But let's take the ham, cheese or ham
and cheese sandwich example. What caused us to creatively come up with the ham
and cheese sandwich solution
and to choose that option isn't known to us. We can certainly say that if that decisive ability is subject to the laws of cause and effect then it is not "free" as we understand the term. But until we know it is subject to cause and effect we only have a theory....and without a 'basis' choice would be random and thus not 'free will', unless you include the ability not to have any sandwich - to not make a choice.
I think that's where you're logic fails.
Agency, to use the psychological term, is the ability to decide
between options, to
create a new option or to
not make a choice. Were "free will" locked into some "between choices" model, I would have to agree it doesn't exist. Since it isn't, we have to conclude that the ability to decide not to choose allows there to be "free will".How indeed?No true materialist takes a cheese and ham sandwich without pickle

You're welcome, but I'm not convinced your logic contains all factors. I'm not sure it can since we don't have complete information about consciousness and don't seem set to any time soon.I disagree. Consider positive and negative numbers, with the urges for the cheese or ham options being thoughts that are positive in force. How does your model explain the creative third option or the nullifying fourth option?
At some point, however briefly, the third option must have been a positive urge unattached to any thought at all that subsequently became attached to both the cheese
or ham options to create the third cheese
and ham option. The nullifying fourth option, likewise, must at some point have been a negative urge (which really boggles the mind!) that was unattached to any thought at all that somehow either negates the positive options (make no decision to do anything) or transforms into a positive thought (actively decide to do nothing) that is strong enough to nullify both other positive options, and possibly even the third should that arrise.
To me, that both the creative and nullifying choices don't have an evidential cause like the ham
or cheese options (in the form of ham, cheese, bread and hunger) is a real spanner in the works of your logic. You need to know the cause of those other two options.
_
HypnoPsi