There is No God (And You Know It)

- If all of these events are caused then they are predetermined by the chain of cause and effect, the standard determinist position. Free will cannot exist in this model.

- If some or all of our thinker's events are not caused then they are random. Our thinker may or may not have some predetermined thoughts (the caused ones) and some (or all) that are just randomly occuring events. Free will cannot exist in this model.

You make quite an assumption that there are only two possibilities: caused or random. Free will would be a third possibility, and would be neither caused nor random. If you could prove that such a thing does not or can not exist, then you will have accomplished something that no philosopher has ever been able to accomplish.

-Bri
 
The calculations would equate to a first run.

Actually, they wouldn't. I'm a programmer, and the word "run" as it refers to a program has a specific meaning. If you were using it in a different way (as you seem to have been) then it certainly doesn't justify calling me a liar.

Omniscience must be looked at as a set, if freewill is not compatible with a part of the set, the it is not compatible with the entire set.

I never said otherwise. What I did say was that proving that free will is compatible with part of the set doesn't prove that it is compatible with the set. Your insinuation that I deliberately lied was unfounded and uncalled for.

-Bri
 
You make quite an assumption that there are only two possibilities: caused or random. Free will would be a third possibility, and would be neither caused nor random. If you could prove that such a thing does not or can not exist, then you will have accomplished something that no philosopher has ever been able to accomplish.

-Bri

For that matter, if you could prove that such a thing does or can exist, then you will have also accomplished something that no philosopher has ever been able to accomplish.
 
No, ceo_esq is right - if God is outside of time and can see all of time it does not mean that everything is deterministic - it is (roughly) analogous to viewing a tape of something that happened yesterday.

Exactly what the example was demonstrating. You answered your own question (and Ossai's if he's paying attention).

The programmer can view the timeline, once instantiated, at as many different points in time as he likes without affecting the timeline. One "run" but multiple windows.

-Bri
 
For that matter, if you could prove that such a thing does or can exist, then you will have also accomplished something that no philosopher has ever been able to accomplish.

Quite right! Of course, I never claimed that I could prove such a thing.

-Bri
 
You make quite an assumption that there are only two possibilities: caused or random. Free will would be a third possibility, and would be neither caused nor random.

I said that there are 2 possibilities - caused or not caused. I have described a non-caused event as random since from our perspective at least, that's what it appears to be. As I also said, an event that is not caused can, in fact be deemed to have caused itself. This does not break determinism.

Are you trying to claim that the events of free will are neither caused nor not caused?

Suppose we take a conscious mind and offer it 2 choices. If it takes choice A and we say - 'why did it take choice A?' we are in fact asking what caused it to take choice A. There are 2 answers:

- It was not caused, it just spontaneously happened (we can reasonably describe that as random).

- It was caused by the will of the conscious mind.

The conscious mind has a particular state at the point of the decision and that state is what determines the decision (unless the choice is entirely random). Now we can ask 'why did the conscious mind have that particular state at that time?'. There are 2 answers:

- For no reason - it spontaneously configured in that way.

- As a result its interactions and choices made hitherto.

In other words, its state at that point was a product of its previous state and all internal and external factors affecting it.

Now we can go on ad-infinitum tracing the line of cause / effect and possible random influences but there will never be room for 'free will', for each choice and event we need only ask 'why?'. The simplest refutation, as I have implied before is if it is willed how can it be free?.
 
Exactly what the example was demonstrating. You answered your own question (and Ossai's if he's paying attention).

The programmer can view the timeline, once instantiated, at as many different points in time as he likes without affecting the timeline. One "run" but multiple windows.

-Bri
If you have been paying attention, I have understood and accepted the 'outside of time' option from the beginning.

An omniscient being might observe a temporal world containing free will, but it cannot participate in the least little way.

You have always claimed you example is programmable so you will have to back this up if you persist in claiming there is no second run in the second window. I am pretty sure that you can't have a moving dot on a screen without some code that is animating it. And that code will not be exhibiting even simulated free will - it will just be following a preset pattern.

Feel free to show the code to prove me wrong.

Your simulated free will function can never be called for this timeline once the "foreknowledge" exists. It just can't. That is an indisputable fact.

Feel free, again, to show the code to prove me wrong.

Because non-determinism is incompatible with infallible foreknowledge. Your program illustrates the problem very well.
 
You make quite an assumption that there are only two possibilities: caused or random. Free will would be a third possibility, and would be neither caused nor random. If you could prove that such a thing does not or can not exist, then you will have accomplished something that no philosopher has ever been able to accomplish.

-Bri

Unfortunately free will doesn't make sense unless you posit an extra-physical sentience entity that can make decisions NOT based solely on physical factors and YET not determined by random quantum fluctuations. How would that work ?
 
I've quoted this first because I'm going to refer back to it. In the following remarks, my references to "foreknowing" and "foreknowledge" allude to the "timeless viewing" scenario, rather than the "prediction" scenario (as we have previously distinguished the two in this thread).
Then you are not addressing my point. If God is to participate as a free agent in the temporal world then he must participate temporally. Events in the temporal world do not just follow each other chronologically, they follow each other ontologically. If Gods knowledge of all time informs his choices about an action at a particular point in time then it becomes a prediction.
Yet if God observes a phenomenon it in a manner somewhat akin to how we view the past, God's observation of it does not affect whether such phenomenon was deterministic, nor how it was determined. The example of our own pasts tells us that there is nothing logically inconsistent between a phenomenon's being determined and such phenomenon's being partially caused by free agency. There is an obvious contrast between deterministic and merely determined.
Clearly there is - for example something that is determined cannot be changed. Once God observes a single event in the universe he is atomically observing every single other event in all times in the universe. So at God's first observation of anything in the universe the entire universe is determined at that point, so God cannot change it.

Craigs argument does not include any actual participation from God, other than knowing, so it is not really relevant to the point I am making. The problem was not so much that God foreknew that Peter would sin, but he made plans contingent on the fact.
Yet my past is a fait accompli to me, and I participated in it.
But you did not participate in it with a full lifetime of memories from the start. Imagine you are born remembering your dying breath. You start your first day of school remembering the marks you got in your final examination. You ask a person for a date already knowing that you will marry them. You start every conversation already knowing every word that will be said, even your own.

Would you have free will in that scenario? Only if your memories of the future were wrong.

But God, participating in the temporal world, would take each and every decision about that world in full knowledge of the result and consequences of that decision.
 
I said that there are 2 possibilities - caused or not caused. I have described a non-caused event as random since from our perspective at least, that's what it appears to be.

I am confused about your use of the term "caused." Normally, the term is used to describe a natural event that is completely determined by one or more prior natural events. But you seem to be using it to mean non-random.

There are at least three possibilities:

  1. an event is caused by one or more other natural events
  2. an event is random
  3. an event is the result of free will

Now, you can file free will under "caused" or "uncaused" as you like depending on what definition you want to use, but there are still at least three possibilities, not two. Personally, I would place free will under "uncaused" along with "random."

As I also said, an event that is not caused can, in fact be deemed to have caused itself. This does not break determinism.

Actually, I believe it does break determinism. It doesn't break current quantum theory though. I'm also not sure if it is accurate to say that an event that is uncaused/random causes itself.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
You have always claimed you example is programmable so you will have to back this up if you persist in claiming there is no second run in the second window. I am pretty sure that you can't have a moving dot on a screen without some code that is animating it. And that code will not be exhibiting even simulated free will - it will just be following a preset pattern.

Sure, it's following a preset pattern. The pattern is set when the timeline is instantiated, the instant the simulation is started. The pattern is completely based on free will / randomness (depending on which function is used) and not by the programmer.

Because non-determinism is incompatible with infallible foreknowledge.

The following quote by you seems to indicate that you feel otherwise:

Robin said:
No, ceo_esq is right - if God is outside of time and can see all of time it does not mean that everything is deterministic - it is (roughly) analogous to viewing a tape of something that happened yesterday.

If God can see all of time, he has perfect foreknowledge because he knows future events by observing them directly. Remember, we are not defining foreknowledge as prediction, but simply being able to observe what will happen in the future.

-Bri
 
First, it would be necessary to determine if ANY event is truly uncaused or random. What we presently understand as 'random' may very well be quite determined by a number of factors not known by us at this time. What we currently claim is 'uncaused' is most likely 'caused by unknown agents'. It may very well be that there are no random OR uncaused events in the universe - though how we could possibly discover this to be true, I have no idea.

As to 'free will', if we're discussing absolute uncaused choices, it would be necessary to determine if any event in the brain is in any way uncaused by prior agents... a daunting, but not impossible, task, to be sure. But until such time as we learn the truth, the search for absolute free will is no more nor less purposeful than the search for God, Heaven, invisible pink unicorns, or honest politicians. Since our current set of observations includes caused events, both deterministic and apparently random, the most logical inferrence is that all events are caused, either deterministically or randomly. Further, since many examples of apparently random or chaotic events are, in fact, deterministic as well, it is similarly more logical to state that an apparently random event is simply a deterministic one being affected by complex factors which we do not have full awareness or understanding of.
 
an event is caused by one or more other natural events
an event is random
an event is the result of free will

Now, you can file free will under "caused" or "uncaused" as you like depending on what definition you want to use, but there are still at least three possibilities, not two. Personally, I would place free will under "uncaused" along with "random."

Please define free will, according to you, and please adress my previous question. Let's see if we can agree at least on the terms.
 
Unfortunately free will doesn't make sense unless you posit an extra-physical sentience entity that can make decisions NOT based solely on physical factors and YET not determined by random quantum fluctuations. How would that work ?

Belz, you might want to read up on "dualism" for one possible explanation of the mechanism by which we might have free will. Essentially, it is the notion that we are more than the sum or our parts (i.e. some part of us is indeed extra-physical).

Please define free will, according to you, and please adress my previous question. Let's see if we can agree at least on the terms.

Simply stated, when one has acted of one's own free will, one could have done otherwise, and one was the ultimate source of the action. In order to be the ultimate source of one's action, some condition necessary for the action must originate within oneself (rather than externally).

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Belz, you might want to read up on "dualism" for one possible explanation of the mechanism by which we might have free will.

Does it explain free will or does it merely assert that it could exist, as you do ?

Simply stated, when one has acted of one's own free will, one could have done otherwise, and one was the ultimate source of the action. In order to be the ultimate source of one's action, some condition necessary for the action must originate within oneself (rather than externally).

I know what you want free will to mean. I want to know how it would be possible, according to you, given that the only factors we know of are either deterministic or random.
 
If Gods knowledge of all time informs his choices about an action at a particular point in time then it becomes a prediction.

No. Prediction, in the sense I have been using the term, means calculation on the basis of (1) all causal laws and (2) all circumstances in the universe, solely as (1) and (2) exist on the timeline at a given point prior to the point at which the predicted event exists. I do not consider God's knowledge of the future through direct cognition to be either an antecedent or a causal law in this sense (or based on an antecedent or a causal law); therefore, it is never, strictly speaking, a prediction.


Robin said:
So at God's first observation of anything in the universe the entire universe is determined at that point, so God cannot change it.

I don't see any logical problem with God "instantaneously" perceiving a timeline in which he is nonetheless an actor, albeit that it's a bit of a mind-bender from a purely human perspective. I have been searching the literature for a workable proof of such a problem, and find none.


zaayrdragon said:
For that matter, if you could prove that such a thing [as free will] does or can exist, then you will have also accomplished something that no philosopher has ever been able to accomplish.

No one has to prove that free will exists. I think we must assume that free will can exist (that is, it exists in at least one logically possible universe), since it does not appear to present any internal contradictions. The question we have been disputing regards not the possibility of free will per se, but the compossibility of free will and the God of classical theism (divine omniscience in particular).

I think it is impossible to prove, deductively or otherwise, the actual existence of free will. I am strongly inclined to believe that it is impossible to prove the actual existence of an omniscient agent. But we do not need to do any of those things in order to consider the question of whether both could hypothetically exist at the same time.


zaayrdragon said:
Since our current set of observations includes caused events, both deterministic and apparently random, the most logical inferrence is that all events are caused, either deterministically or randomly.

Yet it is virtually universally acknowledged that our set of observations also includes events that are neither apparently deterministic nor apparently random! I can't recall reading a single thinker on the subject, in any discipline, who ever denied that some human actions are apparently free (even if he disputed that they were actually free).
 
I am confused about your use of the term "caused." Normally, the term is used to describe a natural event that is completely determined by one or more prior natural events. But you seem to be using it to mean non-random.

Forget natural events, I am talking at a higher level of abstraction - there are simply states and events, howsoever rendered. A cause is the reason that an event happens - the distinguishing characteristics of the preceeding state that facilitates a particular event.

The logical argument does not need to consider the physical (or otherwise) composition of the universe. That discussion is not only irrelevant to this but also (as seen in this thread) muddies the waters - providing intellectual bolt-holes for the proponents of free will.

There are at least three possibilities:

  1. an event is caused by one or more other natural events
  2. an event is random
  3. an event is the result of free will

Bearing in mind what I said above there are only 2 possibilities:

- An event is caused by some preceeding cause (for example, the will of the conscious mind).

- An event is not caused (otherwise describable as causing itself or random but those terms are not necessary for the argument).

Personally, I would place free will under "uncaused" along with "random."

This is self-contradictory. If you 'will' an event (e.g. choice) then the will is the cause of the event (since without the will, or with the will having a different state, a different choice, or no choice at all, would be made).

You can't just say 'will did it' and leave it there - ask yourself 'why did will do it?' and you immediately refute 'free' will. Your list of possibilities is like saying that the list of possibilities for my balloon floating northward is:

- It was caused to float northwards.
- It spontaneously floated nothward with no cause.
- The wind blew it.

For some reason you think that the wind / free will lies outside of logic.
 
Last edited:
This is self-contradictory. If you 'will' an event (e.g. choice) then the will is the cause of the event (since without the will, or with the will having a different state, a different choice, or no choice at all, would be made).

I think he meant that the WILL itself is uncaused. I'm still waiting on his explanation of how that would work, though.
 
Unfortunately free will doesn't make sense unless you posit an extra-physical sentience entity that can make decisions NOT based solely on physical factors and YET not determined by random quantum fluctuations. How would that work ?

Even if the entire universe is just an illusion perceived by an 'extra-physical' sentience - there is still no logical possibility for free will. That's the real point, the discussion of physical vs non-physical, material vs spiritual etc... is just a red herring and a diversion form the logic of the argument.

Whether the sentience is 'physical' or not is irrelevant. Logically, it must have some state that determines whether it will make choice A or choice B. As soon as you ask why it has that particular state 'free will' vanishes in a puff of logic.
 
I think he meant that the WILL itself is uncaused. I'm still waiting on his explanation of how that would work, though.

The current 'will' is either:

- The result of previous states of the will plus external and internal interactions (hence caused).

- Spontaneously generated (hence uncaused)

Or a combination of the above. There is no 'free' will there.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom