Bri
I don't know what you mean about "activating" the decision. The results of the decision were calculated before the simulation was even started, and never change afterwards.
Completely deterministic.
I have never claimed any limitation of foreknowledge.
Wrong.
There is certainly a limitation of knowledge of the random and free-will functions (which have nothing to do with foreknowledge of the simulated timeline).
Again incorrect. If the programmer can look at any the simulation at any point t=0 to t=60, then looking at the random number is also possible.
Limitation on omniscience! Again you limit omniscience in order for freewill to function.
Again, no. Here I'm simply responding to your post. The answer to whether the programmer of my example could know the result of the random function and whether the programmer in my example is omniscient was a given (he can't, and he's not). Yet he still has foreknowledge.
And it is still deterministic. The programmer knows that the agent will turn left at t=30. No matter how many times the program is ran, the agent will turn left at t=30. Absolutely nothing the agent does (random number) will ever cause it to turn right, go straight, or pause.
The related questions that were discussed after the example was given were about whether God, in the programmer's position, could know the results of the random function and whether his not knowing somehow limits his omniscience.
The basic definition of omniscience already answers that question. God would already know the number that the random number generator would produce. By declaring that god would not know, you are limiting omniscience, again.
God to choose to limit his ability to infallably predict the results of the random function, but oddly enough this "limitation" wouldn't really limit his knowlege at all since it still results in his knowing the results of the random function by observation rather than prediction.
What, so god’s a moron now as well?
God wouldn’t know whether 0 or 1 would come up, the random number.
God knows the program and what each random number would cause it to do.
God knows that the agent is constrained by the program.
God knows what the agent will do.
Yet god cannot deduce either 0 or 1?
Oh, wait, apparently god doesn’t know something thereby rendering him non-omniscient to begin with.
Remember you already said that the programmer already knows which direction will be chosen. No matter how many times the simulation is run at t=30, the agent will turn left, there is no possibility of the agent ever turning right.
Not true at all. If the simulation is run again, the agent might very well not turn left (might stop instead).
No. You go back and reread what you originally posted. There is only one simulation. If it is run again with the agent’s reaction being variable each time then the programmer does not have foreknowledge.
I never said that the agent would always turn left and in fact specifically said that a recalculation of the timeline could result in a different outcome. However, if the programmer would have foreknowledge of either outcome that might result from either the random or the theoretical free-will function. Please re-read the example until you understand it, and if you have questions I'd be happy to answer them.
Oh look, you’ve changed your position yet again. This time you want freewill and the only way to have it is to limit foreknowledge. You’ve expressed what the programmer knows as a possibility. As I said before, foreknowledge cannot be wrong. It is not prediction, because prediction implies the possibility of incorrectness.
No. No paradox either. The random number generator would only be random to a non-omniscient entity.
It is a paradox, of course, because you didn't answer the question.
Nope, I understood the question. If you think it doesn’t ask what you intended rethink it and ask again.
I asked if an omniscient God can create a random number generator that is so random that even he cannot predict. You answered "no" which means that the God you're referring to obviously isn't omniscient (because he doesn't know how to create such a thing). So please answer the question about whether an omniscient God would be able to create a random number generator that he cannot predict.
The answer remains no. It doesn’t matter which question you apply it to either. You’re trying to use logic to support an illogical proposition.
When it comes to an omniscient God, a prediction would imply a chance of 100%.
No, semantics – omniscience eliminates prediction. God would have infallible foreknowledge. Prediction implies a chance of error. There is no chance of error.
That doesn't prevent it from being a prediction (as opposed to an observation). But if you insist, God can limit his knowledge of the results in order to allow it to be random.
So, you do admit you are wrong. Infallible foreknowledge is incompatible with freewill.
Ossai