Why? It’s a direct limitation to omnipotent based on ignorance. Again, if an omnipotent entity can change the laws of reality, then nothing could be considered illogical or impossible for it.
As for
why the historically predominant usage of
omnipotent evolved in a different direction than the one you prefer, it's probably due to an innate linguistic and rational preference for interpreting words in a way that endows them with meaning, rather than in a way that ultimately renders them gibberish. More important than the
why the prevailing meaning evolved in this way, however, is the fact that it
did. Other usages, including yours, are secondary.
You mean like causing the sun to stand still in the sky, or causing darkness to fall over a large geographic area with no other cause but one’s will, or walking on water, or creating matter, or observing all the surface of a spherical world from one place. All those things seem logically impossible, especially given the technological level at the time.
You are incorrect, and the giveaway is that you were able to add "given the technological level at the time." No specific practical circumstances are relevant to logical impossibilities. If practical circumstances seem at all relevant to whether something is possible, that's a sure sign that you are really considering
practical or
physical impossibilities.
Logical impossibilities are impossible
a priori.
Let me put this in a different way. Something is
logically impossible only if it would not be possible under
any coherent real or imaginary circumstances. If all that is necessary to accomplish something is to violate, suspend or replace
physical laws (such as the laws of thermodynamics, gravity, etc.), but you don't need to violate any [l]logical[/i] relationships to do it (such as causing something simultaneously to possess a property and not possess it), then it is logically possible.
Here's a handy rule of thumb: if you can imagine writing an understandable fictional account of something (such as a novel about magic-using fairies), it's not logically impossible. If you
can't imagine writing an understandable fictional account of something (such as a novel about married bachelors or colorless red objects), it probably
is logically impossible.
Can you imagine an understandable fictional account of someone causing the sun to stand still in the sky, walking on water, or creating matter? Sure; we already have one: the Bible. Those things are logically possible, albeit phsyically and/or practically impossible.