Why? For one thing, a game with an infinite board and infinite tiles is not, by definition, a game of Scrabble, just as a bowling round with unlimited frames would not correspond to the standard definition of a game of bowling.The 'omnibowler' was a pretty poor scenario. Much better to compare it to a game of 'Scrabble' with an infinite tile set and infinite space on the board.
Let me propose a compromise analogy drawn from baseball: consider a being who possesses the quality of perfection with regard to batting average. We'll call him the Omnibatter. There is no intrinsic limit to the number of at-bats or hits a batter can have - a quality which might make the analogy more palatable for you. But there is an intrinsic limit to batting averages; a batter who is perfect in this respect earns a hit each and every time he appears at bat. The Omnibatter therefore has a batting average of 1.000. (Not 2.000, and not infinity.)
Knowledge, it would also seem, is a quality that has an intrinsic upper limit: a being possessing perfection with respect to knowledge (i.e. omniscience) knows every true proposition, and believes none that are not true. It is not possible to be more omniscient than that - and note that this intrinsic limit does not depend on there being a finite or quantifiable set of true propositions. If there are any true counterfactuals of freedom, an omniscient being obviously knows them. If there are no true counterfactuals of freedom (i.e. if middle knowledge is impossible), he obviously doesn't - but this doesn't affect whether the being knows every true proposition, and believes none that are not true (i.e. whether he is omniscient). He meets the definition equally well in both cases.
Now, let us posit the nonexistence of middle knowledge. This means that the set of all true propositions does not include some propositions (true counterfactuals of freedom) which it would otherwise include if middle knowledge were a possible phenomenon. To me, this is like subtracting from the potential number of at-bats (and therefore hits) of the Omnibatter. Yet this would have no consequences whatsoever for either the Omnibatter's batting average or his innate ability to hit every time. The specific "omni-quality" of perfection that defines the Omnibatter remains intact. So why would the unavailability of non-existent truths impair God's quality of perfection with respect to knowledge (better known as his omniscience)?
Last edited: