Robin
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Apr 29, 2004
- Messages
- 14,971
I said nothing of hypotheticals. I am not even sure what you mean by that statement. Let me ask you again - if God exists then would it be possible that he simultaneously doesn't exist? Would that change if nobody knows he exists?No, we're not talking about hypotheticals. Whether or not God exists, we don't know that God exists. Since we don't know whether God exists, it is possible that he does exist and it is possible that he doesn't. The burden of proof lies on the person claiming that it is impossible for God to exist or claiming that it is impossible for God not to exist (i.e. that God must exist).
If I ask someone "Can we complete this project for under $50,000?" and he says "I don't know" then I don't interpret this to mean "It is possible to bring this project in under $50,000".
On the other hand if someone tells me "It is possible to complete this project for under $50,000" then I would expect that he has done at least some initial costings and does not mean "I don't know whether or not this project will cost under $50,000".
Similarly if someone says "It is possible for God to exist" I would expect some justification for this statement.
It is simply absurd to say that not knowing about something makes it possible. If someone claims that it is possible that God exists then they are making a positive statement which requires justification.
If you don't know that something exists then you also don't know if it is possible for that thing to exist.
If you are going to appeal to authority at least have an authority in mind. "I'm sure someone must have come to the opposite conclusion" is a weak response to a deductive argument. Point me to someone who has given the matter of omniscience, free will and immanence serious thought and come to the opposite conclusion and I will have a look at their argument.So you actually believe that for thousands of years nobody has given the matter serious thought and come to the opposite conclusion? Amazing!
But as far as I can see theologians from Augustine onwards have tended to the view that if God does anything he must do everything. There are various attempts to camoflage this basically determinist position by stating that God, for example, knows exactly how a free agent will act in any given circumstances.
Whether or not I have convinced myself is immaterial - where is the fault in my argument?You've aparently managed to convince yourself, that much is certain.
I don't know of any scientific journals that consider the existence or otherwise of God, do you? I doubt that omniscience and immanence have much currency outside of theology.If you actually feel that you have proven it, please feel free to submit your proof to a peer-reviewed scientific or philosophical journal.
I doubt in any case that I am the first to demonstrate these results. If you know of anybody that has a good argument showing that it is possible for an omniscient being to participate in a world that contains free will please let me know.
Last edited: