There is No God (And You Know It)

Ok - I think we are pretty clear on what constitutes a caused event. An uncaused one is clearly one that happens for no other reason than that it happens. Your logic implies that your free event is uncaused and you give 2 classifications of uncaused events - random and free.

We can easily define a random event as one that happens by chance with no predetermining causes (pretty close to a plain old uncaused event in my opinion but let's not get distracted).

Now please can you provide a definition of a free event.

A free event is one that doesn't happen by chance with no predetermining causes.

-Bri
 
A free event is one that doesn't happen by chance with no predetermining causes.

-Bri

Pretty good definition - except that it's contradictory.

In other words, a free event is a Acausal Cause... which, as far as we know, simply doesn't exist at all.
 
Therefore they are both useless and meaningless.

If you believe that all opinions are useless and meaningless then yes they are useless and meaningless. On the other hand, if you believe that some opinions have value or are meaningful, then some unfalsifiable theories might also have value or be meaningful.

As we told you before, either your decisions are caused by the various environmental factors, or they are "uncaused" in which case it is random. In NEITHER case do you have some metaphysical control over your decisions. Ergo, no free will.

Uncaused does not mean random. Just because you say it does doesn't make it so.

Not to sound too dodgy, but I'm sure other, more specialised people could answer that question. As I said, though, photons for magnetism and either gravitons or properties of the space-time continuum for gravity.

You sound more hodgy than dodgy! Seriously, please don't make claims unless you can support them.

I'm not sure why I would have to write something to confirm, philosophically, what we already know.

Because "we" don't already know what you claim to know. If you can provide evidence that free will cannot or does not exist, then you'd probably be the greatest scientist or philosopher alive (depending on what type of evidence you've offered). Somehow I doubt either is the case.

-Bri
 
Bri said:
A free event is one that doesn't happen by chance with no predetermining causes.
Pretty good definition - except that it's contradictory.

In other words, a free event is a Acausal Cause... which, as far as we know, simply doesn't exist at all.

By chance = random.
No predetermining causes = uncaused.

In other words, a free event is one which is not random but which is uncaused. There is no contradiction unless you make the assumption that all uncaused events must be random.

-Bri
 
Why?

-Bri

Because the definition of 'random' includes 'having no definite apparent cause'.

So an uncaused event is, by definition, random; a caused event is, by definition, not random.

The problem here is that a free will event is not a random event; in fact, it, too, would be a deterministic event. But the free will agent - whatever that is - would itself have to be (at least partially) immune to influence or stimulation from other causes. Since we know of no such agent, again, we must conclude that 'free will' is merely a convenient illusion.

Really, no matter how we look at it, free will, in the absolute sense, simply cannot exist. In some lesser sense, I would argue that free will is a fact; but in the absolute sense of the terms, there can be no such thing as 'free will'.
 
A free event is one that doesn't happen by chance with no predetermining causes.

-Bri

No - that's not defining a free event, its just saying what a free event isn't. Its meaningles.

You are trying to imply that your free event is neither caused not not caused but without actually saying it. That's a logical impossibility.
 
Because the definition of 'random' includes 'having no definite apparent cause'.

Yes, a random event is uncaused.

So an uncaused event is, by definition, random; a caused event is, by definition, not random.

That a random event is uncaused does not imply that an uncaused event must be random. A cat is an animal, but an animal doesn't have to be a cat.

Somehow I expected more from you, zaayr.

-Bri
 
No - that's not defining a free event, its just saying what a free event isn't. Its meaningles.

It's as meaningless as your definition of a random event. If you'd care to define a random event in a different way, I'll give you a different definition of a free event.

You are trying to imply that your free event is neither caused not not caused but without actually saying it. That's a logical impossibility.

No I'm not. I'm simply not making the error of assuming that all uncaused events must be random.

-Bri
 
So by your logic, because we don't know whether or not God exists, I cannot say that it's possible that God exists, and you cannot say that it's possible that God doesn't exist? That's just silly!
So by your logic if God existed and we didn't know that he existed, then it would be possible for Him not to exist - even though he did. Now that is silly!

No, if God existed then it would be impossible for God not to exist. This would be true whether or not we knew. Conversely If God did not exist then it would be impossible for him to exist. Possibility is not contingent on what we do or don't know.

We cannot say that it is possible for God to exist. And we cannot say that it is possible for God not to exist.

"Don't know" means "Don't know" and nothing else.

If you want to say "it's possible" then provide the justifications that this statement requires. Or at the very least provide a definition.
Neither statement bears the burden of proof, but the opposite statements (it is impossible for a pink unicorn to exist, or it is impossible for a pink unicorn to not exist) must be proven. That's exactly the claim that the subject of the thread makes about God, and more recently the claim that several posters including Belz and yourself have made about free will.
And yet again you get it wrong. I have never claimed that free will is impossible. In fact I have included the assumption that it is possible in nearly every post I have made in this topic.


I did show that it was impossible to have an omniscient being participating in a universe in which free will also existed. I think that if anybody gives that any serious thought they will see that this is in fact the case.
I'm sorry, but the burden would be on you to prove claims that God or free will are impossible.
But since I already proved that God is impossible then adding free will would just be showing off. :)
 
Last edited:
Yes, a random event is uncaused.



That a random event is uncaused does not imply that an uncaused event must be random. A cat is an animal, but an animal doesn't have to be a cat.

Somehow I expected more from you, zaayr.

-Bri

*sigh*

I hoped I wouldn't have to stoop to this, but here goes:

Every event observed in our universe is of a type such that two or more preceeding events interact to form the currently considered event. So, for example, if we have cause A and cause B, and event X is their result, our interaction map would simply be (where I'm using # as "interacts with"):

A # B = X

If X has multiple causes, the map might look like

A # B # C # D... # n = X

Further, each cause itself is of the same type, so

Q # R = A
T # L1 = B

and so forth.

Obviously, some of these maps look like this:

A # B = C, D, E (etc)

When we consider randomness, it is incorrect to say

A # B [might equal] X, or [might equal] T, or [might equal] A...
which essentially is what most people conceive of randomness to mean.
The fact is, that randomness, thus far, has proven to be synonymous with 'absurdly complex causally'.

For the most part, we can look at a random series as \

A # B # [unknown series of factors] = possibly X, possibly Y, etc.

Of course, once we narrow down the unknown set of factors, the 'possibly' portions vanish, and are replaced with certain events.

Since this is true (apparently, with a possible exception at the quantum level, but until we know more about it, it would be foolish to include these theories in our speculations), no event currently known could be random, because all events have causes, thus far.

Now, it is true that to claim that a random event is synonymous to an uncaused event is an oversimplification; the fact is, there may be no random events at all, and likewise no uncaused events. But one fact remains: if random is the opposite of determined, then only an uncaused event could be a random event. And if the opposite of uncaused is caused, then all we have are random events and determined (caused) events. We could not have a determined, random event; nor would we have an uncaused, determined event. Determinism, in fact, requires causation; and causation requires determinance. The two are, in fact, categorical equals, IMO.

'Random' events share the same status, I believe, as free will events; both exist for practical purposes, but neither exists in any absolute or complete sense.
 
Definition (Cambridge Online Dictionary)
chance (LUCK) Show phonetics
noun
the force that causes things to happen without any known cause or reason for doing so


By chance = random.
No predetermining causes = uncaused.

In other words, a free event is one which is not random but which is uncaused. There is no contradiction unless you make the assumption that all uncaused events must be random.

-Bri

The terms random and chance already occupy the ground you are trying to squeeze your 'free' into.

You are now making the mistake of thinking that 'uncaused' is some sort of set of reasons (causes) which then allows you to posit free events as a subset (with you giving 'randomness' as another subset). This is wrong because uncaused is not a subset of causes - it is the absence of causes.

If I have a sandwich it can be ham or cheese, if I do not have a sandwich it cannot be a chicken absence-of-sandwich.
 
Last edited:
The terms random and chance already occupy the ground you are trying to squeeze your 'free' into.

You are now making the mistake of thinking that 'uncaused' is some sort of set of reasons (causes) which then allows you to posit free events as a subset (with you giving 'randomness' as another subset). This is wrong because uncaused is not a subset of causes - it is the absence of causes.

If I have a sandwich it can be ham or cheese, if I do not have a sandwich it cannot be a chicken absence-of-sandwich.

I'm gonna order one of those now. Thanks for making some poor wait-staff's life hell.
 
So by your logic if God existed and we didn't know that he existed, then it would be possible for Him not to exist - even though he did. Now that is silly!

No, we're not talking about hypotheticals. Whether or not God exists, we don't know that God exists. Since we don't know whether God exists, it is possible that he does exist and it is possible that he doesn't. The burden of proof lies on the person claiming that it is impossible for God to exist or claiming that it is impossible for God not to exist (i.e. that God must exist).

I did show that it was impossible to have an omniscient being participating in a universe in which free will also existed. I think that if anybody gives that any serious thought they will see that this is in fact the case.

So you actually believe that for thousands of years nobody has given the matter serious thought and come to the opposite conclusion? Amazing!

You've aparently managed to convince yourself, that much is certain. If you actually feel that you have proven it, please feel free to submit your proof to a peer-reviewed scientific or philosophical journal.

-Bri
 
For the most part, we can look at a random series as \

A # B # [unknown series of factors] = possibly X, possibly Y, etc.

Your argument is based completely on an assumption that there are no uncaused events. Not only can you prove that there are no uncaused events, but currently accepted scientific theory disagrees with you. You also cannot prove that if they exist, all uncaused events must be random.

-Bri
 
Your argument is based completely on an assumption that there are no uncaused events. Not only can you prove that there are no uncaused events, but currently accepted scientific theory disagrees with you. You also cannot prove that if they exist, all uncaused events must be random.

-Bri

You mean 'quantum' theory? Well, honestly, I'm not altogether sure why they think 'uncaused' events happen. Events with 'unknown' causes, maybe, but not with 'no cause'. But I'm not that clear on quantum theory, I'm afraid.

'Random' in this case is just opposed to 'deterministic', where an event behaves in a fashion inconsistant with any pattern or rule. Since an uncaused event cannot have any pattern or rule underlying it (otherwise, it would be 'caused', though that cause may be unknown), it would be random.

Still - is it really a solid, hard-set theory that uncaused events happen? Or does it just 'appear' as if uncaused events happen? Have these events been observed, or only theorized? I'm seriously curious, now.
 
You mean 'quantum' theory? Well, honestly, I'm not altogether sure why they think 'uncaused' events happen. Events with 'unknown' causes, maybe, but not with 'no cause'. But I'm not that clear on quantum theory, I'm afraid.

As they say, anyone who is clear on quantum theory doesn't understand quantum theory. Quantum theory provides accurate and precise descriptions for many phenomena that strict determinism cannot explain. Of course, quantum theory could be wrong, but nonetheless is currently the most widely accepted theory.

'Random' in this case is just opposed to 'deterministic', where an event behaves in a fashion inconsistant with any pattern or rule. Since an uncaused event cannot have any pattern or rule underlying it (otherwise, it would be 'caused', though that cause may be unknown), it would be random.

It is possible that there are events which are both non-deterministic and non-random.

Still - is it really a solid, hard-set theory that uncaused events happen? Or does it just 'appear' as if uncaused events happen? Have these events been observed, or only theorized? I'm seriously curious, now.

According to quantum theory, random, non-deterministic, events actually occur. So not only have uncaused events not been ruled out by science, they are assumed to exist by many scientists. Uncaused, non-random events could also exist.

-Bri
 
GOD, being "omni" but still with indescribable & infinite properties, can do/know everything & remain present everywhere, in evey thing or being. He may effect such act or deeds himself, by forming/creating/concentrating-- HIS complexes. OK? One out of those complexes may be you.:) HIS indescribable property make people to feel/misunderstood--There is no God. Going towards HIM with deepest love, belief, faith, dedication & practices(concentration, meditation etc.) for long, may make you to feel/know HIM--probably but mostly. :)

Heaven/Hell, Angels/devils, excesses/defficiencies, good/bad etc. may be a deviation from the "BALANCE" or from the "GOD".
 
Last edited:
GOD, being "omni" but still with indescribable & infinite properties, can do/know everything & remain present everywhere, in evey thing or being. He may effect such act or deeds himself, by forming/creating/concentrating-- HIS complexes. OK? One out of those complexes may be you.:) HIS indescribable property make people to feel/misunderstood--There is no God. Going towards HIM with deepest love, belief, faith, dedication & practices(concentration, meditation etc.) for long, may make you to feel/know HIM--probably but mostly. :)

Heaven/Hell, Angels/devils, excesses/defficiencies, good/bad etc. may be a deviation from the "BALANCE" or from the "GOD".

Oh Hell, Kumar found the thread.

Sorry, Bri - discussion over.

See ya elsewhere!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom