There is No God (And You Know It)

Correct, a random phenomenon is a phenomenon that cannot be predicted, but not necessarily the only type of phenomenon that cannot be predicted.

Well, frankly you're just plain wrong, obviously wrong, by definition wrong. If you cannot predict an event it is random, that's how the rest of the world defines it, good luck in your little corner of the universe. Even if for the sake of arguement we withhold the obvious, that still leaves us with the unanswered question, if you're making up this new term for a phenominon that is non-predictable and non-random, what is the difference between a non-random non-predictable phenominon and a random non-predicatable phenominon?

The same way that a caused event differs from a random event: it's not random.

??? A caused event differs from a random event in that one is predictable and the other is not. That is not the difference between a random event and a "free" event, or whatever you want to call it, sense you're making this stuff up I suppose you can call it whatever you want. Both a random event and a "free" event are unpredictable, so I'll ask you again, what is the difference?

However, I'm not certain that we would be able to tell the difference between a caused event (where the causes are unknown), a random event, or a free event if that's what you're asking.

You can't tell the difference between a caused event (where the causes are unknown) and a random event in the same sense that you can't tell the difference between a blue object and a red object if you can't see what color they are. That's hardly relevent or thought provoking. If there's no possible way to tell the difference between a random event and a free event, then a free event is random. You may, like Clinton, be struggling with the definition of the word IS, but I assure you that you have stated in slightly different language that a free event is random.
 
Uhhh...that was my point. Very little if anything in science is a fact (I think that's exactly what I said)! If you would like to prove me wrong, then you name one thing in science that is a fact, otherwise we are in agreement.

We aren't. You've simply proven that you don't believe in facts. That speaks volumes about your outlook on reality.

I don't. It was you who were asking for an explanation of free will.

Then why in Hephaistos' name were you asking me about randomness ?

True, free will cannot exist if everything is either random or determined. However, perhaps everything is not either random or determined.

Perhaps, but I am not inclined to consider that possibility unless someone, you or someone else, shows that the idea is even coherent.

Belz, please go back and re-read the discussion before responding. This is getting somewhat tiring, my having to continually recap the conversation so you don't lose track of what's been said previously.

You initially demanded that I explain how free will works. I said that it isn't necessary to explain how something works to theorize that it exists, in the same way that science cannot explain how randomness works but yet theorizes that randomness exists.

Bri, please understand what terms mean before responding. This is getting somewhat tiring, my having to continually explain things so you don't lose track of the issue.

Your examples are flawed. Science theorises the existence of randomness, but the THEORY is well-supported by evidence. You allege the possible existence of free will, but you have no evidence to support it. In fact, you don't even know what free will is or what it could be like. To make matters worse, your idea goes against known physics, which puts you in the place of the claimant.

Again, your burden.
 
You don't have to show anyone that free will exists any more than you have to show anyone that consciousness exists. That we can't do this is irrelevant since indemonstrable to others does not equal without evidence.

Then I submit you don't know what the word EVIDENCE, in the scientific context, means.
 
Originally Posted by HypnoPsi :
You don't have to show anyone that free will exists any more than you have to show anyone that consciousness exists. That we can't do this is irrelevant since indemonstrable to others does not equal without evidence.
Then I submit you don't know what the word EVIDENCE, in the scientific context, means.
And I offer you are confusing it with the burden of proof. The words evidence and demonstrable are not synonymous.
_
HypnoPsi
 
And I offer you are confusing it with the burden of proof. The words evidence and demonstrable are not synonymous.
_
HypnoPsi

This thread has described repeatedly and in great detail that 'free will' does not exist. It has done that using logic, that is the only evidence that it needs to be demonstrable.
 
This thread has described repeatedly and in great detail that 'free will' does not exist. It has done that using logic, that is the only evidence that it needs to be demonstrable.

Hodgy, so far as we know, no one in history has heretofore successfully been able to establish that free will does not exist. You think we've managed to do it in this thread? Come on.

By the way, don't confuse "logic" with "evidence". Logic is used to deduce a priori truths; evidence is used to ascertain a posteriori truths. They're completely different beasts.
 
Hodgy, so far as we know, no one in history has heretofore successfully been able to establish that free will does not exist. You think we've managed to do it in this thread? Come on.

IT seems as if you are bothered by the idea that a bunch of armchair philosophers might have adequately done something that your adored authority figures have not. Frankly, your appeal to authority is noted, and your opinion subsequently graded on that note.

Although I don't think there is any one point within this thread where a formal proof of the non-existence of free will has been stated, I think that, overall, this thread contains all the necessary elements of that proof. Certainly, the overall gist of this thread is that free-will is nothing more than a convenient illusion, UNLESS we subscribe to a form of interactive dualism - which is fraught with its own metaphysical problems - or immaterial idealism, in either case, that is atheistic in nature.

You know, the 'great thinkers' of history started off just like we are now. Who knows? Five hundred years from now, the collected postings of Belz might be the current authority on the subject. Don't go grasping for authority, just because some amateurs have come up with something you don't like.
 
You know, the 'great thinkers' of history started off just like we are now. Who knows? Five hundred years from now, the collected postings of Belz might be the current authority on the subject. Don't go grasping for authority, just because some amateurs have come up with something you don't like.


:eek: :p

I guess it could be worse...it could be MY posts that become the future authority.
 
Hodgy, so far as we know, no one in history has heretofore successfully been able to establish that free will does not exist. You think we've managed to do it in this thread? Come on.

I don't care if they have or haven't. What's in this thread is proof enough for me, please fell free to address the points rasied and show how they are wrong. I would welcome a genuine challenge to my argument - for someone to show me a logical possibility that I haven't previously considered (I'm bored of my current position as it can't be developed any further at present).

I apologise that I am not a mathematician so I cannot present a mathematical proof. Likewise I aplogise for not being able to quote several passages of well-known philosophers' b******t to lend bogus credibility to my argument.

By the way, don't confuse "logic" with "evidence". Logic is used to deduce a priori truths; evidence is used to ascertain a posteriori truths. They're completely different beasts.

I think it is perfectly reasonable to present logic as evidence although I take your point on the strict definition. I think my argument is a priori but I am being asked to present evidence - you will see in my posts that I suggested that I did not need to do so (implicitly because my argument is a priori). I did not make the formal distinction because I did not think it was necessary to convey the meaning.
 
You know, the 'great thinkers' of history started off just like we are now. Who knows? Five hundred years from now, the collected postings of Belz might be the current authority on the subject. Don't go grasping for authority, just because some amateurs have come up with something you don't like.

Better believe it, son.
 
Hodgy, so far as we know, no one in history has heretofore successfully been able to establish that free will does not exist. You think we've managed to do it in this thread? Come on.

By the way, don't confuse "logic" with "evidence". Logic is used to deduce a priori truths; evidence is used to ascertain a posteriori truths. They're completely different beasts.
As far as we know no one in history has heretofore successfully been able to describe precisely what they mean by free will, except in a determinist sense. Even the definition given here in support of the concept says in effect 'determined by our nature'. That is still 'determined'.

That would be about right, if free will were not determined by our nature then it would not be our will but some independent will.
 
Likewise I aplogise for not being able to quote several passages of well-known philosophers' b******t to lend bogus credibility to my argument.
It should be pointed out that so far no passages (bs or otherwise) from well-known philosophers have been presented so far to define and defend the idea of non-deterministic free will.

I, for one, would be interested in seeing this argument if one such exists.

The only real defense of non-deterministic free will that has been presented is the claim that most people believe that they have this type of free will.

Well that is a claim that needs to be justified like every other. As far as I know the person in the street would not describe their decisions as 'undetermined' or 'uncaused' - most would be happy with the idea that their choices were determined by pre-existing things like their intelligence, skills, knowledge, beliefs, attitudes, desires etc.

Most people regard themselves as largely being in control of their decisions and control is more compatible with determinism than non-determinism.
 
IT seems as if you are bothered by the idea that a bunch of armchair philosophers might have adequately done something that your adored authority figures have not.

Not at all. I would find that prospect absolutely appealing, believe me. I don't see that here, however.

Frankly, your appeal to authority is noted, and your opinion subsequently graded on that note.

That was not really an appeal to authority, at least of the fallacious variety - as it would be if I had, say, argued that because some authority believes that free will exists (or at least that its non-existence cannot be established), that it is so. Hodgy's assertion about what has been accomplished here simply seems dubious to me in a probabilistic sense - and I am basing this largely on what I've seen here, not merely what I've seen elsewhere.

Although I don't think there is any one point within this thread where a formal proof of the non-existence of free will has been stated, I think that, overall, this thread contains all the necessary elements of that proof.

Great. I'm open to correction. Would somebody please distill the argument?
 
It should be pointed out that so far no passages (bs or otherwise) from well-known philosophers have been presented so far to define and defend the idea of non-deterministic free will.

I, for one, would be interested in seeing this argument if one such exists.

The only real defense of non-deterministic free will that has been presented is the claim that most people believe that they have this type of free will.

Well that is a claim that needs to be justified like every other. As far as I know the person in the street would not describe their decisions as 'undetermined' or 'uncaused' - most would be happy with the idea that their choices were determined by pre-existing things like their intelligence, skills, knowledge, beliefs, attitudes, desires etc.

Most people regard themselves as largely being in control of their decisions and control is more compatible with determinism than non-determinism.

Correct
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom