?

As to the armchair experts who think "torture" (read harsh interrogation) doesn't get answers; that's rubbish. The only question is whether it is done in a manner that obtains independently verifiable information, not simply unverifiable confessions for the satisfaction of "sadists" like you seem to think all military people are prone to be.
All talk, no research cited, no experts cited, no evidence cited. And those armchair soldiers I cited were sitting in top positions in military interrogation units, not in the civilian military leader armchairs like those Bush and Cheney sit in.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom