I was just trying to help.
Actually, I should have known better. I took 7 years of French.
True. I meant, in our current situation, whether gravity is mediated by gravitons or not doesn't make a difference.
Right, but once we prove their existance, THAT makes a difference, grok?
Maybe, but mainstream christianity pretty much requires the existence of free will. Otherwise, God made us all good or evil at the start. Pretty much makes the idea of a "judgment" useless.
Methodists are fairly mainstream. I do get your jist tho, I'm just trying to point out that Christianity isn't monolithic on this subject, so be forwarned, you could run into one that believes in predetermination.
Since particles compose the "macro", then the macro is just as deterministic as the particles. Can we or can we not determine the outcome of a particle-to-particle interaction if we know all the variables ?
If that were true, then light would act as either a wave or a particle all the time. No, we cannot, we can only describe the probability field. Once the particle enters into a state, that prob. field collapses, and then we can know certain aspects (as described by Heisnburgh Uncertainty Law).
Good, good..how's the wife and my kids?
They don't allow for multiple outcomes. It either happens or it doesn't. There is no "random" there. The only reason we call it random, in this case, is because we don't know all the variables. But make no mistake, there is only one possible outcome.
Oh, sure, after the fact we can easily make up all sorts of ad hoc reasons why one choice was picked over another. Monday morning quarterbacking is a world-wide sport, possibly the most popular. But this doesn't remove the fact that at the time of the choice, many things could have been chosen. I can choose to sit here and continue to write this; I can go off and get some tea and THEN continue (hrmm...tea, that sounds good), I could stop right in the middle and give you all the cold sholder from now on (some of you might like it if I did this), etc, etc, etc. The choice I made (and continue to make) is to sit here and finish. Now, we could examine my psyche and figure out all the nuiances that went into my choice to finish this, but it still comes down to me making the choice to do it. No divine involved at all, is there? I don't need a god to "allow" me to have free will, it's just an innate part of living.
Well, anyway. All I'm saying is, if the universe and all its laws are, as far as we can tell, completely deterministic or, in some cases, completely random, then our "choice" is only illusory, in that it is a direct consequence of those factors, random or not, that affect us, unless someone can come up with another, non-paranormal factor that we, somehow, control. I don't see this happening anytime soon.
Lemme see if I correctly read this pararaph...
As far as we can tell:
1) The universe has laws governing it. Ok, so far so good.
2) These laws are completely deterministic. For the sake of argument, i'll allow this to pass with only this brief comment, saying that I'm letting it pass.
3) Or they're completely random (in 'select cases')....who/what does the selecting? Or, to put it less parjoritively, how does this selecting get done? How is the determination between the processes that are going to be "completely deterministic" (aka ORDERED) or "completely random" (aka CHAOTIC)?
Belz....you got some es'plainin' to dooooo.
Well, it would help our discussion if you defined what free will is for you. How would you put it, if you had to make your own definition ? Let's work from there.
Done.