There is No God (And You Know It)

Ok, would it be at all possible for the two sides to start to come to some sort of an agreement as to what ya'll are saying?

I believe that all parties acknowledge that God may not exist. However, the topic of the thread had to do with whether it could be proven that no God exists. Some of us have held that there is no reason to believe that it is impossible for many common notions of God to exist (not that they necessarily do exist, but that they might exist, and we simply cannot prove otherwise). Others claimed that they could offer logical proofs against the possibility of various combinations of omniscience, omnipotence, and omnibenevolence.

This eventually lead to the Problem of Evil, which lead to a discussion of libertarian free will, although to refute the Problem of Evil only requires the possibility that human suffering is for the greater good. Free will would be one explanation, but certainly not the only one.

Several logical arguments against varying combinations of omniscience (as it pertains to foreknowledge) and free will were made. I've heard both the claim that libertarian free will cannot exist if an omniscient God also exists and the claim that libertarian free will cannot exist at all. Neither of these claims really have much to do with the topic of the thread, but I would still be interested in seeing an actual logical proof of either based on the arguments made.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Okay... back from hell.

And that throughly confuses me. Again, free will, even as usually defined by the Xians, is the ability to choose for yourself. Determinism is following some kind of script (not necessarily consciously).

Not really. Consider this: if the universe comes from a random fluctuation, then, as soon as the "symmetry" breaks were done with, then the laws of physics as we know them were set. Do you know of anything that can break these laws ? I don't. So, if everything follows these laws, then everything, as soon as the laws were established, had to happen as they did.

I tend to think that the inputs are so complex that we cannot ever hope to trace them all down in any coherant sense. We can make decisions freely, and act upon those decisions.

The term "free" in free will does not mean that you KNOW, in advance, what the result is supposed to be. That very knowledge would be ANOTHER factor in reaching your decision; a factor that would also be pre-determined. Free will, by definition, means that we make decisions not purely based on physical factors or random chance. I don't see how this is possible

But here's the thing I'll keep coming back to. We can never perform a test that can prove either way conclusively.

I don't think it's necessary. If free will is logically impossible, then it must go, unless one contends that free will operates beyond the realm of logic.
 
Gee, I'm sorry that I didn't read 900+ posts before commenting on this. Golly...

I often post without reading the whole thread so I don't hold it against you.

No, because this whole thread has been derailed by this argument. What I'm looking for here is some kind of closure on this topic so it can move on.

Perhaps it has although my view is that if one of the premises (on both sides of the argument) is in doubt then resolving that doubt is not a derail.
 
Several logical arguments against varying combinations of omniscience (as it pertains to foreknowledge) and free will were made. I've heard both the claim that libertarian free will cannot exist if an omniscient God also exists and the claim that libertarian free will cannot exist at all. Neither of these claims really have much to do with the topic of the thread, but I would still be interested in seeing an actual logical proof of either based on the arguments made.

Apologies if anyone thinks I have contributed to derailing the thread. IMO, any thread that talks about 'free will' is fair game for the suggestion that the proponents thereof shoud define and defend the concept. If you don't want to, or can't, offer a logical defence of the premise then don't use it in an argument.

Despite the appeals to authority and irrelevance that have been made in this thread I have yet to see a logical refutation of the arguments made by the rationalists amongst us. Whenever a step-by-step argument is placed it is studiously ignored, whenever a logical conclusion is reached it is looped by supercillious suggestion several stages prior to its conclusion.

So, we come back to the question - given that all events must be either caused or uncaused, how can the will be described as 'free'?
 
You are using the same circular argument as Bri has done - always starting with nthe assumption that there is something called 'free will' when in fact, what we are really trying to discuss is whether or not the will can be considered free or not.

We've been trying to discuss a number of things, hodgy. But most recently what I've been trying to discuss is whether it can be proved that free will is logically impossible. A good way of doing that is to see whether an absurd or impossible conclusion must eventually be drawn if one assumes the existence of free will. This is not the place for a lesson in argumentation, but nothing I have said is circular.


You also have some confusion concerning our use of the term event so let me restate the position:

...

- Each choice made by the will is an event (a change in the state of the will).

I remarked on zaayrdragon's description of the will itself (not "each choice made by the will" as an event, and it is indeed a questionable characterization (and one which obviously differs from the one you just gave). Perhaps he simply made an inadvertent misstatement; nevertheless, the confusion is not on my side.


- The event must either be caused or not caused.

- If the event is caused (by whatsoever prior factors) then it is predetermined by those factors, hence it is not free.

- If the event is not caused then it is not controlled or otherwise influenced by the will.

...

So, the question is (addressing the argument described in bold above), how can the will considered to be 'free' (assuming that you do not accept the definition in italics).

I have a problem with this step: "If the event is caused (by whatsoever prior factors) then it is predetermined by those factors, hence it is not free." Although, as I alluded earlier, there is arguably a sense of determined that is roughly equivalent to caused, causation does not equal predestination in what I take to be the customary sense of determinism - which entails predictability in the limited sense I have elsewhere defined.
 
Apologies if anyone thinks I have contributed to derailing the thread.

I don't think you contributed to derailing the thread any more than anyone else, so no problem there.

IMO, any thread that talks about 'free will' is fair game for the suggestion that the proponents thereof shoud define and defend the concept. If you don't want to, or can't, offer a logical defence of the premise then don't use it in an argument.

I don't think there are any proponents of free will aside from those of us claiming that it probably cannot be disproven and is therefore possibly true. The problem with free will is that it's similar to God in that you can only identify properties that are common in definitions and attempt to disprove those properties. Certainly freedom to make actual choices is a common property of free will. The choices being undetermined by prior causes is another common property. The choices not being random is another common property.

Despite the appeals to authority and irrelevance that have been made in this thread I have yet to see a logical refutation of the arguments made by the rationalists amongst us.

I believe that every argument you have made has been refuted insofar as it has been shown to inadequately disprove the possibility of free will. You have certainly not met your burden of proof if you wish to show that free will is impossible.

Whenever a step-by-step argument is placed it is studiously ignored, whenever a logical conclusion is reached it is looped by supercillious suggestion several stages prior to its conclusion.

So, we come back to the question - given that all events must be either caused or uncaused, how can the will be described as 'free'?

I find any attempt to separate the words "free" and "will" to be awkward at best. Free will is a concept, not a thing, just as chance is a concept and not a thing. Free will is the freedom to make choices that are not determined by prior causes and that are also not random. So a free choice is "of free will" in the same sense that a random event is "by chance." In either case, the event is either entirely uncaused or influenced (but not determined) by prior causes.

I don't see any reason that a choice that is not determined by prior causes and is non-random couldn't be described as "free." Can you prove that such an event is impossible?

-Bri
 
That's N'est-ce pas, by the way.

Hey, cut me some slack, I'm an ignorant American not some Roughneck from Alberta.

However, I don't see how it would decrease our chances of discovering a mechanism of controlling gravity no matter HOW gravity works. As long as it is a naturalistic explanation, I think the controlling mechanism is there. I don't see why it would be harder without gravitons.



No, and, as I said, gravitons or not, gravity exists. Still, if you're in a debate about the nature of gravity, knowing whether or not gravitons exist is important. If free will cannot exist, that's an important piece of argument against the christian God.

1) To be able to control one of the natural forces, you have to understand it at a fundamental level. We really didn't start harnessing the electron until we realized that it was there.

2) How does free will act aginst the xian god? Ever read Calvin? There's an entire branch that believes that everything IS predestined. So knock out free will, all you've done is made more Methodists....<shudder> ;)




If particle A hits particle B with a certain angle and a certain speed, you can bet that the outcome can be determined exactly. Why is that ? The governing rules of the universe ensure that the same outcome occurs every time. Now, if everything is composed of particles, everything should also be so determined.

however, if you have as many inputs as you can muster, and the best you can do is reduce the number of strange attractors in the weather.

Besides, if we don't allow the woos to use quantum mechanics to explain away their pet theories, why should we allow amoungst our own ranks? What particles do have is a teneous, at best, effect at the macro, or Newtonian, level. Besides, at the particle level, almost everything is a probabilstic event anyhoo, that's the reason Schrodinger had such a problem that he theoretically non-killed that cat.

But, this is not the basis of the thread. I wasn't able to read all of them yet, but read enough to get the basis of the origional issue. It's a conflict between free will and God's alleged omni-benevelence and his alleged omnies..omniec...oh, chicken God knowing everything.

So. Let me get this straight. The argument started over one thing (that is assumed to be fictional) conflicting with another (which is ALSO assumed to be fictional).

Ok, and from there some "logical" proofs were posited. I'll have to read these before I pass comment.



Could you rephrase that ? I'm not sure I'm following you.

More later... gotta go.

Never mind.
 
Okay... back from hell.

Welcom back. Enjoy your trip?



Not really. Consider this: if the universe comes from a random fluctuation, then, as soon as the "symmetry" breaks were done with, then the laws of physics as we know them were set. Do you know of anything that can break these laws ? I don't. So, if everything follows these laws, then everything, as soon as the laws were established, had to happen as they did.

Ok, but since most of these laws have a probabalistic component in them that allows for multiple outcomes, what is the final arbitrer as to what outome is "chosen"?


The term "free" in free will does not mean that you KNOW, in advance, what the result is supposed to be. That very knowledge would be ANOTHER factor in reaching your decision; a factor that would also be pre-determined. Free will, by definition, means that we make decisions not purely based on physical factors or random chance. I don't see how this is possible

The more you expalin this to me Belz, the more I think that we're saying the same thing, just calling it different things. I've never (even in my fundy days) heard of a definition of free will being one that includes an ability to make totally random choices, but rather ones base off all the factors that brought us to this point. It kind of sounds like I'm limiting my POV to a time-bound frame, and you've broken that frame and are looking at it from an eternal POV.

I don't think it's necessary. If free will is logically impossible, then it must go, unless one contends that free will operates beyond the realm of logic.

I still maintain that free will isn't logically impossible. I still need to go back, but all the arguments i've read so far have had all the outputs being solely linear, which they aren't.
 
I often post without reading the whole thread so I don't hold it against you.



Perhaps it has although my view is that if one of the premises (on both sides of the argument) is in doubt then resolving that doubt is not a derail.

Ok, fair 'nuff. For my sake (and my poor eyes which are really geting fatigued from reading all the posts) could you summarize your position?
 
Apologies if anyone thinks I have contributed to derailing the thread. IMO, any thread that talks about 'free will' is fair game for the suggestion that the proponents thereof shoud define and defend the concept. If you don't want to, or can't, offer a logical defence of the premise then don't use it in an argument.

Despite the appeals to authority and irrelevance that have been made in this thread I have yet to see a logical refutation of the arguments made by the rationalists amongst us. Whenever a step-by-step argument is placed it is studiously ignored, whenever a logical conclusion is reached it is looped by supercillious suggestion several stages prior to its conclusion.

So, we come back to the question - given that all events must be either caused or uncaused, how can the will be described as 'free'?

Because, in nigh every case, there are multiple possible outcomes (e.g. the strange attractors from higher order differential equations) what "chooses" between each of the outcomes? I'll grant you that the probabability for each of the outcomes isn't equally distributed, but that doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.
 
I have a problem with this step: "If the event is caused (by whatsoever prior factors) then it is predetermined by those factors, hence it is not free." Although, as I alluded earlier, there is arguably a sense of determined that is roughly equivalent to caused, causation does not equal predestination in what I take to be the customary sense of determinism - which entails predictability in the limited sense I have elsewhere defined.

Since most of these philosophical ideas have been newly introduced to me, I've been making guesses, generally, at what certain terms mean. Since determinism, and the way folks here have discussed it, appears to mean a belief that all things are determined by antecedent conditions, that is what I have assumed it meant. ceo_esq, though, is offering a definition that seems to be less stringent and more vague, and admitting I know little of the term, I did what I always do when in doubt, on terminology: google define.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=define:determinism

Now, forgive me if it seems I'm cherry-picking; admittedly, I only checked the first few definitions. But there it is, fairly plainly: ranked by popularity, and therefore more 'customary', the top definitions are pretty clear: that determinism is "the teaching that every event in the universe is caused and controlled by natural law", etc. In fact, few of these first few definitions bothers with predictability, and instead focus on causation and deterministic factors prior to the choice in question. So even a random thing is, on some level, also a caused thing; and the only way for free will to be possible is if it is uncaused entirely - that is, if a decision made via free will is [at least partially] free from antecedent cause. The problem there being, the only way to know, for sure, that a decision IS made via free will, is to strip away all antecedents and determine if any such choice can still be made. This is not only difficult to do; it may very well be impossible for us to accomplish, at this stage of our knowledge.

If we become even more strident and rigid in our definitions, we could simply state that a decision made of our free will must be free of ALL antecedents, but if this is the case, then we are already discounting free will entirely, as no choice, action, or decision made by any person is free from some influence from some antecedent factor. And in spite of Bri's misunderstandings, an influence IS a causal factor. One cannot have an uncaused event that is influenced by some antecedent factor, I believe. All influences upon a given choice combine to form the cause of that choice.
 
Because, in nigh every case, there are multiple possible outcomes (e.g. the strange attractors from higher order differential equations) what "chooses" between each of the outcomes? I'll grant you that the probabability for each of the outcomes isn't equally distributed, but that doesn't mean that it doesn't exist.

It doesn't matter what 'chooses', only that the choice is either caused or not. What has 'higher order differential equations' got to do with it other than to obscure the real argument?
 
Ok, fair 'nuff. For my sake (and my poor eyes which are really geting fatigued from reading all the posts) could you summarize your position?

I will summarise my position on [your] definition of free will if you will kindly provide it. I would not want to make the assumption that you have the same defintion as Bri, for example, since I may well agree with your definition.
 
Hey, cut me some slack, I'm an ignorant American not some Roughneck from Alberta.

I was just trying to help.

1) To be able to control one of the natural forces, you have to understand it at a fundamental level. We really didn't start harnessing the electron until we realized that it was there.

True. I meant, in our current situation, whether gravity is mediated by gravitons or not doesn't make a difference.

2) How does free will act aginst the xian god? Ever read Calvin? There's an entire branch that believes that everything IS predestined. So knock out free will, all you've done is made more Methodists....<shudder> ;)

Maybe, but mainstream christianity pretty much requires the existence of free will. Otherwise, God made us all good or evil at the start. Pretty much makes the idea of a "judgment" useless.

Besides, if we don't allow the woos to use quantum mechanics to explain away their pet theories, why should we allow amoungst our own ranks? What particles do have is a teneous, at best, effect at the macro,

Since particles compose the "macro", then the macro is just as deterministic as the particles. Can we or can we not determine the outcome of a particle-to-particle interaction if we know all the variables ?

But, this is not the basis of the thread. I wasn't able to read all of them yet, but read enough to get the basis of the origional issue. It's a conflict between free will and God's alleged omni-benevelence and his alleged omnies..omniec...oh, chicken God knowing everything.

Chicken God ? Are we talking about the Great Brown Chicken here ?

Welcom back. Enjoy your trip?

Home, sweet home, man.

Ok, but since most of these laws have a probabalistic component in them that allows for multiple outcomes, what is the final arbitrer as to what outome is "chosen"?

They don't allow for multiple outcomes. It either happens or it doesn't. There is no "random" there. The only reason we call it random, in this case, is because we don't know all the variables. But make no mistake, there is only one possible outcome.

The more you expalin this to me Belz, the more I think that we're saying the same thing, just calling it different things. I've never (even in my fundy days) heard of a definition of free will being one that includes an ability to make totally random choices, but rather ones base off all the factors that brought us to this point. It kind of sounds like I'm limiting my POV to a time-bound frame, and you've broken that frame and are looking at it from an eternal POV.

Well, anyway. All I'm saying is, if the universe and all its laws are, as far as we can tell, completely deterministic or, in some cases, completely random, then our "choice" is only illusory, in that it is a direct consequence of those factors, random or not, that affect us, unless someone can come up with another, non-paranormal factor that we, somehow, control. I don't see this happening anytime soon.

I still maintain that free will isn't logically impossible. I still need to go back, but all the arguments i've read so far have had all the outputs being solely linear, which they aren't.

Well, it would help our discussion if you defined what free will is for you. How would you put it, if you had to make your own definition ? Let's work from there.
 
It doesn't matter what 'chooses', only that the choice is either caused or not. What has 'higher order differential equations' got to do with it other than to obscure the real argument?

Sorry, I probably should have explained that that was an illustration from mathematics and meterology where multiple outcomes are allowed and even expected. I (as I'll illustrate later) don't see free will as a linear event.

hodgy said:
I will summarise my position on [your] definition of free will if you will kindly provide it. I would not want to make the assumption that you have the same defintion as Bri, for example, since I may well agree with your definition.

Belz... said:
Well, it would help our discussion if you defined what free will is for you. How would you put it, if you had to make your own definition ? Let's work from there.

Ok, two requests, I guess I have to do it.

My definintion of Free Will
by Kenneth J. Mortis

Well, you see, every person is born with a certain genetic code, right? And they live their lives up to a point where a decision has to be made (ok, they will probably live PAST a goodly portion of their choises, but that's another story). These moments happen quite frequently, some would argue that a person lives their lives moment to moment making choices, I don't know about that, and that's beyond the scope of this missive.

So, the choice has to be made. All the events leading up to The Choicetm (genetic code, life events, mood etc et al) factor into reducing the total number of likely possible outcomes from a nigh infinite to a limited number. From this number (personal experience has led me to believe that on average this number is three, but I could be wrong) the person chooses one of them. Granted, it is still possible to choose an option that isn't in the limited set of highly possible, it's just <ahem> less likely.

Is this clear? Questions? Comments? Ken, yer a jerk?

PS Belz, The chicken comment should have read "oh, chicken, God knows everything" I hate, I hate, I hate this ergonomic keyboard.
 
The preamble is irrelevant...

...the person chooses one of them...

You specify that the person chooses - why do they choose? Does logic somehow stop at the boundary you call 'person' (like Bri's 'internal')?
 
How do you do the 'tm' superscript? I'd like to use that in sarcastic posts of my own.
 
BTW - varaiable probability of an outcome (given exact same inputs) is no different from uncaused events having an influence on the outcome.
 
I was just trying to help.

Actually, I should have known better. I took 7 years of French.

True. I meant, in our current situation, whether gravity is mediated by gravitons or not doesn't make a difference.

Right, but once we prove their existance, THAT makes a difference, grok?

Maybe, but mainstream christianity pretty much requires the existence of free will. Otherwise, God made us all good or evil at the start. Pretty much makes the idea of a "judgment" useless.

Methodists are fairly mainstream. I do get your jist tho, I'm just trying to point out that Christianity isn't monolithic on this subject, so be forwarned, you could run into one that believes in predetermination.

Since particles compose the "macro", then the macro is just as deterministic as the particles. Can we or can we not determine the outcome of a particle-to-particle interaction if we know all the variables ?

If that were true, then light would act as either a wave or a particle all the time. No, we cannot, we can only describe the probability field. Once the particle enters into a state, that prob. field collapses, and then we can know certain aspects (as described by Heisnburgh Uncertainty Law).

Home, sweet home, man.
Good, good..how's the wife and my kids? ;)



They don't allow for multiple outcomes. It either happens or it doesn't. There is no "random" there. The only reason we call it random, in this case, is because we don't know all the variables. But make no mistake, there is only one possible outcome.
Oh, sure, after the fact we can easily make up all sorts of ad hoc reasons why one choice was picked over another. Monday morning quarterbacking is a world-wide sport, possibly the most popular. But this doesn't remove the fact that at the time of the choice, many things could have been chosen. I can choose to sit here and continue to write this; I can go off and get some tea and THEN continue (hrmm...tea, that sounds good), I could stop right in the middle and give you all the cold sholder from now on (some of you might like it if I did this), etc, etc, etc. The choice I made (and continue to make) is to sit here and finish. Now, we could examine my psyche and figure out all the nuiances that went into my choice to finish this, but it still comes down to me making the choice to do it. No divine involved at all, is there? I don't need a god to "allow" me to have free will, it's just an innate part of living.

Well, anyway. All I'm saying is, if the universe and all its laws are, as far as we can tell, completely deterministic or, in some cases, completely random, then our "choice" is only illusory, in that it is a direct consequence of those factors, random or not, that affect us, unless someone can come up with another, non-paranormal factor that we, somehow, control. I don't see this happening anytime soon.
Lemme see if I correctly read this pararaph...
As far as we can tell:
1) The universe has laws governing it. Ok, so far so good.
2) These laws are completely deterministic. For the sake of argument, i'll allow this to pass with only this brief comment, saying that I'm letting it pass.
3) Or they're completely random (in 'select cases')....who/what does the selecting? Or, to put it less parjoritively, how does this selecting get done? How is the determination between the processes that are going to be "completely deterministic" (aka ORDERED) or "completely random" (aka CHAOTIC)?

Belz....you got some es'plainin' to dooooo.


Well, it would help our discussion if you defined what free will is for you. How would you put it, if you had to make your own definition ? Let's work from there.
Done.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom