I doubt that any atheist philosopher is a philosopher of religion as such I would be surprised if any of the guys you mentioned would welcome that soubriquet. They would probably consider themselves philosophers that deal with religion from time to time. Many atheist philosophers similarly deal with the topic of religion but without getting into any nature of God topics.
Most academic philosophers who do work even primarily in philosophy of religion probably do not consider themselves
exclusively philosophers of religion, but that wasn't really what I was suggesting. I note that one of the more celebrated names in that field, though - the atheist William Rowe of Purdue University (well-known for his work on the evidential PoE, among other things) - lists "philosophy of religion and metaphysics" as his area of specialization on his academic webpage. The page of another star figure in the field, atheist Paul Draper of Florida International University, lists "philosophy of religion" at the top of his areas of interest.
So let
philosophers of religion simply designate philosophers for whom philosophy of religion (in a modern sense, per the
Oxford Companion, "philosophical analyses of certain concepts or tenets central to the Western monotheistic religions and especially to Christianity") is an area of substantial interest. And let
atheist philosophers of religion (or
atheologians) simply designate those philosophers of religion who are atheists, or whose analyses, at any rate, tend toward the justification of an atheistic viewpoint over a theistic one.
But some philosophers appear to suggest that since moral perfection is intrinsically impossible we should just take the next best thing and call that moral perfection.
True. The same thing happens in many analyses of other divine attributes. I don't really have a problem with that argument with respect to, say, omnipotence (indeed, I have problems with contrary arguments), so I have no basis to reject the same approach with respect to moral perfection.
That is indeed a lot of reprints for a paper that has apparently been so utterly discredited. Again I wonder at the motivations. Maybe the editors don't consider it quite so utterly defeated as you suggest.
Maybe they don't; in the case of strongly atheistic compilations such as
The Impossibility of God, perhaps the editors don't want to admit it. Moreover, some of those anthologies arguably have a history-of-philosophy dimension as well, and there's undeniably a basis there for including Mackie. But whatever the views of the editors, the more telling point is the dropoff in the production of recent academic work on the logical PoE. There's such a dearth of recent, well-written treatments from an atheist perspective that an editor is all but constrained to reach back several decades (and Mackie is probably the most celebrated and most accessible treatment from that period) or else not include any modern primary sources at all.
It occurs to me that perhaps I have overstated the point in this thread. Every particular formulation of the logical, deductive PoE specifically known to me is, I believe, widely considered (though not, perhaps, universally acknowledged) to have been refuted (
i.e., satisfactorily shown not to prove a
logical inconsistency between the existence of the God of classical theism and the existence of evil). It is also my impression that deductive proofs of the non-existence of God from evil are not pursued or examined with nearly as much interest in the literature as they were thirty or forty years ago, and that there is considerable skepticism among even atheists in the field as to whether such deductive proofs are worth pursuing in the light of prior refutations. That said, no one is in a position to assert that a novel formulation of the logical PoE will not be advanced successfully in the future. Indeed, I personally am not in a position to assert that an airtight deductive argument from evil has not already been written which has not come to my attention.
Admittedly I am looking at the Concise edition of the Routledge Encyclopedia but the I can only see one edition of the Oxford Companion and neither index Mackie or Flew.
Are you looking at the "Shorter" or the 10 volume set of Routledge? Or perhaps the online version (which might be supposed to contain even obscure references).
I was looking at the full, printed multivolume Routledge.
I was also consulting the single-volume, 1995 edition of the
Oxford Companion to Philosophy (Honderich, ed.). "Mackie, John L." has a full entry to himself (sandwiched in between "MacIntyre, Alasdair C." and "macrocosm and microcosm"), and his index listing cross-references further mentions of Mackie in the following entries: "Australian philosophy"; "causality"; "cement of the universe"; "conditionals"; "error theory of value"; "God, arguments against the existence of"; "laws, natural or scientific"; "moral philosophy, history of"; "moral scepticism"; and "religion, history of the philosophy of". Anthony Flew does not appear therein; I didn't go back to the multivolume Routledge to see whether he is mentioned.