CaptainManacles
Muse
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2005
- Messages
- 821
Correct, a random phenomenon is a phenomenon that cannot be predicted, but not necessarily the only type of phenomenon that cannot be predicted.
Well, frankly you're just plain wrong, obviously wrong, by definition wrong. If you cannot predict an event it is random, that's how the rest of the world defines it, good luck in your little corner of the universe. Even if for the sake of arguement we withhold the obvious, that still leaves us with the unanswered question, if you're making up this new term for a phenominon that is non-predictable and non-random, what is the difference between a non-random non-predictable phenominon and a random non-predicatable phenominon?
The same way that a caused event differs from a random event: it's not random.
??? A caused event differs from a random event in that one is predictable and the other is not. That is not the difference between a random event and a "free" event, or whatever you want to call it, sense you're making this stuff up I suppose you can call it whatever you want. Both a random event and a "free" event are unpredictable, so I'll ask you again, what is the difference?
However, I'm not certain that we would be able to tell the difference between a caused event (where the causes are unknown), a random event, or a free event if that's what you're asking.
You can't tell the difference between a caused event (where the causes are unknown) and a random event in the same sense that you can't tell the difference between a blue object and a red object if you can't see what color they are. That's hardly relevent or thought provoking. If there's no possible way to tell the difference between a random event and a free event, then a free event is random. You may, like Clinton, be struggling with the definition of the word IS, but I assure you that you have stated in slightly different language that a free event is random.