There is No God (And You Know It)

Sorry, I can't help myself (particularly when I think that the statement is pretty much self-evident).

We can start with a determinist notion that all events are caused. If we accept this then there is clearly no free will since the thought events that I am having now would have causes that stretch back into a past that predates my existence.

The only alternative that we can posit against this is that not all events are caused - in which case we could say that some events are random. Random events do not, however, support the notion of free will.

I do not think that there is a logically definable concept of 'free-will'.
Well I don't know if there is one or not, but the premise of this discussion is that there is. Certainly if there is not then the whole concept of God, which rests on moral responsibility, goes out the door.

I posted one definition earlier and nobody complained. However I think a better one is:

J has libertarian free will if for at least one voluntary act X at time t the possibility existed before t that John will not do X at t even though he is able to.

But I am open to suggestions of something better.
 
Actually I think it doesn't accurately model things. The use of an OS analogy would be more accurate since that is a system that has to deal with the randomness of a user. You can't program something with a predefined end-state - which is what is being proposed here if I follow correctly.
Nevertheless the interesting thing is that if you actually try to program the model as described it neatly contradicts the point that Bri brought it in to illustrate.

In fact it illustrates that free will and infallible foreknowledge are mutually exclusive.
 
This thread has gone on far to long. And so now i will end the debate concerning evidence of my existence, by posting on this forum myself!
 
Last edited:
1. At t=20 P knows that A will choose S at t=30
2. If A chooses ~S at t=30 P's knowledge will be wrong (Hyp)
3. A may choose ~S at t=30 (from definition of free will)
4. P's knowledge may be wrong (MP 2,3)

And now that God is posting here he can confirm that this is right!
 
This thread has gone on far to long. And so now i will end the debate concerning evidence of my existence, by posting on this forum myself!

.... wow, God has typos. God makes mistakes.

Cool - now we know. God is not infallible, omniscient, or timeless; this is good to know.

Bri - you're skating on thin water without a paddle, I'm affraid. But I'm on Vicondena ndn endtex and startting to wfeel fuzzzsy.
 
Well I don't know if there is one or not, but the premise of this discussion is that there is. Certainly if there is not then the whole concept of God, which rests on moral responsibility, goes out the door.

I posted one definition earlier and nobody complained. However I think a better one is:

J has libertarian free will if for at least one voluntary act X at time t the possibility existed before t that John will not do X at t even though he is able to.

There is no such possibility so there is no free will. The concept breaks down as soon as you ask the question of why John took action A instead of action B.
 
Bri
Incorrect, and you are overloading the term "determined." Just because the timeline is calculated before the simulation begins relative to the programmer's timeline, that doesn't mean that it was calculated deterministically.
Would you quit throwing the red herring up about the programmer’s timeline. The programmer’s timeline never affected the simulation and is entirely irrelevant to the discussion at hand.


Robin
Nevertheless the interesting thing is that if you actually try to program the model as described it neatly contradicts the point that Bri brought it in to illustrate.

In fact it illustrates that free will and infallible foreknowledge are mutually exclusive.
Because it deserves to be repeated, in big glowing letters. :clap:

Ossai
 
Saying it's so doesn't make it so. Repeating it in a large colorful font doesn't make it any moreso.

I think zaayrdragon said it best:

...no posting raw opinion without discourse or evidence, if you please.

Of course, you can still maintain the belief by simply admitting that it's a belief based on faith rather than fact, but if you wish to prove that God does not exist, you'll have to provide some evidence that it would be impossible for God to exist.

So far, you have failed in every attempt to demonstrate that any commonly-held notion of God cannot exist, much less all of them. Not completely surprising considering that philosophers smarter and with more time on their hands have been discussing these issues for centuries without a definitive answer.

Oh, and claims of delirium or ad hominem attacks whenever evidence is requested don't count as evidence.

-Bri
 
So far, you have failed in every attempt to demonstrate that any commonly-held notion of God cannot exist, much less all of them.

While this may be true, I think we have succeded in demonstrating that absolute free will cannot exist. Notice that I'm not arguing as to whether an omniscient God can exist; AFAIK, there's no problem at all with an omniscient God. But the existence of such a God neutralizes absolute free-will. THAT'S the only point I've seen proven, thus far.

The presence of an omniscient God means that the Universe is entirely deterministic.
 
While this may be true, I think we have succeded in demonstrating that absolute free will cannot exist.

You have yet to provide a shred of evidence that it is impossible for libertarian free will to exist with an omniscient God, much less without one.

Again, because you say it's so doesn't make it so. When asked to provide evidence, you claimed that "your mind is too bizarre in how it functions for me to put that into writing." You might be the most impressive philosopher of all time, but your statement doesn't exactly inspire my confidence in the existance of your proof, especially in light of a lack of proof by other brilliant philosophers over the past several thousand years.

-Bri
 
You have yet to provide a shred of evidence that it is impossible for libertarian free will to exist with an omniscient God, much less without one.

Again, because you say it's so doesn't make it so. When asked to provide evidence, you claimed that "your mind is too bizarre in how it functions for me to put that into writing." You might be the most impressive philosopher of all time, but your statement doesn't exactly inspire my confidence in the existance of your proof, especially in light of a lack of proof by other brilliant philosophers over the past several thousand years.

-Bri

Who said anything about MY proof? YOU are the one who has given us this brilliant proof which demonstrates, rather clearly, that free will cannot exist with an omniscient, timeless creator God.

I haven't had to say so - you've done all the work for us.

Thank you, Bri!
 
Who said anything about MY proof? YOU are the one who has given us this brilliant proof which demonstrates, rather clearly, that free will cannot exist with an omniscient, timeless creator God.

Again, if you claim that my example demonstrates this rather clearly, you should have no problem proving it.

I have on many occasions made it clear that my example isn't about God and doesn't attempt to demonstrate that the programmer in question is omniscient, so I'm not certain how you come to the conclusion that it proves anything about an omniscient God.

If my example is all you've got, then it's no wonder you're not able to provide evidence of your claim.

-Bri
 
While this may be true, I think we have succeded in demonstrating that absolute free will cannot exist. Notice that I'm not arguing as to whether an omniscient God can exist; AFAIK, there's no problem at all with an omniscient God. But the existence of such a God neutralizes absolute free-will. THAT'S the only point I've seen proven, thus far.

Agreed but I would go further and say that free will does not exist - regardless of the existence or omniscience of God. The argument that free will can only be an illusion does not even require a given scientific or physical framework, it only requires logic.

If an entity (person or God) has a state that represents a choice (the will to do one thing as opposed to another) then let us call that state X.

Now ask ourselves the question, how did this entity arrive at state X? The determinist would suggest a series of caused events correlated to produce that state. From this position the determinist would extrapolate back to reason that all previous states / events were also caused (going back ad-infinitum) and so free will cannot exist since our choice (state X) is a product of millenia of chained events.

Note that the events described above can be logical events - we do not need to couple them to any known physical laws or infrastructure.

If we object and ask the determinist to prove that all events are caused then it is likely that he will not easily (or at all) be able to do so. This leaves us with the possibility of events that are not caused - essentially randomly occuring events. Of course this does not logically require that no events at all are caused (neither does it preclude that possibility). In any case, if state X is arrived at via a random chance mutation from state S then it can hardly be considered to represent free will.
 
I posted one definition earlier and nobody complained. However I think a better one is:

J has libertarian free will if for at least one voluntary act X at time t the possibility existed before t that John will not do X at t even though he is able to.

But I am open to suggestions of something better.

Here's one definition I've come across from time to time:

J has free will if for at least one voluntary act X at time t, no antecedent conditions and/or causal laws determine that J will perform X, or that he won't perform X.
 
Here's one definition I've come across from time to time:

J has free will if for at least one voluntary act X at time t, no antecedent conditions and/or causal laws determine that J will perform X, or that he won't perform X.

Clearly, j's state at t is what determines his action x. If you remove all 'antecedent conditions and causal laws' you are left with a sudden (effectively random) event to produce that state (or at least the part of it that is responsible for determining whether or not J does x). Do you think it is reasonable to describe that as free will?
 
Clearly, j's state at t is what determines his action x. If you remove all 'antecedent conditions and causal laws' you are left with a sudden (effectively random) event to produce that state (or at least the part of it that is responsible for determining whether or not J does x). Do you think it is reasonable to describe that as free will?
I have often argued that not only does libertarian free will not exist, the average person would not be surprised or alarmed to learn this.

In fact if you question people about why they did a particular thing they will list a set of determinants, such as intelligence, emotional states, knowledge, skills etc. These things plus outside influences are clearly the determinants of choices. Once you take all these away what is left?

A sudden effectively random state as you say, just about describes it.

But of course the tricky thing is proving it.
 
I have often argued that not only does libertarian free will not exist, the average person would not be surprised or alarmed to learn this.

In fact if you question people about why they did a particular thing they will list a set of determinants, such as intelligence, emotional states, knowledge, skills etc. These things plus outside influences are clearly the determinants of choices. Once you take all these away what is left?

A sudden effectively random state as you say, just about describes it.

But of course the tricky thing is proving it.

How is it tricky to prove? I thought I pretty much just proved it?
If you don't agree then please let me know what is wrong with my original argument.
 
I have often argued that not only does libertarian free will not exist, the average person would not be surprised or alarmed to learn this.

In fact if you question people about why they did a particular thing they will list a set of determinants, such as intelligence, emotional states, knowledge, skills etc. These things plus outside influences are clearly the determinants of choices. Once you take all these away what is left?

A sudden effectively random state as you say, just about describes it.

But of course the tricky thing is proving it.

And, of course, the 'average person' thinks they have free will - I feel that I have free will even though I know intellectually that it does not exist. It is an agreeable illusion which is part of our conciousness.
 
Again, if you claim that my example demonstrates this rather clearly, you should have no problem proving it.

I have on many occasions made it clear that my example isn't about God and doesn't attempt to demonstrate that the programmer in question is omniscient, so I'm not certain how you come to the conclusion that it proves anything about an omniscient God.

If my example is all you've got, then it's no wonder you're not able to provide evidence of your claim.

-Bri
I have done so several times. Even if we accept your rather absurd premise that the inside of a locked safe is somehow outside our timeline your example is still flawed.

In fact your program - if coded according to your description - rather neatly demonstrates the incompatibility of free will and infallible foreknowledge.

In the original window the actions of the agent through the period t=0 to 60 are determined by a call to the free will function whenever it encounters an obstacle.

In the second window foreknowledge of the agent's action is inserted into some time before the action occurred. Now you say
... and the free agent will turn left as expected at time 30.
In order to have coded this it would have been necessary to save the state of the original choices in some array or vector and then have the agents movements in the second window follow this array. In other words follow a predetermined path. In the second window the agent does not even have to check for objects ahead - it will just neatly dodge them without being aware that they are there - it is only an automaton.

So the first window illustrates free will without infallible foreknowledge

The second window illustrates infallible foreknowledge without free will.

But you simply cannot code the situation where the free will function can be called in the second window when you have placed the infallible foreknowledge.

If I am wrong, then you should be able to code the second window so that the agent will "... turn left as expected at time 30." with foreknowledge in place and utilising the free will function. You can't. Because free will and infallible foreknowledge are incompatible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom