There is No God (And You Know It)

Talk about shifting the burden of proof! Everything is possible, then, and knowledge is useless.

Yes, everything is possible unless proven otherwise. That said, there are plenty of things that are falsifiable and can be proven impossible. So, I'm not sure why you conclude that knowledge is useless. ceo_esq already commented on this here and I don't think I could improve on his comments.

The point is that your point would be much more credible if you could provide an explanation for free will's existence, or an effect it has on the universe that it (the universe, that is) wouldn't have without it.

How so? Can you provide an explanation of the existance of randomness? How about gravity or magnetism -- what causes them? Somehow you hold free will to a different standard than other things that cannot be explained.

Without randomness, there WOULD be no universe.

As zaayrdragon pointed out, since randomness is far from proven, I'd say that it's quite possible that without randomness the universe would be exactly the same as it is.

-Bri
 
Originally Posted by HypnoPsi :
Bri is right, the logical fallacy you are presenting is called a false dilemma based upon a materialistic world view.
That's not true. Earlier in the thread I explicitly stated that the argument is one of logic and has nothing to do with the spiritual v material etc.... As I said before, even if the universe is just an illusion beheld by my spiritual consciousness there is still no free will.
Correct me if I'm wrong (the thread is rather long to go hunting through) but your theory is that free-will is either caused or not caused and that this somehow logically falsifies free-will? If so, then I think we need to be clear how we are defining our terms. To me, "will" just means the ability "to act" while "free-will" means the ability to choose "how to act".

Even though we have to accept that "free-will" is by necessity limited by the options available, we also need to factor in creativity. In your ham or cheese sandwich example you don't need to choose between the two - you could decide to have a ham and cheese sandwich.

In fact, let's consider that in even more precise terms. You're feeling hungry and exactly half of your hungry neurons are yelling "Cheese!" and the other half are yelling "Ham!". Having no central processor capable of creative problem solving would lead to complete inaction and crash the system. So we have to factor in creativity when we think about free-will.
Rather than special pleading based on the spiritual realm, please help Bri in addressing the logic of the no-free-will argument and show what is wrong with it - point out the place where the logic breaks down.
Your self-contained and self-defining logic is flawless. The question is does it match reality? My answer would be partly "no" and partly "how can we ever really know for sure?", meaning I'd, skeptically, assume the negative until the assertion is based upon better evidence.
_
HypnoPsi
 
You want us to frame questions in the material because it provides you with the convenient intellectual bolt-hole to avoid logic by invoking the spiritual argument.
No, as per my previous reply, I'm saying that we need to consider the nature of creativity to understand choices.
However - as I pointed out I have deliberately avoided that because I knew the someone would exploit it. I'm saying that even God can't have free will.
God is an interesting choice because while we, never knowing everything about everything, have to be creative at some level, God is supposed to know everything about everything and thus to always make the right choice. But, if you think about it, knowing "cheese sandwich" and "ham sandwich" completely and in perfect detail doesn't preclude the idea that the creative "cheese and ham sandwich" is the better choice.

I would argue that our and God's "free will" is the decision to act from a choice that is always creative at some level rather than a "forced choice" situation. Indeed, anyone who's ever ran a survey will tell you that people don't always like 'forced-choice' questionaires, often engaging the interviewer in debate about what the question and choice of answers mean, considering exceptions to the rule and/or adding comments about why they're making a choice.

I think questions about "free will" are difficult to answer (perhaps even impossible to answer) because we don't have a clear enough definition of "free will" to start from.
_
HypnoPsi
 
We are not asking questions about the cause of free will

Yes you were.

No we are not. We are not saying 'lets look at free will and show that nothing could possibly cause it' which I think is what you think we are trying to do. My argument is based on looking at the nature of the 'will' (NOT free will, just will - see below) and then demonstrating that it cannot be 'free will'. Our questions are not analogous to your 'what causes gravity'.

As I said - Rather, we are looking at individual events of the conscious will and for each one saying 'how could that event have come about?'


Uh...you just stated that we're not asking questions about the cause of free will, and then asked about the cause of free will!

No I didn't - please read the argument carefully. In my 'rather...' statement I said we were asking questions about events of the will NOT the 'free will'.

However - let's allow for the other logical possibility - that some events might not be caused, they just happen for no reason, effectively they are random events.

WRONG! You keep making the same assumption in your logic. Uncaused does NOT necessarily mean random, it simply means not completely determined by prior events.

To avoid a pointless tangent to the argument let's not use the term random (although I think it is a reasonable term to use).

We can neither predict nor prevent the uncaused events from taking place - they are just chance events - nevertheless they will happen so our will is not 'free' of them. This is not dissimilar to the extent to which our will is not free from caused events.
 
Last edited:
In order for an event to be the result of free will, it cannot be entirely caused by prior events, but could be influenced by prior events.

Ok - so we have a choice made by the will. In this case lets say there are 4 factors in play at the time when the choice is made. 3 of the factors are the result of determined previous cause and effect but one factor appears spontaneously with no apparent cause. Can you explain where 'free will' is in this example?

In my example, randomness gave rise to the decision and it had nothing to do with the state of the brain. If determinism is true, then yes perhaps the state of the brain may be the cause of the decision. If free will is true, then perhaps free will may be the cause of the decision. All could seem exactly the same to us, and we have no way to know which is true.

You are avoiding the crucial step of asking questions about the events of the will - it is precisely the nature of those events that prevent it from being 'free will'.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong (the thread is rather long to go hunting through) but your theory is that free-will is either caused or not caused and that this somehow logically falsifies free-will?

No - you are making the same mistake as Bri. I am NOT trying to show that 'free will is either caused or not caused'. I am saying that the will cannot be considered to be free will since the events that comprise it can only be caused or uncaused.

If so, then I think we need to be clear how we are defining our terms. To me, "will" just means the ability "to act" while "free-will" means the ability to choose "how to act".

And on what basis do you make the choice of how to act? If you have a 'basis' then you have cause and effect and so no free will. The logic of state and cause and effect does not com to a sudden stop as soon as someone invokes the term free-will. In fact it is generic to any system - not just the will.

Even though we have to accept that "free-will" is by necessity limited by the options available, we also need to factor in creativity. In your ham or cheese sandwich example you don't need to choose between the two - you could decide to have a ham and cheese sandwich.

And then we can ask - how is it that Hodgy is creative today? I would almost certainly add some pickle to it by the way.

In fact, let's consider that in even more precise terms. You're feeling hungry and exactly half of your hungry neurons are yelling "Cheese!" and the other half are yelling "Ham!". Having no central processor capable of creative problem solving would lead to complete inaction and crash the system. So we have to factor in creativity when we think about free-will.Your self-contained and self-defining logic is flawless.

Thanks :)

The question is does it match reality? My answer would be partly "no" and partly "how can we ever really know for sure?", meaning I'd, skeptically, assume the negative until the assertion is based upon better evidence.
HypnoPsi

Its not something that evidence can be provided for, neither is it needed - the evidence is the logical argument itself.
 
Yes, everything is possible unless proven otherwise. That said, there are plenty of things that are falsifiable and can be proven impossible.

Again, you're working in the opposite direction. If science worked that way, we would never verify theories because we'd be satisfied that they are possible even if it's only in appearance.

How so? Can you provide an explanation of the existance of randomness? How about gravity or magnetism -- what causes them?

There are known (and proposed) causes for gravity and magnetism. Free will doesn't JUST not have anything going for it, it actually goes AGAINST everything we know.

Somehow you hold free will to a different standard than other things that cannot be explained.

Only because you consider that they are unexplained.

As zaayrdragon pointed out, since randomness is far from proven, I'd say that it's quite possible that without randomness the universe would be exactly the same as it is.

Yes, I'm sure no manner of evidence would ever convince you that anything is proven, lest it burst your private bubble.
 
Ok - so we have a choice made by the will. In this case lets say there are 4 factors in play at the time when the choice is made. 3 of the factors are the result of determined previous cause and effect but one factor appears spontaneously with no apparent cause. Can you explain where 'free will' is in this example?

The factor which has no apparent cause is either the result of randomness, free will, or actually has a cause that isn't apparent.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Again, you're working in the opposite direction. If science worked that way, we would never verify theories because we'd be satisfied that they are possible even if it's only in appearance.

Actually, science doesn't deal with unfalsifiable theories at all. Unfalsifiable theories are possible because they cannot be proven impossible.

There are known (and proposed) causes for gravity and magnetism. Free will doesn't JUST not have anything going for it, it actually goes AGAINST everything we know.

What causes gravity and magnetism? What do "we know" that free will contradicts?

Only because you consider that they are unexplained.

Then please explain them. In fact, it is not just me who considers them unexplained. Science considers them unexplained.

Yes, I'm sure no manner of evidence would ever convince you that anything is proven, lest it burst your private bubble.

Not true. Provide any evidence that free will cannot or does not exist and I'll gladly change my opinion. While you're at it, please submit your evidence to scientific and philosophical publications for review, as it's sure to create quite a stir!

-Bri
 
Yes, everything is possible unless proven otherwise.
No, as I have pointed out plenty of times before "don't know" means "don't know" and nothing else. Not knowing that something is impossible does not mean that it is possible.
That said, there are plenty of things that are falsifiable and can be proven impossible.
Like an omniscient being participating in a world that contains non-deterministic elements. And if we can agree that the type of free will you are talking about is non-deterministic then we have pretty much disproved God.
 
You are avoiding the crucial step of asking questions about the events of the will - it is precisely the nature of those events that prevent it from being 'free will'.

Which questions exactly? The same questions you ask about events of the will can be asked about uncaused random events. I think you're missing that point.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I am NOT trying to show that 'free will is either caused or not caused'. I am saying that the will cannot be considered to be free will since the events that comprise it can only be caused or uncaused.
But let's take the ham, cheese or ham and cheese sandwich example. What caused us to creatively come up with the ham and cheese sandwich solution and to choose that option isn't known to us. We can certainly say that if that decisive ability is subject to the laws of cause and effect then it is not "free" as we understand the term. But until we know it is subject to cause and effect we only have a theory.
And on what basis do you make the choice of how to act? If you have a 'basis' then you have cause and effect and so no free will. The logic of state and cause and effect does not com to a sudden stop as soon as someone invokes the term free-will. In fact it is generic to any system - not just the will.
...and without a 'basis' choice would be random and thus not 'free will', unless you include the ability not to have any sandwich - to not make a choice.

I think that's where you're logic fails. Agency, to use the psychological term, is the ability to decide between options, to create a new option or to not make a choice. Were "free will" locked into some "between choices" model, I would have to agree it doesn't exist. Since it isn't, we have to conclude that the ability to decide not to choose allows there to be "free will".
And then we can ask - how is it that Hodgy is creative today?
How indeed?
I would almost certainly add some pickle to it by the way.
No true materialist takes a cheese and ham sandwich without pickle :)
Your self-contained and self-defining logic is flawless.
Thanks :)
You're welcome, but I'm not convinced your logic contains all factors. I'm not sure it can since we don't have complete information about consciousness and don't seem set to any time soon.
The question is does it match reality? My answer would be partly "no" and partly "how can we ever really know for sure?", meaning I'd, skeptically, assume the negative until the assertion is based upon better evidence.
Its not something that evidence can be provided for, neither is it needed - the evidence is the logical argument itself.
I disagree. Consider positive and negative numbers, with the urges for the cheese or ham options being thoughts that are positive in force. How does your model explain the creative third option or the nullifying fourth option?

At some point, however briefly, the third option must have been a positive urge unattached to any thought at all that subsequently became attached to both the cheese or ham options to create the third cheese and ham option. The nullifying fourth option, likewise, must at some point have been a negative urge (which really boggles the mind!) that was unattached to any thought at all that somehow either negates the positive options (make no decision to do anything) or transforms into a positive thought (actively decide to do nothing) that is strong enough to nullify both other positive options, and possibly even the third should that arrise.

To me, that both the creative and nullifying choices don't have an evidential cause like the ham or cheese options (in the form of ham, cheese, bread and hunger) is a real spanner in the works of your logic. You need to know the cause of those other two options.
_
HypnoPsi
 
No, as I have pointed out plenty of times before "don't know" means "don't know" and nothing else. Not knowing that something is impossible does not mean that it is possible.

So by your logic, because we don't know whether or not God exists, I cannot say that it's possible that God exists, and you cannot say that it's possible that God doesn't exist? That's just silly!

On the contrary, if we don't know whether an invisible pink unicorn exists, we can certainly say that it's possible that a pink unicorn exists, and we can also say that it's possible that a pink unicorn doesn't exist. That's what "don't know" means!

Neither statement bears the burden of proof, but the opposite statements (it is impossible for a pink unicorn to exist, or it is impossible for a pink unicorn to not exist) must be proven. That's exactly the claim that the subject of the thread makes about God, and more recently the claim that several posters including Belz and yourself have made about free will.

I'm sorry, but the burden would be on you to prove claims that God or free will are impossible.

-Bri
 
Originally Posted by hodgy :
Ok - so we have a choice made by the will. In this case lets say there are 4 factors in play at the time when the choice is made. 3 of the factors are the result of determined previous cause and effect but one factor appears spontaneously with no apparent cause. Can you explain where 'free will' is in this example?


The factor which has no apparent cause is either the result of randomness, free will, or actually has a cause that isn't apparent.

-Bri

We are already talking about the will - your reply makes no sense in that context. What you are effectively saying there is that the will can be free because events in it can be the result of free will. Its a circular argument.

The question you need to answer is - given that the will can only have events that are either caused or uncaused how can it be described as free?
 
We are already talking about the will - your reply makes no sense in that context. What you are effectively saying there is that the will can be free because events in it can be the result of free will. Its a circular argument.

No, I'm saying that events of the will are either caused, random, or free. They can be free for the same reasons they can be random.

The question you need to answer is - given that the will can only have events that are either caused or uncaused how can it be described as free?

Because free will might be uncaused just as "random will" would be uncaused (if such a thing exists).

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by hodgy :
We are already talking about the will - your reply makes no sense in that context. What you are effectively saying there is that the will can be free because events in it can be the result of free will. Its a circular argument.

No, I'm saying that events of the will are either caused, random, or free. They can be free for the same reasons they can be random.

Ok - I think we are pretty clear on what constitutes a caused event. An uncaused one is clearly one that happens for no other reason than that it happens. Your logic implies that your free event is uncaused and you give 2 classifications of uncaused events - random and free.

We can easily define a random event as one that happens by chance with no predetermining causes (pretty close to a plain old uncaused event in my opinion but let's not get distracted).

Now please can you provide a definition of a free event.
 
Actually, science doesn't deal with unfalsifiable theories at all. Unfalsifiable theories are possible because they cannot be proven impossible.

Therefore they are both useless and meaningless.

What do "we know" that free will contradicts?

As we told you before, either your decisions are caused by the various environmental factors, or they are "uncaused" in which case it is random. In NEITHER case do you have some metaphysical control over your decisions. Ergo, no free will.

Then please explain them. In fact, it is not just me who considers them unexplained. Science considers them unexplained.

Not to sound too dodgy, but I'm sure other, more specialised people could answer that question. As I said, though, photons for magnetism and either gravitons or properties of the space-time continuum for gravity.

While you're at it, please submit your evidence to scientific and philosophical publications for review, as it's sure to create quite a stir!

I'm not sure why I would have to write something to confirm, philosophically, what we already know.
 
Because free will might be uncaused just as "random will" would be uncaused (if such a thing exists).

Bri, you seem confused as to what "uncaused" means. We take it to mean that the "cause" is random, therefore it cannot be determined or controlled. The term "free will" implies that randomness is not the key factor. But if it's not randomness, it has to be caused, right ? But, if its caused, then the factors can be known, and therefore no other decision could be taken in the same circumstances. Where's that free will, again ?
 
To me, that both the creative and nullifying choices don't have an evidential cause like the ham or cheese options (in the form of ham, cheese, bread and hunger) is a real spanner in the works of your logic. You need to know the cause of those other two options.
_
HypnoPsi

Oh my Whateverness, I can't believe you'd be as stupid as to make such a claim.

Yes, you could choose ham and cheese. Causes: you know you like both together; the potentials between 'ham' and 'cheese' are equal in your mind, causing a disturbance; etc. etc. Nothing in there about free will - in fact, the so-called 'creative' solution is another illustration of the deterministic nature of the universe.

The nullification solution - no sandwich at all - could also be demonstrated to have equally valid causation. For example, if someone was trying to force you to choose, your resentment against control could create a counter-potential that overpowered any hunger potentials or desires for ham and/or cheese.

The real key to understanding decision making is in potential strength of available pathways. Every decision is a junction between two (or more) potential neural pathways, and every prior influence has weakened or strengthened these pathways. What we 'feel' as a decision is really nothing more than neuron pathways firing because their potential to fire was greater or lesser. Continual firings along certain pathways lead to exceedingly strong pathways - hence, 'preferences' or 'hobbies' or 'learned skills' emerge. Other neural pathways are naturally, for whatever reason, stronger or weaker - hence, 'innate skills' or 'natural talents'. And so on.

Your moronic examples above (creative and nullifying options) are nothing more than two additional choices. Other additional choices are to eat just bread, or rolls of ham slices, or a bit of cheese, or perhaps two pieces of ham with bread between it - and so on.

And since we're not talking about any single pathway for any choice - it's quite possible, for example, that the pathways to the 'ham' or 'cheese' option number in the thousands - we end up dealing with an incredibly complex, multiply redundant network of logic gates, causing the inevitable choices we make to SEEM like 'free will', and making it difficult for scientists to pinpoint the exact process of 'will' within the brain.

Of course, the more we know, the worse things may actually get for us. Awareness of the process of cognition and decision-making becomes yet another factor of every decision, strengthening and weakening potentials across the entire brain. I can only imagine that total awareness of the entire cognitive function might lead to some people being unable to make choices at all. Then again, just about anything can lead to that... :D

In short, every choice is backed by causation. Therefore, absolute free will does not exist.
 
But let's take the ham, cheese or ham and cheese sandwich example. What caused us to creatively come up with the ham and cheese sandwich solution and to choose that option isn't known to us. We can certainly say that if that decisive ability is subject to the laws of cause and effect then it is not "free" as we understand the term. But until we know it is subject to cause and effect we only have a theory....and without a 'basis' choice would be random and thus not 'free will', unless you include the ability not to have any sandwich - to not make a choice.

I think that's where you're logic fails. Agency, to use the psychological term, is the ability to decide between options, to create a new option or to not make a choice. Were "free will" locked into some "between choices" model, I would have to agree it doesn't exist. Since it isn't, we have to conclude that the ability to decide not to choose allows there to be "free will".How indeed?No true materialist takes a cheese and ham sandwich without pickle :)You're welcome, but I'm not convinced your logic contains all factors. I'm not sure it can since we don't have complete information about consciousness and don't seem set to any time soon.I disagree. Consider positive and negative numbers, with the urges for the cheese or ham options being thoughts that are positive in force. How does your model explain the creative third option or the nullifying fourth option?

At some point, however briefly, the third option must have been a positive urge unattached to any thought at all that subsequently became attached to both the cheese or ham options to create the third cheese and ham option. The nullifying fourth option, likewise, must at some point have been a negative urge (which really boggles the mind!) that was unattached to any thought at all that somehow either negates the positive options (make no decision to do anything) or transforms into a positive thought (actively decide to do nothing) that is strong enough to nullify both other positive options, and possibly even the third should that arrise.

To me, that both the creative and nullifying choices don't have an evidential cause like the ham or cheese options (in the form of ham, cheese, bread and hunger) is a real spanner in the works of your logic. You need to know the cause of those other two options.
_
HypnoPsi

As Zaaydragon said, the other options that you discussed at so much length, are just that - other options. The same logic applies to those options as to the original 2.

I do not need to know the actual cause of anything to appreciate the simple logical truth that events must be either caused or not caused.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom