There is No God (And You Know It)

No, we're not talking about hypotheticals. Whether or not God exists, we don't know that God exists. Since we don't know whether God exists, it is possible that he does exist and it is possible that he doesn't. The burden of proof lies on the person claiming that it is impossible for God to exist or claiming that it is impossible for God not to exist (i.e. that God must exist).
I said nothing of hypotheticals. I am not even sure what you mean by that statement. Let me ask you again - if God exists then would it be possible that he simultaneously doesn't exist? Would that change if nobody knows he exists?

If I ask someone "Can we complete this project for under $50,000?" and he says "I don't know" then I don't interpret this to mean "It is possible to bring this project in under $50,000".

On the other hand if someone tells me "It is possible to complete this project for under $50,000" then I would expect that he has done at least some initial costings and does not mean "I don't know whether or not this project will cost under $50,000".

Similarly if someone says "It is possible for God to exist" I would expect some justification for this statement.

It is simply absurd to say that not knowing about something makes it possible. If someone claims that it is possible that God exists then they are making a positive statement which requires justification.

If you don't know that something exists then you also don't know if it is possible for that thing to exist.
So you actually believe that for thousands of years nobody has given the matter serious thought and come to the opposite conclusion? Amazing!
If you are going to appeal to authority at least have an authority in mind. "I'm sure someone must have come to the opposite conclusion" is a weak response to a deductive argument. Point me to someone who has given the matter of omniscience, free will and immanence serious thought and come to the opposite conclusion and I will have a look at their argument.

But as far as I can see theologians from Augustine onwards have tended to the view that if God does anything he must do everything. There are various attempts to camoflage this basically determinist position by stating that God, for example, knows exactly how a free agent will act in any given circumstances.
You've aparently managed to convince yourself, that much is certain.
Whether or not I have convinced myself is immaterial - where is the fault in my argument?
If you actually feel that you have proven it, please feel free to submit your proof to a peer-reviewed scientific or philosophical journal.
I don't know of any scientific journals that consider the existence or otherwise of God, do you? I doubt that omniscience and immanence have much currency outside of theology.

I doubt in any case that I am the first to demonstrate these results. If you know of anybody that has a good argument showing that it is possible for an omniscient being to participate in a world that contains free will please let me know.
 
Last edited:
It was cool once, Kumar. Twice is spamming. I'm reporting you and nominating you for the same post on two different threads.

No, one is relevant to "omnipotence", other to "omniscience" still other to "God". Why you people posted so many threads on one enrity. Is it not spam/creating confusions type postings?
 
'Random' in this case is just opposed to 'deterministic', where an event behaves in a fashion inconsistant with any pattern or rule. Since an uncaused event cannot have any pattern or rule underlying it (otherwise, it would be 'caused', though that cause may be unknown), it would be random.

Exactly - I wish I'd said that.
 
If you believe that all opinions are useless and meaningless then yes they are useless and meaningless.

They are scientifically useless unless supported by evidence, in which case they are not opinions.

Uncaused does not mean random. Just because you say it does doesn't make it so.

Then please explain how something could be UNCAUSED by any factor whatsoever, be NON-random and still exist.

You sound more hodgy than dodgy! Seriously, please don't make claims unless you can support them.

So quantum physics are untrue because I can't explain them properly to you ?

Because "we" don't already know what you claim to know. If you can provide evidence that free will cannot or does not exist, then you'd probably be the greatest scientist or philosopher alive (depending on what type of evidence you've offered). Somehow I doubt either is the case.

Apparently you haven't been paying attention. No stars for you.
 
It's as meaningless as your definition of a random event. If you'd care to define a random event in a different way, I'll give you a different definition of a free event.

The problem is, you want free will to exist, but you can't even define what it is without parroting some obscure definition that does not make sense. I therefore rule that, unless you can show, clearly, what free will is all about, we can consider this issue closed.
 
You mean 'quantum' theory? Well, honestly, I'm not altogether sure why they think 'uncaused' events happen. Events with 'unknown' causes, maybe, but not with 'no cause'. But I'm not that clear on quantum theory, I'm afraid.

'Random' in this case is just opposed to 'deterministic', where an event behaves in a fashion inconsistant with any pattern or rule. Since an uncaused event cannot have any pattern or rule underlying it (otherwise, it would be 'caused', though that cause may be unknown), it would be random.

Still - is it really a solid, hard-set theory that uncaused events happen? Or does it just 'appear' as if uncaused events happen? Have these events been observed, or only theorized? I'm seriously curious, now.

As far as I can tell, it's well-supported, and the underlying principles of that theory form the only model which explains the existence of the universe properly. "Random" events in that sense are not caused events with no KNOWN causes. They are RANDOM events with NO causes.
 
As far as I can tell, it's well-supported, and the underlying principles of that theory form the only model which explains the existence of the universe properly. "Random" events in that sense are not caused events with no KNOWN causes. They are RANDOM events with NO causes.

Got a link I could study? Like a 'quantum theory for idiots' or something?
 
Good point - they are random by virtue of being uncaused.

At any rate, you have two types of events: events with causes, and events with no causes. Since 'free will' is a cause, 'free will events' are causal, and therefore, deterministic; but since the mechanism of 'free will' is, itself, apparently causal as well, free will itself is just an illusion.
 
I said nothing of hypotheticals. I am not even sure what you mean by that statement. Let me ask you again - if God exists then would it be possible that he simultaneously doesn't exist? Would that change if nobody knows he exists?

Robin, are you a native English speaker? You are exploiting an ambiguity in the English language, which can be hilighted by the following two statements:


It is possible that God exists.
It is possible for God to exist.
​

My statement was the former, not the latter. I don't know if it is possible for God to exist. Like you said, if God doesn't exist it would be impossible for him to exist, and if God does exist it would be impossible for him not to exist. However, it is possible that God does exist (it is possible that the existance of God is true).

When one says that something is possible (rather than something is certain), they are often simply admitting a lack of knowledge either way. To say "it is possible that God exists" is another way of saying that it is possible given our current lack of knowledge that that the existance of God is reality. This also allows for the possibility that the nonexistance of God is reality. In other words "it is possible" is often an agnostic statement rather than a positive statement of fact.

Unless it is proven that God does not exist or unless it is proven that God cannot exist (i.e. it is proven that it is impossible for God to exist), it is possible that the existance of God is reality. Unless it is proven that God does exist or unless it is proven that God must exist (i.e. it is impossible for God not to exist), it is possible that the existance of God is not reality. Given our current lack of knowledge, either the existance or nonexistance of God might be true. This is an agnostic statement and does not bear the burden of proof.

If I ask someone "Can we complete this project for under $50,000?" and he says "I don't know" then I don't interpret this to mean "It is possible to bring this project in under $50,000".

On the other hand if someone tells me "It is possible to complete this project for under $50,000" then I would expect that he has done at least some initial costings and does not mean "I don't know whether or not this project will cost under $50,000".

Again, there are two ways to answer the question, and you are confusing them:


It is possible that we can complete this project for under $50,000.
It is possible for us to complete the project for under $50,000.
​

The first statement means "I don't know for certain" and the second means "yes." The first statement means "It is possible that we can complete the project for under $50,000, but it is also possible that we cannot." In other words, "I don't know the answer, but it is not beyond the realm of possibility for us to complete the project for under $50,000." The second answer means "Yes, it is possible for us to complete the project for under $50,000."

The statement "It is possible to complete this project for under $50,000" is ambiguous and doesn't actually answer the question "CAN WE complete the project for under $50,000?" Just because something is possible doesn't mean that we can do it. Usually, if the person knew whether the project could be completed for under $50,000 he would simply answer "yes" or "no" to avoid the ambiguity.

Similarly if someone says "It is possible for God to exist" I would expect some justification for this statement.

Yes, but I never said that it is possible for God to exist. I said that it is possible that God exists, which is an agnostic statement and doesn't bear the burden of proof.

It is simply absurd to say that not knowing about something makes it possible. If someone claims that it is possible that God exists then they are making a positive statement which requires justification.

If you don't know that something exists then you also don't know if it is possible for that thing to exist.

Not knowing whether or not something is true means that it possible that the something is true. This does not mean that it is necessarily logically possible for that something to be true, nor does it mean that the something is necessarily true, it only means that it is possible that the something is true.

Not knowing whether or not God exists means that it possible that God exists. That does not mean that it is necessarily logically possible for God to exist, nor does it mean that God necessarily does exist, it only means that it is possible that God exists.

-Bri
 
They are scientifically useless unless supported by evidence, in which case they are not opinions.

Absolutely wrong, Belz. If it's not a fact, it's an opinion. Very little in science is fact.

Then please explain how something could be UNCAUSED by any factor whatsoever, be NON-random and still exist.

Gladly, once you explain how something can be UNCAUSED by any factor whatsoever, be RANDOM, and still exist.

So quantum physics are untrue because I can't explain them properly to you ?

Of course not. Nor is free will untrue because I can't explain it properly to you. Thanks for stating my point so succinctly.

Apparently you haven't been paying attention. No stars for you.

If you say so!

-Bri
 
Bri
Uncaused does not mean random. Just because you say it does doesn't make it so.
Actually it does.

In other words, a free event is one which is not random but which is uncaused. There is no contradiction unless you make the assumption that all uncaused events must be random.
Unless we follow the standard definitions.

Belz...
The problem is, you want free will to exist, but you can't even define what it is without parroting some obscure definition that does not make sense. I therefore rule that, unless you can show, clearly, what free will is all about, we can consider this issue closed.
Bri has been doing this since the beginning by continually waffling between two sides of the issue. When you show the illogic of one side she switches to the other and declares you haven’t really addressed the issue.

Ossai
 
The problem is, you want free will to exist, but you can't even define what it is without parroting some obscure definition that does not make sense. I therefore rule that, unless you can show, clearly, what free will is all about, we can consider this issue closed.

I've posted a defintion twice now. It's not obscure and it makes sense, but perhaps you didn't understand it.

-Bri
 
Got a link I could study? Like a 'quantum theory for idiots' or something?

Yes I do, as a matter of fact! It's a fascinating subject, but quite impossible to fully understand. I'm not just saying that either. Even scientists who "understand" quantum theory don't really understand it.

Wikipedia has one, but it's still pretty complicated. Try this one first.

-Bri
 
At any rate, you have two types of events: events with causes, and events with no causes. Since 'free will' is a cause, 'free will events' are causal, and therefore, deterministic; but since the mechanism of 'free will' is, itself, apparently causal as well, free will itself is just an illusion.

Free will events are causd by free will in the same sense that random events are caused by randomness.

You cannot prove that the mechanism of free will is itself caused any more than you can prove that the mechanism of randomness is caused, nor that either are just an illusion.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Absolutely wrong, Belz. If it's not a fact, it's an opinion. Very little in science is fact.

Name one that is.

Gladly, once you explain how something can be UNCAUSED by any factor whatsoever, be RANDOM, and still exist.

Again:

http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/quentin_smith/uncaused.html

Of course not. Nor is free will untrue because I can't explain it properly to you. Thanks for stating my point so succinctly.

Again, you weren't paying attention. You said that, if I couldn't support what I claimed [personnally], then basically I wasn't worth listening to. In other words, if _I_ can't prove it, it isn't so.
 
I've posted a defintion twice now. It's not obscure and it makes sense, but perhaps you didn't understand it.

No, you didn't. You said that free will is something "uncaused" but "non-random". That's not a definition, because we have no idea of that could be uncaused AND non-random.
 
Free will events are causd by free will in the same sense that random events are caused by randomness.

I challenged you on that a number of posts ago - are you deliberately ignoring it?

Uncaused means absence of cause. There is not a cause called 'randomness', rather, the term random is an attribute of an uncaused (hypothetically) event. That is to say, that because the event was uncaused (not predetermined) it is genuinely random.

Another aspect I challenged you on was your persistent use of circular logic (the will can be said to be free because of the possibility of free will). You are persisting with this approach by using the term 'free will' rather than addressing the 'will' and showing how it can be considered free (your answer has consistently been 'because of free will').

We have provided repeated explanations and definitions to our terms (including uncaused / random being the absence of cause) whereas you have refused to define how your free events are in any way different from our standard random events. This is despite the fact that you could supposedly 'gladly' do so were we, at your bequest, to redefine our terms (for what reason, given that they already accurately describe what we are discussing).

Unless you can pitch something compelling into the argument then there is little else to say on free will.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom