There is No God (And You Know It)

Belz, you might want to read up on "dualism" for one possible explanation of the mechanism by which we might have free will. Essentially, it is the notion that we are more than the sum or our parts (i.e. some part of us is indeed extra-physical).

As I have said, dualism is irrelevant - the logic is not bounded by the physical world.

Simply stated, when one has acted of one's own free will, one could have done otherwise, and one was the ultimate source of the action. In order to be the ultimate source of one's action, some condition necessary for the action must originate within oneself (rather than externally).

(My empasis) Thanks - that's cause and effect at work. Internal / external makes no difference to the logic.
 
First, it would be necessary to determine if ANY event is truly uncaused or random. What we presently understand as 'random' may very well be quite determined by a number of factors not known by us at this time. What we currently claim is 'uncaused' is most likely 'caused by unknown agents'. It may very well be that there are no random OR uncaused events in the universe - though how we could possibly discover this to be true, I have no idea.

I largely agree with this sentiment although ultimately there is the question of 'why is there any existence at all?'. In one respect, whilst there may be local causation of states and events, the whole of existence is one big uncaused event. This is also why I stated that uncaused events can be said to have caused themselves - meaning that the only difference between them and caused events is the length and complexity of the causal chain.

As to 'free will', if we're discussing absolute uncaused choices, it would be necessary to determine if any event in the brain is in any way uncaused by prior agents... a daunting, but not impossible, task, to be sure. But until such time as we learn the truth, the search for absolute free will is no more nor less purposeful than the search for God, Heaven, invisible pink unicorns, or honest politicians. Since our current set of observations includes caused events, both deterministic and apparently random, the most logical inferrence is that all events are caused, either deterministically or randomly. Further, since many examples of apparently random or chaotic events are, in fact, deterministic as well, it is similarly more logical to state that an apparently random event is simply a deterministic one being affected by complex factors which we do not have full awareness or understanding of.

Again - I agree with the sentiment but please be aware that your inclusion of physical aspects (e.g. the brain) is what allows the dualists / free-will proponents their respite from logic. They can dodge the issue by moving into the physical vs non-physical debate.
 
The current 'will' is either:

- The result of previous states of the will plus external and internal interactions (hence caused).

- Spontaneously generated (hence uncaused) [random -Belz...]

Or a combination of the above. There is no 'free' will there.

That's what I've been saying all along.
 
Yet it is virtually universally acknowledged that our set of observations also includes events that are neither apparently deterministic nor apparently random!

Really? I've never seeen any such acknowledgement - beyond the individual human 'will', that is - and even that is heavily disputed.

But, please - enlighten me. Aside from human free will, what events have we observed which are apparently neither deterministic nor random? For that matter, how would you even know that an event could be neither deterministic nor random? What would such an event look like / appear / etc? Even human free will appears to fall into one or the other category, without so much as a single variation (when one is honest and determines their true motivations for each choice).

I can't recall reading a single thinker on the subject, in any discipline, who ever denied that some human actions are apparently free (even if he disputed that they were actually free).

Argumentum ad populum aside for a moment - but I'm guessing your recall is either shoddy, or your reading fairly limited. But let's do distinguish between writers acknowledging a 'practical' (or apparent) free will, and absolute free will.

Plus, we're dealing with a purely subjective concept, from the written point of view - and no matter how great you may consider most writers in most disciplines, I would gamble that a huge majority of them have a personal, intense desire for human free will to exist - so much so, that even in the face of contrary evidence, they will still insist that some choice they made was absolutely free.
 
Bri
Actually, they wouldn't. I'm a programmer, and the word "run" as it refers to a program has a specific meaning. If you were using it in a different way (as you seem to have been) then it certainly doesn't justify calling me a liar.
I know the meaning of “run” when used by a programmer, and I was using it correctly.

Your insinuation that I deliberately lied was unfounded and uncalled for.
There was no insinuation. I flat out called you a liar, and then provided evidenced that you had lied. Robin pointed it out as well.

The programmer can view the timeline, once instantiated, at as many different points in time as he likes without affecting the timeline. One "run" but multiple windows.
The programmer views the timeline, the agent turns right at t=30. No matter how many times the timeline is viewed the agent always turns right at t=30. The agent is incapable of ever doing anything else. Likewise, the programmer is incapable of interaction.

Sure, it's following a preset pattern. The pattern is set when the timeline is instantiated, the instant the simulation is started. The pattern is completely based on free will / randomness (depending on which function is used) and not by the programmer.
You’re confusing the cause of determinism with determinism itself. The entity with the infallible foreknowledge and/or omniscience does not have to be the same one to cause the determinism required for either.

If God can see all of time, he has perfect foreknowledge because he knows future events by observing them directly. Remember, we are not defining foreknowledge as prediction, but simply being able to observe what will happen in the future.
You are speaking about dependant knowledge again. Even if the observer is outside time, he is still dependant upon the progress of the agent’s timeline and cannot interact with it.

Belz, you might want to read up on "dualism" for one possible explanation of the mechanism by which we might have free will. Essentially, it is the notion that we are more than the sum or our parts (i.e. some part of us is indeed extra-physical).
Dualism is nothing more than a form of special pleading. Present some evidence and then we’ll talk.

Ossai
 
Really? I've never seeen any such acknowledgement - beyond the individual human 'will', that is - and even that is heavily disputed.

The human will is exactly what I'm referring to. It is disputed whether human beings actually have free will, but I really don't think it can be seriously disputed that we appear (at least superficially) to have free will. This appearance is what has given rise to the very old human notion that free will exists.

But, please - enlighten me. Aside from human free will, what events have we observed which are apparently neither deterministic nor random?

For that matter, how would you even know that an event could be neither deterministic nor random?

We don't, but this is irrelevant to the point I was making, and which you inexplicably insist on contesting. An event could appear to be the result of free will, but in fact be either deterministic or purely random.


What would such an event look like / appear / etc?

It would look like many human choices appear to us: neither immediately and easily identifiable as random, nor immediately and easily identifiable as deterministic.


Argumentum ad populum aside for a moment...

It would be an argumentum ad populum if I had argued that, from the fact that most people believe their actions to be free, we may deduce that their actions are actually free. Obviously I didn't. But since it appears to most people that their own actions or the actions of third parties are free, then almost by definition their actions are apparently free - they give the appearance of being free. This may be a facade, of course.

Even thinkers who dispute the existence (or even the possibility) of free will tend to take as their starting point the commonplace that certain human actions have the outward appearance, to human beings, of being free. If this were not the case there would be very little call, historically, to consider the problem of human freedom.


... but I'm guessing your recall is either shoddy, or your reading fairly limited.

I think everyone here knows me better than that.


But let's do distinguish between writers acknowledging a 'practical' (or apparent) free will, and absolute free will.

I don't think anyone has said anything here to obscure that distinction, if by "practical" you simply mean "apparent."
 
No. Prediction, in the sense I have been using the term, means calculation on the basis of (1) all causal laws and (2) all circumstances in the universe, solely as (1) and (2) exist on the timeline at a given point prior to the point at which the predicted event exists.
That definition is fine by me. The book in the safe exists on the timeline at a given point prior to all events in John's life, so the infallibly true statements about John's life count as predictions under this definition.
I do not consider God's knowledge of the future through direct cognition to be either an antecedent or a causal law in this sense (or based on an antecedent or a causal law); therefore, it is never, strictly speaking, a prediction.
That is why it is a book in a safe, rather than talking directly about God's knowledge. As I said when I put the example, God might be outside of time, but the book is not.

God should be capable of making a true statement about the world, in the world. Even if God's knowledge was not antecedent to an event, such a statement would be.

So there is a time before John turns left that God's infallible prediction say's that the possibility does not exist that John will turn right. But the definition of free will says that the possibility does exit.

A contradiction. Makes no difference how God came by the knowledge.
I don't see any logical problem with God "instantaneously" perceiving a timeline in which he is nonetheless an actor, albeit that it's a bit of a mind-bender from a purely human perspective. I have been searching the literature for a workable proof of such a problem, and find none.
I am not aware of one. It is impossible nevertheless.

Forget the chronology, the universe consists of states that are ontologically dependent on the previous state (if free will exists)

So say there are five choices, each contingent on the previous and God makes choice 3, then he makes choice 3 in full knowledge of the outcome of choice 5, even though choice 4 was supposed to be beyond his control and contingent on the outcome of his choice. Moreover it was impossible that choice 4 and 5 even existed until choice 3 was made, yet choice 3 was made in full knowledge of the outcome of these non-existent choices.

It is not a mind bender. It is just intrinsically impossible.
 
We don't, but this is irrelevant to the point I was making, and which you inexplicably insist on contesting. An event could appear to be the result of free will, but in fact be either deterministic or purely random.

Perhaps this is what you or I mean when we talk about free will and, for example, responsability.

But the debate on "free will" doesn't refer to appearances but about the actual existence of free will; that is, the ability to make decisions that are not deterministic and, obviously non-random. In sum, decisions that would be completely independent of any factor. This is why a number of people posit a human soul. Unfortunately for them, this doesn't answer the question, because then we have to assume that this soul would have some form of "creative" properties that would be neither random nor determined, and no one has ever explained what those could be like to any satisfactory extent.
 
...This is why a number of people posit a human soul. Unfortunately for them, this doesn't answer the question, because then we have to assume that this soul would have some form of "creative" properties that would be neither random nor determined, and no one has ever explained what those could be like to any satisfactory extent.

I agree but why leave the argument open like that? the reason that 'no one has ever explained what those could be like to any satisfactory extent' is because it is logically impossible to have an event that is neither caused nor not caused (your 'determined' or 'random').

Its not that we're just waiting for an explanation - there cannot be such an explanation.
 
Does it explain free will or does it merely assert that it could exist, as you do ?

It explains how it could exist, although it does not explain the mechanism by which it works. I don't know if free will exists, and I don't know how it works if it does exist.

I know what you want free will to mean. I want to know how it would be possible, according to you, given that the only factors we know of are either deterministic or random.

You asked for my definition of free will and I gave it to you. We don't even know if true uncaused random events actually occur -- although science currently theorizes that they do. I'm not sure exactly what you're asking here. Please explain to me how randomness is possible and perhaps I'll understand better the type of answer you seek.

-Bri
 
Forget natural events, I am talking at a higher level of abstraction - there are simply states and events, howsoever rendered.

What causes random events? If you claim that a random event is uncaused (or causes itself), then so is free will uncaused.

-Bri
 
What causes random events? If you claim that a random event is uncaused (or causes itself), then so is free will uncaused.

-Bri

Well, clearly nothing causes (excepting self-cause) random events (if they exist at all).

If free will is not caused then it is not 'will'. Have you not read this thread?
 
I know the meaning of “run” when used by a programmer, and I was using it correctly.

There was no insinuation. I flat out called you a liar, and then provided evidenced that you had lied.

If you believe the above nonsense, then we have nothing more to talk about. Thanks for the conversation.

-Bri
 
Well, clearly nothing causes (excepting self-cause) random events (if they exist at all).

If free will is not caused then it is not 'will'. Have you not read this thread?

By what definition of "will" do you come to the conclusion that it must be caused?

What causes gravity and magentism? Free will events could ultimately be caused by some unknown force. Or they could be uncaused (or could "cause themselves") similar to how you defined random events.

-Bri
 
By what definition of "will" do you come to the conclusion that it must be caused?

If you attribute a choice to the will then you are saying that the will caused the choice. The state of the consciousness at the point when the decison was made determined the choice.

Now you have 3 choices for how the consciousness arrived at that state:

- Through a chain of cause and effect.
- Randomly.
- A combination of the above.

What causes gravity and magentism?

I don't know. We do not need to know what causes events in order to understand the logical argument that they must be either caused or not caused.

Free will events could ultimately be caused by some unknown force. Or they could be uncaused (or could "cause themselves") similar to how you defined random events.

(My emphasis - read the whole then just the bold bits).

Exactly, as soon as you stop dressing it up with unnecessary flummery the argument becomes plain.
 
I agree but why leave the argument open like that? the reason that 'no one has ever explained what those could be like to any satisfactory extent' is because it is logically impossible to have an event that is neither caused nor not caused (your 'determined' or 'random').

Its not that we're just waiting for an explanation - there cannot be such an explanation.

I know. But I'd like the freel will proponents to either admit that or propose an actual explanation, if they can manage that. They just refuse to answer.
 
You asked for my definition of free will and I gave it to you.

Then would you care to repeat, because I have missed it. A short, un-linked one will do just fine.

We don't even know if true uncaused random events actually occur -- although science currently theorizes that they do. I'm not sure exactly what you're asking here. Please explain to me how randomness is possible and perhaps I'll understand better the type of answer you seek.

That's besides the point. IF random events exist, how would they produce free will, since they have nothing to do with making a decision ? Making decisions NOT based strictly on physical factors doesn't seem possible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom