zaayrdragon said:
OK, forget 'true propositions' and all the psychobabble garbage for a minute - Prior to God creating the Universe, does God know every aspect of that universe, every possible choice that every possible being will ever make, etc? If God does, God is omniscient. If God doesn't, God isn't. If 'middle knowledge' does not exist, then God is not omniscient. "Why, why, why?" you cry, shaking your fists to the Heavens. Because if middle knowledge does NOT exist, then God cannot know the future, God cannot predict the actions of free agents, and God is restricted by Time.
If middle knowledge does not exist, then God cannot know absolutely how free agents
would have acted in circumstances which are never actualized, because there is nothing
to know. But I fail to see how this prevents him from knowing the future - that is, how actual free agents
will behave in circumstances which
do appear somewhere in the timeline of the natural universe. As you pointed out, once the initial conditions of the universe are actualized (let's call this actualization the "Big Bang" for short, without tying ourselves at all to what that term denotes in physics), the entire timeline leaps into being at once. In the absence of any actualized universe, the actions of hypothetical free agents constitute middle knowledge; there is no future to see into; no timeline at all. It would be logically impossible for an omniscient being to perceive an absent timeline. Thus, it is only in causing the Big Bang and actualizing a timeline that an omniscient God achieves an absolute guarantee of the choices of free agents. Logically, he cannot rely on such a guarantee in actualizing the initial conditions that constitute the Big Bang.
If middle knowledge is intrinsically impossible, then the foregoing is what we should reasonably expect divine omniscience to entail. Under those circumstances, I am satisfied that an omniscient being must have perfect knowledge of any actualized timeline without needing knowledge of non-actualized timelines (such "knowledge" would be meaningless).
Your instinct seems to be that the more things there are that
don't constitute knowledge (for, by hypothesizing that middle knowledge is impossible, we also hypothesize accordingly that it is not a form of knowledge), the less omniscient God is. This is formally untrue, however. If there are no true counterfactuals of freedom, this fact simply modifies (indirectly) the significance of
omniscience. Why theists or atheists need be troubled by this is not clear to me. The removal of some tea from China has a similar consequence on the what the expression
All the tea in China signifies. Yet it has zero consequence on whether someone does or does not possess all the tea in China.
zaayrdragon said:
Again, I have to disagree with your analogy, because the two comparisons are not analogous. Here, you refer to a batting average, and the removal of 'hits'... I'm not a baseball geek, so forgive me if I have no idea what all that is about.
I will not pursue that particular argument any further, in that case.