There is No God (And You Know It)

The preamble is irrelevant...

But hopefully entertaining. :D

You specify that the person chooses - why do they choose? Does logic somehow stop at the boundary you call 'person' (like Bri's 'internal')?
Well, here's where I get stuck. i'll admit it. I have a gap. I only really started thinking seriously about this two days ago, so I haven't filled in all my gaps. (if you recall, my first post in this thread, I indicated that I was something of a fence sitter...ok, I tend to root for the underdog)

Why do they choose...well, I guess the trivial answer is "cause they gotta". However, I find that as lacking as I assume you will, once you read it.

For a non-trivial answer...Why do they choose? Well, um...<scratches head>..uh...I really don't have a good answer right now, could I get back to you? I need to think about that.

I don't understand the second question, could you clarify? ("Does logic somehow stop at the boundary you call 'person' ")

My initial read of it seems to say that you're asking if the person can use logic, and I have a hard time believeing that you'd ask that.
 
KMortis,

The point you are seriously missing is that the term 'free will' is not very well defined. All us atheists can nicely agree that it is a feeling induced somehow. Unfortunately it is held as a tenet of religion and some philosophies - in which case we are entitled to ask - how is the will free? Then we are talking about something more logical, more well defined than the common notion of free will.

Any vague logic will be exploited to show that if this strange (free will) thing can exist then so can any (b******t) non-real thing exist.
 
Last edited:
KMortis,

The point you are seriously missing is that the term 'free will' is not very well defined. All us atheists can nicely agree that it is a feeling induced somehow. Unfortunately it is held as a tenet of religion and some philosophies - in which case we are entitled to ask - how is the will free? Then we are talking about something more logical, more well defined than the common notion of free will.

Any vague logic will be exploited to show that if this strange (free will) thing can exist then so can any (b******t) non-real thing exist.

But I don't see determinism any more logical. See my responces to Belz.

Again, give me a chance to think about this. i've never bothered to think about it before and it caught me off guard.

Also, just because something has been co-opted by a disreputable group, doesn't mean that it's all bad. We have to judge the weight of the idea on it's own. I mean, should we throw out all of Quantum Mechanics? The woo crowd uses it to explain away a multitude of sins. The Butterfly Effect as well (mumble, mumble, grumble). Don't fall into the "guilt by association" fallacy.
 
I don't see how this pertains to our discussion, here. Our beliefs are irrelevant. We're trying to make sense of various things to determine whether or not we can "prove" that there's a God or not.

Actually, Belz, all we have are our beliefs in this argument. We have no hard an fast evidence that either side can hold up and say "By this Thingamagiggertm, I hereby conclusively prove My Point!"

There, ya want some proof that I'm going back and reading the old posts...you got it. :D
 
Last edited:
But I don't see determinism any more logical. See my responces to Belz.

Again, give me a chance to think about this. i've never bothered to think about it before and it caught me off guard.

Also, just because something has been co-opted by a disreputable group, doesn't mean that it's all bad. We have to judge the weight of the idea on it's own. I mean, should we throw out all of Quantum Mechanics? The woo crowd uses it to explain away a multitude of sins. The Butterfly Effect as well (mumble, mumble, grumble). Don't fall into the "guilt by association" fallacy.

WARNING: Work in process. I could change my mind during discussion on this topic. You have been warned.

Ok, so why does a person make a choice. Because they can. Here I am limiting myself, for the time being, to what I'll call "impetus choices" (ie the chili v. lasagne from an earlier post) as opposed to an "analog choice" (the idea that our lives are made up of an infinte number of choices each moment...I'm still not sure if I agree with that or not).

Ok, so the time comes to make the choice. All the inputs have rung in, made themselves known and I'm ready to make the choice. I make it cause I recognize it as a choice (this recognition could be made at a subconscious level), by definition, a choice must be chosen, eh? ;)

Does this make sense? I know in my mind what I want to say, but it ain't coming out.
 
If that were true, then light would act as either a wave or a particle all the time. No, we cannot, we can only describe the probability field. Once the particle enters into a state, that prob. field collapses, and then we can know certain aspects (as described by Heisnburgh Uncertainty Law).

Yeah but that principle doesn't say that photons are all over the place and then, suddenly, are in one given spot. They are in one given spot all the time. It's just that we don't KNOW what that spot is. Same diff with our "choices" they're choices to use because we're not aware of all the factors. To an omniscient god who, for the sake of argument, knows ALL the factors, even if he can't "see" the future per se, your choices are all determined in advance.

The choice I made (and continue to make) is to sit here and finish. Now, we could examine my psyche and figure out all the nuiances that went into my choice to finish this, but it still comes down to me making the choice to do it. No divine involved at all, is there? I don't need a god to "allow" me to have free will, it's just an innate part of living.

I'm not talking about God. My position on that subject should be known, by now. What I'm saying is that nothing "determines" our choices, because they are not choices to begin with. Just particles moving around in a clockwork manner.

3) Or they're completely random (in 'select cases')....who/what does the selecting? Or, to put it less parjoritively, how does this selecting get done? How is the determination between the processes that are going to be "completely deterministic" (aka ORDERED) or "completely random" (aka CHAOTIC)?

Okay, that's not what I meant. According to theory, there are a number of quantum fluctuations going off all the time. These are supposed to be truly random. That is, they have no actual cause. Now, assuming these can have an impact on actual particles and stuff, then they can affect your decisions, in theory. But even so, this wouldn't help the free will argument, because it's random. So your choices are either determined in advance by fixed factors or by random factors. Either way, no choice at all.



Where ? Where's your definition ?
 
Actually, Belz, all we have are our beliefs in this argument. We have no hard an fast evidence that either side can hold up and say "By this Thingamagiggertm, I hereby conclusively prove My Point!"

There, ya want some proof that I'm going back and reading the old posts...you got it. :D

I never said you didn't. But I think we can build a convincing, if not conclusive, argument against the existence of free will, and against the existence of God. Of course, we shouldn't expect these to be 100% airtight. No argument is, if you want to look at it in absolutes.
 
The point you are seriously missing is that the term 'free will' is not very well defined. All us atheists can nicely agree that it is a feeling induced somehow. Unfortunately it is held as a tenet of religion and some philosophies - in which case we are entitled to ask - how is the will free? Then we are talking about something more logical, more well defined than the common notion of free will.

Many Christians don't believe in free will, particularly those who believe in predestination. The impetus for the discussion of free will usually stems from ethics rather than religion.

Any vague logic will be exploited to show that if this strange (free will) thing can exist then so can any (b******t) non-real thing exist.

You have to let go of this notion that everything can be proven. Most things cannot. It is possible that anything that has not or cannot be proven is actually true, regardless of how strange it is. In fact, people once thought the idea of the earth revolving around the sun to be very strange indeed, yet it was later shown to be true.

You want strange...look no farther than quantum theory. Particles of light going backwards in time in order to appear in two locations simultaneously, our merely perceiving something actually having a physical effect on the thing being perceived, billions of parallel universes splitting off every second...all of these things not only possible but some of them probably true according to quantum theory.

Now I'm not saying that free will is true, or even that it's probably true (indeed it probably is not true) but do you really have that much of a problem with the mere possibility of free will being true?

-Bri
 
...So even a random thing is, on some level, also a caused thing...

Zaayr, I believe you are mistaken here. According to quantum theory, random events are nondeterministic because they are uncaused.

The problem there being, the only way to know, for sure, that a decision IS made via free will, is to strip away all antecedents and determine if any such choice can still be made. This is not only difficult to do; it may very well be impossible for us to accomplish, at this stage of our knowledge.

Indeed it would be difficult if not impossible, but on top of that the results would be inconclusive (they would neither prove nor disprove free will). I don't know that free will can be tested, so it is likely that the only way to disprove free will would be logically.

If we become even more strident and rigid in our definitions, we could simply state that a decision made of our free will must be free of ALL antecedents, but if this is the case, then we are already discounting free will entirely, as no choice, action, or decision made by any person is free from some influence from some antecedent factor. And in spite of Bri's misunderstandings, an influence IS a causal factor. One cannot have an uncaused event that is influenced by some antecedent factor, I believe. All influences upon a given choice combine to form the cause of that choice.

I don't recall denying that an influence is a causal factor. Quite the opposite, I believe I said that something is not considered to be determined unless all causal factors (influences) are determined. Determinism states that every event is caused entirely by prior events. In order for something to be determined, it must be entirely determined by prior events which are all themselves determined. If any event is not determined, then any event which is caused in full or in part by the undetermined event cannot be said to be determined.

ceo_esq is correct that determinism implies that if all prior events are known, it is theoretically possible to predict all future events with 100% accuracy. Contradicting determinism, quantum theory states that events are probabilistic (because they are based on randomness), so a future event can be predicted within a certain probability, but not with 100% accuracy. An event which is undertermined cannot be predicted with 100% accuracy even by knowing all prior events, nor can any event which is caused in part or in full by the undertermined event.

If something is caused in full or in part by a random event, then it can itself be considered random, even though it may also be influenced by other prior causes that are entirely determined. Similarly, a choice could be considered free even if it is also influenced by other prior causes that are determined, as long as some cause of that choice is free.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I've heard both the claim that libertarian free will cannot exist if an omniscient God also exists and the claim that libertarian free will cannot exist at all. Neither of these claims really have much to do with the topic of the thread, but I would still be interested in seeing an actual logical proof of either based on the arguments made.

-Bri
You mean apart from the ones I made?
 
Many Christians don't believe in free will, particularly those who believe in predestination. The impetus for the discussion of free will usually stems from ethics rather than religion.

Good for them.

You have to let go of this notion that everything can be proven. Most things cannot. It is possible that anything that has not or cannot be proven is actually true, regardless of how strange it is.
-Bri

I don't have that notion. I do have a notion that the concept of 'free will' is self-contradictory and illogical - EXCEPT in its normal everday sense. What I object to is the extraploation of the everyday meaning of free will into the 'spiritual' / 'we just don't know' / 'beyond our comprehension' etc... realm of religion. For this reason, when we are debating 'free will' in a philosophical / religious context I think it is right that it should be rigorously defined and defended.

If all parties agree that it is an effect of the psyche - fine. If anyone wants to claim more tha that for it then they must justify it. Unfortunately the default appears to be that it is more than just an effect / illusion so I have to call the claimants to task and ask 'HOW SO?'.
 
You want strange...look no farther than quantum theory. Particles of light going backwards in time in order to appear in two locations simultaneously, our merely perceiving something actually having a physical effect on the thing being perceived, billions of parallel universes splitting off every second...all of these things not only possible but some of them probably true according to quantum theory.-Bri

Of course, nothing in Quantum theory supports your version of free will. Reality can be as strange as it likes - that makes no difference to the argument on 'free will'. An infinite number of versions of your will existing (probabilistically) in infinite universes doe snot make any of the iterations of your will free-er.
 
Maybe, but mainstream christianity pretty much requires the existence of free will. Otherwise, God made us all good or evil at the start. Pretty much makes the idea of a "judgment" useless.
On the other hand most mainstream Christian theologies do not include free will as defined here. For example Augustinian and Thomist definitions include the idea that God could calculate exactly what you would do in a given situation and therefore can control the whole universe still allowing you free will.

Certain Christian theologies include the idea of free will as defined here but as far as I can see ignore the problems of an omniscient being participating in a universe with free will.
 
You mean apart from the ones I made?

I guess. Too many claims were made to remember all of them. But yes if you made a different claim I would like to see an actual logical proof.

-Bri
 
What I object to is the extraploation of the everyday meaning of free will into the 'spiritual' / 'we just don't know' / 'beyond our comprehension' etc... realm of religion. For this reason, when we are debating 'free will' in a philosophical / religious context I think it is right that it should be rigorously defined and defended.

I don't know that anyone was using it in a spiritual context. In fact, religion doesn't have a lot to do with free will at all. Some atheists believe in free will. The only positive claim made about free will was from those claiming that it cannot exist. So, define free will and show how it cannot exist by your definition. I tried to help you with a definition, but you didn't like my suggestions. It is likely that any defintion you come up with that doesn't include at least some of the properties I outlined aren't going to come close to disproving free will for most people.

If all parties agree that it is an effect of the psyche - fine. If anyone wants to claim more tha that for it then they must justify it. Unfortunately the default appears to be that it is more than just an effect / illusion so I have to call the claimants to task and ask 'HOW SO?'.

The default position is simply that it is possible that free will is more than just an illusion and it is also possible that free will is merely an illusion. If you wish to prove that it is impossible that free will is more than an illusion (i.e. that free will must be an illusion), then you must define free will and prove that it is only an illusion. Otherwise, simply admit that it's possibile that free will is more than an illusion and let it go.

-Bri
 
Of course, nothing in Quantum theory supports your version of free will. Reality can be as strange as it likes - that makes no difference to the argument on 'free will'. An infinite number of versions of your will existing (probabilistically) in infinite universes doe snot make any of the iterations of your will free-er.

Of course nothing in quantum theory supports any version of free will. I was not implying that quantum theory either proves or disproves free will. As far as I know, free will is outside of the scope of quantum theory.

-Bri
 
I guess. Too many claims were made to remember all of them. But yes if you made a different claim I would like to see an actual logical proof.

-Bri
In fact I have only made two claims in total in this thread. Is that really too many for you to remember?

1. That an omniscient being cannot participate in a universe that contains free will (3 deductive proofs provided, no refutation received to date)
2. That the libertarian definition of free will is internally inconsistent (2 deductive arguments provided)

Your blanket refutation for all these things is that you are pretty sure that in thousands of years somebody must have come up with an answer to these but you are not sure exactly who.

I take you on your word that your program example had nothing whatsoever to do with God and omniscience.
 
In fact I have only made two claims in total in this thread...

1. That an omniscient being cannot participate in a universe that contains free will (3 deductive proofs provided, no refutation received to date)
2. That the libertarian definition of free will is internally inconsistent (2 deductive arguments provided)

My post to which you were responding was in reference to the recent claims that there was one or more proofs among the discussion even though none have yet been posted to support it. I already mentioned the second of your claims in reference to "the claim that libertarian free will cannot exist at all." I believe ceo_esq has already refuted your arguments.

As for your first claim, I do remember plenty of arguments, but I don't recall any of those arguments being unrefuted. The fact that you claim to have posted three unrefuted proofs seems suspect since there would be no reason for you to post more than one if it wasn't refuted, but I'm not about to go back through all the posts to confirm that. Feel free to post them again though.

Your blanket refutation for all these things is that you are pretty sure that in thousands of years somebody must have come up with an answer to these but you are not sure exactly who.

That is quite a mischaracterization of what I said. I did say that these issues have been well-documented areas of discussion in philosophy for thousands of years and that nearly no reputable source considers them to have been decided one way or the other. Of course, that comment wasn't meant to be any sort of refutation, but merely an observation in addition to refutations that were already posted. Until you post a definitive proof or have one published in a peer-reviewed journal, you'll have to forgive me for placing more stock in articles from Stanford and other reputable sources than in your own assessments of your arguments.

I take you on your word that your program example had nothing whatsoever to do with God and omniscience.

Again, that is a mischaracterization of what I said. The example demonstrates that a person can have foreknowledge of events of the free agent in the simulation. Certainly the example has something to do with God and omniscience, but you have to be careful in how you proceed in drawing conclusions about God and omniscience since foreknowledge is only one part of omniscience and the programmer isn't timeless as God might be.

-Bri
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom