There is No God (And You Know It)

I know. But I'd like the freel will proponents to either admit that or propose an actual explanation, if they can manage that. They just refuse to answer.

Fair point - we could be waiting a while by the looks of it.
 
If you attribute a choice to the will then you are saying that the will caused the choice.

Of course, just like events that are random are caused by randomness. I'm also saying that free will could itself be uncaused, just like randomness.

The state of the consciousness at the point when the decison was made determined the choice.

Now you have 3 choices for how the consciousness arrived at that state:

- Through a chain of cause and effect.
- Randomly.
- A combination of the above.

Again, a big assumption that uncaused necessarily means random. There are of course at least four choices:


- Through a chain of cause and effect.
- Randomly.
- Of free will.
- A combination of the above.

I don't know. We do not need to know what causes events in order to understand the logical argument that they must be either caused or not caused.

So are gravity and magnetism caused or uncaused?

Exactly, as soon as you stop dressing it up with unnecessary flummery the argument becomes plain.

Yes, it does. Free will could be uncaused in the same way that randomness is uncaused. Thanks for clarifying.

-Bri
 
Then would you care to repeat, because I have missed it. A short, un-linked one will do just fine.

You didn't miss it, you quoted it in a response. Here it is again:

Simply stated, when one has acted of one's own free will, one could have done otherwise, and one was the ultimate source of the action. In order to be the ultimate source of one's action, some condition necessary for the action must originate within oneself (rather than externally).

That's besides the point. IF random events exist, how would they produce free will, since they have nothing to do with making a decision ? Making decisions NOT based strictly on physical factors doesn't seem possible.

I wasn't implying that random events cause free will. You were demanding to know how free will works, and I was simply pointing out that science doesn't know how randomness works, yet theorizes that random events occur nonetheless. In other words, I don't have to know how free will works to theorize that it is possible for free will to exist. Unless you can prove that free will is impossible, you must admit that it is possible.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Or you must admit that randomness may not exist, after all. Our observations tell us that an uncaused event does not exist, and if an event is caused, it is deterministic. Even so-called 'random' events haven't been proven to be uncaused; in fact, many 'random' events turn out to have quite complex causes. It is far more logical to declare of an event, 'we don't know its causes yet' than to claim 'this event is uncaused'.
 
Again, quite right (but completely besides the point of the topic)! Of course, I never claimed that randomness must exist, only that it is possible. And I never claimed that free will must exist, only that it is possible.

-Bri
 
I'm also saying that free will could itself be uncaused, just like randomness... Free will could be uncaused in the same way that randomness is uncaused. Thanks for clarifying.

Bri - why do you have so much trouble applying cause and effect within a thinker?

Please answer - given a choice between a ham sandwich and a cheese sandwich why did I choose the cheese today?
 
I wasn't implying that random events cause free will. You were demanding to know how free will works, and I was simply pointing out that science doesn't know how randomness works, yet theorizes that random events occur nonetheless. In other words, I don't have to know how free will works to theorize that it is possible for free will to exist. Unless you can prove that free will is impossible, you must admit that it is possible.

-Bri

You are seriously missing the point. We are not suggesting that random events actually happen, we are saying that logic permits them.

How they might happen is irrelevant - the point is that there are 2 logical possibilities - that events are caused or not caused. Events canot be flimmeried, flummeried, flying-pigified or free-willed. They can only be caused or not caused.

We have proved that free will is impossible but you refuse to acknowledge the logic of it.
 
I wasn't implying that random events cause free will. You were demanding to know how free will works, and I was simply pointing out that science doesn't know how randomness works, yet theorizes that random events occur nonetheless. In other words, I don't have to know how free will works to theorize that it is possible for free will to exist. Unless you can prove that free will is impossible, you must admit that it is possible.

So, basically, you WANT free will to exist, but have no idea whether it could exist, how it would work, how we might be able to tell if it does exist, etc.

This is a very weak point. You can't say there are no pink unicorns in the universe, so they are possible. However, I would be the last person to argue, seriously, that pink unicorns exist. You alledge that free will exists. Either show that free will is either required, or a reasonable possibility, or do not claim at all.
 
Or you must admit that randomness may not exist, after all. Our observations tell us that an uncaused event does not exist, and if an event is caused, it is deterministic. Even so-called 'random' events haven't been proven to be uncaused; in fact, many 'random' events turn out to have quite complex causes. It is far more logical to declare of an event, 'we don't know its causes yet' than to claim 'this event is uncaused'.

Let's not forget quantum physics, here. According to theory, underlying the universe are true random fluctuations. They are uncaused, and unpredictable.
 
Sure, it's following a preset pattern. The pattern is set when the timeline is instantiated, the instant the simulation is started.
The instant? Are you serious? Even with assembly language and only one call to the random number generator I would be surprised if you could set the pattern in less than 6,000 instruction cycles. You should not confuse "very fast" with instantaneous. As far as your program is concerned those 6,000 cycles are the beginning and end of history.

Also don't confuse the animated illusion with the underlying reality. Your dots on screen might be slowed down by some sleep function, but in fact they are doing much less work than your original pattern setting run. And by 'run' I mean some loop with an exit condition which is all that run means in computing.

But I welcome your admission. When the 'foreknowledge' is in existence the agent must follow a preset pattern.
The pattern is completely based on free will / randomness (depending on which function is used) and not by the programmer.
None of this matters - what I said was absolute and unavoidable fact. In your program you cannot call the "free will" function if the "foreknowledge" is in existence. You just can't. Try programming it and you will see that I am right. Because foreknowledge implies determinism.

All you really needed to say was that we could video a man walking through a maze and then superimpose titles on the recording to predict his every turn. That is what you example boils down to.
If God can see all of time, he has perfect foreknowledge because he knows future events by observing them directly. Remember, we are not defining foreknowledge as prediction, but simply being able to observe what will happen in the future.
But you are not paying attention - I never cast doubt on the possibility that some being could see all of time. But I proved that such a being could not participate in the temporal world.

I have pointed out several times it is irrelevant how God can produce the statements in the safe - whether he directly observes the future, uses counterfactuals, reads tea leaves - it makes no difference whatsoever.

The important point is that God can make a true statement about the world in the world. If the statement is in the world it is in the world at a particular time. If God's knowledge is timeless then the statement is not. If God makes the statement appear in time before the event that it describes then it becomes a prediction, in the ordinary, dictionary and well-known sense of the word - a fore-telling. A pre-diction.

And it is either right, or it is not. If it is not right then God is wrong and not omniscient.

If God is incapable of making such a simple and unambiguous statement then he can take his place with John Edwards, James Van Praagh and Doris Stokes.

But if he can then the statement is testable and would make his omniscience testable. So if such a statement was inserted into time before the event it would be logically impossible for the statement to be infallibly true and for the event to be a free choice.

You see the people that advance the 'God can see all of time' argument just tend to ignore that the future is not just after the present. It is contingent on the present.
 
Last edited:
Acutally the moral aspect of free will is interesting.

My choices are apparently the result of a process so absolutely unfathomable that even an infinite intelligence is intrinsically incapable of understanding it.

So how can I be held morally responsible for the result of such a process?
 
Let's not forget quantum physics, here. According to theory, underlying the universe are true random fluctuations. They are uncaused, and unpredictable.

"According to theory"... it might also be that their 'fluctuations' have definite causes, and may be predicted, given sufficient information. It's foolish at this point to declare that something is uncaused, especially when we don't even know for sure if the thing in question exists. I might just as well say pixies, according to theory, are uncaused. That doesn't make it so.
 
"According to theory"... it might also be that their 'fluctuations' have definite causes, and may be predicted, given sufficient information. It's foolish at this point to declare that something is uncaused, especially when we don't even know for sure if the thing in question exists. I might just as well say pixies, according to theory, are uncaused. That doesn't make it so.

No, but the theory is the best approximation we have, so far. If those fluctuations are truly chaotic, then they truly are uncaused.
 
Acutally the moral aspect of free will is interesting.

My choices are apparently the result of a process so absolutely unfathomable that even an infinite intelligence is intrinsically incapable of understanding it.

So how can I be held morally responsible for the result of such a process?

Excellent point! In a fully deterministic world, where your choices are mechanistic ones based on various inputs and memory, you must be held responsible because threats of that are what alter your computations!

And yet, this hypothetical spiritual decision maker, that makes decisions, at least partly, outside of determinism or determinism with random influences, seems impossible to exist -- how can something happen if it isn't caused by something else, or isn't truly random? Heck, even true quantum randomness is hard enough to believe that there isn't some determinism buried somewhere underneath it.
 
Bri - why do you have so much trouble applying cause and effect within a thinker?

Please answer - given a choice between a ham sandwich and a cheese sandwich why did I choose the cheese today?

I understand cause and effect. I'm simply saying that it is possible that not everything is the result of a prior cause.

I have no idea why you chose a cheese sandwich today. You tell me.

-Bri
 
You are seriously missing the point. We are not suggesting that random events actually happen, we are saying that logic permits them.

I don't think I missed that point at all. I'm also not saying that events of free will actually happen, only that logic permits them.

How they might happen is irrelevant...

Exactly, which was why I made the same comment to Belz who was demanding to know how free will works.

...the point is that there are 2 logical possibilities - that events are caused or not caused. Events canot be flimmeried, flummeried, flying-pigified or free-willed. They can only be caused or not caused.

I never said otherwise. I said that it's possible that free will is uncaused.

We have proved that free will is impossible but you refuse to acknowledge the logic of it.

Saying it's so doesn't make it so. In order to prove something, you have to provide some evidence.

-Bri
 
So, basically, you WANT free will to exist, but have no idea whether it could exist, how it would work, how we might be able to tell if it does exist, etc.

Whether or not I WANT free will to exist is irrelevant -- it either does or it doesn't. I know that it could exist, but I don't know whether it does exist. I don't know how it would work any more than I know how randomness would work if it exists. I don't know how we might be able to tell if it does exist any more than we can currently tell if randomness actually exists.

You can't say there are no pink unicorns in the universe, so they are possible. However, I would be the last person to argue, seriously, that pink unicorns exist.

I agree. It is possible that pink unicorns exist, but I would never argue that they exist, only that it is possible that they do.

You alledge that free will exists.

I did no such thing.

Either show that free will is either required, or a reasonable possibility, or do not claim at all.

Free will is a possibility because it's not impossible. Whether that possibility is "reasonable" is subjective, but given that many reasonable people believe it, I would say that it's a reasonable possibility. It may or may not be "required" any more than randomness may or may not be required -- we simply don't know yet. That said, your appendix isn't "required" either, yet we are all born with them.

-Bri
 
I understand cause and effect. I'm simply saying that it is possible that not everything is the result of a prior cause.

So you're saying that events are either caused or not caused, right? Where is your 3rd way there?

I have no idea why you chose a cheese sandwich today. You tell me.

It was actually a serious question. I'm trying to get you to analyse what is behind my / your apparent free will. Put it another way - why did you choose to have a cheese sandwich today (or whatever)?
 
The instant? Are you serious? Even with assembly language and only one call to the random number generator I would be surprised if you could set the pattern in less than 6,000 instruction cycles.

The calculation of the timeline begins the instant the simulation is started. The actual amount of time it takes to perform this calculation is irrelevant (and limited only by the speed of the computer) since it isn't related to the simulated timeline. From the programmer's perspective, it could occur in an instant or it could take 10 years. From the agent's perspective, it takes 60 seconds. If we're extending the analogy to God, the "calculation" could actually occur instantaneously.

There is only one "run" of the program, and only one calculation of the timeline given the scenario you provided.

All you really needed to say was that we could video a man walking through a maze and then superimpose titles on the recording to predict his every turn. That is what you example boils down to.

This is a fair analogy from the perspective of a timeless God (though inaccurate as ceo_esq has already pointed out). So now prove that the man didn't have free will when choosing which path to take through the maze.

But you are not paying attention - I never cast doubt on the possibility that some being could see all of time. But I proved that such a being could not participate in the temporal world.

There is nothing to prevent God from changing the timeline and thereby participating in the world. Changes made might affect our decisions from that point forward, but so what? God would still have perfect foreknowledge of our "new" future by timelessly observing any changes made. God could also make changes that don't affect free agents at all, as in your scenario.

The important point is that God can make a true statement about the world in the world. If the statement is in the world it is in the world at a particular time. If God's knowledge is timeless then the statement is not. If God makes the statement appear in time before the event that it describes then it becomes a prediction, in the ordinary, dictionary and well-known sense of the word - a fore-telling. A pre-diction.

In your scenario, there is nothing to prevent God from inserting the "prediction" into the world in such a way that it will never affect John's decision, and thereby will always remain true.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
So you're saying that events are either caused or not caused, right? Where is your 3rd way there?

There is no third way. I said that there are (at least) three possibilities: caused, random, or free will. The latter two might be "uncaused" by your definition.

It was actually a serious question. I'm trying to get you to analyse what is behind my / your apparent free will. Put it another way - why did you choose to have a cheese sandwich today (or whatever)?

My question was also serious, and I fully understand why you asked the question you asked.

Let's assume for a moment that your decision to have a cheese sandwich instead of ham was in fact random, but you didn't know it was random. Like all decisions, your brain was telling you that there was a reason you made the decision you made. What would be your answer if I asked you why you chose the cheese? You would likely provide a reason such as "I had ham yesterday" or "I felt like cheese today." Or maybe if you really overthought the question, you might say "the state of my brain caused me to choose cheese." How would your answer differ if the choice was actually the result of determinism? It likely wouldn't. How would it differ if it was the result of free will? It likely wouldn't.

The point is that any of these are possibilities, but your answer would likely still be the same and your experience would likely be the same. So I understand your reason for asking me the question, but the answer would be irrelevant as to whether one or more of causation, randomness, or free will are in fact reality.

-Bri
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom