There is No God (And You Know It)

Yet, in order to prove conclusively that a decision was made via free will, you would have to remove all of these factors systematically, and still see if any decision was possible.

I don't think that even removing all of these factors would prove or disprove that a decision was made via free will.

If we removed all of the factors and a decision was still possible, free will might be true since there is presumably nothing else causing the decision. But it could be that the decision made simply becomes random without input from the removed factors, and we wouldn't be able to tell whether or not the original decision was via free will, causation, or randomness.

If we removed all of the factors and no decision was possible, it might be that there was no free will and therefore removing all causes removed the decision. But it could be that the original decision might still have been free but simply required the input from the removed factors.

Unless and until we can do that, there is no reason to consider any choice, act, or decision to be 'free' in the absolute sense.

Sure, unless we can provide evidence of free will, there is no reason to believe it to be true. Nobody's arguing that.

Of course, there's also no reason to believe that it's impossible for free will to be true without evidence to the contrary.

-Bri
 
I am not sure this is the normal sense. The normal sense is that we are controlled by the laws of nature. To say that the laws of nature are external to the self would seem to be making a dualist assumption.

I was inspired to consult Routledge (under "Determinism and Indeterminism") on this point, and my findings were ambiguous: "Since the rise of modern science in the seventeenth century, [the doctrine of determinism] has been commonly understood as the 'law of universal causation', that every event has a cause; or as the predictability, in principle, of all of the future, given full knowledge of the present." In the second part of the passage, the dictionary seems to agree with me that that the traditional sense of determinism denotes predictability in essentially the sense I've been using it - which was really my sole point when I made my earlier response. However, in the same breath the dictionary equates this with the notion that every event has a cause, and I don't agree that the two concepts are equivalent. I've argued the possibility that, assuming every event has a cause, not all causes are necessarily deterministic ones (in the "predictability" sense), and thus a hypothetically free choice could be "caused" or "determined" by the will, without giving rise to a predictable (deterministic) result.


That would not work in the scenario I described. If you say '6' and I percieve '3' in the future I am not in a position to guarantee you your '6'. We might be able to foretell the outcome of an unpredictable event by perceiving the future, but we still couldn't control it.

Scratch what I said earlier; for some reason I misread your hypothetical. If it's me taking the guess and you trying to make good on the guarantee, I don't think it can be done within the terms of the scenario.

I accept the definition, but it still says that no amount of knowledge of the operation and circumstances of the box would allow you to control it. Even a direct perception of the future does not allow you to control it. Not predictable (in your sense) implies not controllable. Not even by an atemporal omnimax.

Okay so far, I think. Again, scratch my earlier response to the hypothetical.


If we can control the box then it is predictable.

Not necessarily, at least in any objective sense: Let's say you have sole direct control over the box and, each day, you can make it flash whatever number you decide. Is it necessarily possible for me to predict (even if I had full knowledge of TLOP, etc.) what number the box will flash tomorrow? Indeed, if you make a good faith prediction about what number the box will flash tomorrow, will it necessarily be correct?


I was merely generalising the definition to account for the possibility of dualism and idealism. We can reliably know that whatever domain the mind exists in - physical, spiritual, whatever - it must exist in the context of sufficient predictable order to make thinking and choosing possible in the first place.

Yes, however much would be sufficient in that case. At a bare minimum, this order would be comprised of the rules of logic.


If your definition of free will includes not constrained even by the order that made it possible in the first place then you must see that this is a logical impossibility. You would be talking four-sided triangles. The result would be the same for dualism, idealism or any other ism you could care to mention.

Okay, I can see that it is impossible to will a logical contradiction. On the other hand, I really don't know what is the minimum order that makes free will possible. I somehow doubt that it has anything to do with physical laws; for example, hypothesizing a world in which no physical universe exists but at least one free-willed spirit exists does not appear to lead to a contradiction.


But if you allow that freedom might exist even under the constraints of the underlying order then freedom might equally exist in a mind that was made entirely of electro-chemical activity inside the brain.

I suppose a mind that was purely physical might possibly possess free will in a universe in which physical laws were at least partly non-deterministic. It hurts my head to think about the specifics, though. My gut feeling is that any free will that human beings have depends in part on the truth of the dualist thesis.
 
First of all, it's not clear to me that free will, if it exists, is an event at all. It is a property. An act of free will - that is, an instance of the exercise of the hypothetical faculty of free will - is of course an event, but, as I suggested, it's simply shorthand for "an act the proximate cause of which is the actor's free will". We might similarly speak of an act of passion, or an act of instinct - the very formulation indicates the presumed or hypothetical cause. Defining an act of free will as a wholly uncaused event is arguably self-contradictory.

You are using the same circular argument as Bri has done - always starting with nthe assumption that there is something called 'free will' when in fact, what we are really trying to discuss is whether or not the will can be considered free or not. You also have some confusion concerning our use of the term event so let me restate the position:


- The will is an agent capable of making choices.

- Each choice made by the will is an event (a change in the state of the will).

- The event must either be caused or not caused.

- If the event is caused (by whatsoever prior factors) then it is predetermined by those factors, hence it is not free.

- If the event is not caused then it is not controlled or otherwise influenced by the will.

Note that we have not (and do not need to) make any distinction between material and spiritual or between internal and external. We are only concerned that there is a change of some state that represents a choice made by the will.

Now - if you deem that the will can be said to be free on the basis that it might be influenced by uncaused events then there is nobody here that would argue with you. If so, you can say so now.

However - I do not think that this is what you and Bri mean by 'free will'. So, the question is (addressing the argument described in bold above), how can the will considered to be 'free' (assuming that you do not accept the definition in italics).
 
Last edited:
How? How would anythig be different if we could proove that we had "free" will, or "free will" or even free "will"? Nothing, from our POV would change. We'd still "make decisions" based on an accumulated set of inputs.

I know. I already said that. But, objectively speaking, it would make a difference.

To your final point here, my argument is that it's a non-senseical discussion. We cannot proove it one way or another, so any other argument based upon it is invalid.

I don't think it can't be proven, unless one contends that free will is a supernatural thing, in which case it becomes unfalsifiable. Otherwise we can pretty much show that it can't exist.
 
The reason it matters is because if we defy logic to accept this self-contradictory notion we present a chink in the armour of reason - If free will can be the caused yet uncaused, decisive yet disordered thing described by its proponents in this thread then pretty much anything goes - Gods, Magic and the fairies at the bottom of my garden.

You cannot effectively defend rationality if you accept that the irrational is possible.



I think we can and have. There are numerous workarounds that 'allow' free will to exist but they are invariably definitions of 'free will' along the lines of 'practical free will' or 'the illusion of free will'. Nobody is arguing that we do not feel like we have free will.

I fail to see how free will is considered to be of supernatural origin. At least, I know that I haven't presented it as such. To me, free will means being able to make up your own mind. I know there are some that will try to complicate this issue by attributing its origins to a deity, but seeng as I subscribe to an atheistic philosophy, I don't have that option, do I?

And how would you falsify free will? I'd really like to see THAT particular test. Remove all other influences on a person's decision making capability other than his will. Good luck.

Ok, if we can agree on the working terms of "practical free will" or some such, then I'll remove all arguments.
 
I know. I already said that. But, objectively speaking, it would make a difference.

What? How would it make a difference? Ya lost me on this one.

I don't think it can't be proven, unless one contends that free will is a supernatural thing, in which case it becomes unfalsifiable. Otherwise we can pretty much show that it can't exist.
Well, I can assure you that you'll never hear the supernatural source argument coming from me. At least not in any serious form. ;)
 
What? How would it make a difference? Ya lost me on this one.

Well... because it either exists or it doesn't. There is an ACTUAL difference between the two. If one says that free will is one of the many causes of a decision, and free will doesn't exist, then he is wrong. How this affects our subjective point of view is irrelevant. We're trying to determine if free will exists or not.
 
Well... because it either exists or it doesn't. There is an ACTUAL difference between the two. If one says that free will is one of the many causes of a decision, and free will doesn't exist, then he is wrong. How this affects our subjective point of view is irrelevant. We're trying to determine if free will exists or not.

But what is the actual difference?

If free will doens't exist will we stop making choices? Will we loose anything? Will our lives change in anyway? I doubt it. Ok, there'll be a certain segment of the population that goes through a philosophical breakdown, but at this point in history, the concept of determinism is not a new thing.

And how it affects our subjective POV is very much the point. If it doens't change anything, then WTF? Why argue this long over a pointless topic?

Again, as long as the person proposing or opposing free will doesn't try to tie their POV into a supernatural source, then what's the hu-hu? I see that the inputs to my decision making such a complex set as to be random; you say that no matter how complex it's still knowable. Ok, so what? I have yet to see the major philosophical connumdrums that this will posit later on.
 
The only reason the topic of free will came us is not because the world would seem different with/without it (indeed we cannot know if it would or not). If free will could be logically disproved or if it could be logically disproved that a certain property commonly considered to be possessed by God cannot exist alongside free will, then some refutations of the "Problem of Evil" could be discounted. In other words, proving that free will cannot exist alongside certain notions of God would take a tiny step towards advancing the idea put forth as the topic of this thread -- that it is a fact that there is no God.

Some have contended that such an iron-clad logical proof would be very difficult if not impossible, especially in light of the thousands of years of debate on the topic without a definitive answer. Others have contended that contained within the pages of this very thread is an actual bonefied iron-clad logical proof. Unfortunately, they have thus far been unwilling or unable to articulate exactly what the proof is. Even if they did and the proof was flawless, it would be only a very small advancement towards proving the subject of the thread.

-Bri
 
But what is the actual difference?

If free will doens't exist will we stop making choices? Will we loose anything? Will our lives change in anyway? I doubt it. Ok, there'll be a certain segment of the population that goes through a philosophical breakdown, but at this point in history, the concept of determinism is not a new thing.

Well, I think this is where I lost you. I'm not talking about the human point of view. Of course, from our point of view it doesn't change a thing. But then, whether gravitation is caused by gravitons or not also doesn't change a thing for us. But there is an actual difference in that gravitons either exist or they don't. Same thing here. Also, there is a procedural difference. If free will exists, then the causes of a choice are different than if it doesn't.

And how it affects our subjective POV is very much the point. If it doens't change anything, then WTF? Why argue this long over a pointless topic?

Well, you could ask the same question about a whole lot of topics.

Again, as long as the person proposing or opposing free will doesn't try to tie their POV into a supernatural source, then what's the hu-hu? I see that the inputs to my decision making such a complex set as to be random; you say that no matter how complex it's still knowable. Ok, so what? I have yet to see the major philosophical connumdrums that this will posit later on.

I'm not interested in the philosophical repercussions. I just want to know what the workings of a decision are. So far, it seems pretty much deterministic.
 
I fail to see how free will is considered to be of supernatural origin. At least, I know that I haven't presented it as such.

How you presented it is not the question. We are taking exception to how Bri and others have presented it. Their 'free will' is either impossible to define or a logical contradiction, this is what the argument is currently about.

One reason why this is important in the context of this thread is that 'God' is supposed to give us free will by which to decide whether to sin or not. If our actions are predetermined by the nature of His creation than how can he hold us to account? If you are not interested in the argument find another thread to read.

To me, free will means being able to make up your own mind.

Fine - nobody is disputing the everday usage of the term. However - when you use a loosely defined everday term in a philosophical/moral/religious argument like the one in this thread then you must examine its true nature before using it as a premise (or defend your use of it).

I know there are some that will try to complicate this issue by attributing its origins to a deity, but seeng as I subscribe to an atheistic philosophy, I don't have that option, do I?

I'm not suggesting otherwise but it appears that, even as an atheist, you are trying to undermine or ignore one of the logical premises that argues against the existence of the Christian (and various other flavours of) God. If you're not interested in the detailed logical argument, why contribute?

And how would you falsify free will? I'd really like to see THAT particular test. Remove all other influences on a person's decision making capability other than his will.

We do not need to falsify it in that way since the notion of 'free will' (in the sense that it is being debated here) is a logical contradiction.

Ok, if we can agree on the working terms of "practical free will" or some such, then I'll remove all arguments.

I think we all agree with that.
 
Even if they did and the proof was flawless, it would be only a very small advancement towards proving the subject of the thread.

-Bri

And on THAT point, you are absolutely right.

After all, it may well be that God exists, and that neither He nor we have absolute free will at all.
 
If it were proven that, for example, an omniscient God and free will cannot both exist, it would be a small but decidedly positive step towards a defense of the Problem of Evil. More accurately, it would remove those arguments against the Problem of Evil that rely on free will, at least as far as an omniscient God is concerned.

Of course, the Problem of Evil assumes omnibenevolence and there are other arguments against the Problem of Evil that don't rely on free will. And there are certainly those notions of God that might not fit within your particular definition of omniscience or omnibenevolence that would be unaffected, but let's not understate the importance of such a proof (if it exists and is unflawed) as a step in the right direction.

I, for one, am waiting anxiously.

-Bri
 
The only reason the topic of free will came us is not because the world would seem different with/without it (indeed we cannot know if it would or not). If free will could be logically disproved or if it could be logically disproved that a certain property commonly considered to be possessed by God cannot exist alongside free will, then some refutations of the "Problem of Evil" could be discounted. In other words, proving that free will cannot exist alongside certain notions of God would take a tiny step towards advancing the idea put forth as the topic of this thread -- that it is a fact that there is no God.

Some have contended that such an iron-clad logical proof would be very difficult if not impossible, especially in light of the thousands of years of debate on the topic without a definitive answer. Others have contended that contained within the pages of this very thread is an actual bonefied iron-clad logical proof. Unfortunately, they have thus far been unwilling or unable to articulate exactly what the proof is. Even if they did and the proof was flawless, it would be only a very small advancement towards proving the subject of the thread.

-Bri

Ok, now I see the issue. The problem is, that I see determinism as more demanding a deity than free will. I mean, who's doing the determining, eh?
 
Well, I think this is where I lost you. I'm not talking about the human point of view. Of course, from our point of view it doesn't change a thing. But then, whether gravitation is caused by gravitons or not also doesn't change a thing for us. But there is an actual difference in that gravitons either exist or they don't. Same thing here. Also, there is a procedural difference. If free will exists, then the causes of a choice are different than if it doesn't.

well, if gravity was caused by gravitons, it seriously increases our chances of discoveing a mechanism of controlling gravity, n'est pas?

Ok, but if our "choices" are the outgrowth of an anarchic "Free Will" or quasi-authortarian "Determinism" it doesn't change the fact that we still make them. I can understand that a lot of religious types like to proclaim that free will is a "gift from GAWD", but that's like saying that breath is a "gift from GAWD". So what? I've never really understood that particular line of reasoning.

God gave me the opportunity to think for myself, therefore he must exist due to the absence of His meddling in my thoughts...???

Now, determinisim, that smacks of divine intervention. GAWD wrote this here script, and we're a'following it.

I think it was Calvin that proposed the idea that if God was truely omniescent, then free will was an illusion and everything was predetermined.

That's probably more where my confusion is coming from. I see some of the more ardently atheistic members arguing against something that is more in line with the overall scientific approach and it sneds me realing. And then to spend nigh 1000 posts arguing over it.

Well, you could ask the same question about a whole lot of topics.

True. And i'm sure we will. Let's face it, we still argue the existance of God here, so...

I'm not interested in the philosophical repercussions. I just want to know what the workings of a decision are. So far, it seems pretty much deterministic.

And that throughly confuses me. Again, free will, even as usually defined by the Xians, is the ability to choose for yourself. Determinism is following some kind of script (not necessarily consciously).

Ok, ok, you say that the inputs are so complex as to be difficult to account for them all, but still, if you WERE able you could connect the dots and see how the "choice" follows the inputs. Ok, fine, if that's how you want to define determinism, it sounds fair, and as far as it goes, I can agree with you.

I tend to think that the inputs are so complex that we cannot ever hope to trace them all down in any coherant sense. We can make decisions freely, and act upon those decisions.

But here's the thing I'll keep coming back to. We can never perform a test that can prove either way conclusively.

To the religious base of this argument. So what if the religious types claim that god gave them free will. They could claim that He game them a kumquat and it wouldn't matter without the acceptance of the a prirori idea that God exists. Free Will/Determinism is a piss poor way to determine the existance/non-existance of a divine.
 
To the religious base of this argument. So what if the religious types claim that god gave them free will. They could claim that He game them a kumquat and it wouldn't matter without the acceptance of the a prirori idea that God exists. Free Will/Determinism is a piss poor way to determine the existance/non-existance of a divine.

Agreed. Ultimately, we don't have any way of knowing the final decision of the divine, as we get our scorecards after we die.

If there is free will with an omniscient Creator, we really shouldn't even have a scorecard, as we were simply doing what we were to do. It's no different than having no free will: the Creator knows your scorecard, so by setting what grade is passing you are predestined.

If there is no free will and an omniscient Creator, then we will be sorted as we were supposed to be sorted.

If there is free will and a non-omniscient Creator, then we are truly responsible for our own actions, and can correctly be judged rather than sorted.

If there is no free will and a non-omniscient Creator, then we are doing what we are supposed to do anyway, it's just that the scorecards are sorting that the Creator didn't peek at beforehand.

Any way you look at it there is no way to test this without getting a scorecard (i.e. returning with information from beyond death), so it is a moot point. Useless for determining or inferring the existence of a Creator.
 
One reason why this is important in the context of this thread is that 'God' is supposed to give us free will by which to decide whether to sin or not. If our actions are predetermined by the nature of His creation than how can he hold us to account? If you are not interested in the argument find another thread to read.

Gee, I'm sorry that I didn't read 900+ posts before commenting on this. Golly...



Fine - nobody is disputing the everday usage of the term. However - when you use a loosely defined everday term in a philosophical/moral/religious argument like the one in this thread then you must examine its true nature before using it as a premise (or defend your use of it).

Ok, would it be at all possible for the two sides to start to come to some sort of an agreement as to what ya'll are saying?

I'm not suggesting otherwise but it appears that, even as an atheist, you are trying to undermine or ignore one of the logical premises that argues against the existence of the Christian (and various other flavours of) God. If you're not interested in the detailed logical argument, why contribute?

Because, I can, doggamnit. :p

No, because this whole thread has been derailed by this argument. What I'm looking for here is some kind of closure on this topic so it can move on.

We do not need to falsify it in that way since the notion of 'free will' (in the sense that it is being debated here) is a logical contradiction.

i'll see if I can wade through the posts to see if I agree with that statement.
 
well, if gravity was caused by gravitons, it seriously increases our chances of discoveing a mechanism of controlling gravity, n'est pas?

That's N'est-ce pas, by the way.

However, I don't see how it would decrease our chances of discovering a mechanism of controlling gravity no matter HOW gravity works. As long as it is a naturalistic explanation, I think the controlling mechanism is there. I don't see why it would be harder without gravitons.

Ok, but if our "choices" are the outgrowth of an anarchic "Free Will" or quasi-authortarian "Determinism" it doesn't change the fact that we still make them.

No, and, as I said, gravitons or not, gravity exists. Still, if you're in a debate about the nature of gravity, knowing whether or not gravitons exist is important. If free will cannot exist, that's an important piece of argument against the christian God.

Now, determinisim, that smacks of divine intervention. GAWD wrote this here script, and we're a'following it.

If particle A hits particle B with a certain angle and a certain speed, you can bet that the outcome can be determined exactly. Why is that ? The governing rules of the universe ensure that the same outcome occurs every time. Now, if everything is composed of particles, everything should also be so determined.

That's probably more where my confusion is coming from. I see some of the more ardently atheistic members arguing against something that is more in line with the overall scientific approach and it sneds me realing. And then to spend nigh 1000 posts arguing over it.

Could you rephrase that ? I'm not sure I'm following you.

More later... gotta go.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom