There is No God (And You Know It)

I'm trying to figure out why there would be any collateral damage. Could God not simply will out of existence Satan and anyone else who has to go?

It's exciting to imagine God having to go to war, but it's not consistent with being all-powerful.
Exactly, as I have said elsewhere, surely omnipotence might be expected to include getting it right in the first place.
 
Forgive my ignorance, but I cannot comprehend this paragraph:



I've read it now four times - and it still seems to be meaningless gibberish and word-play.

Could you translate that into something an ignorant commoner could grasp, please?

Thanks! :D
Remember that logically necessary states of affairs are states of affairs that could not possibly fail to obtain. Accordingly, it makes no sense to describe them as being voluntarily caused by the power of any agent.

Take that earlier example of "any red object's being colored" as a logically necessary state of affairs. If it were possible for any agent to bring it about that red objects are colored, then possibly if that agent did not intervene with respect to an already red object, the object would have been red but would have no color. Yet red objects have a color just by virtue of the fact that they are red; this is true whether or not anyone acts, or indeed whether or not any red objects actually exist.

(We mustn't confuse an object's being red in the first place, which is a logically contingent state of affairs within the power of an omnipotent agent, with a red object's being colored, which, as noted, is a logically necessary state of affairs.)

If you can't prevent something from being the case, does it really make sense to say that you have the "power" to make it the case?

Hopefully that's a little clearer. To the extent that it is impossible for necessary circumstances not to occur, one might consider all of this to be simply a corollary to the idea that God cannot bring about logical impossibilities.
 
Last edited:
Remember that logically necessary states of affairs are states of affairs that could not possibly fail to obtain. Accordingly, it makes no sense to describe them as being voluntarily caused by the power of any agent.

Take that earlier example of "any red object's being colored" as a logically necessary state of affairs. If it were possible for any agent to bring it about that red objects are colored, then possibly if that agent did not intervene with respect to an already red object, the object would have been red but would have no color. Yet red objects have a color just by virtue of the fact that they are red; this is true whether or not anyone acts, or indeed whether or not any red objects actually exist.

(We mustn't confuse an object's being red in the first place, which is a logically contingent state of affairs within the power of an omnipotent agent, with a red object's being colored, which, as noted, is a logically necessary state of affairs.)

If you can't prevent something from being the case, does it really make sense to say that you have the "power" to make it the case?

Hopefully that's a little clearer. To the extent that it is impossible for necessary circumstances not to occur, one might consider all of this to be simply a corollary to the idea that God cannot bring about logical impossibilities.

Understood now - thanks! Very good.
 
Exactly, as I have said elsewhere, surely omnipotence might be expected to include getting it right in the first place.

Most theists would probably argue that God did get it right in the first place, that although the world doesn't seem "perfect" from our perspective, it is exactly as God intended it to be.

-Bri
 
Bri
Perhaps God's purpose is for us to exercise our free will to choose good over bad. To have choices between good and good wouldn't meet this criteria.
This still leaves suffering in this world unaccounted.

We're only "shooting blind" if you assume that God has given us no moral compass. As I said, many atheists and some theists believe that human beings possess an innate ability to tell right from wrong, even if they don't believe in God.
People believe in the Easter bunny as well. It doesn’t mean that one exists.


ceo_esq
Ossai, omnipotent is a philosophical term of art. At least since the days of Aquinas and Maimonides - in other words, well before the term technically even entered the English language - the prevailing usage has specifically excluded the sorts of things you're insisting it must include.
Why? It’s a direct limitation to omnipotent based on ignorance. Again, if an omnipotent entity can change the laws of reality, then nothing could be considered illogical or impossible for it.

accomplishing logical impossibilities can't intelligibly be conceived of as a "power";
You mean like causing the sun to stand still in the sky, or causing darkness to fall over a large geographic area with no other cause but one’s will, or walking on water, or creating matter, or observing all the surface of a spherical world from one place. All those things seem logically impossible, especially given the technological level at the time.

Can you imagine anyone arguing that omnipresent should mean also being present in places that do not exist?
Sorry, but the fundies already do this as well, so the answer is yes.

jjramsey
Neither Bri nor myself have contended that God would be restricted by physical laws, only by logic.
Why would god be restricted by logic? Again, this is an appeal to ignorance. You don’t see how god could go against logic therefore to you god can’t go against logic.

Ossai
 
This still leaves suffering in this world unaccounted.

Unaccounted how? Who says that all suffering is bad?

People believe in the Easter bunny as well. It doesn’t mean that one exists.

Nor that one doesn't. That's the point you seem to be missing in the discussion, which is about proving that no God exists, not about proving that a God does exist.

Why? It’s a direct limitation to omnipotent based on ignorance. Again, if an omnipotent entity can change the laws of reality, then nothing could be considered illogical or impossible for it.

Here is a pretty good overview of various definitions of omnipotence. The problem with arguments that use self-contradicting terms is that the argument itself is illogical for two reasons. First, saying that "omnipotence" means that you can create a "square circle" is utter nonsense since the latter part (square circle) is nonsense. Second, you're defining the first part (omnipotence) by the ability to do something that is nonsense, which makes your definition nonsense as well (and not a definition that is accepted by many people). Therefore, you are arguing against one very restrictive definition of omnipotence that hardly anyone would agree with.

That said, some would say that yes an omnipotent being could in fact create a square circle by adding the term "square circle" to the dictionary. Is that what your argument is asking, because your argument really assumes that the words "square circle" have some meaning. It's also possible that God could make the concept of an actual "square circle" logical by changing the rules of logic. If that's what you're claiming an omnipotent God must be able to do, then sure an omnipotent God could probably do that by some definitions of omnipotence. Can you prove that he can't?

You mean like causing the sun to stand still in the sky, or causing darkness to fall over a large geographic area with no other cause but one’s will, or walking on water, or creating matter, or observing all the surface of a spherical world from one place. All those things seem logically impossible, especially given the technological level at the time.

No, these things are physically impossible, but the terms do not contradict themselves unless you change their definitions. For example, if you assert that if the sun were to stand still that it can no longer be called a "sun" then saying that God must be able to make the sun stand still would be self-contradictory and therefore logically impossible. If you hold (as most would) that the sun is still called "the sun" if it stands still in the sky, then yes an omnipotent God might be able to make the sun stand still.

Why would god be restricted by logic? Again, this is an appeal to ignorance. You don’t see how god could go against logic therefore to you god can’t go against logic.

Some believe that God isn't restricted by logic, but that our understanding of him is. Therefore, to try to understand God by using self-contradictory nonsense terms would not lead to any logical understanding of God any more than saying that an omnipotent God must be able to make a flurblebum bounce without defining what a "flurblebum" is. Define what a "square circle" is and we'll talk.

-Bri
 
Why? It’s a direct limitation to omnipotent based on ignorance. Again, if an omnipotent entity can change the laws of reality, then nothing could be considered illogical or impossible for it.
As for why the historically predominant usage of omnipotent evolved in a different direction than the one you prefer, it's probably due to an innate linguistic and rational preference for interpreting words in a way that endows them with meaning, rather than in a way that ultimately renders them gibberish. More important than the why the prevailing meaning evolved in this way, however, is the fact that it did. Other usages, including yours, are secondary.

You mean like causing the sun to stand still in the sky, or causing darkness to fall over a large geographic area with no other cause but one’s will, or walking on water, or creating matter, or observing all the surface of a spherical world from one place. All those things seem logically impossible, especially given the technological level at the time.
You are incorrect, and the giveaway is that you were able to add "given the technological level at the time." No specific practical circumstances are relevant to logical impossibilities. If practical circumstances seem at all relevant to whether something is possible, that's a sure sign that you are really considering practical or physical impossibilities. Logical impossibilities are impossible a priori.

Let me put this in a different way. Something is logically impossible only if it would not be possible under any coherent real or imaginary circumstances. If all that is necessary to accomplish something is to violate, suspend or replace physical laws (such as the laws of thermodynamics, gravity, etc.), but you don't need to violate any [l]logical[/i] relationships to do it (such as causing something simultaneously to possess a property and not possess it), then it is logically possible.

Here's a handy rule of thumb: if you can imagine writing an understandable fictional account of something (such as a novel about magic-using fairies), it's not logically impossible. If you can't imagine writing an understandable fictional account of something (such as a novel about married bachelors or colorless red objects), it probably is logically impossible.

Can you imagine an understandable fictional account of someone causing the sun to stand still in the sky, walking on water, or creating matter? Sure; we already have one: the Bible. Those things are logically possible, albeit phsyically and/or practically impossible.
 
Last edited:
The correct statement is:

There is no good evidence for God, and we may never find any.
 
Not necessarily. I can imagine a world where we have free will but only between a limited number of "moral states". In other words, we can chose to do what we want, but harming others would be impossible.
Did you have in mind, say, a world where if I push a boulder off a cliff above your head, it dematerializes prior to impact or something?

As a small aside, since God is supposedly omniscient, he already knows what will happen in advance, making the issue of free will moot, as the christian universe must be deterministic.
As an equally small aside, God's (hypothetical) knowledge of future outcomes, per se, is not inconsistent with the human exercise of free will.
 
As an equally small aside, God's (hypothetical) knowledge of future outcomes, per se, is not inconsistent with the human exercise of free will.

To resolve the inconsistency, Calvinists reject man's free will (so far as salvation, anyway) while Deists reject the Christian nature of God entirely.

Other Christians just don't allow the problem to bother them, no matter the glaring absurdity produced.
 
To resolve the inconsistency, Calvinists reject man's free will (so far as salvation, anyway) while Deists reject the Christian nature of God entirely.

Other Christians just don't allow the problem to bother them, no matter the glaring absurdity produced.
To suggest that aside from the "incompatibilists", Christians ignore the thesis of theological fatalism, is to overlook at least 1,500 years' worth of compatibilist philosophical arguments to the effect that there is no absurdity produced.

For a decent, not-too-technical overview of theories of divine foreknowledge and human freedom, read this article from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
 
I'm not so sure; time travel into the past could lead to a logical contradiction, such as an event having both occurred and not occurred, or someone having been both present and absent at some event. Speculating on possible ways around this (such as divergent timelines) would not appear to change the basic logical difficulty of backwards travel along the same timeline.

Actually, I agree with you; to truly travel backwards along the sequence of events which led up to your present point in time is, by definition, a logical impossibility because that sequence is foundational to your present place in the space-time continuum.

The method of time travel I envision which avoids this logical problem entails essentially "reaching back" to the desired juncture in the past and creating a new "timeline" which may either exactly parallel, diverge temporarily from but then rejoin, or else permanently diverge from the original sequence of events. It is still a physical impossibility for us, but, to my mind, it poses no logical difficulties.
 
For a decent, not-too-technical overview of theories of divine foreknowledge and human freedom, read this article from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Good God I don't have time for that. I have a life!

Point taken though. I got the gist of it.....
 
Exactly, as I have said elsewhere, surely omnipotence might be expected to include getting it right in the first place.

Except that, in my view, omnipotence has developed as the space-time continuum has developed. Compare to a pearl: There may very well have been errors in judgment and execution in the initial, foundational layers. But, as the struggle has progressed, those initial errors have been compensated and mitigated as a structure has taken shape which provides, eventually, the greatest possible good and maximum positive impact upon the lives of those who love God.

So, to address your statement about "getting it right in the first place", I say that you must first define "first place." Do you mean in those initial, foundational steps recorded in Genesis which established the pattern for our world? There was much, I believe, back then which God did not anticipate--he had to learn and grow, as did we. Or do you mean in linear time, as we experience it, stretching back some fifteen billion years in this present timeline? That represents the outer layer (so far) of the pearl, in which God's knowledge is perfect--and from fifteen billion years in the past to the present God sees no need to make any changes because he knows that the ultimate outcome is everything which he desires.
 
No, I was simply pointing out that the sentence where you claimed that I was putting words in your mouth was copied and pasted in its entirety from the post to which I was responding, and therefore I couldn't have been putting any words into your mouth other than your own.

Well, I'm sorry, there. I thought you were saying I HAD made grammatical errors. My mistake.

Actually, I included the entirety of the post, so it was most certainly not taken out of context.

You can take a quote out of context and still take the entire quote. But when quoting, be sure to remember why I said what I did.

If you don't understand the statement, then how can you accuse me of putting words in your mouth? If you don't understand, please just say so and I'd be glad to explain. No need to go on the offensive with unnecessary accusations.

I agree.
 
Did you have in mind, say, a world where if I push a boulder off a cliff above your head, it dematerializes prior to impact or something?

Well, that'd be pretty funny, but assuming God can create a world with ANY physical laws he wishes, I don't see why he couldn't make one where hurting other people is impossible.

As an equally small aside, God's (hypothetical) knowledge of future outcomes, per se, is not inconsistent with the human exercise of free will.

Not per se, because we don't know the future, but, from his point of view, none of us could have taken any other decisions than those we did.
 
I seem to have trouble getting my point across. Probably because I can't express myself properly. I do make the difference between logically possible and physically possible. My posts may just have been very confusing. Here goes:

Basically, in order to argue whether God can exist or not, we need a clear definition of god.

A) If God cannot do the physically impossible, but is instead limited to the physically possible, then he's not God. I don't think many theists would argue that God is limited to physical possibilities.

B) If one claims that God can do the logically impossible, I contend that God, as so defined, does not exist. Otherwise he can be and not be something simultaneously, and nothing makes sense anymore.

In order to be somewhat plausible and still be called God, this entity must be somewhere in the middle. In other words, have abilities beyond the physically possible and yet restrained by logic. Of course, he'd still be beyond scientific inquiry unless he interracted with the physical world from time to time.

However, I'm sure that a good proportion of theists would maintain that God can do everything, even what is illogical. My whole point here is that God, as defined by christianity in general, cannot exist.

Do I make sense here ?
 
Bri
Unaccounted how? Who says that all suffering is bad?
I said suffering meaning both that caused by freewill and that not caused by freewill. How can you say that all suffering is good?

Nor that one doesn't. That's the point you seem to be missing in the discussion, which is about proving that no God exists, not about proving that a God does exist.
There is no way to prove that a god doesn’t exist. At best we could prove that a specific god doesn’t exist, in this case one that is omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent.

First, saying that "omnipotence" means that you can create a "square circle" is utter nonsense since the latter part (square circle) is nonsense.
To us a “square circle” is nonsense, to an entity that can change the laws of physics a “square circle” would be child’s play.
Now if you want to limit omnipotence to conform to the current laws of nature we know then a “square circle” is nonsense, but then so are quiet a few of the “miracles” in the bible.

Second, you're defining the first part (omnipotence) by the ability to do something that is nonsense, which makes your definition nonsense as well (and not a definition that is accepted by many people).
Would changing or breaking the natural laws (physics, speed of light in a vacuum, etc) be a power?
If yes, then it’s illogical to limit omnipotence by the natural laws.
If no, then explain the “miracles” listed in the bible. They become conjuring tricks which grew through multiple telling, lies created in support of the stories or a combination of the two.

It's also possible that God could make the concept of an actual "square circle" logical by changing the rules of logic. If that's what you're claiming an omnipotent God must be able to do, then sure an omnipotent God could probably do that by some definitions of omnipotence. Can you prove that he can't?
Sigh, so close.
I’m stating that an omnipotent entity could not only change the rules of logic but the rules of nature as well so that a square circle becomes physically possible.

ceo_esq
As an equally small aside, God's (hypothetical) knowledge of future outcomes, per se, is not inconsistent with the human exercise of free will.
Omniscience and free will are mutually exclusive.

For a decent, not-too-technical overview of theories of divine foreknowledge and human freedom, read this article from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
I’ll read it later.

Ossai
 
In order to be somewhat plausible and still be called God, this entity must be somewhere in the middle. In other words, have abilities beyond the physically possible and yet restrained by logic.

Yet this is what Bri, ceo_esq, and I have maintained all along. God, if he exists, is restrained by logic, but nothing else.

However, I'm sure that a good proportion of theists would maintain that God can do everything, even what is illogical. My whole point here is that God, as defined by christianity in general, cannot exist.

The theists that define terms of the debate like "omnipotent," such as Aquinas and Maimonides, maintain no such thing, however. Maimonides is Jewish, but Aquinas is solidly within the Christian tradition, especially the Catholic part of it, so one could hardly claim that the God of Christianity is necessarily expected to do the illogical.
 
The theists that define terms of the debate like "omnipotent," such as Aquinas and Maimonides, maintain no such thing, however. Maimonides is Jewish, but Aquinas is solidly within the Christian tradition, especially the Catholic part of it, so one could hardly claim that the God of Christianity is necessarily expected to do the illogical.

I don't expect him to, either. I don't believe in God, mind you. But if he existed I'd expect him to be as we agreed. However I don't thing I personally know a christian who has ever admitted that his god COULDN'T do the impossible, logical or not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom