Robin
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Apr 29, 2004
- Messages
- 14,971
Well I don't know if there is one or not, but the premise of this discussion is that there is. Certainly if there is not then the whole concept of God, which rests on moral responsibility, goes out the door.Sorry, I can't help myself (particularly when I think that the statement is pretty much self-evident).
We can start with a determinist notion that all events are caused. If we accept this then there is clearly no free will since the thought events that I am having now would have causes that stretch back into a past that predates my existence.
The only alternative that we can posit against this is that not all events are caused - in which case we could say that some events are random. Random events do not, however, support the notion of free will.
I do not think that there is a logically definable concept of 'free-will'.
I posted one definition earlier and nobody complained. However I think a better one is:
J has libertarian free will if for at least one voluntary act X at time t the possibility existed before t that John will not do X at t even though he is able to.
But I am open to suggestions of something better.