There is No God (And You Know It)

Name one that is.

Name one what that is what?


That article explains how the universe might be the result of uncaused randomness. In other words, it assumes that randomness exists, but it doesn't explain randomness. If we assume that free will exists, I can show how events that are the result of free will can exist, but I don't think that's the question you were asking.

Again, you weren't paying attention. You said that, if I couldn't support what I claimed [personnally], then basically I wasn't worth listening to. In other words, if _I_ can't prove it, it isn't so.

I like how you placed "personally" in brackets like that. Actually, I meant that quantum physics CAN be true even though you can't explain it, personally or otherwise. So, you've proven my point, that free will can also be true without my being able to explain to you exactly how it might work.

-Bri
 
No, you didn't. You said that free will is something "uncaused" but "non-random". That's not a definition, because we have no idea of that could be uncaused AND non-random.

Belz, I posted the following definition both here and here:

Bri said:
Simply stated, when one has acted of one's own free will, one could have done otherwise, and one was the ultimate source of the action. In order to be the ultimate source of one's action, some condition necessary for the action must originate within oneself (rather than externally).

You even commented on the definition, so I know you saw it. You are starting to waste my time again by making me search back through old posts.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I challenged you on that a number of posts ago - are you deliberately ignoring it?

No, I've already responded to it. Uncaused simply means without cause. It doesn't mean random. If you're using the term "uncaused" to mean "random" then you're using a different definition than I am.

Uncaused means absence of cause.

I agree.

There is not a cause called 'randomness', rather, the term random is an attribute of an uncaused (hypothetically) event.

Random events may be uncaused, but the opposite is not necessarily true. You can also say the same about free will, by the way. There is not a cause called 'free will', rather, the term free will is an attribute of an uncaused event. Except that I would describe free will (if it exists) as an attribute of some uncaused events since others might be random.

Another aspect I challenged you on was your persistent use of circular logic (the will can be said to be free because of the possibility of free will).

Interesting, you use the same logic to explain random events. Events can be random because of the possibility of randomness. And I said that if you provide a different explanation of random events, I'll give you a different explanation of free events.

You are persisting with this approach by using the term 'free will' rather than addressing the 'will' and showing how it can be considered free (your answer has consistently been 'because of free will').

I don't claim that anything else can be free except for will, although there is probably no reason to believe that other things cannot be free. Will can be free in the same way that it could be random or deterministic. I already explained that.

We have provided repeated explanations and definitions to our terms (including uncaused / random being the absence of cause) whereas you have refused to define how your free events are in any way different from our standard random events.

You're attempting to define "a pig" as "a horse" and then say that a pig can't exist because if it did, it would be a horse. If you define "uncaused" to be "random" and then I claim that free will is uncaused, you say that it can't be because then it would be random. Please don't talk to me about the use of circular logic!

-Bri
 
Last edited:
That article explains how the universe might be the result of uncaused randomness. In other words, it assumes that randomness exists, but it doesn't explain randomness.

I am not disputing that there is a logical possibility of random events. Linking that article is an unnecesarily complicated way of saying you agree that events can logically be random (a point that I have never contested).

If we assume that free will exists, I can show how events that are the result of free will can exist, but I don't think that's the question you were asking.

:) Of course - if we all '...assume that free will exists...' - this is exactly the circular argument that I have previously criticised you for.
 
I am not disputing that there is a logical possibility of random events. Linking that article is an unnecesarily complicated way of saying you agree that events can logically be random (a point that I have never contested).

That post was in response to Belz, not you.

Of course - if we all '...assume that free will exists...' - this is exactly the circular argument that I have previously criticised you for.

I was pointing out Belz's circular logic -- I wasn't making that assumption myself!

-Bri
 
No, I've already responded to it. Uncaused simply means without cause. It doesn't mean random. If you're using the term "uncaused" to mean "random" then you're using a different definition than I am.

Tel you what - let's stop using the term random. It seems to me that you are exploiting the (tenuous) semantic argument to dodge the logic - so let's just talk about caused and uncaused events.

Random events may be uncaused, but the opposite is not necessarily true.

What is the opposite of this statement?

You can also say the same about free will, by the way. There is not a cause called 'free will', rather, the term free will is an attribute of an uncaused event. Except that I would describe free will (if it exists) as an attribute of some uncaused events since others might be random.

As I said - in order to make headway let's forget the term random and just discuss caused and uncaused.

There are 4 factors at play in the state of a will at the point that it makes a choice (an event). 3 of the factors are caused by previous events. The 4th factor is an uncaused event (it just happened for no reason). Where is your free will there?
 
No, I've already responded to it. Uncaused simply means without cause. It doesn't mean random. If you're using the term "uncaused" to mean "random" then you're using a different definition than I am.

A cause is a conceptual model that allows prediction of a phenominon. A random phenominon is a phenominon that cannot be predicted, most often defined in a subjective sense, but in most philosophical arguements objective randomness is discussed. If you are using definitions other than these, please eleborate, because these are the definitions everyone else uses. These defintions are clearly mutually exclusive, either an event can be predicted or it cannot.

You can at least concede that free will ads a measure of unpredictibility to an agent, yes? How then does this concept of "free will" differ from normal randomness?
 
Name one what that is what?

Name one thing in science that is a fact.

That article explains how the universe might be the result of uncaused randomness. In other words, it assumes that randomness exists, but it doesn't explain randomness. If we assume that free will exists, I can show how events that are the result of free will can exist, but I don't think that's the question you were asking.

Well, if you want a full discourse of quantum physics, you're asking the wrong layman. Still, I don't see how free will can exist if everything is either random or determined. Even assuming that randomness does not exist, all we're left with is determinism, which pretty much precludes free will.

I like how you placed "personally" in brackets like that.

Would I have been justified to NOT place them in brackets ? I added them because that was my interpretation, and I didn't want you to think I was putting words in your mouth.

Actually, I meant that quantum physics CAN be true even though you can't explain it, personally or otherwise. So, you've proven my point, that free will can also be true without my being able to explain to you exactly how it might work.

How the hell did I prove that ? You said YOU meant that it CAN be true, not I.
 
Tel you what - let's stop using the term random. It seems to me that you are exploiting the (tenuous) semantic argument to dodge the logic - so let's just talk about caused and uncaused events.

OK.

Bri said:
Random events may be uncaused, but the opposite is not necessarily true.
What is the opposite of this statement?

That uncaused events are random is not necessarily true.

There are 4 factors at play in the state of a will at the point that it makes a choice (an event). 3 of the factors are caused by previous events. The 4th factor is an uncaused event (it just happened for no reason). Where is your free will there?

It's not necessarily free, but it could be free. If the uncaused factor is free, then the will is free.

-Bri
 
A cause is a conceptual model that allows prediction of a phenominon.

Agreed.

A random phenominon is a phenominon that cannot be predicted, most often defined in a subjective sense, but in most philosophical arguements objective randomness is discussed.

Correct, a random phenomenon is a phenomenon that cannot be predicted, but not necessarily the only type of phenomenon that cannot be predicted. Free will, if it exists, also cannot be predicted.

If you are using definitions other than these, please eleborate, because these are the definitions everyone else uses. These defintions are clearly mutually exclusive, either an event can be predicted or it cannot.

I don't know if others are using different definitions. I do agree that an event can either be predicted or not. I do not agree that an event which cannot be predicted must be random.

You can at least concede that free will ads a measure of unpredictibility to an agent, yes?

Absolutely. It's unpredictable in the sense that it cannot be predicted 100% of the time with 100% accuracy as caused events can (if all contributing causes are known).

How then does this concept of "free will" differ from normal randomness?

The same way that a caused event differs from a random event: it's not random. However, I'm not certain that we would be able to tell the difference between a caused event (where the causes are unknown), a random event, or a free event if that's what you're asking.

-Bri
 
Originally Posted by hodgy :
There are 4 factors at play in the state of a will at the point that it makes a choice (an event). 3 of the factors are caused by previous events. The 4th factor is an uncaused event (it just happened for no reason). Where is your free will there?

It's not necessarily free, but it could be free. If the uncaused factor is free, then the will is free.

And so now define 'free' in the context you have used it here. Don't forget - we have stopped arguing about the meaning of the term random - I'm not using it so you have no reason to use it in your definition.

To be clear - you need to show that an uncaused event can be 'free' where you are going to provide us with your meaning of the word 'free' (in this context).
 
Name one thing in science that is a fact.

Uhhh...that was my point. Very little if anything in science is a fact (I think that's exactly what I said)! If you would like to prove me wrong, then you name one thing in science that is a fact, otherwise we are in agreement.

Well, if you want a full discourse of quantum physics, you're asking the wrong layman.

I don't. It was you who were asking for an explanation of free will.

Still, I don't see how free will can exist if everything is either random or determined.

True, free will cannot exist if everything is either random or determined. However, perhaps everything is not either random or determined.

Even assuming that randomness does not exist, all we're left with is determinism, which pretty much precludes free will.

True, neither randomness nor free will can exist if everything is determined. But perhaps everything is not determined.

Would I have been justified to NOT place them in brackets ? I added them because that was my interpretation, and I didn't want you to think I was putting words in your mouth.

You mischaracterized my whole statement, so I don't think it mattered if you put it in brackets or not.

How the hell did I prove that ? You said YOU meant that it CAN be true, not I.

Belz, please go back and re-read the discussion before responding. This is getting somewhat tiring, my having to continually recap the conversation so you don't lose track of what's been said previously.

You initially demanded that I explain how free will works. I said that it isn't necessary to explain how something works to theorize that it exists, in the same way that science cannot explain how randomness works but yet theorizes that randomness exists. You then continued to demand that I explain it, and posted an article as "explanation" of randomness. I pointed out that the article didn't explain randomness, but rather used the assumption of randomness to explain the existance of the universe. You then correctly pointed out that just because you can't explain randomness doesn't mean that it isn't true. Then I said that, yes, that is exactly what I was saying all along, and the same holds true for free will. That I cannot explain how free will works, but that doesn't mean it isn't true.

-Bri
 
And so now define 'free' in the context you have used it here. Don't forget - we have stopped arguing about the meaning of the term random - I'm not using it so you have no reason to use it in your definition.

To be clear - you need to show that an uncaused event can be 'free' where you are going to provide us with your meaning of the word 'free' (in this context).

Webster's definition will suffice:

2 a : not determined by anything beyond its own nature or being : choosing or capable of choosing for itself

-Bri
 
As Zaaydragon said, the other options that you discussed at so much length, are just that - other options. The same logic applies to those options as to the original 2.
I disagree entirely and don't see how any real explanation has been offerred.
I do not need to know the actual cause of anything to appreciate the simple logical truth that events must be either caused or not caused.
So, events are caused and some degree of creative will is the cause. What of it?
_
HypnoPsi
 
That definition is fine by me. The book in the safe exists on the timeline at a given point prior to all events in John's life, so the infallibly true statements about John's life count as predictions under this definition.

The book in the safe does not fully exist at a given point on the timeline in the sense which I was intending. The antecedent conditions and causal laws on which a "prediction" could be based, in the defined sense I have offered, would be more along the lines of: the location, nature and activity of every particle in the universe (to the extent logically ascertainable), plus all laws of physics, logic, causality, and so forth, each as it exists at a given time t prior to the predicted phenomenon. This is a non-exhaustive description intended only to give an example of the types of things I'm talking about; the book in the safe is definitely outside my (no doubt imperfectly) offered definition.


I am not aware of one. It is impossible nevertheless.

I hope I am not unreasonable in withholding my assent until such a proof is forthcoming.
 
We cannot show that free will doesn't exist any more than we can show that it does exist, clearly or otherwise.
You don't have to show anyone that free will exists any more than you have to show anyone that consciousness exists. That we can't do this is irrelevant since indemonstrable to others does not equal without evidence.

That we experience ourselves as having the ability to choose between options (deterministic will), to create an entirely new option (creative will) or to choose not to take any action at all (free will) is obvious. That this is all actually 'deterministic' and governed by brain activity is theory and nothing more.

The burden of proof isn't on you here. As per Sagan's dictum that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence the claim being made (that brains cause consciousness and the illusion of free will) is that which has to be proven (and can't be).
_
HypnoPsi
 
Robin, are you a native English speaker? You are exploiting an ambiguity in the English language, which can be hilighted by the following two statements:


It is possible that God exists.
It is possible for God to exist.
​
The ambiguity is all yours. The sentences differ in the tense of the verb clause and the fact that they use the tense-appropriate conjunction.

The first implies the second. It would not be possible that X exists unless it were possible for X to exist.

Or are you saying that you are using "possible" in it's colloquial sense of "It is possible I will go to the shops this afternoon"?

Is is not reasonable to assume that in a discussion of this nature the word 'possible' is used in the sense 'logically possible'?

Either way, would you then agree that the following statements are all false?
Unless you can prove that free will is impossible, you must admit that it is logically possible.
Free will is a logical possibility because it's not impossible
Free will is logically possible unless it can be proven impossible. Since it has yet to be proven that free will is impossible, it is assumed to be logically possible.
Yes, everything is logically possible unless proven otherwise.
Unfalsifiable theories are logically possible because they cannot be proven impossible.
 
The burden of proof isn't on you here. As per Sagan's dictum that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence the claim being made (that brains cause consciousness and the illusion of free will) is that which has to be proven (and can't be).
You are confusing two concepts "evidence" and "proof". Except in a mathematical sense we have very little or no proof of anything. But we have a towering weight of evidence that the brain causes consciousness.

But even if the brain did not cause consciousness, how would that make it any more likely that we have free will?
 
Bri is a liar. Shall I link to my previous post, or just point out some of the newer lies?
 
Originally Posted by hodgy :
And so now define 'free' in the context you have used it here. Don't forget - we have stopped arguing about the meaning of the term random - I'm not using it so you have no reason to use it in your definition.

To be clear - you need to show that an uncaused event can be 'free' where you are going to provide us with your meaning of the word 'free' (in this context).

Webster's definition will suffice:

2 a : not determined by anything beyond its own nature or being : choosing or capable of choosing for itself

Ok, good. Clearly there are 2 clauses in this defintion, the 2nd one would be applicable to a chooser but not to a choice (our event).

Which leaves us with your definition of a free event being 'not determined by anything...'. So, your free event is just a plain uncaused event - do you agree? Let's get this point settled before proceeding.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom