There is No God (And You Know It)

Maybe my logic is flawed, I'm sure you'll point out that it is. But is it possible for god to maximize the 'goodness' in the world without showing any evidence of it?

I've always found very suspicious that God made this world to function exactly like one that would have come into existence without his help. That, in and of itself, raises questions as to his existence.
 
I've always found very suspicious that God made this world to function exactly like one that would have come into existence without his help.

Somewhat ironically, theists often use the existance of the world as evidence of the existance of God. The argument goes that the universe never would have come into existance without something causing the big bang.

Another angle on your comment that the world would be exactly the same without God is that perhaps God doesn't want us to know of his existance. It would therefore make sense that he would create a world that would seem to be the same without God as with God.

That, in and of itself, raises questions as to his existence.

Indeed.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I just doubt that there is anyone out there who, if he or she had absolute power at his disposal, wouldn't remove some of the suffering in the world. I doubt they would think "Oh, but that suffering is there for a reason..."

There is no way for us to know if suffering is there for a reason. Many theists point out that God may consider free will more important than eliminating all suffering. In other words, in order to have free will, there also has to be the possibility of suffering.

Suffering might be necessary for humans to exercise free will for two possible reasons. First, suffering is necessary if there is free will because humans can choose to cause suffering by exercise of their free will. Second, it is possible that if the world were perfect, nobody would have any reason to exercise free will.

If God's purpose is for humans to choose good over bad, then both of these explanations are valid. Of course, they don't prove that God exists, but they do demonstrate that there could still be suffering in the world if an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God exists.

-Bri
 
Yes, I've heard the "utilitarian argument" before, that God allows suffering because by preventing it, he will only be inadvertently causing a greater amount of it in the future. But then one has to question how paradises separate from the material world described in many of the holy texts of the major religions such as Heaven can exist. God doesn't allow suffering in Heaven, and still, no unintentional suffering is produced there.

Free will could also be an answer to your question concerning heaven. Is there a reference that states that free will exists in heaven? Even though there is no suffering in heaven, there is presumably no exercise of free will since everyone gets what they want without having to toil for it. If God's purpose of creating the world is for humans to choose good over bad, then heaven wouldn't meet that criteria.

-Bri
 
Another angle on your comment that the world would be exactly the same without God is that perhaps God doesn't want us to know of his existance. It would therefore make sense that he would create a world that would seem to be the same without God as with God.

I agree, but that would make every religion false, because they all claim that God demands obediance.
 
I agree, but that would make every religion false, because they all claim that God demands obediance.

How so?

That God left us clues of how he wants humans to behave is in no way proof of his existance, as I'm sure you will agree.

That some religions claim that God demands obediance doesn't make them false if, in fact, God does demand obediance.

-Bri
 
There is no way for us to know if suffering is there for a reason. Many theists point out that God may consider free will more important than eliminating all suffering. In other words, in order to have free will, there also has to be the possibility of suffering.

Not necessarily. I can imagine a world where we have free will but only between a limited number of "moral states". In other words, we can chose to do what we want, but harming others would be impossible.

As a small aside, since God is supposedly omniscient, he already knows what will happen in advance, making the issue of free will moot, as the christian universe must be deterministic.
 
Not necessarily. I can imagine a world where we have free will but only between a limited number of "moral states". In other words, we can chose to do what we want, but harming others would be impossible.

Perhaps God's purpose is for us to exercise our free will to choose good over bad. To have choices between good and good wouldn't meet this criteria.

-Bri
 
If God doesn't want us to know he exists it makes little sense to demand obedience. Would you obey a non-existent entity ?

You can believe that God exists without knowing that God exists. That's what faith is all about.

-Bri
 
As Jesus stated, "So you do good to those that do good to you? Big deal, anybody can do that."
"Anyone can follow good sense, but only a true believer acts in ways grossly against their own best interests. Wanna prove you're a believer? Do something dumb - it'll show the power of faith!"
 
Perhaps God's purpose is for us to exercise our free will to choose good over bad. To have choices between good and good wouldn't meet this criteria.

If he choses to make himself unknown to us, we have no moral compass to determine what is objectively "good" or "bad", making the reward system of heaven completely arbitrary.
 
You can believe that God exists without knowing that God exists. That's what faith is all about.

Why would an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God expect reasonable people to chose to believe in something that seems illogical and supernatural ? Why would he reward these guys, anyway ?
 
IThe fact that c4ts is using unsound logic in an attempt to prove that something that is a subset of another thing must be equal to that thing notwithstanding,

Huh? I think you're reading too far into my question. If I were trying to prove something I would have said so, or at least waited until I had what I needed to support it. Or I would have followed it up with an actual argument. I responded to what I thought was an interesting statement, so I looked for a connection, or lack of connections, between the physically possible and logically possible. I had thought the two were related, somehow, but I can't tell you why. Dare I ask what is logically possible but physically impossible? But then, I think "time travel" answers that instead of my previous question.
 
Nope, you’re just being weasely again. Omnipotent means all powerful. If you want a lesser form come up with another word for it.
Ossai, omnipotent is a philosophical term of art. At least since the days of Aquinas and Maimonides - in other words, well before the term technically even entered the English language - the prevailing usage has specifically excluded the sorts of things you're insisting it must include.

General awareness of the semantic untenability of interpreting omnipotent to cover the accomplishment of logical impossibilities is extremely old and well-established (albeit not universal). You (rather than everyone else) are being unreasonable by insisting that everyone should use a common philosophical term in an alternate sense that is not only inconsistent with its most customary traditional meaning, but which ultimately makes the term unintelligible to boot. If anything, you should come up with a new word to designate what you mean by omnipotent - though, since your definition is ultimately nonsensical, I recommend that you not waste much time on it.

You make about as much sense as I would make if I were to go around insisting that the term bachelor should naturally encompass both unmarried bachelors and married ones.

It might help you get your head around the concept to think of it in these terms: Logical impossibilities are not really "things", and thus the inability to accomplish them does not reduce the number of things an omnipotent being has the power to do. Or else: accomplishing logical impossibilities can't intelligibly be conceived of as a "power"; therefore it is not really relevant to the concept of omnipotence.

Can you imagine anyone arguing that omnipresent should mean also being present in places that do not exist?
 
Last edited:
Physically (to us humans) but not logically impossible: Time travel.
I'm not so sure; time travel into the past could lead to a logical contradiction, such as an event having both occurred and not occurred, or someone having been both present and absent at some event. Speculating on possible ways around this (such as divergent timelines) would not appear to change the basic logical difficulty of backwards travel along the same timeline.
 
I think it all boils down to social inhibitions to rejecting such an entity. We are social creatures first and foremost. Many are afraid even if expressed that view covertly that there may still feel be a certain parson looking over their shoulder and as a consequence would be rejected and lose all their theist friends and just be a lonely little atheist sitting in the corner. Simple as that.
 
Huh? I think you're reading too far into my question. If I were trying to prove something I would have said so, or at least waited until I had what I needed to support it. Or I would have followed it up with an actual argument. I responded to what I thought was an interesting statement, so I looked for a connection, or lack of connections, between the physically possible and logically possible. I had thought the two were related, somehow, but I can't tell you why. Dare I ask what is logically possible but physically impossible? But then, I think "time travel" answers that instead of my previous question.

c4ts, I apologize. I assumed (as did some others) that in this post you were attempting to argue against jjramsey's statement that Ossai was conflating "physically impossible" and "logically impossible."

-Bri
 
I think it all boils down to social inhibitions to rejecting such an entity. We are social creatures first and foremost. Many are afraid even if expressed that view covertly that there may still feel be a certain parson looking over their shoulder and as a consequence would be rejected and lose all their theist friends and just be a lonely little atheist sitting in the corner. Simple as that.

And many others actually believe in God. Simple as that.

-Bri
 
If he choses to make himself unknown to us, we have no moral compass to determine what is objectively "good" or "bad", making the reward system of heaven completely arbitrary.

So you're saying that unless you know that God exists, you don't know the difference between "good" and "bad?" That sounds a lot like a theist argument, although many theists and most atheists would disagree with your statement.

-Bri
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom