Name one thing in science that is a fact.
Uhhh...that was my point. Very little if anything in science is a fact (I think that's exactly what I said)! If you would like to prove me wrong, then you name one thing in science that is a fact, otherwise we are in agreement.
Well, if you want a full discourse of quantum physics, you're asking the wrong layman.
I don't. It was you who were asking for an explanation of free will.
Still, I don't see how free will can exist if everything is either random or determined.
True, free will cannot exist if everything is either random or determined. However, perhaps everything is
not either random or determined.
Even assuming that randomness does not exist, all we're left with is determinism, which pretty much precludes free will.
True, neither randomness nor free will can exist if everything is determined. But perhaps everything is
not determined.
Would I have been justified to NOT place them in brackets ? I added them because that was my interpretation, and I didn't want you to think I was putting words in your mouth.
You mischaracterized my whole statement, so I don't think it mattered if you put it in brackets or not.
How the hell did I prove that ? You said YOU meant that it CAN be true, not I.
Belz, please go back and re-read the discussion before responding. This is getting somewhat tiring, my having to continually recap the conversation so you don't lose track of what's been said previously.
You initially demanded that I explain how free will works. I said that it isn't necessary to explain how something works to theorize that it exists, in the same way that science cannot explain how randomness works but yet theorizes that randomness exists. You then continued to demand that I explain it, and posted an article as "explanation" of randomness. I pointed out that the article didn't explain randomness, but rather used the assumption of randomness to explain the existance of the universe. You then correctly pointed out that just because you can't explain randomness doesn't mean that it isn't true. Then I said that, yes, that is exactly what I was saying all along, and the same holds true for free will. That I cannot explain how free will works, but that doesn't mean it isn't true.
-Bri