Go away for a couple of days and look how far behind I am. :sigh:
Bri
Oh and for jmercer, I haven’t forgotten the proof, still working.
Ossai
Bri
You’ve posted another great example of an illusionary freewill.We have foreknowledge of the agent's future but the agent has free will. As long as we're careful about how we interact with the world, we can ensure that the foreknowledge will be accurate. Even if we decide to interact with the world, as long as we do it after time 30 or in such a way that it won't affect the free agent's history at time 30, we know that the agent will always turn left at time 30. For example, we could remove one of the walls to the safe at time 40, and the agent could run into the message wall, but it won't affect the agent's past behavior at time 30. Even if we DID want to interfere with the free agent's history at time 30 by placing a new wall into the world in front of the agent, say at time 20, we would instantly know what the agent's new future is at time 30.
What you are actually saying is that if god were not omniscient then people would have freewill. It negates the rest of your argument nicely.It is possible that God restricts his own knowledge in order to provide free will; however, I'm not sure that God's knowledge would be restricted at all in this case. First, the programmer could know exactly how the random function works without being able to predict its outcome, so God could know how the function works but restrict his knowledge of the outcome in order to provide free will.
Oh and for jmercer, I haven’t forgotten the proof, still working.
Ossai