Torture memo...OMG

Some of "you" think that feeling good about yourself is more important than winning and that is all you focus on, implying you already had little to feel good about.

The second mistake you make is thinking that being harsh with your enemies always amounts to torture.
congratulations on the use of "being harsh", you win the award for the latest limp substitute for that "T" word that you are unable to face.
 
How is mistreatment different from torture? Can you please be specific?

DR

Mistreatment and torture differ only in degree. Trying to find a difference between them is arbitrary and a waste of time. Abuse of prisoners violates the spirit and the intent of our laws. The current administration seems bent on playing rhetoric games trying to find loopholes.

Non-mistreatment includes securing the prisoners in a cell or a yard, feeding them, housing them, keeping them out of mischief, and thats about it.

Whacking prisoners in the head, waterboarding, handcuffing naked, sleep deprivation, generally causing misery - these are abuse. Whether this is called mistreatment or torture or marklar makes no god damn difference.
 
This is your pov, based on your "moral compass" it is no more (or less) right than anyone elses really, but it is yours, and you are entitled. I think the issue is more complex for many people.

TAM:)

Maybe so. I don't think is has to be.
But I have been called 'simple' more than once.
 
The first problem with that often stated "law of the universe of the morally superior", is that the only implied difference between the two parties is how they conduct themselves in war, not in peace.

The second problem is that these morally superior beings, like you of course, are more concerned with playing by certain civilian rules than actually fighting, which is a pretty good predictor of how to eventually lose, while feeling good about it.

You seem to have little actual faith in your (or your culture's) moral superiority since all you are concerned with is how people might perceive your moral superiority, particularly how your enemies perceive it. Did it ever occur to you that they already made that decision long before the fighting started?

Fighting is not at issue here. Winning or losing are not the issue here. We are talking about treatment of prisoners. The fighting is over, we won.
The prisoners are rounded up and disarmed and confined. The war for them is over.
This is where you demonstrate your morality - demonstrating it to our country, our citizens, our laws. What our 'enemies' perceive is irrelevant. You would be crazy to give a rats red patootie our 'enemies' perceptions.
 
Last edited:
Some of "you" think that feeling good about yourself is more important than winning and that is all you focus on, implying you already had little to feel good about.

The second mistake you make is thinking that being harsh with your enemies always amounts to torture.

1 - untrue.
2 - untrue also.
3 - pthbbb
 
I'm not claiming it gets good information.
Then what's the point? To punish someone who hasn't even been proven guilty, and who can now get off on a technicality because they were subjected to illegal treatment while in custody?

You know, I'm not a religious man, as a matter of fact, I'm an atheist, but sometimes those guys who wrote the Old Testament got it right: the wages of sin is death.
 
If you have any constructive ideas, let's hear them.
I have one; you and I may disagree elsewhere, but apparently we agree here. How's this grab you: extend the statute of limitations on violations of the Geneva Conventions to ten years. Or even fifteen.
 
Some of "you" think that feeling good about yourself is more important than winning and that is all you focus on, implying you already had little to feel good about.
No, some of us think that because people are corruptible, no person should have the power to impose torture, or for that matter to impose any punishment whatsoever without due process of law. I'd say the current administration is proof enough of that, if Torquemada, Hitler, and Stalin weren't proof enough to go on with. I think that's more important than "winning" a third-world dustup against a country that never posed a realistic threat to us, however "winning" has been redefined this week.

The second mistake you make is thinking that being harsh with your enemies always amounts to torture.
Maltreatment of persons in custody is against the laws of the United States, always has been. We won't even talk about the Geneva Conventions, which, by signing up for them, we have made our law as well.

To top it all off, Shin Bet, one of the most feared security services in the world, and one that has little if any restraint on their actions, does not torture people. They could if they wanted to; they don't. It's not effective. It doesn't work.

The CIA knew that in 1961. It's in the interrogation manual from that era. It wasn't ideological; pure pragmatism, nothing more. That manual, and the reports it was no doubt based upon, was written at the behest of John Fitzgerald Kennedy. And if you think he didn't have the advice of an entity that has more experience with physical coercion and interrogation, and has had a longer time to digest said experience, than just about any other you could name, you better think again.
 
The CIA knew that in 1961. It's in the interrogation manual from that era. It wasn't ideological; pure pragmatism, nothing more. That manual, and the reports it was no doubt based upon, was written at the behest of John Fitzgerald Kennedy. And if you think he didn't have the advice of an entity that has more experience with physical coercion and interrogation, and has had a longer time to digest said experience, than just about any other you could name, you better think again.

Exactly. Torture is NOT about "getting information."
What it is really used for is
A) Demoralizing the enemy, and
B) Letting soldiers vent some steam.

For that, it is very effective.
 
Exactly. Torture is NOT about "getting information."
What it is really used for is
A) Demoralizing the enemy, and
B) Letting soldiers vent some steam.

For that, it is very effective.
Listen, I'll be real frank. If some guy gets a little beat up while being captured, that's fine. Bummer. Happens too often, or it was just a routine pickup of someone unarmed, maybe an officer or noncom needs to step in and point out to the boys that they sure do seem to bring in a lot of guys who have the **** beat out of them. A wink is as good as a nod, and anybody who's been around a bit knows how to handle that. The boys will calm down a bit, talk it over, and the next one won't have quite so many corners knocked off.

That's not what we're talking about. We're talking about someone who's in custody being taken away for interrogation by some other party or parties, and being, not just beat up, but actually tortured, for real, not a beating but actual deliberate imposition of pain using clinical methods. So while I'll admit point A, I won't admit point B. And point A is not just the boys working out some steam; the people who do stuff for reasons like point A aren't good people.

They're not us, or at least I used to think so. And it troubles me greatly, in fact it makes me mad as ****, that anyone would engage in that, and then pretend it was to protect me. I don't need protection like that. I don't want protection like that. I'm not on the side of anyone who thinks that's appropriate, no matter the circumstances. And trying to justify it by claiming it's effective is insulting to my intelligence. I want it to stop, now only, and if I had my way, the people who did it would be prosecuted for it. Pour encourage les autres. You following what I'm saying here?
 
Some of "you" think that feeling good about yourself is more important than winning and that is all you focus on, implying you already had little to feel good about.

That's like me saying you would rather loose while looking tough than use methods that work.

Torture is a bad way of gaining information. I cite the links provided earlier.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A2302-2005Jan11.html

Just for a moment, let's pretend that there is no moral, legal or constitutional problem with torture. Let's also imagine a clear-cut case: a terrorist who knows where bombs are about to explode in Iraq. To stop him, it seems that a wide range of Americans would be prepared to endorse "cruel and unusual" methods.

[...] these arguments rest on an assumption: that torture -- defined as physical pressure during interrogation -- can be used to extract useful information.

[...] An up-to-date illustration of the colonel's point appeared in recently released FBI documents from the naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. These show, among other things, that some military intelligence officers wanted to use harsher interrogation methods than the FBI did. As a result, complained one inspector, "every time the FBI established a rapport with a detainee, the military would step in and the detainee would stop being cooperative." So much for the utility of torture.

Prove your side of the argument.
Does torture work? Or does it, as the experts claim, get bad infomation? Is it worth the costs?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/01/15/AR2007011501204.html?nav=rss_world

http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0212/p99s01-duts.html
 
Exactly. Torture is NOT about "getting information."
What it is really used for is
A) Demoralizing the enemy, and
B) Letting soldiers vent some steam.

For that, it is very effective.
Really? Then why do studies show that enemies are more likely to surrender to opponents that wouldn't torture them, and would actually treat them like human beings?

But don't let that get in the way of "venting steam"... :rolleyes:

If you want to turn enemies more and more against you, then the answer is to treat them like ****. Torture them, hurt them, kill them, treat them like they're beneath human dignity. Everything demonstrates that this turns the enemy more and more against you, and makes them less and less likely to surrender. Thus, torturing opponents doesn't help your cause, it only hurts it.
 
Last edited:
I thought this thread was about how to treat alleged "bad" guys who are in custody, not about combat in the field. In fact, I'm sure it is. Why are you veering off topic? Torture is not fighting, it's sadistic gratification and nothing more.

Here we go again. One persons torture is another persons interrogation without saying please.

Always this discussion seems to be with those who think the enemy should be treated with kids gloves, so they can feel good about themselves.

Sadistic gratification is entirely different from harsh interrogation. The former is what our enemy does with pride, the latter is what we need to do to win, and the two are not the same thing at all.

The bottom line is that a brutal primitive enemy laughs at the agonizers about torture. They will gladly give up to fight another day when they know there are kind people in the West who will protect them from harsh treatment. They should instead fear us, and that can be achieved without maiming or cutting off heads.

As to the armchair experts who think "torture" (read harsh interrogation) doesn't get answers; that's rubbish. The only question is whether it is done in a manner that obtains independently verifiable information, not simply unverifiable confessions for the satisfaction of "sadists" like you seem to think all military people are prone to be.
 
Here we go again. One persons torture is another persons interrogation without saying please.

Always this discussion seems to be with those who think the enemy should be treated with kids gloves, so they can feel good about themselves.

Sadistic gratification is entirely different from harsh interrogation. The former is what our enemy does with pride, the latter is what we need to do to win, and the two are not the same thing at all.

The bottom line is that a brutal primitive enemy laughs at the agonizers about torture. They will gladly give up to fight another day when they know there are kind people in the West who will protect them from harsh treatment. They should instead fear us, and that can be achieved without maiming or cutting off heads.

As to the armchair experts who think "torture" (read harsh interrogation) doesn't get answers; that's rubbish. The only question is whether it is done in a manner that obtains independently verifiable information, not simply unverifiable confessions for the satisfaction of "sadists" like you seem to think all military people are prone to be.
You just ignore the things people post, and reality in general, and make up strawmen to attack instead, while parroting phony "tuff-guy" nonsense that the chickenhawks always spout.
 
My personal feelings on what constitutes morally correct actions is entirely irrelevant to the point I was making. Let me try phrasing it in a different way via hypothetical example.

Nation 1 and nation 2 are in conflict. Nation 1 says nation 2 must be fought because it perpetrates actions A, B, and C. Such actions are reprehensible, vile, evil, against freedom, insert moral argument and terminology of your choice.

But what if it turns out nation 1 is also perpetrating action C?

Nation 1 has framed the fight in moral terms by labelling the actions of the other side as being morally wrong. But how can it claim such moral high ground if it itself is also engaging in one of the vile actions? How can the same action be morally acceptable if done by own's own side and morally unacceptable if done by the other side? That would seem to me to be sheer hypocrisy.

Does that make more clear the larger philosophical point I was getting at?

It makes your point just about as clear as the first time you made it, and obviously my point came across as clear as mud.

First ask yourself if nation 2 was being vile while not in a state of war. Then ask if nation 1 was also. Then ask if you see no moral difference between the two, culturally and politically speaking.

As to when they go to war, if they are not the same then they will not behave, within individual human limitations, in the same way because they don't think the same way; but war is not civil and it must be fought to win, and it can be fought to win without becoming like the other.

We won WWII by being much more brutal than how we fight today, but it did not corrupt everything about us. The truth is that civil society is more robust than you give it credit for.

As to all those who claim to fear too much toughness will corrupt our entire morality, I also see much of that posturing as simple partisan politics. Hypocritical in other words, when it is not simple naivety.
 
You just ignore the things people post, and reality in general, and make up strawmen to attack instead, while parroting phony "tuff-guy" nonsense that the chickenhawks always spout.


You do seem to be degenerating into just personal insults, rather than addressing anything, but be my guest.

Clearly there is a difference of perspective at work here, which to some minds translates into "ignoring the things people post" rather than what it is....
 
That's like me saying you would rather loose while looking tough than use methods that work.

Torture is a bad way of gaining information. I cite the links provided earlier.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A2302-2005Jan11.html



Prove your side of the argument.
Does torture work? Or does it, as the experts claim, get bad infomation? Is it worth the costs?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/01/15/AR2007011501204.html?nav=rss_world

http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0212/p99s01-duts.html

First, I'm sorry but I don't take the Washington Post as an authority on anything except partisan politics anymore.

There's an expert for everything and every opinion and there is no doubt that individual humans without external rules can make up their own rules and can do so for the hell of it rather than any other reason, but that doesn't mean it makes sense to try to sanitize reality.

If information can be verified it is good information and if you think that anecdotes about all of these fundies clamming up regardless of what is done to them are true, then I can't persuade you otherwise, but my experience of life tells me that most people aren't like that.

One thing that is appreciated, and felt, by most humans is fear. There would be far less need for "torture" (as I don't call it) if captives were afraid from the first moment they were captured, rightly or wrongly. However thanks to many people they know they have little to fear. When I lived in Arab countries many years ago, I always thought it amusing how criminals (before OBL times) that one read about being arrested always immediately took the police to their accomplices or their loot. Fear is a powerful tool when properly used.
 
Maltreatment of persons in custody is against the laws of the United States, always has been. We won't even talk about the Geneva Conventions, which, by signing up for them, we have made our law as well.

By the Geneva conventions essentially all "insurgent" saboteurs, assassins etc. are subject to summary execution. I propose that to satisfy your criteria we give them an opportunity to talk, and if their information is actionable, then they will not be executed by next week.

To top it all off, Shin Bet, one of the most feared security services in the world, and one that has little if any restraint on their actions, does not torture people. They could if they wanted to; they don't. It's not effective. It doesn't work.

You get that from the horses mouth, no doubt? Lucky thing that Shin Bet doesn't have to contend with the Washington Post or the NYT. They sure would have had fun with all the assassinations they've carried out.:rolleyes:

It doesn't work!! Really? Wouldn't work on you I suppose? Well I'm supposed to be playing the tough guy here, but I suspect it would work on me.


The CIA knew that in 1961. It's in the interrogation manual from that era. It wasn't ideological; pure pragmatism, nothing more. That manual, and the reports it was no doubt based upon, was written at the behest of John Fitzgerald Kennedy. And if you think he didn't have the advice of an entity that has more experience with physical coercion and interrogation, and has had a longer time to digest said experience, than just about any other you could name, you better think again.

:shrug: I haven't read it. Obviously "torture" isn't going to produce non existing information, but if you know what you want to know, if you know what is likely known, if you know how to cross check it (say via someone else being interrogated) then some pressure points can elicit responses from most humans. Perhaps not from the most dedicated fanatic, or patriot for that matter, but certainly from most.
 
Actions analogous to whatever would prompt you to say we shouldn't "brag" about checks and balances. When you define those things better, I will define "undesirable" better.

If you know what would prompt me to say "brag", then you don't have to ask me to define it better. In which case, you can answer what you meant by "undesirable".

There. I have answered your questions.

No, you haven't. What did you mean by "undesirable"?

1. Why did you introduce "illegal" in comparison to my "undesirable" when "illegal" wasn't in the post to which I was responding?

You introduced "undesirable" before I introduced "illegal".

2. Is genocide illegal?

According to the United Nations Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, it is.

3. Is your issue one of definitions and not of efficacy?

I have no idea what you mean.

4. Would you have a problem if I amend my analogy to all Danish laws needing to be abolished because crimes still occur? Can I insist Danish laws not be held up as a good example of a legal system?

Who has talked about abolishing all laws?

Start with a blank slate. What would a hypothetical system that accomplishes that look like?

Like a system where the decision to throw the world into a nuclear holocaust was not placed on such few people.

This administration learned from Nixon's mistakes and I believe that is part of the problem why we are not seeing the public outraged and screaming "Impeach them". This administration is controlling information in a much tighter way. The truth comes out but they are very good at stopping it from snowballing.

However, that only goes so far. Everything is falling apart for these guys now. There isn't enough lipstick to put on all the pigs that they've made. But since the Democrats expect to win the Presidency in 2008 and probably expand their lead in the Senate and Congress, I think a number of them are afraid (they shouldn't be but they are) that if they undertake a harsher attack against Bush it could backfire.

That still doesn't solve the problem of too much power in one person.
 
As to the armchair experts who think "torture" (read harsh interrogation) doesn't get answers; that's rubbish.

Feel free to cite scientific evidence that supports this claim.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom