There is No God (And You Know It)

Why would an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God expect reasonable people to chose to believe in something that seems illogical and supernatural ? Why would he reward these guys, anyway ?

Do you mean why would an omnipotent, omnibenebolent God expect reasonable people to choose to believe in something that seems illogical to you?

Obviously, belief in God doesn't seem illogical to the majority of people who believe in God. So who are "these guys" to which you are referring?

-Bri
 
So you're saying that unless you know that God exists, you don't know the difference between "good" and "bad?" That sounds a lot like a theist argument, although many theists and most atheists would disagree with your statement.

Perhaps you should care to read what I write rather than assign random meanings to it.

What I said was that, if God exists and chooses who gets to be saved based on his own moral code, it would make sense, were he perfect, to make that code known to us, clearly, so that everybody can choose to follow it or not. Otherwise we're just shooting blind. If he were more careful we might not have all these contradictory religions.
 
Do you mean why would an omnipotent, omnibenebolent God expect reasonable people to choose to believe in something that seems illogical to you?

No, it's not what I mean. That's basically why it's not what I said.

Given the current, leading scientific theories that are available to everyone to read up about in the civilised world, the universe came into beign as one large quantum fluctuation. The underlying spacetime foam is utter, simple chaos. No God needed here. God is superfluous.

If God is omnipotent, can he create an even more powerful God ? If so, he's not omnipotent, because otherwise nothing could be more powerful than he is. Otherwise, he's not omnipotent, because there's something he can't do. God is inconsistent.

If God is omniscient, could he create an event he could know nothing about ? If so, he's not omniscient. If not, he's not omnipotent. The same goes for omnipresence. God is inconsistent.

If God is perfect, why would he have needs ? He couldn't. Why create the universe ? Why do anything without needs ?

I could go on, but there are simply several, serious logical problems with the very concept of God. If logic is incompatible with God, God is impossible, unless you can show that there can be illogical, real things.
 
Perhaps you should care to read what I write rather than assign random meanings to it.

What I said was that, if God exists and chooses who gets to be saved based on his own moral code, it would make sense, were he perfect, to make that code known to us, clearly, so that everybody can choose to follow it or not. Otherwise we're just shooting blind. If he were more careful we might not have all these contradictory religions.

Oh, I'm sorry. I thought you said that if he choses to make himself unknown to us, we have no moral compass to determine what is objectively "good" or "bad", making the reward system of heaven completely arbitrary. Oh, wait. You did.

We're only "shooting blind" if you assume that God has given us no moral compass. As I said, many atheists and some theists believe that human beings possess an innate ability to tell right from wrong, even if they don't believe in God.

-Bri
 
Oh, I'm sorry. I thought you said that if he choses to make himself unknown to us, we have no moral compass to determine what is objectively "good" or "bad", making the reward system of heaven completely arbitrary. Oh, wait. You did.

Did I ? Read on.

We're only "shooting blind" if you assume that God has given us no moral compass. As I said, many atheists and some theists believe that human beings possess an innate ability to tell right from wrong, even if they don't believe in God.

I said CLEAR. Clear moral compass. That God wants us to do things simply because we're genetically compelled to do them is ludicrously naive, and goes somewhat against the idea of free will. Who's to say that our "compass" is reliable ? Or that it has anything to do with God ? It's far from a clear and honest way to give us a choice. Besides, there are things we "feel" are wrong and others "feel" are right. Who's correct, here ?
 
No, it's not what I mean. That's basically why it's not what I said.

Your original statement assumed that whatever God expects people to believe in would seem illogical to everyone. This is clearly not the case. It seems illogical to you, but not to everyone.

If God is omnipotent, can he create an even more powerful God ? If so, he's not omnipotent, because otherwise nothing could be more powerful than he is. Otherwise, he's not omnipotent, because there's something he can't do. God is inconsistent.

If God is omniscient, could he create an event he could know nothing about ? If so, he's not omniscient. If not, he's not omnipotent. The same goes for omnipresence. God is inconsistent.

Have you been reading this thread at all? ceo_esq stated it here better than I could.

If God is perfect, why would he have needs ? He couldn't. Why create the universe ? Why do anything without needs ?

Again, there are many explanations for these questions, including the old "we don't know." None of them provide evidence that an omnipotent or omnibenevolent God must be illogical.

I could go on, but there are simply several, serious logical problems with the very concept of God. If logic is incompatible with God, God is impossible, unless you can show that there can be illogical, real things.

So far you haven't even named a logical problem with an omnipotent or omnibenevolent god, much less a logical problem with every concept of God.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Oh, I'm sorry. I thought you said that if he choses to make himself unknown to us, we have no moral compass to determine what is objectively "good" or "bad", making the reward system of heaven completely arbitrary. Oh, wait. You did.

Did I ? Read on.

Uhhh...YES! I exerpted your post word for word (including the grammatical and spelling errors), so yes that is exactly what you said:

If he choses to make himself unknown to us, we have no moral compass to determine what is objectively "good" or "bad", making the reward system of heaven completely arbitrary.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I neglected to point out earlier, for what it's worth, that the term omnipotence excludes not only the "power" to bring about logically impossible states of affairs, but also the "power" to bring about logically necessary states of affairs.

(Knowing this board, I'm half expecting to see an argument that bringing about logically necessary states of affairs is a real power and that an omnipotent being must possess it.)
 
Are you meaning, perhaps, the ability to lay down, for example, the necessary physics laws, etc., needed for some event to occur? Why would the term omnipotence exclude this, specifically? Not that I disagree, but I'm curious as to the reasoning employed in reaching this conclusion.
 
And many others actually believe in God. Simple as that.

-Bri

I can recall a favorite old quote from Oscar Wilde. "give a man a mask and he will tell you the truth" So how can you separate the actual believers from those that are just lieing about it.
 
Your original statement assumed that whatever God expects people to believe in would seem illogical to everyone. This is clearly not the case. It seems illogical to you, but not to everyone.

Please stop trying to put words in my mouth. Besides, I can't make heads or tails of your statement, here.

Have you been reading this thread at all? ceo_esq stated it here better than I could.

Yes I read that already, thanks. If God cannot do the illogical, or is not illogical, why would he be beyond the scope of scientific inquiry ? He can't be both beyond logic and within its bounds.

So far you haven't even named a logical problem with an omnipotent or omnibenevolent god, much less a logical problem with every concept of God.

Putting your hands on your ears and shouting "la la la la la" doesn't cancel out anything I've said. If God can only do what we expect is possible using known physical laws, then he's not God.
 
Uhhh...YES! I exerpted your post word for word (including the grammatical and spelling errors), so yes that is exactly what you said:

Oh, he's pointing out that my english isn't perfect. He's got me now!!

Quoting sentences out of context is not only nasty but dishonest. You said:

"Perhaps God's purpose is for us to exercise our free will to choose good over bad. To have choices between good and good wouldn't meet this criteria."

All I said, in case you need a translation, is that if he wants us to follow HIS moral code then he should make THAT code plain and obvious to us. Hiding his existence from us does not accomplish this.
 
If God cannot do the illogical, or is not illogical, why would he be beyond the scope of scientific inquiry ? He can't be both beyond logic and within its bounds.

You seem to be misusing "scientific inquiry" as a synonym for logic.

Putting your hands on your ears and shouting "la la la la la" doesn't cancel out anything I've said. If God can only do what we expect is possible using known physical laws, then he's not God.

Neither Bri nor myself have contended that God would be restricted by physical laws, only by logic. If you continue to conflate the physically possible with the logically possible, then your thinking is muddled, and there is little point in continuing to argue with you.
 
Last edited:
Yes I read that already, thanks. If God cannot do the illogical, or is not illogical, why would he be beyond the scope of scientific inquiry ? He can't be both beyond logic and within its bounds.
I think you may be collapsing the distinction between logical (i.e. purely rational) inquiry and scientific (i.e. empirical) inquiry. Generally speaking, logic is a non-empirical enterprise. It is widely (though not universally) acknowledged by theists that God is an appropriate object of rational inquiry, even though they assert that the human faculty of reason cannot, ultimately, give a complete account of the divine nature. Indeed, the rigorous application of logic to ideas about God was the most salient preoccupation of medieval philosophy (viz. the Scholastics).

Putting your hands on your ears and shouting "la la la la la" doesn't cancel out anything I've said. If God can only do what we expect is possible using known physical laws, then he's not God.
We were speaking of the laws of logic, not the laws of physics.
 
Are you meaning, perhaps, the ability to lay down, for example, the necessary physics laws, etc., needed for some event to occur? Why would the term omnipotence exclude this, specifically? Not that I disagree, but I'm curious as to the reasoning employed in reaching this conclusion.
From the Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy:
[It is impossible] for an agent to bring about a necessary state of affairs (for example, any red object's being coloured). If it is possible for an agent, a, to bring about a necessary state of affairs, s, then possibly, (1) a brings about s, and (2) if a had not acted, then s would not have obtained. But a necessary state of affairs obtains whether or not anyone acts, so (2) is false. Therefore, it is not possible for an agent to bring about a necessary state of affairs.
All I meant was that any definition of omnipotence requiring an omnipotent agent to possess that "power" is unintelligible.
 
Last edited:
Forgive my ignorance, but I cannot comprehend this paragraph:

[It is impossible] for an agent to bring about a necessary state of affairs (for example, any red object's being coloured). If it is possible for an agent, a, to bring about a necessary state of affairs, s, then possibly, (1) a brings about s, and (2) if a had not acted, then s would not have obtained. But a necessary state of affairs obtains whether or not anyone acts, so (2) is false. Therefore, it is not possible for an agent to bring about a necessary state of affairs.

I've read it now four times - and it still seems to be meaningless gibberish and word-play.

Could you translate that into something an ignorant commoner could grasp, please?

Thanks! :D
 
I can recall a favorite old quote from Oscar Wilde. "give a man a mask and he will tell you the truth" So how can you separate the actual believers from those that are just lieing about it.

You probably can't, which is why you must assume that believers are telling the truth. By the way, the same goes for those who believe that no gods exist, and even for agnostics. How can you know if anyone is telling the truth?

-Bri
 
We were speaking of the laws of logic, not the laws of physics.

Well, in order to circumvent the problems I mentionned with the concept of God, we would need a solid definition of "omnipotence". Unfortunately, though a "limited" omnipotence may be more plausible, a lot of theists (dare I say, most of them ?) believe that there is nothing, logical or not, that God cannot accomplish.

Personnally, I'm interested in both the logical and physical aspects of this discussion.
 
You seem to be misusing "scientific inquiry" as a synonym for logic.

Oh, no. Sorry if I led you to believe that. I meant what I said, though.

Neither Bri nor myself have contended that God would be restricted by physical laws, only by logic. If you continue to conflate the physically possible with the logically possible, then your thinking is muddled, and there is little point in continuing to argue with you.

Well, thank you. I'm aware of the difference between the two, by the way. All I'm saying, is that if we claim that "omnipotence" limits God to physical possibilities, then he's not God. If "omnipotence" includes the illogical, I say he can't exist. That leaves us the middle ground. The logically possible but physically impossible.
 
Oh, he's pointing out that my english isn't perfect. He's got me now!!

No, I was simply pointing out that the sentence where you claimed that I was putting words in your mouth was copied and pasted in its entirety from the post to which I was responding, and therefore I couldn't have been putting any words into your mouth other than your own.

Quoting sentences out of context is not only nasty but dishonest.

Actually, I included the entirety of the post, so it was most certainly not taken out of context.

You said:

"Perhaps God's purpose is for us to exercise our free will to choose good over bad. To have choices between good and good wouldn't meet this criteria."

This was, of course, in response to a completely different post, specifically this one:

Not necessarily. I can imagine a world where we have free will but only between a limited number of "moral states". In other words, we can chose to do what we want, but harming others would be impossible.

Please stop trying to put words in my mouth. Besides, I can't make heads or tails of your statement, here.

If you don't understand the statement, then how can you accuse me of putting words in your mouth? If you don't understand, please just say so and I'd be glad to explain. No need to go on the offensive with unnecessary accusations.

So far you have accused me of quoting you out of context, putting words in your mouth, and attacking your imperfect English. At this point I'm going to take jjramsey's advice and discontinue arguing with you unless you can continue the discussion without resorting to incorrect accusations and illogical reasoning. However, if you have something new to add in the way of proving that there is no God, I'd be happy to hear it.

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom